Engines Aether Legend of the Lunar Priest NIFE Roadmap
Shatterloop Game Projects Deprecated Starwright
Saepes Mundi Other Projects Blog  

Mafia

Moderated by: Speed Bike Pro

game 11 night 4 actually night 4

Posted September 11, 2012 by MajorasMask9

DAY FOUR

At exactly 12:00am, White Thunder woke up from a deep sleep. Bored, he looked out his window. Five houses down he saw a hitman from the international mob in the process of murdering Shad~, a Townie. The hitman for the international mob then ran out of the town, never to be seen again.

White Thunder rushed out to the streets in hopes that Shad~ was still alive, but it was too late. He headed back home, but before he could reach his front door, he was also attacked and killed by an unknown person! White Thunder was also a Townie.

1. White Thunder - Townie
2. `Roxas`
3. white lancer - Hooker
4. Zanic
5. Feral - Nurse
6. Shad~ - Townie
7. CtR Black
8. Frustro
9. Female Alpha Wolf
10. #85 - Townie
11. Serpe
12. Xhin
13. Jo Nathan
14. hezekiah
15. Trever Leingod
16. Count Dooku
17. chiefsonny
18. Redack - Special Club Member
19. Kassie the Eevee

Ratio: 3-8 (2)

Roles:
Ninja, Silencer, Newcomer
Watcher, Tracker, Special Club Member x1, Nurse, Sheriff, Sleepwalker x3?, Townie x4?
Prosecutor, Defense Attorney.

Day round will end in 72 hours or when there are 8 votes for the same option.

Additionally, I want to announce now that starting on Day Round 6, I'm going to enforce a new set of rules that will determine when the Day Rounds are allowed to come to an end. Starting Day 6, the Day Rounds will not end until 18 hours have passed from the start of the round unless every player submits a vote (this includes the option of "Not Voting"). This is to prevent the Day Rounds from ending without some players having the opportunity to participate. Any other important details will be posted when Day 6 starts.

There are 72 Replies

extensionEnable Post Pagination

Well, I'm sorry for doubting all those voting for Lancer. You have to understand my concern though. I'm glad we got him, but the loss of two townies was pretty big. Stupid Knukles.

I'm not sure who to vote for, so I'll just wait for others to post.

September 11, 2012
Edit
Zanic

Dare I ask, what exactly did Knuckles do to get super-mega-host-nuke-killed?

Also, I'm mostly convinced Zanic's also Mafia. But with it being only Round 3 and already we're dangerously low on numbers, I'm pretty nervous on jumping to conclusions.

September 11, 2012
Edit
Frustro

Knukles broke the terms of his agreement, so he was globally banned again. Feral decided to take the initiative to kill him off in the mafia game himself, which I have asked him to refrain from doing again.

In this situation, I don't think it really has a big impact on the game, but just so everyone knows, in the future, if something like this happens, leave it up to the host to decide.

September 11, 2012
Edit
Yeano

I also think Zanic is very likely to be Mafia, but I agree it's not opportune for us to jump to conclusions hastily with the number of people we've lost.

I'm a bit suspicious of Kassie as well.

Roxas I am pretty sure is innocent.

Frustro, you played a great game last time so it wouldn't surprise me if Majora entrusted you with a Mafia role, but that's not anything I feel like pursuing right now since there isn't really any evidence that you're Mafia. Just something I'll keep in mind for later... {:P}

I'm not sure what to think of everyone else yet.

Just a suggestion to whomever is Sherrif - if you have a really really (and I mean really) good reason to suspect a particular person, please consider acting on that soon. The less people we have, the bigger the risk that you get killed during the night. I just don't want to see your body show up before you get a chance to use your one shot. {:?}

September 11, 2012
Edit
Jo Nathan

I kinda agree with Jo, but only kinda... if you think you have a good target, take the shot. I'm afraid that the Sheriff will turn out like the nuke tokens in most playings of the BSG board game I'm involved in, where they sit there unused for the entire game because the Admiral didn't think the situation was bad enough to risk using one.

