Mafia

I vote for White Lancer

Howdy, CtR! I was so worried I was going to get recruited by the Cultists, haha, so at least now I don't have to worry about that.

I was the Doctor before, so if I die and someone claims Doctor, you can call them out.

Hey there!

Wow unlucky that i recruit the doctor.

But I suppose it is better you're a mason than a cultist.

Yeah, for sure. I was pretty much only going to protect myself anyway as the Doctor because I didn't want to risk saving a Cultist, so it's not too much of a loss. Good call on me not being Mafia, though.

By the way, I think #85 is a little suspicious. He was a little too gung-ho in going after Knukles last round--I obviously can't be sure of it, but I'd stay away from recruiting him.

Organizing my thoughts:

#85 is still my greatest suspicion. My guess is that he is silenced this round (it's either him or poptart), but last game when we were Mafia together I suggested silencing one of our own Mafia members to make us seem less suspicious and I wouldn't be surprised if he tried that tactic this time. Aside from him, I see LLight and Knukles as being a little suspicious, probably enough so that we should avoid recruiting them for the time being.

I'm not really suspicious of Roxas, Shadowwalked, or chiefsonny, but they haven't done much to make me think they're innocent, either. We haven't really heard from poptart, so I've no clue on him, but he probably isn't worth recruiting anyway.

That leaves Zanic, hezekiah, MajorasMask9, and Teddy-Son as likely Townies, although I'm not sure on any of them. MajorasMask9 would probably be more likely to be recruited by the Cultists if we get to him first, meaning recruiting him might help us to wipe them out, but he's also more likely to get killed by the Mafia. If we're just looking to increase our network, Teddy-Son or Zanic might be a better bet.

Oh, and if the Cop does come out and say that someone is Guilty, we should obviously vote with him and then we should recruit him. That way, the Cultists won't be able to take him, and he should cast all of the recruitment votes for the Masons to ensure that we don't lose someone who isn't as obviously safe.

That's almost exactly along the lines of what i was thinking.

Roxas doesnt seem to be sticking out very much, which makes me kinda iffie on whether or not he's a mafia.

I'm actually afraid knuckles is a mafia member. He seems pretty bent on lynching someone. I don't feel safe debating with him, cause I dont want to seem a threat to the mafia.

marjora is playing exactly like last game, so if he's mafia it'd be the perfect way to blind in.

I was thinking the safest vote for the night round would be teddy-son.

Alright, we could recruit Teddy. I'm a little nervous about his last post ("LLight is confusing therefore he must be Mafia!") but I'm not certain he would be the sort of player to attempt that kind of aggression as Mafia.

Only one of us should need to vote during the next night round, while the other one just doesn't cast any vote at all. I'm fine with taking the risk since you took the first risk. Plus I wouldn't be too surprised if I became a target for the Mafia anyway. And if I die and Teddy doesn't join us here, at least you'll know that he's Mafia.

I'm not sure either now. I first thought he was joking, but he is voting for Llight. but he may still be joking about that comment.

but either way, one vote would be enough, so if you die I'll know he's a mafia.

#85 doesnt very suspicious to me. He did however make knuckles seem very suspicious.

I dont believe 85 has much to gain from lynching knuckles. However he does have a lot to lose; if we lynch and he's wrong he'd probably be suspected of being mafia and then himself be lynched. so that would be a 1 mafia lost for 1 townie, and since there are only 2 mafia i dont think thats a smart gamble for the mafia.

In my opinion we're looking at Llight and Knuckles as being special roles.

85 could be faking being silenced this round though

I still think #85 is extremely suspicious, just in the way that he went after Knukles--it seemed like he was taking every little thing Knukles said and twisting it to make it sound like he was Mafia. He also decided he wanted to take a gamble immediately when he's historically been against that.

I also think he was using a lot of the same arguments we used last game to try to get Knukles lynched--he's a loose cannon, he's changing his vote, etc. Knukles is just a naturally suspicious character and if the Mafia could get away with putting suspicion on anyone, it would be him. Not to mention that #85 theorized that Knukles was a special role even if he wasn't Mafia, but was still okay with killing him.

Obviously I can't be 100% sure, but there's enough about how #85 has been posting to make me highly suspicious of him. Knukles is also suspicious, though, and I wouldn't want to recruit either of them.

not voting

I'm really nervous about voting tonight haha, but gotta hope for the best!

I vote Teddy-Son.

I vote for Zanic

zanic dont let em know ur a mason, so we can get the cultists

marjora is trying to bait you out. he is obviously a cultist

I vote for poptart

actually i rescind my vote.

do they win if their number equals the number of the town?

Edit: nevermind I'm still voting for poptart

Sorry. Been busy all day. Why thank you CtR. I'm honored! Told you I was a townie.

And sure. Poptart. Let's go.

And after him, I'm thinking Majora or Roxas.

you can pick this time zanic.

no vote

i just realized we have to kill a cultist unless they try to recruit you. i think marjora is a cultist. he earlier said that he was a mason and then changed it.

but its your vote buddy

I vote MajorasMask9

Since Roxas is the cop, no point in recruiting him.

Now that i think of it, roxas may well be lying.

but theres a 4 out of 6 chance we will hit a cultist, so whatever your choice is

And if we don't they become a mason anyway.

So I think it might be safe to say that we win already