Engines Aether Legend of the Lunar Priest NIFE Roadmap
Shatterloop Game Projects Deprecated Starwright
Saepes Mundi Other Projects Blog  

Mafia

Moderated by: Speed Bike Pro

game 5 thread 4 night 4 rebound for the town and yes the round ended with sufficient votes i

Posted May 15, 2012 by Yeano

Continued from [p:65311]

Day 4.

Screams of pain could be heard through the night. Screams! But no one could exactly identify where they were coming from. In the morning, the town found a giant statue on top of #85. He had been chained to the ground and forced to watch the statue slowly being lowered onto him, eventually crushing him. He was a Townie.

Additionally, Bubba came to the meeting with a wound in his chest. Seems he was shot! Fortunately, it appears that he had an operation to take care of the wound.

1. Shadowwalked
2. CtR Black - Townie
3. Teddy-Son
4. Redack
5. #85 - Townie
6. Count Dooku - Mafia Investigator
7. MajorasMask9 - Ghoul
8. hezekiah
9. Helius
10. Eagle0
11. `Roxas`
12. Zanic
13. Xhin - Insane Cop
14. poptart!
15. Knukles2000
16. Bubba
17. white lancer - Townie
18. DragonintheShadow - Sensor
19. chiefsonny - Arsonist

Godfather, Mafia Investigator, Silencer, Mafioso, Lunatic Vigilante, Sensor, Cop, Doctor, Psychiatrist, Arsonist, Double-voter, Ghoul, Townie.

Mafia-Town Ratio: 4-7

72 hours or 7 votes.

WARNING: If your role changes to "Silenced," you may NOT post in this thread. If you do, you will be host-killed.

There are 78 Replies

extensionEnable Post Pagination

I tagged a post by #85 that seems like it may interfere with the game...

May 15, 2012
Edit
hezekiah

At any rate, i'm shocked that one of Roxas's for the most part BLIND suspicions were correct. However, we have to remember this dosn't instantly validate his claims. He only claimed to be a townie, but he could easily have used Dooku as a sacrificial lamb to throw us off like what happened last game. Thus, he could still be mafia, and his actions are strange for a townie... Imo, I think he COULD be right about Teddy.. the rest though, I don't see it. Plus he was wrong about White Lancer.

Heres my suspects:

Roxas

Poptart!

Bubba

Redack.

such, i'm voting Roxas unless given a reason to do otherwise.

May 15, 2012
Edit
Knukles2000

This is hezekiah making a post as #85 to conceal the vote he cast while dead.

May 15, 2012
Edit
#85

Well I'm not sure about Roxas right now, but that's not what I want to look at right now anyway...

Clearly somebody targeted Bubba for a kill last night, and the Doctor saved him. We were either lucky or unlucky. Hard to say which, though...

May 15, 2012
Edit
hezekiah

Knukles. I don't think it's Roxas anymore. Last round he went against Count Dooku completely and he was a mafia. As for Redack, Bubba, and Poptart!, I'm not sure. But I'm starting to suspect you. You sided with Dooku last round.

May 15, 2012
Edit
Zanic

I'm going to randomly vote and see where it gets me till we have an idea of the next lynching.

May 15, 2012
Edit
Helius

That didn't work.

May 15, 2012
Edit
Helius

-_- Nor did that.

May 15, 2012
Edit
Helius

By the way, Roxas is ID 1242. If you want to cast a vote for him, it's possible to do so by using that info. Here's an example:

May 15, 2012
Edit
hezekiah

And now, canceling that vote. Like last time, going to No Kill because I can't completely retract my vote and we need to make a kill.

May 15, 2012
Edit
hezekiah

I sided with no one last round. And i'm to sick to bother with this right now.... catch ya later.

May 15, 2012
Edit
Knukles2000

Continuing with my suspicions, and since Dooku was indeed Mafia, I'm going against the person who sided with him.

May 15, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

such a horrible liar, mafia! I sided with no one last round. I didn't even defend him! You get ONE right, and you get so cocky. Ugh, i'mma barf soon.

May 15, 2012
Edit
Knukles2000

Yeah. I think I'm going to go for this one.