Also, I'm seeing that the last night round went for the full 24 hours (+3 minutes).

September 11, 2012
Edit
hezekiah

I think the Sherrif should use their power today, and honestly I think he should use it against Zanic. Here's why:

GTX0 operates based on your IP. If I log into this computer as Count Dooku, I can get on a laptop across the house and still be logged in as Count Dooku. As a result of this, I was able to visit the mod forum when Redack visited me this last summer. Once he logged in, every computer at my house was logged in as Redack.

Because of this, its very unlikely that Zanic was unaware of Lancer's role unless he checked that he was logged in as Zanic EVERY SINGLE TIME he got on GTX0.

Furthermore, I'm going to go out on a limb and say that some of the roles weren't exactly randomly assigned this game. Redack and me ended up not only on the same side, but in the same special group. It stands to wager that Zanic and Lancer would also end up on the same team because they're brothers.

Add to this the fact that Lancer made an excuse for Zanic on Night 1:

Sorry for my absence, guys. I'm obviously not Silenced--Zanic and I were at a family gathering this weekend.

If Lancer was mafia but knew Zanic wasn't, why make an excuse for him? Why not just let the town see that Zanic hadn't replied and let us lynch him?

And finally, given how badly Zanic reacted to the mere IDEA that he could be guilty, I'm fairly certain that he's mafia.

With that in mind, I'd personally like to see the sheriff use their power against Zanic. The longer you delay at this point, the higher the chance you'll end up dead without using your power. Zanic is a logical choice, all things considered.

September 11, 2012
Edit
Count Dooku

Here's problems with your opinion Dooku.

Lancer and I have never had a problem with the IP address before. We didn't have a problem with it this time either. We are both very careful to check before as cheating could be a problem. Lancer has mod powers, so it was easy to see the mod editing options above the GTXO Mafia logo.

I've already pointed out that the post Lancer made had really nothing to do with me. You're simply being way too paranoid and I'm getting tired of hearing that excuse.

Just because I act defensively against accusations, you suddenly gain suspicion of me? That's so stupid Dooku. You should know better. Anyone would react to getting hammered with suspicion about nothing. It pissed me off.

September 11, 2012
Edit
Zanic

The problem I have is that I'm certain in previous games you and Lancer have admitted that you've known each others roles but 'didn't take advantage of the information.' Hence why I find your claim that you had no knowledge of his role suspicious.

Let's ignore the IP thing for a minute, let's also ignore the randomized teams thing because that could be a hilariously lucky coincidence that me and Redack ended up on the same team.

It still doesn't explain why Lancer covered for you.

It still doesn't explain why you're so hostile when one person is pushing to get you killed. I'm more than willing to ignore one or even two people thinking I'm guilty if I'm not (or even if I am) because you avoid casting suspicion on yourself.

Instead, when I suggest you're guilty you go out and call me stupid and get generally upset.

Its very odd behavior, and I don't think it adds up to you being upset over your fantasy football team.

September 11, 2012
Edit
Count Dooku

Lancer did not cover for me. He was explaining a fact and I don't see why you find it suspicious at all. It no connection between him and myself.

I was in a bad mood. We all have meltdowns. I apologize for calling you stupid, but I just down see why you're mistaking simple things for suspicious activity.

September 11, 2012
Edit
Zanic

It would be to his advantage to just cover himself and let the town wonder what your excuse was. Since he was mafia, it makes sense that he was simply helping explain his fellow mafia's absence. Lancer knows the town likes to lynch the inactive people these days.

In either case, I'm off to bed. I'll do you the courtesy of not voting for you unless the town agrees with my suspicions and begins the proceedings.

September 11, 2012
Edit
Count Dooku

MID-DAY FOUR

*BANG*

The sound of a shot rang through the air, and out of nowhere Zanic dropped dead. Zanic was the Silencer.

He was shot by none other than the famous Sheriff Frustro!

The town continuted on with their votes for lynching.

