Engines Aether Legend of the Lunar Priest NIFE Roadmap
Shatterloop Game Projects Deprecated Starwright
Saepes Mundi Other Projects Blog  

Mafia

Moderated by: Speed Bike Pro

game 7 thread 3 night 3 what a day what a day

Posted June 29, 2012 by Yeano

Continued from [p:67458]

Day 3


This morning, there was one person in a prison cell, and one person missing.

After reviewing the mugshots of new prisoners, white lancer's face was caught among them. He is a Townie, but the court system is all whacked out, so he'll probably be in prison for a while...

Additionally, there were traces of a struggle at Wild Luxray's house, but it seems that he is missing. I wonder what happened to him.


1. Xhin
2. Count Dooku
3. hezekiah
4. Shadowwalked
5. Wild Luxray - ???
6. Trever Leingod - ???
7. White Thunder
8. Teddy-Son
9. MajorasMask9
10. CtR Black
11. Morrigan
12. `Roxas`
13. DragonintheShadows
14. Black Yoshi
15. chiefsonny
16. Vandy
17. white lancer - Townie
18. #85 - Godfather

Starting Mafia-Town-Other Ratio: 4-11-3

Our roles this game include: Doctor (1), Cop (1), Townie (9), Godfather (1), Janitor (1), Mafioso (2), FBI Agent (1), Journalist (1), Fool (1)

You have 72 hours or 9 votes for the same option.

There are 128 Replies

extensionEnable Post Pagination

Since it has been asked of me, here is the night action priority list:

1. Journalist staking out a house (not that it needs to be first, but it is)
2. FBI Agent
3. Mafia
4. Cop
5. Doctor

June 29, 2012
Edit
Yeano

Damn -- well, at least Lancer was just a Townie. Last thing we need is to accidentally lynch the Fool. I still have my suspicions of Teddy-Son, seeing his attitude this game versus previous games, even given his fun-loving personality, but I doubt we should lynch him this round -- let the FBI Agent take care of that.

June 29, 2012
Edit
Black Yoshi

I agree that we shouldn't lynch unless we get evidence from the cop or the journalist. Too risky with the Fool around.

June 29, 2012
Edit
MajorasMask9

it's possible that Morrigan is one of our power roles. Well, the fool or FBI agent at least. Has anyone heard from her?

June 29, 2012
Edit
Vandy

IIRC, last round someone said she had Internet problems and wouldn't be on for some time -- I can't quite remember how long they said.

June 29, 2012
Edit
Black Yoshi

There were some things that DitS said that I found suspicious, so I chose to investigate him last night. He's innocent. Unless our Journalist has some information to give us, then I think we should no kill.

Assuming that the Mafia hasn't taken out any of the third party roles, the ratio should be, right now, 2M-9T-3TP. The third party roles couldn't care less who wins, so the sooner we take out the Mafia, the sooner we can start narrowing down who the fool could be.

June 29, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

Two Mafia? IIRC, we took down #85 and he was the Godfather, leaving two Mafiosi and the Janitor -- so, three Mafia, right?

June 29, 2012
Edit
Black Yoshi

^ 3 Mafia and 8 townies, actually.

June 29, 2012
Edit
White Thunder

Yeah, 3-8-3. x.x Gah, I don't know why I keep thinking there were only three Mafia members.

June 29, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

I bet it was because last game when me, you, and lancer were Mafia it was just us 3, that's probably what you were thinking.

Or you're Mafia and playing us, and hoped no one would notice. One of the two.

June 29, 2012
Edit
White Thunder

Pretty sure if I were Mafia, the real cop would have spoken out by now and gotten two Mafia members taken care of instead of just one with some help from the journalist.

June 29, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

Not necessarily, Roxas. There are any number of reasons why the cop could've chosen not to counter-claim you.

I wish the FBI Agent had gone for Teddy over lancer, certainly seemed more suspicious to me.

Even with this goddamn Fool running around, I think that taking a shot at a lynch is better than not... it makes sense in my head, but I'm having trouble finding the words to explain it.