May 15, 2012
Edit
Zanic

FUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU. I HATE DYING! I'm not playing next time. so f'ing >;P @ this.

May 15, 2012
Edit
Knukles2000

Angry winking tongue-out emoticon? That's a new one...

May 15, 2012
Edit
hezekiah

Both #85 and I had the same suspicions, and one of us were taken out, most likely by the Mafia. I think it's safe to assume that since we were both right about Dooku, we damn well may be right about you, Teddy and Kyon.

May 15, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

I think those are actually fair choices. We'll see how it goes anyway

May 15, 2012
Edit
Zanic

Thank you, Doctor! You saved a townie last night.

I originally thought Roxas and #85 were both mafia and staged that confrontation in the last round. I still believe Roxas to be guilty.

May 15, 2012
Edit
Bubba

Or you could be completely wrong about Knuckles... and that's what the Mafia wants you to think. Come on, Roxas... that's textbook Mafia.

Roxas is my vote

May 15, 2012
Edit
Helius

Hey, if I'm the one to go so be it. Like I said last round, I'm just a vanilla townie going off of coincidental evidence. I will say the same thing this time as I did last time around:

Upon my death and being revealed a townie, maybe you all will believe what #85 and I were saying. Then again, it will probably be too late, especially if the Vigilante doesn't target one of those that we found suspicious.

May 15, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

I get the feeling that Roxas is a townie now. I thought him and #85 to be mafia. But don't you see? He went all out on Dooku last round and Dooku was mafia. If he didn't want Dooku lynched, he could have not voted for him.

May 15, 2012
Edit
Zanic

I agree with Helius... taking out one of the people attacking you the most as mafia is just about the most obvious play that could be made. Too obvious, almost.
Looking back at yesterday's thread, it didn't seem like #85 was really cooperating with Roxas at all... yeah they ended up voting the same, but Roxas was voting for Kyon prior to #85 going after Dooku.

Browsing through the last thread, I noticed 1336766041... not sure how that relates, but it's interesting how his post kinda mirrors what happened.

May 15, 2012
Edit
hezekiah

Seeing as others are now voting for him I'll just continue with the same vote from last round.

May 15, 2012
Edit
Redack

If it's not Knuckles we're fucked.

May 15, 2012
Edit
poptart!
 

test

May 15, 2012
Edit
Bubba

Didn't mean to vote for Kyon, changing that to no kill.

But my real vote is with Roxas. Poptart's last reply is suspicious. He votes for knuckles with no argument other than "we're fucked". I know I used this argument before and was wrong, but there are too many votes going toward Knuckles with no basis.

We need to vote out Roxas now and the vigilante needs to kill Poptart if he wants to kill anyone.

I vote for Roxas

May 15, 2012
Edit
Bubba

You get ONE right, and you get so cocky.

I'm not cocky. I'm going after the people I have been suspicious of since Round Two.

FUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU. I HATE DYING! I'm not playing next time. so f'ing >;P @ this.

Yes, because everybody who has died so far this game LOVES DYING. It's part of the game, and if you can't accept that then don't play. Also, why get so wound up about two people voting for you out of the ten (or eleven) that could vote this round? Makes no sense to me, unless you have something to hide.

We need to vote out Roxas now and the vigilante needs to kill Poptart if he wants to kill anyone.

Yeah, just hand the Mafia the win. Not like we have a shot if we take out Knux now and the Vig takes out Kyon or Teddy.


EDIT:
Voting as it stands now

Knukles2000: 4 (`Roxas`, Zanic, Redack, poptart!)
`Roxas`: 3 (Knukles2000, Helius, Bubba)

May 15, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

But if we lynch Knuckles and the vigilante kills Kyon, who is killing you?

May 15, 2012
Edit
Bubba

Let's negotiate on the matter then:

If I am wrong about Knukles being Mafia (which I won't be, I believe), the Vig lynches me tonight and the town loses.

May 15, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

I know I used this argument before and was wrong, but there are too many votes going toward Knuckles with no basis.