1. White Thunder - Townie
2. `Roxas`
3. white lancer - Hooker
4. Zanic - Silencer
5. Feral - Nurse
6. Shad~ - Townie
7. CtR Black
8. Frustro - Sheriff
9. Female Alpha Wolf
10. #85 - Townie
11. Serpe
12. Xhin
13. Jo Nathan
14. hezekiah
15. Trever Leingod
16. Count Dooku
17. chiefsonny
18. Redack - Special Club Member
19. Kassie the Eevee

Ratio: 2-8 (2)

Roles:
Ninja, Newcomer
Watcher, Tracker, Special Club Member x1, Nurse, Sheriff, Sleepwalker x3?, Townie x4?
Prosecutor, Defense Attorney.

September 11, 2012
Edit
MajorasMask9

This just became the most awesome round of the game so far.

September 11, 2012
Edit
Jo Nathan



September 11, 2012
Edit
Frustro

Ahahaha! 2 for 2 as Zanic would say if he weren't dead!

Excellent job to our sheriff, what an excellent play.

September 11, 2012
Edit
Count Dooku

*claps* Well done, Mister Sheriff!

So that's 2 down, 2 to go.

I think it's safe to say Count Dooku is in fact the Special Club Member, if there was any doubt.

September 11, 2012
Edit
Trever Leingod

I'll probably get killed for that, but totally worth it.

I was wanting to check out chiefsonny, given that he was pretty against lynching white lancer, and his activity ground to a halt as soon as the votes started piling against lancer. But then, half of us were wary, myself included, seeing how that was a risky move based off gut feeling alone.

I'm really unsure of trying to catch Mafia based off of how Zanic and white lancer voted. Given that those two had different votes cast, it's entirely possible the Mafia are avoiding acting as a group in the Town post.

But I'd like to take a look at Trever. The evidence really isn't that convicting, but the way he fully agreed with Zanic in Round 3 just doesn't make sense. He said we shouldn't vote based off gut feeling, but then remarks that given the role of the Ninja, it would be nigh-impossible to vote based off hard evidence anyway. So, what, do we just not vote at all then?

September 11, 2012
Edit
Frustro

... Well. Things just got interesting and awesome.

And if we're gonna make a list of suspicious people, I would add Kassie to your list, Frustro. Something just doesn't sit right with me.

September 11, 2012
Edit
Female Alpha Wolf

Great job Sheriff Frustro :D

Maybe we can win this game after all.

Good thing you didn't waste your time checking me out. For the 2nd time in the last 3 games I have a shit role. First Gambler and now townie.

If you don't get killed check out either FAW or Serpe. Just a feeling I have. Or you can check me out.

September 11, 2012
Edit
chiefsonny
 

But I'd like to take a look at Trever. The evidence really isn't that convicting, but the way he fully agreed with Zanic in Round 3 just doesn't make sense. He said we shouldn't vote based off gut feeling, but then remarks that given the role of the Ninja, it would be nigh-impossible to vote based off hard evidence anyway. So, what, do we just not vote at all then?

Well, look at it this way. A lot of lynches in the last game were "gut feelings", and they were wrong. And the town lost because of it. We cannot afford to go by mere gut feelings, not without solid evidence. Before white lancer and Zanic were killed, we actually had some solid evidence, mostly due to the fact they had the signature defensiveness of past Mafiosos. And then Dooku's clever report on Zanic through the course of the game.

As for the Ninja bit, I was considering the exploit that the Mafia are able to use with him. The Watcher/Tracker will not be able to spot him going after his target. Thankfully we took out the other two power roles, but we can't catch the Ninja. We can catch the Outsider though, assuming he is still looking to join the Mafia.

No, I am not saying we shouldn't vote, I am merely suggesting caution. And what's wrong with that? Lynching people recklessly won't be help the town, but sitting back and waiting for the Mafia to incriminate themselves can.

September 11, 2012
Edit
Trever Leingod

We can catch the Outsider though, assuming he is still looking to join the Mafia.


Given how lancer was suspected early on, I wonder if the Newcomer had already thought to visit him before he got lynched...

This isn't pertinent to the current game, but what if there were a "traitor" role, a person who switches teams halfway through the game? Especially if a traitor defects from the Mafia - I think that would make for one interesting day round before the Mafia kills him the next night.