June 29, 2012
Edit
hezekiah

Yeah, I realized that after I posted. I'd rather not go into detail about those, because it may not help my case and leave the town without its Cop.

We're more likely to hit a Mafia member than we are the Fool, but just as likely to hit the latter or one the other two third party roles. Of course, we're even more likely to hit one of the Town's power roles.

June 29, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

You guys are all suspicious! Lets kill everyone!

June 29, 2012
Edit
Teddy-Son

Well, that was certainly a lucky combination of Roxas and the Journalist singling out #85. Excellent work ^_^

Shame about Lancer, but he has been less active this game than normal.

Hopefully our journalist is still in the game and can provide us with a nice writeup of the night's events. Until then, I'm still in favor of jailing Teddy.

June 29, 2012
Edit
Count Dooku

I can't arrest myself.

June 29, 2012
Edit
Teddy-Son

Dear lord I hope you didn't just say that seriously.

June 29, 2012
Edit
Count Dooku

Well, if he isn't the Agent, the Agent knows who to arrest for sure now.

June 29, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

If he is, we've just lost the Agent. And if we've just lost the Agent, we've no counter to the Fool other than keeping him alive.

June 29, 2012
Edit
Count Dooku

I am the cop and Vandy and Shadowalked are guilty.

June 29, 2012
Edit
Teddy-Son

And he's lying. Now it's whether or not he's the fool trying to get killed, or Mafia trying to throw us off his trail.

June 29, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

Agent, you NEED to apprehend Teddy.

June 29, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

{<00}

June 29, 2012
Edit
MajorasMask9

I'm 99% sure Teddy is the Fool. That or a REALLY unhelpful townie.

Ugh, can we make a list of the people that haven't talked much this game? I've got the feeling too many people are remaining silent.

June 29, 2012
Edit
Count Dooku

chief and Shadow mostly. Morrigan too.

June 29, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

I am the cop and Vandy and Shadowalked are guilty.


well look at you, pointing your fingers

so it's just coincidence that Roxas's call on #85 was true?

can't attest for Dragon in the Shadows just yet but I think Roxas has proven himself with his call on #85. He could have been playing his odds (and they would certainly be in his favor), but still risky for a claim on Day 1.

hopefully Dragon can chime in here before Teddy here makes cause for quite the mistake

June 29, 2012
Edit
Vandy

No pointy fingers Vandy I did my night actions and you came out guilty.

June 29, 2012
Edit
Teddy-Son

chief and Shadow mostly. Morrigan too.

Hezekiah as well. Just a few posts day one, only one reply on day 2 I believe.

Hezekiah is also interesting because he still seems rather suspicious of you, Mr. Cop.

June 29, 2012
Edit
Count Dooku

I didn't check him out last night. But I could do that tonight.

June 29, 2012
Edit
Teddy-Son

Teddy, just stop. You've been caught in your lie. You won't be checking anybody tonight, because:

1) You will be apprehended.
2) Only I can officially check people.

June 29, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

So who are you going to arrest in the next night round, Teddy?

June 29, 2012
Edit
MajorasMask9

How can he arrest, if he's "Cop" though?

June 29, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

I am not lying, next round I am going to arrest either Vandy or Shadowalked or maybe Hezekiah.

June 29, 2012
Edit
Teddy-Son

He can't, so the fact that he claims he'll arrest someone shows he doesn't know the specifics of the role he claimed, and is therefore lying as we all suspected.

June 29, 2012
Edit
MajorasMask9

yeah I thought only FBI agent could make arrests

June 29, 2012
Edit
Vandy

yeah I thought only FBI agent could make arrests

That is because ONLY the Agent can make arrests, just as ONLY the Cop can investigate other players (aside from the Journalist, but that's more snooping to see what goes on during an investigation).

June 29, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

Can we get our journalist's article?

June 29, 2012
Edit
Count Dooku

Fine I lied who doesn't lie here on Mafia?

June 29, 2012
Edit
Teddy-Son

Yeano's offline right now, so if Feral wasn't the Journalist, and the Journalist wrote something, it'll be posted when he gets back.

Considering the time he left, I'd say he might be back in 3-5 hours? Dunno!