My basis on voting for Knukles is off the fact that one, he seemed to side with Dooku last night. Two, how he reacted when Roxas and I voted for him. And three, I don't think Roxas is mafia anymore based off what I said. Dooku had one more vote than the other person last round. If Roxas was mafia, then he wouldn't have voted for his teammate.

May 15, 2012
Edit
Zanic

Roxas voting for Dooku was to throw off suspicion off himself. If Roxas can clear his name by that vote, who else would we vote for? There is no other viable vote. All of the other mafia members are playing low key.

It was a sacrifice that in my mind, was well worth it for the mafia. Especially considering that our vigilante is trigger happy. Had the Doctor not have saved me last night we would have lost two townies.

May 15, 2012
Edit
Bubba

All of the other mafia members are playing low key.

Or they are pulling the wool over your eyes.

I'm not saying that all of you have to believe me, but siding with Knux is going to get you nowhere.

May 15, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

All of Poptart's replies in the last two threads

If it's not Knuckles we're fucked.

Ugh I have no idea who to vote for & I'm too lazy to read this whole thread. All I know is that our vigilante is shit

What the fuck, we're getting our asses kicked ):

I'm not sure what poptart's past is like, but he has been a non contributing factor in the game. BUT, he does have 4 points in the player score, suggesting that he can't be someone who doesn't know how to play. He also voted to lynch CtR Black, a townie. Of course, that doesn't say much since a lot of people voted to lynch him, including myself.

He's playing a low key member of the mafia. I want to kill both Roxas and Poptart.

May 15, 2012
Edit
Bubba

Also, lynching Knux this round would prove my innocence. A member of the Mafia wouldn't willingly throw two fellow members under the metaphorical bus this close to them having a clean sweep of the game.

May 15, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

No, poptart always plays like this. He waits until the game is near to its close before speaking up regularly.

May 15, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

No, poptart always plays like this. He waits until the game is near to its close before speaking up regularly.

So you would defend Poptart instead of pushing me to cast my vote for him when I currently have my vote casted for you? Of course you would, YOU'RE BOTH MAFIA.

Sacrificing dear old Dooku was fine, strategic even. But losing two mafia members this late in the game especially when we have two in our sights is too much for the mafia to bare.

May 15, 2012
Edit
Bubba

Uh, no. This is exactly how he has played the game each time that he's participated. Ask anybody that's been around since the start of Mafia, or go take a look for yourself on prior games. I'm defending somebody because he is playing the same he has every game. Outside of last game, I've done relatively the same thing. (EDIT) I'm trying to protect somebody who I do not think is Mafia. You're too blinded by Knux's accusatory remarks. The extent of white lancer's death that goes on me is stating him as a suspicion. The Mafia or Vig took him out, not me.

So then why not switch your vote to any of three Knux, Teddy and Kyon? If any players are the obvious ones, it's any of those three.

May 15, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

Have you forgotten, Roxas, that so far you're only at a 50% success rate with the "kill his random rolls" strategy? Seems a bit fishy, and I don't know if Knukles being mafia would convince me that you're not.

May 15, 2012
Edit
hezekiah

"I'm not sure what poptart's past is like, but he has been a non contributing factor in the game."

I'm too lazy to pay attention or care until the end, lool.

"He also voted to lynch CtR Black, a townie."

Hey look at the vote tallies and pay attention. I didn't vote for CtR Black. I backed out when I realized that he was silenced. You voted for CtR Black. I don't think that you're mafia though.

Anyway, I'm just going to keep my vote as Knux for now.

May 15, 2012
Edit
poptart!
 

No, I have not forgotten. I will say again: The extent of my involvement is naming him as a suspect. I did not play a direct hand in his death.

May 15, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

"I'm too lazy to pay attention or care until the end, lool."

Why are you allowed to play if you're not going to participate? Bugged me last time you played, bugs me now.

May 15, 2012
Edit
hezekiah

I understand the cover up of voting for a fellow mafia member, but why would Roxas vote for Dooku when just one person taking away their vote from Dooku would have resulted in no one getting lynched thus giving Dooku one more round to investigate?

