Engines	Aether	Legend of the Lunar Priest	NIFE Roadmap
Shatterloop	Game Projects	Deprecated	Starwright
Saepes Mundi	Other Projects	Blog

Mafia

Moderated by: Speed Bike Pro

What is Mafia? Mafia Rules Mafia Roles Player Scores Player Scores Info Game Archive The Star Wars Republic/Empire Game Mafia Player Profiles Host Priority List

game 15 over

Posted March 14, 2013 by Helius

Quote Edit

“What do you have to say for yourself, Lancer?” asked White Thunder, Governor.

“Nothing.”

With this, the town was going to put a noose around his neck, but White Lancer, The Executioner bit down on a cyanide pill hidden inside his back molar. It killed him within a matter of seconds.

The town rejoiced as the final Mafia member was killed. Lancerville was theirs until the next crew came in.

1. `Roxas` - Townie
2. ~~white lancer~~ – Executioner Dead
3. White Thunder - Governor
4. ~~Black Yoshi~~ –Mafioso (Arrested/Dead)
5. ~~MajorasMask9~~ – Townie (Arrested/Dead)
6. Female Alpha Wolf - Townie
7. Count Dooku – FBI Agent
8. ~~Castrael~~ –Janitor (Dead)
9. ~~CtR Black~~ – Journalist Dead
10. ~~hezekiah~~ – Townie (Arrested/Dead)
11. ~~Jo Nathan~~ – Godfather (Arrested/Dead)
12. Feral - Townie
13. ~~Redack~~ –Psychiatrist (Dead)
14. chiefsonny - Townie
15. ~~Trever Leingod~~ –Townie (Dead)
16. Xhin - Townie
17. Vandy - Cop

Sorry it took so long. I was in civil court this morning for my internship and I tried to update it by phone before court, but my phone reset. I have class all day, but I do have an idea of player scores and what went wrong this game. I’ll post all that relevant information later on this day.

Good job everyone! Well played!

There are 28 Replies

Enable Post Pagination

What went wrong is that Cas gave away two other mafia members {:P}

March 14, 2013

Edit

Redack

great job hosting, helius

game 16 soon?

March 14, 2013

Edit

Vandy

Sigh. v.v Still feel bad.

March 14, 2013

Edit

Castrael

Don't feel bad, Cas!

Let me share with you some of my Mafia history:

Acted crazy, got myself lynched and lost it for the town at the end of my first game.

First time being Mafia - was completely non-suspicious for nearly all of the game... made some dumb moves at the very end and lost it for the Mafia.

Basically committed suicide by killing you in the Christmas game.

Had mild suspicions of Majora, used vigilante powers to kill Roxas instead.

Game 14 - Went thermo-nuclear on White Thunder - turned out to be innocent.

{:P}

March 14, 2013

Edit

Jo Nathan

Game 14 - Went thermo-nuclear on White Thunder - turned out to be innocent.

Uh uh. I started that one and it was entirely my fault. Looks like I made the right call by playing more quietly this game.

March 14, 2013

Edit

White Thunder

End Game:

1. `Roxas` (+1 for surviving and winning team) (2 points)
2. white lancer (+1 for being last man standing, +1 for good play) (2 points)
3. White Thunder (+1 for winning team and +1 surviving) (2 points)
4. Black Yoshi (+1 pity point and team play) (2 points)
5. MajorasMask9 – (+1 for winning team)(1 point)
6. Female Alpha Wolf (+1 for winning team and surviving) (2 points)
7. Count Dooku (+2 for nailing Mafia members, +1 for winning team) (3 points)
8. Castrael (+1 for pity) (1 point)
9. CtR Black  (+1 for influencing Cas’ death, +1 pity point) (2 points)
10. hezekiah (+1 for winning team) (1 point)
11. Jo Nathan  (+1 for team play and pity) (2 points)
12. Feral (+1 for winning team and surviving) (2 points)
13. Redack  (+1 for Curing Insane, +2 for Good Play, +1 for Winning team) (4 points)
14. chiefsonny (+1 for winning team and surviving) (2 points)
15. Trever Leingod (+1 for winning team)(1 point)
16. Xhin (+1 for winning team) (1 point)
17. Vandy (+1 for winning team and team play, surviving) (3 points)

Missed Opportunities

The Mafia had a huge set back because of a few things. Lancer was only allowed to be on at certain points in time in the very beginning. Castrael’s set back with being thrown into a power role so early on and not being able to defend herself properly. There was also Castrael’s vote against Black Yoshi and Jo Nathan. Jo covered himself properly and he’ll show up as innocent since he’s the Godfather. There was also the lynching of MM9 when there were other more important targets to lynch. Yoshi and Jo both suspected Ctr being the Journalist. I would have lynched him because of the suspicion.