June 29, 2012
Edit
MajorasMask9

Outside of my slip up in the Republic Game, not many people who have lied have changed their story in the game.

June 29, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

That's because you are better then me. I am not that good in this game so I lie its gonna suck.

June 29, 2012
Edit
Teddy-Son

For now I think it's safe not to focus on Teddy. We know he isn't what he claims to be. The FBI Agent can jail him tonight and we'll be rid of either the Fool or a Mafia member.

So the real question is who we should lynch. And I'm leaning heavily toward one of these quiet people.

June 29, 2012
Edit
Count Dooku

you could have got me killed, man

not cool

June 29, 2012
Edit
Vandy

Actually, now that I look at Day 1 and Day 2, I'm almost certain Shadowwalked is up to something.

Day 1 he posted once to cast a No Kill vote.

Day 2 he posted immediately after I suggested Roxas investigate one of those that hadn't voted (as did chiefsonny).

Day 3 and he's gone quiet again

Could be nothing, but I found that Day 2 vote of his suspicious yesterday and his overall quietness even more suspicious.

June 29, 2012
Edit
Count Dooku

I still feel as though it is safest if he is arrested, while we wait for the Journalist's report to see if we have anything to go off of for our vote.

June 29, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

Good points, Dooku. I'll have to keep that in mind when making my decision for who to investigate in the night. Although, don't be surprised if those two start talking quite a bit.

June 29, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

Good points, Dooku. I'll have to keep that in mind when making my decision for who to investigate in the night. Although, don't be surprised if those two start talking quite a bit.

Unless anyone else acts out oddly, go for it.

Went back a few games just to be sure, and Shadowwalked has certainly been far more active in discussion in the past.

June 29, 2012
Edit
Count Dooku

you're probably right, assuming mr. agent is still among us

excuse me though, if I'm a little quick to vote for someone who tried to turn the town against me without reason

looking at shadowwalked's history in days 1 and 2, looks like he always posts later in the day. Does he have a job?

June 29, 2012
Edit
Vandy

I've also noticed in past games (and outside of mafia) that Shadowwalked is typically more active later on, so that could be why he's been quiet this day round in particular.

June 29, 2012
Edit
MajorasMask9

I understand why you want to vote for him, but he's as good as out of the game (if the Agent is in the game). If the Mafia know he's not one of them, as crazy as this sounds, they should have one of the Mafioso inform us so that they still have two players left.

June 29, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

I've also noticed in past games (and outside of mafia) that Shadowwalked is typically more active later on, so that could be why he's been quiet this day round in particular.

Understandable, and I certainly don't want to penalize him for having a job/real life :P

However, it still stands that he's been far more active in past games.

But hey, it's Mafia. Maybe I'm jumping at shadows.

June 29, 2012
Edit
Count Dooku

Shadowalked could just as easily be silenced.

June 29, 2012
Edit
Teddy-Son

Speaking of jobs... I started a new job this week, and it coupled with other things I've had going on (had just returned from a vacation, went to Summerfest, etc) has cut into the time I can give to the game.

The more I'm seeing out of Roxas, the more I'm coming around to him probably being the cop. But like I said, it's hard for me to really take the time to analyze what's a "good" play vs a "bad" play with the Fool role still wandering around. Plus, I learned after getting had by Shadowwalked a few games back not to trust anybody too easily.

-

I'm with Count on wanting to lynch somebody, especially in light of Teddy almost surely being the Fool. I think I'll have some time later tonight to try and make up my mind about who.

June 29, 2012
Edit
hezekiah

Teddy, quit being an idiot. It was already explained during this round that there's no silencer.

June 29, 2012
Edit
hezekiah

Don't call me an idiot Hez, I was not around for most of the round to know either way.

June 29, 2012
Edit
Teddy-Son

Well apparently I didn't do my research; the clarification about the lack of a silencer was during the last day round. Of course, it's also visible in the OP. We've got a (dead) Godfather, a Janitor and 2 regular Mafiosos... no Silencer.

June 29, 2012
Edit
hezekiah

Whatever decision is made, I will probably not be around tonight as I am going to be over at a get together.