May 15, 2012
Edit
Zanic

Thank you for bringing some light on the topic, Zanic. I'm surprised I didn't notice that sooner...

May 15, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

Well, I don't think you to be mafia anymore. If you are, I'm gonna be so pissed >.<

May 15, 2012
Edit
Zanic

I am not Mafia. Just a simple townsman.

May 15, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

Personally I think Knuckles, Teddy and Hezekiah are Mafia... I can't really say I've figured out who the fourth might be, it's either someone playing really well or someone that's barely playing (poptart and kyon being the obvious two).

Also to the vigilante, I urge you not to kill someone unless the town generally agrees someone is a good target at this point. If we lynch wrongly and vig kills wrongly, plus another mafia kill puts us at losing I believe (as it'd leave the town split 50/50 in which we can never out-vote the mafia.)... So yea, vig needs to be careful...

May 15, 2012
Edit
Redack

Unless we hit Mafia this round, the Vig SHOULD NOT KILL. I urge the Townies to rally and take out Knux this round. We can then afford the Vig to kill at night, even though I, personally, would not advise it. The Double Voter is the crucial key during the day today. Whatever his choice is will pretty much decide the game.

May 15, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

Hmmm hmmm hmmm. Of course. Redack, Roxas, Zanic and Poptart. All sticking together. But to what end? And why are they so sure of themselves when their suspicions are so near baseless, and blatant? So what if Roxas was right about Dooku? If he's a townie as he claims, he won't know a real shit about who is Mafia, and as such his suspicions could WELL be misplaced, and he got lucky on Dooku.

I still think Roxas is Mafia though, too much dosn't add up. I urge you all to think carefully before voting. We the town have been duped by cleverly veiled schemes such as this before.

May 15, 2012
Edit
Knukles2000

"Why are you allowed to play if you're not going to participate? Bugged me last time you played, bugs me now."

Fuck you. I like the endgame. It's less frantic and random than the beginning.

"Redack, Roxas, Zanic and Poptart. All sticking together. But to what end?"

Yeah I'm not sticking with anyone. Stop lumping me into groups.

May 15, 2012
Edit
poptart!
 

It's not baseless Knukles. Had you taken the time to read my post, you can see why I'm not voting for Roxas.

May 15, 2012
Edit
Zanic

You at least voted with them, though.

I have read through every post this entire game. And it is pretty much baseless, and what I said. It's baiscally you jumping on board with Roxas cause he was right about Dooku, and you don't think he'd use Dooku as a sacrificial lamb. Yes, Dooku was the investiagtor. But that dosn't mean he wouldn't sell him out just to make it look less suspicious. And even if Roxas is a townie, he can't POSSIBLY know for sure they are all Mafia. So jumping RIGHT aboard with him could be a fatal mistake. Cause for all you know, the rest are townie sided.

May 16, 2012
Edit
Knukles2000

We the town have been duped by cleverly veiled schemes such as this before.

Anybody else see the irony or hypocrisy in this?

Whenever Xhin dies early on, it's usually because you have something to do with it.

I've stated why I believe Teddy and Kyon are Mafia, too. I do admit, these two are more of a crap shoot than going with you for now.

It's baiscally you jumping on board with Roxas cause he was right about Dooku, and you don't think he'd use Dooku as a sacrificial lamb. Yes, Dooku was the investiagtor. But that dosn't mean he wouldn't sell him out just to make it look less suspicious.

Why on God's Green Earth would I sacrifice arguably the MOST IMPORTANT Mafia role so close to being completing a sweep against the town? How the hell does that make ANY sense? The only suspicions against him would be my reasoning for going after Teddy and Kyon, too. I think other than my suspicion, which panned out to be true last round, that the Mafia would have misled the town to going after a townie last round.

And even if Roxas is a townie, he can't POSSIBLY know for sure they are all Mafia.

I have never said for a fact that the three of you are all Mafia. Nor have I tried presenting such as fact, so stop using THAT baseless argument. I've continued saying those are simply suspicions.

So jumping RIGHT aboard with him could be a fatal mistake.

And the same could be said for your voting against me.

