Mafia

Okay, so for reasons beyond me CTR lied about being the DA. We're back to a scenario where it looks like one mafia is hiding in the townies.

2. `Roxas` (Needs to Claim)
9. Female Alpha Wolf (Townie CLAIM)
11. Serpe (Townie CLAIM)
12. Xhin (Prosecutor (Likely))
13. Jo Nathan (Townie CLAIM)
14. hezekiah (Townie CLAIM)
15. Trever Leingod (Townie CLAIM)
16. Count Dooku (Special Club Member CLAIM)
17. chiefsonny (Townie CLAIM)
19. Kassie the Eevee (Needs to Claim)

As it stands, I believe the mafia are solidly in with the townies.

Roxas and Kassie must make up the Watcher/Tracker.

From this point on, we need to start whittling away the townies. We have only 4 real townies, but 6 townie claims:

Female Alpha Wolf
Serpe
Jo Nathan
Hezekiah
Trever Leingod
Chiefsonny

I ask that the watcher and tracker give us all their results and claim their role.

From this point onward, the following players should be considered 'safe' barring a counter-claim:

Roxas
Xhin
Count Dooku
Kassie the Eevee

Unless something changes based on information from the tracker and watcher, I recast my vote for Hezekiah.

Edit of sorts:

Scratch that first part, CTR never said anything about being a townie.

Realized as I was doing my list that there are two false townie claims and never corrected my initial 'one mafia hiding with the townies' statement.

I don't know if I trust Kassie. She claims that she was silenced both days 1 and 3. I missed Day 1, and don't know if I was silenced for it. Regardless, it seems mighty unlikely that the mafia would silence somebody twice without good reason, and it doesn't seem to me like Kassie's play warranted repeated silencing (no offense). I wouldn't be surprised if the Watcher or Tracker was one of us townie claims, similar to what CtR did (whatever his reason for doing so was)... It feels to me like Kassie is trying to draw out a counterclaim, so the mafia would have one less power role to contend with.

Going back to last round, I messed up with counting votes. Should've been less lazy and booted up my computer to make sure I had the counts right. Silver lining is, CtR wasn't really helping us anyway. And if the posts he made are any indication, Count was his client. I'm sorry if my accidentally killing a neutral role is enough to convince you that I'm mafia, but fact is that's not the case. I mean, it's probable that at least one mafia is in the townie group with me, but I do know it's not me.

Turns out I was double wrong, CTR DID claim townie. My mistake... twice...

As for being his client... I wouldn't know.

That said, I find it interesting that I start pushing for you and NOW you want to make 'helpful' observations. Its a dramatic shift in behavior.

And one thing is for certain, Kassie was definitely silenced on Day 3. She was the only one that didn't post.

All things considered, you've confirmed your status as mafia in my eyes. Continued silence would have been your best bet, as maybe someone would have presented a better target as the round went on.

@Dooku: Ctr said in the Day 4 thread that he was a townie. "I am a townie sir."
@hezekiah: I didn't claim to be silenced on day 3. I said I wasn't here. I was silenced on the first day though. Zanic doesn't know me, how would he know on the first night that silencing me would be pointless? And I have to say that I'm equally suspicious of you.
I'll roleclaim, then. I am the tracker. Come at me, ninja.
Cheifsonny did not visit anyone the night I tracked him, so he can't be the ninja.
Roxas visited Dooku, so neither can he.

Scratch that, chief could. But I doubt it.

Thank you for the roleclaim, Kassie.

Unfortunately, the four players I listed, myself included, will undoubtedly be the mafia's next kills. The mafia's mission will be to have 0 special roles and a bunch of townies they can blend in with. Then its just a matter of sweet talking their way to victory.

Normally I'd be playing Minecraft right now, but other people are watching a movie. And the Brewers are sucking tonight, too.

I still don't totally trust that Kassie was silenced Day 1, but there's enough doubt now that I would feel more comfortable killing one of my fellow townie claimants. Of them, I feel like one of the mafia members is probably chief or FAW.

And there's a good chance you're mafia and are only pretending to be suspicious of me because suspicions were already raised. Same with FAW.

I am the Watcher.

Night 0: I watched Zanic. Nobody visited him.
Night 1: I missed this due to helping a friend move.
Night 2: I watched chiefsonny. Kassie visited him.
Night 3: I originally watched Dooku. I rescinded this decision and went with Frustro almost immediately afterwards. No visitors
Night 4: I watched Dooku. No visitors.

Also, immediately following Zanic's death, I messaged Frustro revealing my role to him. I requested he not say anything of my role or silencing.

ALSO, VERY BAD PUN, MM9!

Also, I have been suspicious of hezekiah and Serpe. Both haven't been overly active, though Kassie hasn't either (she is the Tracker!), so that would explain the elongated Night Rounds.

ALSO, VERY BAD PUN, MM9!

I think gtx0 broke because of it... or is it just me?

Well I've been overly suspicious of Kassie since the start of the game just because of the inactivity (same with Serpe), but now its overly obvious she's innocent.

I have some other thoughts, but I'ma think about them more before I vote.

Going by what happened to CtR, it's safe to say that activity levels are hit-and-miss as evidence when it comes to weeding out Mafia. While I still have my doubts about chief, Kassie makes a good point. Hez voted for her despite evidence pointing to her roleclaim, seemingly just because. That to me is suspicious enough.

I'm recasting my vote for hezekiah like before. Things are just leaning towards him being Mafia.

It seems the Tracker and Watcher didn't really confirm the innocence or guilt of anyone =/ Rather unfortunate we did not get any info particularly on the ones that are still possible suspects.

Well, my vote's the last one. Let's see who you really are, hez.