I dunno, just thinking out loud here. {duck}

September 11, 2012
Edit
Jo Nathan

Its very unfortunate that the Ninja survives, as our watcher/tracker will probably be useless from this point on...

I'm not sure how to play from this point. If the Watcher and Tracker reveal what they've seen, we may be able to figure out some 'safe' people. If we see Trever visited me during the last night round, we can presume he's a sleepwalker and therefore safe.

It could help us narrow things down, but its likely that the mafia will target our watcher and tracker when/if they reveal.

If they don't reveal, however, it's the same case as Frustro. The longer they wait, the higher chance they die without helping out the town.

If everyone is in agreement, perhaps we should ask the Watcher and Tracker to present all of their findings on the next day round. That should give us 5 nights worth of information, and I think we'll seriously narrow down the mafia from it.

As for today, I'm a little suspicious of Trever for his roleclaim idea. While Trever presented the roleclaim as a way for the town to weed out the mafia, a roleclaim would also help the newcomer narrow down who his fellow mafia are so that he could join them.

If someone could be bothered (I would do it myself, but I have work shortly) assembling a list of the most inactive posters would be helpful as well. Anyone who has posted... oh... lets say less than 10 times the entire game should probably be scrutinized. The mafia love hiding among the inactive people.

That's my two cents for now.

September 11, 2012
Edit
Count Dooku

I should clarify that I meant Trever's original roleclaim idea on Day 1. He hasn't brought up the roleclaim today.

September 11, 2012
Edit
Count Dooku

I collected some statistics for y'all. I think this is all correct - I used a batch file to count 'em up. Sorry, I'm in a rush and don't have time to sort them.


Day 1
-----
White Thunder - 8
Roxas - 0
white lancer - 3
Zanic - 2
Feral - 9
Shad~ - 19
CtR Black - 2
Frustro - 3
Female Alpha Wolf - 2
#85 - 2
Serpe - 1
Xhin - 1
Jo Nathan - 1
hezekiah - 0
Trever Leingod - 5
Count Dooku - 5
chiefsonny - 5
Redack - 16
Kassie the Eevee - 0


Day 2
-----
White Thunder - 16
Roxas - 22
white lancer - 12
Zanic - 5
Feral - 22
Shad~ - 28
CtR Black - 1
Frustro - 4
Female Alpha Wolf - 2
#85 - 2
Serpe - 0
Xhin - 13
Jo Nathan - 7
hezekiah - 2
Trever Leingod - 2
Count Dooku - 18
chiefsonny - 3
Redack - dead
Kassie the Eevee - 5


Day 3
-----
White Thunder - 4
Roxas - 11
white lancer - 6
Zanic - 5
Feral - 1 despite being DEAD at this point {:P}
Shad~ - 10
CtR Black - 1
Frustro - 2
Female Alpha Wolf - 2
#85 - dead
Serpe - 1
Xhin - 2
Jo Nathan - 3
hezekiah - 3
Trever Leingod - 2
Count Dooku - 7
chiefsonny - 3
Redack - dead
Kassie the Eevee - 0


Totals for the first three days:
-----
White Thunder - 28
Roxas - 33
white lancer - 21
Zanic - 12
Feral - 32
Shad~ - 57
CtR Black - 4
Frustro - 9
Female Alpha Wolf - 6
#85 - 4
Serpe - 2
Xhin - 16
Jo Nathan - 11
hezekiah - 5
Trever Leingod - 9
Count Dooku - 30
chiefsonny - 11
Redack - 16
Kassie the Eevee - 5

September 11, 2012
Edit
Jo Nathan

Sorry, I probably should have clarified this: each number indicates how many posts that person did for that day.

September 11, 2012
Edit
Jo Nathan

aaaaaand one for today


September 12, 2012
Edit
CtR Black

Alright, Sheriff Dangle! {:D}

From watching previous games, I know that Dooku's intuition is pretty spot on. But I don't think the list above really helps distinguish anybody. 8/19 of us have <10 posts. So a lynching of any of them right this instant would only have a 25% chance of yielding good results. Like Trever said, not that we shouldn't do it. But it's for the best to wait for a pattern to emerge.