May 16, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

I have never said for a fact that the three of you are all Mafia. Nor have I tried presenting such as fact, so stop using THAT baseless argument. I've continued saying those are simply suspicions.

However, you say it with such surety in your suspicion. Baselessly.

Whenever Xhin dies early on, it's usually because you have something to do with it.

Oh yes, blame me no matter what, should Xhin die even though 3 out of 5 times it wasn't me.

I've stated why I believe Teddy and Kyon are Mafia, too. I do admit, these two are more of a crap shoot than going with you for now.

Ya, cause i'm the wildcard. I'm ALWAYS suspicious. That means for all you know, i'm the vig, doctor, double voter, or normal townie.

Why on God's Green Earth would I sacrifice arguably the MOST IMPORTANT Mafia role so close to being completing a sweep against the town? How the hell does that make ANY sense? The only suspicions against him would be my reasoning for going after Teddy and Kyon, too. I think other than my suspicion, which panned out to be true last round, that the Mafia would have misled the town to going after a townie last round.

To throw us off. If we saw a vanilla mafia die, people may not buy it. Because that trick was used beforehand. But if the investigator dies, you are instantly validated. I would not be shocked if Dooku agreed to such a thing to ultimately kill of every single townie by yourself.

And the same could be said for your voting against me.

I believe I have better reason against you, than you me.

May 16, 2012
Edit
Knukles2000

Redack, your logic's off...

If our lynch today is a townie, we'll be at 4/6. Taking your advice and vigilante not killing means the night would end 4/5. If the double-voter is killed or silenced, it'll be game over.

And, I resent your assertion that I'm mafia.

May 16, 2012
Edit
hezekiah

Oh yes, blame me no matter what, should Xhin die even though 3 out of 5 times it wasn't me.

If you're so sure that you aren't behind his death at all this time around, then why be so defensive on the topic? We all know that you don't really like Xhin in the first place, and this is really the only non-emotionally driven way you can take things out on him.

Ya, cause i'm the wildcard. I'm ALWAYS suspicious. That means for all you know, i'm the vig, doctor, double voter, or normal townie.

Yet you haven't claimed a role as you usually did. If anything, that should make you more suspicious since it is out of your character for the game.

To throw us off. If we saw a vanilla mafia die, people may not buy it. Because that trick was used beforehand. But if the investigator dies, you are instantly validated. I would not be shocked if Dooku agreed to such a thing to ultimately kill of every single townie by yourself.

Again, this close to the end, where one slip up by the town and Vig, what real sense would it make to take out the only real advantage that the Mafia has over the town? ZERO SENSE.

I believe I have better reason against you, than you me.

What reason is there against me? And let's see:
  • Redone Game Two: Townie Knux urges town to take out Doctor Xhin
  • Game Three: Mafia Knux convinces Mafia Teddy to go ahead with targeting Cultist Xhin Night 1. Also attempted to have the town lynch Cultist Xhin first thing on day one. BASELESS.
  • Game Five: Possibly behind Xhin's death.

    Taking your advice and vigilante not killing means the night would end 4/5.

    I'm thinking that if the Vigilante going out for #85 or Bubba, then they will free fire at somebody. If they land on Townie, then 4-4, GAME OVER.

    • May 16, 2012
    Edit
    `Roxas`

    Xhin is actually one of the more ok people here! Why the hell are you making this so personal? I actually kind of like Xhin.

    I did claim a role earlier. And just as always, I only implied it. My intent was to PROTECT the Sensor, and throw the mafia off.

    It would make perfect sense, because they would never guess you, and you'd single-handedly wipe out the town.

    Redone Game Two: Townie Knux urges town to take out Doctor Xhin

    He was acting weird, and everyone agreed. WHY they voted him out.


    Game Three: Mafia Knux convinces Mafia Teddy to go ahead with targeting Cultist Xhin Night 1. Also attempted to have the town lynch Cultist Xhin first thing on day one. BASELESS.

    He was talking in a way that struck me wrong. So focused on the cult in the way he was.

    Game Five: Possibly behind Xhin's death.

    Only if i'm the vig, or arsonist. As I said when it happened, based on who else was taken out, it was clear they killed Xhin, not the mafia.

