Depending on the roles, I would say 7-3 for sure. 6-4 could be over in a matter of two rounds.

Depending on the "items" you have in mind, plus with the couple killing roles that you plan on using, I would really like more players on the town side but 3 is a good number of mafia. If chiefsonny signs up, I would be pretty okay with 8-3. If even more people somehow sign up, I would suggest adding more town-sided roles but leaving the mafia at 3.

As for inactivity, I like that you want to be a little more lenient but it's something that we need to crack down on. I still want host killing to be a thing but I'll leave the guidelines up to you before I approve, whether it be something like 2 full rounds or 3 half-rounds (day-night-day or night-day-night). As soon as a player fails to participate during a day round or something, make it abundantly clear in your next thread that they are in danger of being host killed.

Neat; add chiefsonny and EvilGuy to the list of players.

EvilGuy0613

I'm somewhat conflicted on the Mafia Investigator, that combined with the Janitor seems like a potentially OP duo. However, I think the 3-9 ratio balances it out somewhat well. A Hooker would also go well in that spot but I think the Investigator would be fine.

Yeah, I think the Hooker may be a better fit in that composition than a Janitor.

Nevermind, with Dooku being added, I think a 10-3 ratio with Godfather/Investigator/Janitor would be okay.

Definitely keep as is.

What's your plan now that Chaos Incarnate signed up?

I switched Kaot0 to Kaotic, I just need you to reassign all the roles and we should be fine.