September 12, 2012
Edit
Serpe

Thanks for assembling that list Jo.

I'm particularly interested in hearing from CtR Black, Hezekiah, Serpe, and Female Alpha Wolf as to why they've not posted much. Particularly from Serpe, as it seems like that list made you post just to discredit it.

Frustro's presence is irrelevant since he's the sheriff.

#85 is dead

Kassie is apparently not very active to begin with and is a new player, but still worth watching.

Trever... I'm somewhat suspicious of him being the Newcomer but given he's been suggesting roleclaims for three games in a row it might just be nothing.

I'm not advocating lynching anyone purely based on posts, as I've found that hilariously damaging to the town in past games, I just think we need to be clear on why people aren't posting. I'm certain a mafia or two are using inactivity to fly below the radar, because after all, you can't say something suspicious if you say nothing at all...

September 12, 2012
Edit
Count Dooku

Honestly, I never really post much in these games. I kinda just prefer to read and watch and then make a decision (also because I can never seem to put my thoughts into words).

A few rounds back I mentioned I hadn't been on that day because the day was bad. That bad day turned into a bad week and it's starting to be a bad month (other reason why I don't really post a lot =/)

Add the fact that I'm just a townie this game and have no power role, the game isn't as exciting as last round. Granted that's not really an excuse, but I'm sure I'm not the first one who has felt that way.

September 12, 2012
Edit
Female Alpha Wolf

I wouldn't doubt at all if the Ninja was the one intentionally being inactive. We already know that's probably the most important Mafia role for this game, and I'm sure the Ninja him/herself knows that too, so they'd rather say nothing since that worked so well last game. Given that, I'm not too focused on Kassie, since she both brought attention to herself with her silenced claim, and was pretty active on Day 2. I'm sure if she was the Ninja, the other Mafia would've helped guide her to not act so rash.

September 12, 2012
Edit
Frustro

To be honest, I have to say the same, down to my status as a Townie. Though my absences are a little more intentional. Bad habit, I know x_x. So far, whether I post or not has been a matter of being name dropped (I posted about the list because I'd noticed that chiefsonny among others have pointed me out as a person of interest. I wouldn't want people getting the wrong idea.)

September 12, 2012
Edit
Serpe

But Frustro's post also raises an interesting point. Deliberately flying too low under the radar would be counterproductive for the Ninja or Newcomer. The last thing a Mafioso would do is be *so* inactive that the inactivity puts the spotlight on them. That's what I attribute to Zanic's and white lancer's relatively high post counts. Back-and-forth about accusations aside.

September 12, 2012
Edit
Serpe

There were 4 townies. 3 are dead.

White Thunder

Shad~

#85

Then I revealed

Good thing you didn't waste your time checking me out. For the 2nd time in the last 3 games I have a shit role. First Gambler and now townie.


Then after I revealed both

Serpe

I have to say the same, down to my status as a Townie



Female Alpha Wolf

Add the fact that I'm just a townie this game and have no power role


claimed to be townies.

Math don't add up boys and girls.(shocked)

September 12, 2012
Edit
chiefsonny
 

OK, forgot about the 3 Sleepwalker's. If they show up to the player themselves as being a townie, then they would think they are a townie. In that case there should be 4 townies left.

September 12, 2012
Edit
chiefsonny
 

I'd rather not have a Mexican standoff between us three, chief. If I'm not mistaken, we have yet to discover who our Sleepwalker(s) is/are, and they would appear as Townies to themselves.

September 12, 2012
Edit
Serpe

Ninja'd :(

September 12, 2012
Edit
Serpe

Ninja'd


Very poor choice of words. {duck}

September 12, 2012
Edit
Frustro

But Frustro's post also raises an interesting point. Deliberately flying too low under the radar would be counterproductive for the Ninja or Newcomer. The last thing a Mafioso would do is be *so* inactive that the inactivity puts the spotlight on them. That's what I attribute to Zanic's and white lancer's relatively high post counts. Back-and-forth about accusations aside.