    May 16, 2012
    Edit
    Knukles2000

    And you're not acting weird now by recycling the same argument? If I recall correctly, that's the same thing that got Dooku lynched.

    You haven't outright implied a role. You've hinted that you were a special role, but that is it. The other games, you've outright implied a role.

    Not necessarily. The Vig could have easily taken out MM9 instead of Xhin. The only way you would know this for sure is if you were Mafia.

    May 16, 2012
    Edit
    `Roxas`

    Here's my ruling on someone getting globally banned:

    In the event that someone participating in the game is globally banned for reasons outside of the game, obviously that person is no longer capable of playing.

    However, they will not be killed or removed from the game by the host. They will just serve as a functionless member of the team they are on. A dummy, as it were.

    May 16, 2012
    Edit
    Yeano

    To make things clearer, that person is Silenced for the rest of the game if they are globally banned.

    May 16, 2012
    Edit
    Yeano

    Well, Silenced for the duration of the ban at least, correct? I really don't see it happening, but if somewhere down the line somebody gets banned mid-game, then unbanned during the same game, it'd be stupid for them to still be silenced.

    May 16, 2012
    Edit
    hezekiah

    Anyway. One of the main targets is a non-factor now. Do we want to lynch him anyway? Seems to me like we'd be better off trying to hit mafiosos who can still play the game.

    May 16, 2012
    Edit
    hezekiah

    Well, Silenced for the duration of the ban at least, correct? I really don't see it happening, but if somewhere down the line somebody gets banned mid-game, then unbanned during the same game, it'd be stupid for them to still be silenced.

    Yes, that is what I meant.

    May 16, 2012
    Edit
    Yeano

    Redack, your logic's off...

    If our lynch today is a townie, we'll be at 4/6. Taking your advice and vigilante not killing means the night would end 4/5. If the double-voter is killed or silenced, it'll be game over.

    And, I resent your assertion that I'm mafia.

    Eh resent it all you want, your attempts to convince the vig to make a kill are proving it in my eyes.

    As for my logic. The town can still win under your example because it's 4/5 as even without the double voter the town can still get one more vote to lynch someone during the night. Under my example if the double voter died its game over, if he survives there's a slight chance of town still winning. Regardless of that, we can't have the vig play recklessly just because the double voter MIGHT not die when there's an equal chance he will die.

    May 16, 2012
    Edit
    Redack

    I agree entirely with Redack. I also think that through this round, Knux has proven himself to be Mafia. I'm still thinking we need to go after Teddy and Kyon, though I do find it odd that Teddy is quiet through almost half the round. If he is Mafia, it wouldn't make sense to silence one of their own at this point in the game.

    May 16, 2012
    Edit
    `Roxas`

    I agree entirely with Redack. I also think that through this round, Knux has proven himself to be Mafia. I'm still thinking we need to go after Teddy and Kyon, though I do find it odd that Teddy is quiet through almost half the round. If he is Mafia, it wouldn't make sense to silence one of their own at this point in the game.

    So you believe Knuckles is mafia, but you don't want to lynch him?

    May 16, 2012
    Edit
    Bubba

    Not only do I think he is Mafia, but I think the Vig should have taken him out last night instead of #85 or yourself. I do think we need to lynch him this day round. I just do not think the Vig should take any action tonight.

    As far as the ruling of the indefinitely silenced player, I am not sure. While it would make sense to go after an active player than to eliminate an inactive player, I'm just not sure.

  • As voting stands 36 hours into the round:
    `Roxas`: (Knukles2000, Helius, Bubba)
    Knukles2000: (`Roxas`, Zanic, Redack, poptart!)

    • May 16, 2012
    Edit
    `Roxas`

    "Eh resent it all you want, your attempts to convince the vig to make a kill are proving it in my eyes."