----------

I think we all learned from The Republic game not to trust anybody. {:P}

June 29, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

I think it's unlikely this round will end quickly. Unless the Journalist gives us something damning again.

June 29, 2012
Edit
Count Dooku

I was at work. What did I miss?

~Starts reading~

June 29, 2012
Edit
Dragon in the Shadows

The more I'm seeing out of Roxas, the more I'm coming around to him probably being the cop. But like I said, it's hard for me to really take the time to analyze what's a "good" play vs a "bad" play with the Fool role still wandering around. Plus, I learned after getting had by Shadowwalked a few games back not to trust anybody too easily.


I think it's a safe bet that Teddy is the Fool. If Teddy is the Fool, there's pretty much no way that Roxas couldn't be the Cop. Too much evidence points to him not being mafia-sided, anyway.

We should know by the next day round whether or not Teddy is the Fool. I think I'm going to no-kill, since I don't think we're going to get anything from the journalist at this point. By tomorrow, if the Fool is gone, we should have a lot more freedom with what we can do.

June 29, 2012
Edit
MajorasMask9

can't attest for Dragon in the Shadows just yet but I think Roxas has proven himself with his call on #85


need to arrest me. I'm not the fool. If I was I would try to make myself look like I was in the mafia. The actions that Roxas thought was suspicious was the fact that I kept saying the fool has no night actions and that it was safe to lynch #85. It was a matter of how the fool role functions. Yeano was kind enough to post the night action priority list:

1. Journalist staking out a house (not that it needs to be first, but it is)

2. FBI Agent

3. Mafia

4. Cop

5. Doctor


as you can see there are no night actions for the fool. My observation was correct and #85 could not have been the fool. That is pretty much it. Some were doubting whether or not we should have lynched #85 and I knew he was mafia.

now for the reveal. I'm a townie. Nothing special.

June 29, 2012
Edit
Dragon in the Shadows

Y-you don't need to reveal! That just limits down who the doctor could be for the mafia :(

June 29, 2012
Edit
MajorasMask9

Y-you don't need to reveal! That just limits down who the doctor could be for the mafia :(

Not to mention it's very easy to claim townie, given that there are potentially 8 or 9 of us. Claiming townie kinda means nothing :P

June 29, 2012
Edit
Count Dooku

way I see it we already got the Godfather. And we have a good suspect for the fool. That means we just have to figure out the remaining mafia members. Besides I felt it necessary to reveal myself before I got arrested. Another arrested townie wouldn't have done any one any good, other than the mafia.

June 29, 2012
Edit
Dragon in the Shadows

I'm relatively certain our FBI Agent will take care of Teddy/The Fool and then we'll be far more careful about jailing anyone.

June 29, 2012
Edit
Count Dooku

Sorry for not posting sooner.

But for the last few days during the day I have been busy helping plan my granddaughters wedding

Xhin can verify this because I told me in a IM before the game started.

Now back to the game and a few thoughts.

In my opinion and it looks a lot of you agree to a extent, The FBI person is as important to us as the Cop, if not more. He can take either Mafia or Townies out of the game with a turn of the cell key.

If he's doing what I think he is, and it's what I would do if I was him, lock someone up every night. It's a win win. Get lucky, get a mafia, get real lucky get the Fool. If he gets one of us no harm no foul as long as he keeps a watch on the number ratio.

So whatever you do FBI Agent DO NOT RAVEL. Just keep doing your thing.

I have not had time to check the numbers, but if the ratio is still us with at least twice as many as them. NO Kill (god I can't believe I just said that) for now.

June 29, 2012
Edit
chiefsonny
 

The agent doesn't care about the fool. He wants to bag mafia members. Last day round I pointed out Teddy's behavior was a bit suspicious and that I thought he might be the fool. Instead of arresting him the agent he arrested Lancer. Trust me, the agent has little to no interest in the fool.

June 29, 2012
Edit
Dragon in the Shadows

Trust me, the agent has little to no interest in the fool.

Why wouldn't he/she.

SPECIAL NOTE ABOUT FOOL - The fool wins if he is killed. If the Fool is killed, the game ends since the Fool has officially "won the game.