The town had set backs because there wasn’t really anything going for them really other than the Seer, Redack. There were also mistakes made in logic and reasoning, but I won’t mention those cause it seemed to have worked out. There were also key individuals who could have stepped up and made a huge impact on the game, but chose to play quietly. I was half way expecting Feral to have some sort of dream.

End Game:

1. `Roxas` (+1 for surviving and winning team) (2 points)
2. white lancer (+1 for being last man standing, +1 for good play) (2 points)
3. White Thunder (+1 for winning team and +1 surviving) (2 points)
4. Black Yoshi (+1 pity point and team play) (2 points)
5. MajorasMask9 – (+1 for winning team)(1 point)
6. Female Alpha Wolf (+1 for winning team and surviving) (2 points)
7. Count Dooku (+2 for nailing Mafia members, +1 for winning team) (3 points)
8. Castrael (+1 for pity) (1 point)
9. CtR Black (+1 for influencing Cas’ death, +1 pity point) (2 points)
10. hezekiah (+1 for winning team) (1 point)
11. Jo Nathan (+1 for team play and pity) (2 points)
12. Feral (+1 for winning team and surviving) (2 points)
13. Redack (+1 for Curing Insane, +2 for Good Play, +1 for Winning team) (4 points)
14. chiefsonny (+1 for winning team and surviving) (2 points)
15. Trever Leingod (+1 for winning team)(1 point)
16. Xhin (+1 for winning team) (1 point)
17. Vandy (+1 for winning team and team play, surviving) (3 points)

Missed Opportunities

The Mafia had a huge set back because of a few things. Lancer was only allowed to be on at certain points in time in the very beginning. Castrael’s set back with being thrown into a power role so early on and not being able to defend herself properly. There was also Castrael’s vote against Black Yoshi and Jo Nathan. Jo covered himself properly and he’ll show up as innocent since he’s the Godfather. There was also the lynching of MM9 when there were other more important targets to lynch. Yoshi and Jo both suspected Ctr being the Journalist. I would have lynched him because of the suspicion.

The town had set backs because there wasn’t really anything going for them really other than the Seer, Redack. There were also mistakes made in logic and reasoning, but I won’t mention those cause it seemed to have worked out. There were also key individuals who could have stepped up and made a huge impact on the game, but chose to play quietly. I was half way expecting Feral to have some sort of dream.

March 14, 2013

Edit

Helius

Unless the scoring system was changed you have it wrong.

How to gain points:

You can gain 2 point for being on the winning team of the game.

You can gain 1 point by being alive at the end of the game.

You get 2 points for being on the winning team not 1.

March 14, 2013

Edit

chiefsonny

The biggest setback for the mafia was clearly the gtx0 coin prediction.

March 14, 2013

Edit

MajorasMask9

Also Arrested has counted as surviving in the past.

March 14, 2013

Edit

hezekiah

Also Arrested has counted as surviving in the past.

I don't think so. That's why the word dead was added.

March 14, 2013

Edit

chiefsonny

Hezy's right that Yeano always gave out survival points if you were arrested. We should probably keep that consistent. Also, winning does count as 2 points rather than 1.

I didn't feel like I ever really got going in this game. I wound up deciding to go out of town and visit some friends the weekend the game started, and by the time I got back Castrael had already been outed. Night Talk being on didn't help--it meant I had more stuff I needed to go through to catch up, and I felt paranoid that if I was online people would notice and wonder why I wasn't posting in the main thread. Add on to that the fact that I've literally blocked this site on my computer for a good chunk of every weekday and that this last weekend was my birthday, and it was tough to maintain the activity I would have needed to really get my head in the game. My analysis wasn't on point this game and a lot of it wasn't as thorough as it should have been due to a number of factors.

Cas being caught on the very first night was a huge problem for us, especially because she immediately linked herself to two others. I personally would have ruled that she didn't leave her house in Night 0 because the Mafia didn't make a kill, but that was Helius' call to make (thus it's not the wrong call). Once I realized the ratio was going to be 9-1-1 with the Cop and FBI Agent still active, the game seemed like it was pretty much over.

March 14, 2013

Edit

white lancer

Also, I'm giving Helius a player point because he did a good job as Host (as many of you have noted (: ).

March 14, 2013

Edit

white lancer

Oh yeah, and Dooku doesn't get points for being on the winning team--he was a third-party role. He does get a survival point, though, so his total for this game stays at 3.

March 14, 2013

Edit

white lancer

[p:70924|Game 12] had survival points given to people who were arrested.

March 14, 2013

Edit

hezekiah

Muh points :(

March 15, 2013

Edit

Count Dooku

Reading through the mafia thread, was reminded of Feral identifying the Journalist due to "Mafia? or town"... I didn't consider that indicative of someone with grammar errors; I thought it was a conscious choice, as if CtR was asking a leading question.