Being inactive is actually historically a very good way to survive for a while as mafia...

Given what Chiefsonny just reminded us of, if we assume the mafia haven't been hasty to claim yet, we've got our safe roles:

3x townie/sleepwalker: Chiefsonny, Serpe, Female Alpha Wolf

1x Prosecutor: Xhin

1x Special Club: Dooku

1x Sheriff: Frustro

1. `Roxas` - ???
2. CtR Black - ???
3. Frustro - Sheriff (CONFIRMED)
4. Female Alpha Wolf - Townie (CLAIM)
5. Serpe - Townie (CLAIM)
6. Xhin - Prosecutor (Pretty certain)
7. Jo Nathan - ???
8. hezekiah - ???
9. Trever Leingod - ???
10. Count Dooku - Special Club Member
11. chiefsonny - Townie (CLAIM)
12. Kassie the Eevee - ???

The numbers add up, I think...

Of the remaining people:

Roxas, CTR, Jo Nathan, Hezekiah, Trever, Kassie

The following roles are most likely present:

1x Tracker
1x Watcher
1x Newcomer
1x Ninja
1x Townie/Sleepwalker
1x Defense Attorney

Its certainly possible that the mafia false claimed a townie (or two) but I think its more likely that they haven't had reason to.

Now, looking at the list compiled by Jo, I think I'd guess the final mafia are something like this:

Hezekiah (tends to be gone a lot, works out well for him when he's mafia because of inactivity excuses. His absence could explain the very long night round we had a while back)

CTR Black (Layed low when I was mafia with him last game, worked out well for him)

Trever (Roleclaim idea being his ticket into the mafia, I think he was the Newcomer if he is mafia)

September 12, 2012
Edit
Count Dooku

To add on:

Roxas may well be mafia too, as he's typically a power player but hasn't said much of anything this game...

Kassie I feel is safe. She was the only one that had 0 posts on Day 3, so she was clearly silenced.

Jo Nathan I haven't played with enough to base anything on his behavior, but he hasn't raised any red flags yet.

Anyway, I'm off to bed. Look forward to seeing everyones take on this tomorrow.

September 12, 2012
Edit
Count Dooku

The more people who role claim, the easier it will be for Mafia to pick out the Tracker and Watcher. Even if these two don't come forward, everyone who isn't Mafia and role claims Townie is probably telling the truth, which gives the Mafia a better chance of guessing who these power roles are. I don't like that... :/

September 12, 2012
Edit
Jo Nathan

The tracker and watcher are relatively useless at this point, though. They may be able to help identify sleepwalkers, but not much else.

I clearly wasn't paying attention last night when I said Roxas hasn't been very active this game. In light of this, and coupled with Kassie being basically inactive/not playing (it seems), I'm going to guess that Roxas was silenced, meaning he's town sided.

So if Roxas and Kassie have been silenced, they're temporarily innocent in my book. That leaves CTR, Hezekiah, Trever, and Jo Nathan.

Because of where we're at in the game right now, I think the mafia have a good chance of identifying our roles as I did in the list above. Because of this, I think its time to start filling in holes.

CTR, Hezekiah, Trever, and Jo should roleclaim. I'm fairly certain when they do we'll see the roles not add up and know who to go after.

That said, I think any of those four that continue to remain silent after this point can be assumed to be avoiding a roleclaim on purpose. In which case I think we should then lynch that person.

September 12, 2012
Edit
Count Dooku

i am a townie sir.

September 12, 2012
Edit
CtR Black

I suppose you're right about the Tracker and Watcher. If they are not of any use anymore, and everyone else is coming out and claiming Townie, I have no reason to not reveal I'm a Townie (or Sleepwalker). That means at least one person has lied at this point.

September 12, 2012
Edit
Jo Nathan

I'm just an ordinary townie WAIT I MEAN I'm not on a bad side so I can help you if you help me hehehe

September 12, 2012
Edit
Xhin
Sky's the limit

Okay, so we have a clear issue now that we have more townies than are possible.