You don't think he/she wants to win.

Why play if that's the case

June 29, 2012
Edit
chiefsonny
 

i dont think teddy's the fool. i think he's mafia again

June 29, 2012
Edit
CtR Black

Can an agent bag the anyone if he or she is dead?

June 29, 2012
Edit
Teddy-Son

I've also noticed in past games (and outside of mafia) that Shadowwalked is typically more active later on, so that could be why he's been quiet this day round in particular.

Its been hotter than hell lately, so I've been taking up a more nocturnal lifestyle. I can hardly motivate myself to do much of anything until the sun starts setting.

As for what I have observed, I think we can conclude without a doubt that Teddy is the fool. It seems to me that everything that he has posted this game contrasts with his usual play-style (Where he is careful and hesitant). Furthermore, he's role-claimed the cop despite 'Roxas' verifying himself with his showing of #85 being 'innocent' (and then the Journalist showing that he was the godfather). The best thing that can happen tonight is the jailing of Teddy by the FBI agent, and the possible revealing of more information by the journalist.

June 29, 2012
Edit
Shadowwalked

So whatever you do FBI Agent DO NOT RAVEL

You can RAVEL all you want.

Just don't REVEAL{:P}

June 29, 2012
Edit
chiefsonny
 

i dont think teddy's the fool. i think he's mafia again


Reasons why? All signs point to him being more likely the Fool. Why would his last defense be a false cop claim and call two people guilty?

Regardless, there's no point in risking it. If he's mafia, then +1 point for the FBI Agent. If he's the Fool, then no more paranoia for the rest of the game.

Riiiight. The agent doesn't care about the fool. He wants to bag mafia members.


The FBI Agent should care about the Fool though. If the Fool dies any other way aside from an arrest, then nobody will get points (for the most part), including the FBI Agent. Perhaps afterward, we can lay off on lynchings and give the FBI Agent some points when we get guilty verdicts.

June 29, 2012
Edit
MajorasMask9

I am not gonna get bagged regardless of what I am as a matter of fact this time, I can be 100% sure on that.{<00}

June 29, 2012
Edit
Teddy-Son

I think we can conclude without a doubt that Teddy is the fool.

Then we need to stop voting for him.

June 29, 2012
Edit
chiefsonny
 

I am not gonna get bagged regardless of what I am as a matter of fact this time, I can be 100% sure on that.{<00}


You already said you were lying though!!

June 29, 2012
Edit
MajorasMask9

But what if I was a mafia member and I end up surviving? You would lose. I would be careful before we plan on what we our going to do.{troll}

June 29, 2012
Edit
Teddy-Son

Its been hotter than hell lately, so I've been taking up a more nocturnal lifestyle. I can hardly motivate myself to do much of anything until the sun starts setting.

This. Oh god this. D:

June 29, 2012
Edit
Morrigan

But what if I was a mafia member and I end up surviving? You would lose. I would be careful before we plan on what we our going to do.{troll}


So you're saying we should lynch you?

June 29, 2012
Edit
MajorasMask9

I lied about being the cop but I am not lying about not getting bagged.

June 29, 2012
Edit
Teddy-Son

You know what, do what you want lynch me, don't lynch me you'll end up losing.

June 29, 2012
Edit
Teddy-Son

-_-'

Teddy is the fool or he's channeling the spirit of Knuckles. Either way I think we should arrest him.

June 30, 2012
Edit
Dragon in the Shadows

I can't help but to literitly laugh out loud.{:3} You guys are so funny {:)}

June 30, 2012
Edit
Teddy-Son

Also, should we assume that Wild Luxray was the Journalist?

Yesterday after the news article was posted, I tried to narrow down who the Journalist could be based on what they wrote, and the way other people talked in the game. I had Feral as one of the most likely to be the Journalist. Just a few of the things he said seemed to make me think it could have been him, and that on top of the fact that there was no article today makes me wonder. After all, the FBI Agent did arrest white lancer, meaning the Journalist would know who the FBI Agent is. And, if the Journalist knew who the FBI Agent was, they probably would have posted it, especially after Teddy's claim.

