Engines Aether Legend of the Lunar Priest NIFE Roadmap
Shatterloop Game Projects Deprecated Starwright
Saepes Mundi Other Projects Blog  

Mafia

Moderated by: Speed Bike Pro

game 39 post game discussion and points

Posted November 10, 2015 by Lady Flare

Points

1. Xhin – (0) low participation even in the Mafia thread.

2. Growlithe: (+2 winning) It sucks dying early.

3. Hezekiah: (+2 good playing) So close…

4. Knuckles: (+3 = +2 winning, +1 surviving) I hope you continue to play in the future. .

5. RockyT: (-1 not participating) That says it all.

6. Feral Wolf: (+3 = +2 winning, +1 good playing) Good effort but bad luck to be Marked so early on.

7. white lancer (+5 = +2 winning, +1 surviving, +2 good playing) As always, you had some great ideas.

8. White Thunder : (+3 = +2 winning, +1 good playing) I think you had fun with this role. It should be added to the Roles List.

9. Vandy: (+4 = +2 winning, +1 surviving, +1 good playing) you were instrumental for the Town’s win. Good Job!

10. Ophelia: (+2 winning) I hope you play in future games. I’m not sure it was a good idea to give a new player a power role on their first play through. But that’s my opinion.

11. FAW: (+1 good playing) A good attempt.

12.chiefsonny: (+2 winning) You were dealt a bit of a bad hand which I think may have put you off this game.

13.Lady Flare: (+2 winning)

Additional Comments

Thank you Hezekiah for updating the stuff I couldn’t. I just noticed I can lock and sticky threads. I don’t like to click things that I don’t know what they do. It would be so embarrassing if I had to ask someone to go to the Mafia panel and fix stuff I messed up. So Thank you.

Just a note about role descriptions. I had my little rant in the Dead Thread. But I would just like to reiterate my suggestion. In future games, could the host please explicitly make clear any role restriction even if they are implied. It will make things easier for the players and any co-hosts.

All in all, I think this was a good game. It went down to the wire which makes things exciting. I hope everyone had fun playing and watching.

Any further comments or point appeals?

There are 16 Replies

extensionEnable Post Pagination

I don't know how to open threads.

November 10, 2015
Edit
Lady Flare

Thank you for taking up the hosting duties! Elsewise the game would have perished. Did we ever find out what happened to Speed?

November 10, 2015
Edit
Vandy

I personally would have used the Drunk as the doc defined it, but take no issue with you defining it differently for this game. I think the rationale for the targeting restriction is so that it can't just shut someone down for the whole game.

Thanks for stepping in as host. I had the same thought in the Mafia thread, having the others take my power and moving myself to Host.

I opened up the role threads. To do that you just need to delete everything but Host from the list of roles.

I don't like the comment you made about Ophelia's points; there shouldn't be any consideration given to a player's experience when assigning roles.

Mafia inactivity was really rough to deal with. I think we'd have had a good shot at getting Knuckles killed over Xhin, but he wasn't around to play his part. Oh well.

November 10, 2015
Edit
hezekiah

So close..

November 10, 2015
Edit
Female Alpha Wolf

I don't like the comment you made about Ophelia's points; there shouldn't be any consideration given to a player's experience when assigning roles.

I agree. Also, while the Feral block was not good, the Knuckles block was more bad luck than anything else (he was actually a reasonable target that night--she had no reason to believe he was a power role).

Mafia inactivity was really rough to deal with. I think we'd have had a good shot at getting Knuckles killed over Xhin, but he wasn't around to play his part. Oh well.

Yeah, that might have happened. I was so thrown by the lack of a Sniper kill that I might have gone along with it if Xhin had sounded convincing. Seemed like by far the most likely reason for no Sniper kill was that they got blocked by the Drunk, so him being targeted that day put him way up on my radar.

Also, I didn't articulate this well at the time, but the reason I turned on FAW when I did was because her post simply reiterated my point about Vandy. It felt so much like she was trying to get me to start a bandwagon against him, and Vandy was making some good points that made me less suspicious of him at the start of the round. Before that day round, though, I had an innocent reading on her because she seemed like she was being helpful strategically.

November 10, 2015
Edit
white lancer

Thanks Lady Flare for stepping up and taking over the Hosting duties.

This could have been a good game if a couple of the roles had been tweaked a little.

But that said, what hurt this game the most was the 9 days where nothing happened and we were given no explanation, that imo broke up the flow of the game and probably added to the inactivity.

As much as I have loved playing the Mafia game, I think it's run it's course and should be turned off. I will be recommending this in the Mod Forum.

Just want to say thanks to those that did stick it out and play.

November 10, 2015
Edit
chiefsonny
 

It might be good for it to go on a bit of a hiatus. But I don't think it should be done with permanently.

November 10, 2015
Edit
Vandy

Yeah, I agree with a Vandy. I enjoy watching the game.

But, I do think there should be a new executive host for Mafia. That's probably worth bringing up too chiefsonny. It just goes to show that Speed has lost interest in Mafia all together.

This is my opinion, of course.

November 10, 2015
Edit
Castrael

I would support a hiatus.

I agree with Cas. it needs a new new executive host.

November 10, 2015
Edit
chiefsonny
 

Well that was interesting near the end.

I've actually tried to get a few new people who are not from this site to try this but so far they've shown no interest.

November 10, 2015
Edit
KnokkelMillennium
 

This was fun.

November 11, 2015
Edit
White Thunder

would you be up for the executive hosting position, chief? maybe that would renew your interest in the game.

November 11, 2015
Edit
Vandy

Not at this time. To much stuff going on irl.

November 11, 2015
Edit
chiefsonny
 

I would be interested, except for the fact that I am a terrible host due to my shortsitedness.

I'd say Lancer is the best bet if he is interested, as he has previous experiences. Hezy could also do well.

November 12, 2015
Edit
Feral Wolf
The Rogue Wolf

Eh, it's a possibility. I'd do it if no one else was able/willing. But I'm not any less busy than I was when I originally resigned, so if there's someone who has the time and energy they're welcome to it.

November 13, 2015
Edit
white lancer

I'd be willing to do it, anything to keep these games alive.

November 13, 2015
Edit
Ghowilo

This thread is locked