March 15, 2013

Edit

hezekiah

White lancer is going to feel silly as heck when he realizes how Redack figured out the cop. I did and I didn't even care who the cop was for most of the game! It's just such a classic series of events that stuck out individually, but I never would have thought of them when trying to prove who the cop was.

I think he realizes now, after Vandy revealed. He thought the cop would not have been so obvious about his role.

Right on both counts. {:(} By the time I made my decision, I knew it wasn't Thunder, Feral, Roxas, Xhin, or FAW. I was pretty sure it wasn't chief and only considered him because there was a chance he was making so many references to the Cop to throw us off. And, well, I mostly forgot about Vandy as a possibility--I thought he was just being funny and it didn't even occur to me that the Cop would intentionally throw out hints like that. Trever was basically my choice by process of elimination, and the quote I posted in the Mafia thread seemed like something you could draw a conclusion from.

Also, I thought the Governor was Roxas, but him getting so defensive when Feral accused him made me wonder. Thunder was my second pick.

And I would have enjoyed my other role better. Of all the roles in this game, the FBI Agent was the one I wanted, and what do you know, I get it...only for it to be taken away with the reset. {:(}

March 15, 2013

Edit

white lancer

And yeah, hezy, I felt similarly, which is why I didn't push to kill CtR that night. Didn't feel like I could get a good read off of so little, but it was a good call on Yoshi's part.

March 15, 2013

Edit

white lancer

I gave three hints

well, one dead giveaway. I instantly regretted this. not sure how the mafia didn't see that

and I was talking to myself

and then I voted "no kill" after basically saying "let's kill someone," pointing towards my problematic decision-making process at the time

not that the town needed me anyway :p

March 15, 2013

Edit

Vandy

1. `Roxas` - 3 points
2. white lancer - 2 points
3. White Thunder -3 points
4. Black Yoshi - 2 points
5. MajorasMask9 –3 point
6. Female Alpha Wolf -3 points
7. Count Dooku -4 points
8. Castrael -1 point
9. CtR Black - 4 points
10. hezekiah -3 point
11. Jo Nathan -3 points
12. Feral - 3 points
13. Redack -5 points
14. chiefsonny -3 points
15. Trever Leingod -3 points
16. Xhin -3 points
17. Vandy -4 points

That look right now?

I'm amazed that I got it over and updated anyhow. Today was an extremely busy day.

March 15, 2013

Edit

Helius

I didn't catch those hints either. Darn.

@Dooku, love the Hemingway/Donne/Metallica reference (not sure which!)

Also, from what I'm seeing, all of you non-Townie roles are boring. TALK MORE

March 15, 2013

Edit

`Roxas`

I just read the Mafia thread, Lancer gave me too much credit.

At some point, I really did forget I was playing third party :P He's quite right, it WOULD have been smarter for me to try and mislead the town while I went after those who were more likely to be guilty.

March 15, 2013

Edit

Count Dooku

Heh, Dooku, I was so convinced you were going to arrest me that night round that I didn't bother to go back and re-read the first couple of rounds of posts like I planned. I'm almost certain I still wouldn't have picked up on Vandy anyway, though...was hoping you WOULD arrest me, cause then at least I would have gotten a survival point. I even considered PMing you and confessing, but I just couldn't bring myself to give up if there was even a sliver of a hope that I could survive. ;D

@Helius: Dooku should get 3 points (2 for arrests, 1 for surviving) and CtR should get 2 points (1 for helping the Town lynch Cas, and 1 for your pity point)--third party roles don't get victory points. Other than that, it looks all good!

I'm going to get the sign-ups for the next game up. I don't think I can edit the documents in this forum for whatever reason--could an admin update the player scores (with my amendments in the previous paragraph) up there when they get a chance?

March 15, 2013

Edit

white lancer

For the admins' reference, the player scores should be exactly like Helius' most recent post, with the following changes:

Count Dooku: 3 points
CtR Black: 2 points
Helius: 1 point

March 15, 2013

Edit

white lancer

Omg I think I have enough points for a new medal now! :D

March 15, 2013

Edit

Female Alpha Wolf

Yep, FAW! Also, the scores from the last game haven't been put in either. So add these ones in:

4 points:
hezekiah

3 points:
Count Dooku
Black Yoshi
MajorasMask9

1 point:
Castrael
CtR Black
Jo Nathan

March 15, 2013

Edit

white lancer

Vandy is also going to go up a step in medals.

I wonder if it would be possible to get an even better medal for players who reach 50 points? MM9 and chief are getting close.

March 15, 2013

Edit

white lancer

Platinum medals!

March 15, 2013

Edit

Count Dooku

Username
Password
Preview

Mafia

game 15 over

There are 28 Replies

Reply to: game 15 over