June 30, 2012
Edit
MajorasMask9

I already know Feral is not the Journalist and I know who the FBI Agent was. But unless you are nice to me I am not gonna tell.

June 30, 2012
Edit
Teddy-Son

Does that mean you're saying that you're the Journalist?

June 30, 2012
Edit
MajorasMask9

Nope I am saying Feral is not.

June 30, 2012
Edit
Teddy-Son

But you're saying that Feral was the FBI Agent. The only way you could know that is if you were the Journalist or the Mafia.

Or, you're just lying again.

June 30, 2012
Edit
MajorasMask9

Or if someone from the dead told me so.

June 30, 2012
Edit
Teddy-Son

Well then they would be breaking the rules.

June 30, 2012
Edit
MajorasMask9

Then people have been breaking the rules for a long time. We've been coming from the dead for a long time doing this.

June 30, 2012
Edit
Teddy-Son

I'm still not going to buy it until we see that nobody gets arrested. I still think Teddy is the Fool, so lynching him regardless would be a bad move.

June 30, 2012
Edit
MajorasMask9

Must agree that this game has a serious problem with people talking...

Perhaps proof of OOC chatting (Screenshot of IM?) can be grounds for a host kill?

June 30, 2012
Edit
Count Dooku

Also agree that Teddy is the fool, and we should be discussing other matters.

Honestly, the mafia is probably laughing over in their thread while we flail about Teddy here.

June 30, 2012
Edit
Count Dooku

That's fine with me. And if I am a Mafia and you let me live then the town loses. IF I was the fool and dies the town still loses. So it doesn't matter either way to me.{troll}

June 30, 2012
Edit
Teddy-Son

That's fine with me. And if I am a Mafia and you let me live then the town loses. IF I was the fool and dies the town still loses. So it doesn't matter either way to me.


you are arrested. Then you are out of the game, but not dead. Then we win, you lose.

June 30, 2012
Edit
Dragon in the Shadows

Not much to discuss. Roxas didn't get a guilty verdict, and the Journalist isn't writing up a story. We could go into the intricate details of players' past posting behaviors to see who's most likely mafia based on that, but that's always open to uncertainty and confirmation bias.

That's fine with me. And if I am a Mafia and you let me live then the town loses. IF I was the fool and dies the town still loses. So it doesn't matter either way to me.


It does matter to you though, since you can't be both mafia and the fool at the same time. Not to mention you'll most likely get arrested, meaning you lose with no exception.

June 30, 2012
Edit
MajorasMask9

But if you make the wrong choice and kill the fool then game over. Make the wrong choice and let the Mafia survive game over I am saying to think before you either vote me dead or leave me alone.

I am telling you I am not going to be arrested.

In fact I believe so much that I wont get arrested then how about we make a wager over it? I get arrested I wont be in Gametalk for a week. I don't get arrested you have to help me out for an entire week.

June 30, 2012
Edit
Teddy-Son

you see, part of being dead is that you're dead

unless we're playing Mafia: Ghost Edition, deceased players should not be saying anything to influence the game in any way

June 30, 2012
Edit
Vandy

Whether the information is true or not, dead players should not be giving any information to living players.

The claim that a dead player may have potentially given information to a living player is under investigation.

June 30, 2012
Edit
Yeano

No votes for me yet? I'll fix that:

June 30, 2012
Edit
Xhin
Sky's the limit

wtf. this is how teddy always plays. guarantee he's not the fool. he always plays like this and if you say he's the fool he'll just roll wit it.

but we dont need to lynch him, guess the agent can find out if he want to. but if we play this way and he's not the fool, the real could get by us and get killed. so it's pretty much all or nothing on lynching in my opinion. the mafia could screw up and kill him too

June 30, 2012
Edit
CtR Black

This is where I stand right now:

-If we go into the next night round and nobody is arrested, then Teddy was telling the truth about being 100% certain that Feral was the FBI Agent (it would have to be Feral since white lancer was arrested last night.)

-If Feral was the FBI Agent, the only way Teddy could have logically known this for certain was if he was mafia and saw the body.