    Well now with Knukles out of the game, we've got more breathing room. Even if we end up lynching a townie today, mafia gets a townie, and vigilante gets yet another townie, we'd still have a chance, as long as the Double-Voter were able to participate in the next day round. If we get a mafioso via lynch (or overnight), we're guaranteed to make it through the next day.
    Have you been the vigilante in any games yet? I was it last go-round, and let me tell you it's not easy. I wouldn't blame the vigilante for ignoring your advise and making an attempt tonight at who he thinks is mafia.

    May 16, 2012
    Edit
    hezekiah

    Count as it stands is 4-7.
    We lynch a townie: 4-6.
    Vigilante kills a townie: 4-5.
    Mafia kills a townie: 4-4.

    Mafia wins.

    Even if we end up lynching a townie today, mafia gets a townie, and vigilante gets yet another townie, we'd still have a chance

    Yeah, I'm convinced your Mafia now. Any townie would say, just as I have, that the town loses if that happens.

    May 16, 2012
    Edit
    `Roxas`

    Also, I still disagree with your assessment of my logic, as the game was at the time I wrote it.

    "The town can still win under your example"

    But that's wrong. Day ends 4/6 if a townie gets lynched. Mafia kill makes it 4/5. No vigilante kill means night ends 4/5. Silencer is still out there (probably the most dangerous role still out there, even before the Investigator died), meaning somebody would get silenced.
    As I said, next day begins with 4 mafia and 5 townies. If the double-voter were silenced, that'd mean there were 4 votes from each side (mafia and town). Mafia could force no kill, or jump on board with townies voting for other townies.
    Because of the Doctor, Vigilante and Double-Voter all still being alive, there are a lot of variables in how it could play out. But this would've been one very real possibility, and I for one would prefer to lose to a Vigilante misfire than the passive approach Redack was advocating.

    May 16, 2012
    Edit
    hezekiah

    Sorry, the Knukles situation is confusing me.

    May 16, 2012
    Edit
    hezekiah

    Yes, but only assuming that the Vigilante doesn't kill, which I am having high doubts about right now.

    May 16, 2012
    Edit
    `Roxas`

    Decided to make a new post here rather than edit, so nobody can claim I'm trying to hide anything...

    Probably should've mentioned in my first post this morning that I've come around on Knukles, especially since he's now unable to play. So I guess what happened was I projected that as being true for part of that first scenario, and forgot about how the rules go concerning the mafia's win condition.

    Anyway.

    May 16, 2012
    Edit
    hezekiah

    Its no use having a silent player... though what in the world happened to Knuckles? Can someone fill me in?

    Also in interest of expediting this round...

    May 16, 2012
    Edit
    Helius

    Also looking at the votes, Teddy was silent for two rounds so far...

    Just an observation.

    May 16, 2012
    Edit
    Helius

    He got angry, spammed a lot, got global banned...

    Pretty sure that's what happened anyway...

    May 16, 2012
    Edit
    Redack

    Uh, he certainly wasn't silent... he posted quite a bit during Day 3.

    May 16, 2012
    Edit
    hezekiah

    Night 4.

    The town's decisions are final! Knukles2000 faced the wrath of the Town. Another Mafioso down!

    1. Shadowwalked
    2. CtR Black - Townie
    3. Teddy-Son
    4. Redack
    5. #85 - Townie
    6. Count Dooku - Mafia Investigator
    7. MajorasMask9 - Ghoul
    8. hezekiah
    9. Helius
    10. Eagle0
    11. `Roxas`
    12. Zanic
    13. Xhin - Insane Cop
    14. poptart!
    15. Knukles2000 - Mafioso
    16. Bubba
    17. white lancer - Townie
    18. DragonintheShadow - Sensor
    19. chiefsonny - Arsonist

    Godfather, Mafia Investigator, Silencer, Mafioso, Lunatic Vigilante, Sensor, Cop, Doctor, Psychiatrist, Arsonist, Double-voter, Ghoul, Townie.

    Mafia-Town Ratio: 3-7

    24 hours!

    WARNING: If your role changes to "Silenced," you may NOT post in this thread. If you do, you will be host-killed.

    Continued in [p:65958].

    May 16, 2012
    Edit
    Yeano

    Reply to: game 5 thread 4 night 4 rebound for the town and yes the round ended with sufficient votes i

    Username
    Password