I'm still requesting Hezekiah and Trever roleclaim.

September 12, 2012
Edit
Count Dooku

Kassie too, if she's not silenced/ignoring mafia...

September 13, 2012
Edit
Count Dooku

So then that means that at the very least, one person out of CtR Black, Female Alpha Wolf, Serpe, Jo Nathan, and chiefsonny should be a Mafia. And out of those, CtR, Serpe, and FMA have been relatively quiet during the game.

September 13, 2012
Edit
Frustro

That means that Roxas, Hezekiah, Kassie, or Trever make up the Watcher, Tracker, and Defense Attorney. Getting roleclaims from these people may give us an easy mafia kill. Then we focus our attention on the townie claims, which are more numerous.

September 13, 2012
Edit
Count Dooku

And out of those, CtR, Serpe, and FMA have been relatively quiet during the game.

Well I already explained why so.

For some reason I think that CTR has a power role and isn't just a Townie... And for some reason I think the same about Kassie despite her inactivity (if she isn't Mafia... that suspicion still hasn't left my mind)

September 13, 2012
Edit
Female Alpha Wolf

CTR's definitely rather high on my radar, and would probably be at the top of my list of townies to lynch first when we get around to it. But I think we really need to focus on the four I said in my last post right now. There's huge potential to weed out a mafia among them.

September 13, 2012
Edit
Count Dooku

But isn't it possible that the one who claims Townie in those four might legit be a Townie?

September 13, 2012
Edit
Frustro

Also I believe we have less than 12 hours to reach a decision...

September 13, 2012
Edit
Count Dooku

We have 5 town claims I believe... we can only have 4 legit townies. At least one claim is false.

September 13, 2012
Edit
Count Dooku

Right, but the person out of Roxas, hezekiah, Kassie, and Trever that claims Townie could really be a Townie. We know for a fact though that one person out of the five that've already claimed Townie has to be lying.

September 13, 2012
Edit
Frustro

is a new player

*returning player

Kassie I feel is safe. She was the only one that had 0 posts on Day 3, so she was clearly silenced.

I wasn't here on Day 3 (or last night) so I honestly don't know whether or not I was. I WAS silenced on the first day though, which I'm still not sure why no one believes me about.

Kassie too, if she's not silenced/ignoring mafia...

would anyone believe me if I did?

September 13, 2012
Edit
Kassie The Eevee

But isn't it possible that the one who claims Townie in those four might legit be a Townie?

True. But in that case, shouldn't there be more people willing to roleclaim? The last night and today were the times to do that if any.

Also I believe we have less than 12 hours to reach a decision...

Weird how the day hadn't ended yet. But that doesn't give us much time to observe the actions of the people on the roster. As far as that goes, I was a little put off that chiefsonny was so specific with who to keep an eye out for (myself and FAW) when a general warning would have sufficed. Then again, I could be reading too much into it.

September 13, 2012
Edit
Serpe

Based on Jo Nathan's post counting, everyone posted on Day 3 except for you. That means that even though you weren't here, you were silenced.

If you would please claim a role Kassie, it would greatly help our effort to weed out the guilty party. Since there's a good chance you're the watcher or tracker, please share your results with the town.

Weird how the day hadn't ended yet. But that doesn't give us much time to observe the actions of the people on the roster. As far as that goes, I was a little put off that chiefsonny was so specific with who to keep an eye out for (myself and FAW) when a general warning would have sufficed. Then again, I could be reading too much into it.

72 hours is the maximum time for a round.

September 13, 2012
Edit
Count Dooku

Also I misinterpreted the time. We have something like 22 hours remaining.

September 13, 2012
Edit
Count Dooku

Ah. In that case, we have a little more leeway.

September 13, 2012
Edit
Serpe

Due to the site being down earlier in the day, I'm going to extend the day round until 8:00am (EST) tomorrow unless you guys choose to lynch someone before then.

September 13, 2012
Edit
MajorasMask9

Thanks MM9.

September 13, 2012
Edit
Count Dooku

Time to get the ball rolling I guess.