-If Teddy is the Fool, then there should have been no legitimate way he could have known about Feral being the FBI Agent.

Thus, logically speaking it should be safe to lynch Teddy, because if we assume there is no dead-talking outside of gtx0, then Teddy would have to be mafia. Either that, or he pulled off the luckiest bluff I've ever seen!

Which means we could either go along with what would make the most sense if no dead-talking went on, or we could assume that people were dead-talking and not vote for Teddy. Since that would require playing under the assumption that someone broke a rule, I kind of have trouble basing ;ynvhes on that. If we assume Teddy did get information from someone that is dead--but he really didn't and was mafia all along--then by assuming he's the Fool and that somebody that was dead told him Feral was the FBI Agent, we'd be letting a mafia member get away because of a simple lie that we shouldn't have to assume is true. If that makes sense anyway!

June 30, 2012
Edit
MajorasMask9

lynches*



June 30, 2012
Edit
MajorasMask9

Thus, logically speaking it should be safe to lynch Teddy, because if we assume there is no dead-talking outside of gtx0, then Teddy would have to be mafia. Either that, or he pulled off the luckiest bluff I've ever seen!


he's the fool trying to make us think he is mafia so we'll lynch him. You are forgetting the fact that we don't know if Feral was the Agent, his body was hidden. For all we know the Agent might still be in play.

June 30, 2012
Edit
Dragon in the Shadows

Right now the ratio is 11 town 3 mafia.

I don't believe a word of what Teddy says.

Where's the proof that Feral was FBI?

I think we no kill/no vote and have the Cop check Teddy, and if the FBI is alive, put Teddy in jail, maximum security cell if possible.

Going against my normal pattern of voting No Vote in order to get the votes we need to end the day round. Can't wait to see what happens in the night round.
It's going to cost us a townie, but we need to see what 3rd party power players are still with us.

June 30, 2012
Edit
chiefsonny
 

Or he's the fool trying to make us think he is mafia so we'll lynch him. You are forgetting the fact that we don't know if Feral was the Agent, his body was hidden. For all we know the Agent might still be in play.


My point is, if he's the Fool, and if the Agent really is dead, there is no way he could have possibly known that unless he was mafia.

If nobody is arrested in the next night round, then that's pretty good evidence that the FBI Agent is dead. That's what I was talking about in my last reply.

June 30, 2012
Edit
MajorasMask9

-If we go into the next night round and nobody is arrested, then Teddy was telling the truth about being 100% certain that Feral was the FBI Agent (it would have to be Feral since white lancer was arrested last night.)


This is what I said in my earlier reply. Basically, it's the only way we can confirm whether or not the FBI Agent is really dead. I think we should no-kill and see what happens in the night round. Based on what happens in the night round, we should be able to make a better-educated lynch.

June 30, 2012
Edit
MajorasMask9

yeahhh yeahhh I suppose you're right

we'll have a much better idea of what's going on come day 4

June 30, 2012
Edit
Vandy

Let's emphasize, then, that if the Agent is still alive they should arrest Teddy, no excuses.

June 30, 2012
Edit
White Thunder

Agreed.

June 30, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

Absolutely.

June 30, 2012
Edit
chiefsonny
 

So just because Teddy is "something" we're gonna cut the round short? Whatever, it's clear I'm in the minority here.

June 30, 2012
Edit
hezekiah

I think we no kill/no vote and have the Cop check Teddy, and if the FBI is alive, put Teddy in jail, maximum security cell if possible.

I wouldn't waste an investigation on Teddy :/ I can't see a member of the mafia getting THIS MUCH ATTENTION ON PURPOSE.

I still say the cop should investigate Shadowwalked, and the FBI Agent will confirm he/she is alive by arresting Teddy.

June 30, 2012
Edit
Count Dooku

So just because Teddy is "something" we're gonna cut the round short? Whatever, it's clear I'm in the minority here.


We have no other leads. If Teddy is the Fool, then arresting him and getting him out of the way will just make the rest of the game flow better for the town, as we won't have to worry about mislynching and ending the game. If he isn't the Fool, then we'll find that out next round.

Unless you have any other information you're willing to share.

June 30, 2012
Edit
MajorasMask9

So just because Teddy is "something" we're gonna cut the round short?



Please keep this day round open for the full 24 hours.

June 30, 2012
Edit
chiefsonny
 

Please keep this day round open for the full 24 hours.
72

June 30, 2012
Edit
chiefsonny
 

Do you know why you should believe me?

I made a wager which no one noticed. Because I am 100% sure that I am not going to get arrested and that Feral is the dead agent thus I can not go to jail. The wager was that if I get arrested I do not come back to Gametalk for an entire week. But if I don't people have to be super nice to me for a week and help me out more often.

June 30, 2012
Edit
Teddy-Son

Do you know why you should believe me?

I made a wager which no one noticed.


good point, I'm with you 100%

June 30, 2012
Edit
Vandy

Fuck it, I'm so sick of this round going nowhere.

June 30, 2012
Edit
hezekiah

Sorry I haven't been on in a while, I was over at a friend's house last night, and a nother friend's before that, and neither had wifi that I could connect to.

Anyway, Roxas PLEASE check on Teddy tonight. Just reading through this thread, some of his replies ring some alarm bells with me. I'm damned sure that if he were Town-sided, he wouldn't be acting like this much of a Fool, making so little sense -- hell, even when I was Mafia in the first game and I damned nere gave myself away, I was more coherent than Teddy is this game.

June 30, 2012
Edit
Black Yoshi

Anyway, Roxas PLEASE check on Teddy tonight. Just reading through this thread, some of his replies ring some alarm bells with me. I'm damned sure that if he were Town-sided, he wouldn't be acting like this much of a Fool, making so little sense -- hell, even when I was Mafia in the first game and I damned nere gave myself away, I was more coherent than Teddy is this game.

WHY?

We're wasting all of our night potential. The FBI Agent will jail Teddy and the cop will investigate Teddy. It's nonsense.

Seriously. I don't care if Roxas investigates someone other than Shadowwalked, but it sure as hell better not be Teddy. Let our Agent deal with him. And end this damn round already.

June 30, 2012
Edit
Count Dooku

Huh. Black Yoshi's is the ninth vote for No Kill. Guess that means we're just waiting on Yeano to end the round.

June 30, 2012
Edit
hezekiah

Well since you guys won't believe me no matter what I say or do just like in every single fucking game well I am just telling you I'm not gonna get arrested. There is nothing more to say except its not gonna happen. You can cry out to the Agent all you want its not gonna happen.

June 30, 2012
Edit
Teddy-Son

Well since you guys won't believe me no matter what I say or do just like in every single fucking game well I am just telling you I'm not gonna get arrested. There is nothing more to say except its not gonna happen. You can cry out to the Agent all you want its not gonna happen.

Please elaborate on how you know the Agent isn't going to do anything. I'm curious to know how you have such information.

June 30, 2012
Edit
Count Dooku

I'm thinking we just leave Teddy alone in the game. If he is right about the Agent being dead, although it isn't guaranteed, then I'd say he is Mafia. If he is around tomorrow, I will investigate him on Night Four.

June 30, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

Night 3


And so the town did their favorite thing and no killed.


1. Xhin
2. Count Dooku
3. hezekiah
4. Shadowwalked
5. Wild Luxray - ???
6. Trever Leingod - ???
7. White Thunder
8. Teddy-Son
9. MajorasMask9
10. CtR Black
11. Morrigan
12. `Roxas`
13. DragonintheShadows
14. Black Yoshi
15. chiefsonny
16. Vandy
17. white lancer - Townie
18. #85 - Godfather

Starting Mafia-Town-Other Ratio: 4-11-3

Our roles this game include: Doctor (1), Cop (1), Townie (9), Godfather (1), Janitor (1), Mafioso (2), FBI Agent (1), Journalist (1), Fool (1)

You have 24 hours for night actions.

June 30, 2012
Edit
Yeano

Continued in [p:67588].

July 1, 2012
Edit
Yeano

Reply to: game 7 thread 3 night 3 what a day what a day

Username
Password