The choice for me really comes down between Trever and Hezekiah, who have yet to post since I requested they role reveal. Hopefully Kassie will check the game again sometime within the next year and state her role, but at least she posted.

I'm voting for Hezekiah. He hasn't contributed much of anything this game and has been very inactive. In my experience playing against him, Hez makes a 'killing' as mafia by remaining quiet and excusing himself for real life troubles.

September 13, 2012
Edit
Count Dooku

ok guys, get ready, next round, i'm coming back, and i'm coming back stronger than ever! It's the rebirth of Chim-o the Reborn! (black)

September 14, 2012
Edit
CtR Black

Gee, we've only got until 8am (EST) tomorrow... I better get my vote in now while I have a chance. Even though Frustro nailed one this round, I'd hate to just have another no-kill.

After much deliberation, I decided on my vote in a careful, logical and scientific manner so I'm pretty confident in my choice.

September 14, 2012
Edit
Jo Nathan

I tried to get on earlier, but was thwarted by the DDOS. Watching Packers now, but I'm just a townie as far as I know.

September 14, 2012
Edit
hezekiah

I just want to point out to Dooku that I was not really that much into a role reveal this game. I considered it on the first day, depending on our conditions, but this round I was not going to push for it at all. We are doing fairly well now, and I really wouldn't want to risk a scatter-and-panic scenario like last game. But since you insist and others are following suit, I'll admit I'm a townie. Or at least as far as I know :$

I'm going to agree with Dooku and have a shot at hezekiah. He is quieter than usual and Dooku's instincts have shown to be quite good. Other things I noticed about hezekiah add up too. I'm pretty sure this is the way to go.

September 14, 2012
Edit
Trever Leingod

I'd vote for hezekiah, but I gotta be honest, I would feel more comfortable voting for someone who claimed Townie since we know at least two of them have lied at this point.

September 14, 2012
Edit
Jo Nathan

Or is that three who've lied now? I've lost track. {:s}

September 14, 2012
Edit
Jo Nathan

At least one's lied. There can only be four Townies, and at that point five were claiming the role. I'm wanting to vote for either CtR or chiefsonny, myself. Seeing how we're running on dangerously low time, I can only throw a vote in and hope for the best.

September 14, 2012
Edit
Frustro

(Ending the round a few minutes earlier than I said I would because I'm leaving in a few minutes.)

NIGHT FOUR

After Frustro's heroic shooting, the town decide to lynch CtR Black. He was the Defense Attorney. Poor CtR Black.

1. White Thunder - Townie
2. `Roxas`
3. white lancer - Hooker
4. Zanic - Silencer
5. Feral - Nurse
6. Shad~ - Townie
7. CtR Black - Defense Attorney
8. Frustro - Sheriff
9. Female Alpha Wolf
10. #85 - Townie
11. Serpe
12. Xhin
13. Jo Nathan
14. hezekiah
15. Trever Leingod
16. Count Dooku
17. chiefsonny
18. Redack - Special Club Member
19. Kassie the Eevee

Ratio: 2-8 (1)

Roles:
Ninja, Newcomer
Watcher, Tracker, Special Club Member x1, Sheriff, Sleepwalker x3?, Townie x4?
Prosecutor

Night will end in 24 hours or when all actions are in.

September 14, 2012
Edit
MajorasMask9

Well I really don't think that CtR's in the mafia. I'm laying in bed right now, and my phone still doesn't let me see the voting totals. If I'm seeing this right, me and him both have 2 votes. I'd rather no kill than take out somebody I think is innocent (he doesn't have any of that "mafia vibe" to him) so I think it's best to just let he round expire with this tie. I'll be quite upset if I read him wrong and he IS mafia, but I feel good about my read.

September 14, 2012
Edit
hezekiah

TOO LATE >:[

September 14, 2012
Edit
MajorasMask9

How'd I miscount? Who did I miss? At least he wasn't a town-sided role...

September 14, 2012
Edit
hezekiah

Reply to: game 11 night 4 actually night 4

Username
Password