Engines Aether Legend of the Lunar Priest NIFE Roadmap
Shatterloop Game Projects Deprecated Starwright
Saepes Mundi Other Projects Blog  

Mafia

Moderated by: Speed Bike Pro

game ix thread 5 night 5 a town here lay in slumber where the townies do outnumber and those wh

Posted August 4, 2012 by Xhin

Day 5

When the townies came out, they noticed that Trever Leingod was missing.. but then they found him dead from high-velocity gunshot wounds. He was a Townie.

Roster

1. chiefsonny -- claimed Gambler
2. Dragon in the Shadows -- claimed Spy
3. Redack -- Silencer
4. Count Dooku -- claimed Governor
5. hezekiah -- claimed Sniper
6. Shadowwalked -- ???
7. Kyon
8. Feral -- claimed Martyr
9. Black Yoshi -- claimed Fisherman
10. Trever Leingod -- Townie
11. White Thunder
12. `Roxas` -- ???
13. white lancer -- claimed Doctor
14. CtR Black
15. #85 -- claimed Cop
16. Zanic
17. MajorasMask9 -- claimed Double-Voter
18. 9 -- Mafioso

Starting Mafia-Town Ratio: 5-13
Total living players: 13

Mafia Roles: Godfather, Executioner, Janitor
Town Roles: Townie, Double-Voter, Cop, Doctor, Sniper, Governor, Fisherman, Gambler, Martyr, Spy

72 hours or 7 votes for the same option. Executioner kill at 4 votes.

There are 101 Replies

extensionEnable Post Pagination

As the townies rubbed the sleep from their eyes and tried to remember Trever Leingod as he was, they saw a crudely-scrawled memo stapled to the governor's gold statue. It read:

By order of Your Overlord His Highness, the town will begin stockpiling food in the Governor's Mansion. The cop will be by shortly to liberate your food supplies.

August 4, 2012
Edit
Xhin
Sky's the limit

3 thiings...

1. Why didn't the Mafia kill anybody? (Trever was obviously a sniper kill)They know who EVERYBODY is! To be honest, I thought I would be the obvious target, but this is ridiculous. Even a dead townie is better then nothing. What the Hell are they up to?

2. BOOYAH! Almost single handedly took out 9, the Mafioso!

3. *points at Dragon* GET HIM!

August 4, 2012
Edit
Feral

Almost forgot...

August 4, 2012
Edit
Feral

I'm glad that at least 3 of us had the good sense to vote to lynch 9.

Makes you wonder about the people that didn't want to take him out.

Not sure that Trever was not a Mafia kill. It would be smart on their part to do the kill, but not hide the body, in order to make us a little wary about using our sniper again.

August 4, 2012
Edit
chiefsonny
 

Alright, my guess is that the Mafia chose not to kill anyone last night in order to frame hezekiah. The other possibility is that hezekiah is Mafia and that they targeted someone 'suspicious' to the town in order to cover for him. If that's the case they also decided not to cover Trever with the Janitor's power.

Anyway, if they're doing the latter it seems to be a little counterproductive to me since they've just lowered our suspect pool. I'll wait to see what #85 came up with but I'm open to voting Dragon or taking a shot at one of the unknowns.

August 4, 2012
Edit
white lancer

If Trever WAS the Mafia kill, they must have specifically asked that the cause of death to be via a powerful rifle shot at a distance, to implicate the Sniper.

August 4, 2012
Edit
Feral

Of course, I managed to fish up the Magnifying Glass last night, so if anyone else needs investigating today, I'll do that once 85 comes back with his results (as there's no way of knowing who 85 investigated last night until he posts today). Who knows, perhaps we'll hit two Mafia with one stone...

That said, Dragon is as good a guess as any; after all, either Shadow and/or Roxas could have been a special role which a Mafia member is impersonating now that they're gone. One of them could have been the Spy, which Dragon is impersonating now. I'll wait until 85 comes back with his verdict before casting a vote.

August 4, 2012
Edit
Black Yoshi

Well there are now 10 of us and 3 of them.

If we decided to lynch someone this round we need to only give that person 3 votes. Now that means we will have to spread the votes out so that no other choice gets more then 2.

This way the Executioner will not get the 4 votes he needs to lock into a kill, there by giving them only 1 kill the next night.

And giving us the majority votes at the end of the day round at 3 votes for who we decided (if any one )lynch.

August 4, 2012
Edit
chiefsonny
 

Or Xhin is just playing with us--wouldn't put it past the Mafia to have a sniper rifle. :P But I agree that it's most likely that Trever was a Sniper kill. Another possibility is that he was targeted by both the Sniper and the Mafia last night.

Anyway, we know there's at least one Mafia among the remaining Townie claimants (and there could be as many as 3):

Kyon
White Thunder (Innocent via Cop check)
CtR Black
Zanic

There are a maximum of two Mafia members in this group:

chiefsonny
Dragon in the Shadows
Count Dooku (probably innocent)
hezekiah (probably innocent)
Feral
Black Yoshi (Innocent by Cop check)
#85

There could be as few as 0 Mafia members among that group.

August 4, 2012
Edit
white lancer

Of course, I managed to fish up the Magnifying Glass last night, so if anyone else needs investigating today

MM9 hezy or #85 in that order.

August 4, 2012
Edit
chiefsonny
 

Getting all my thoughts out now, not sure when I'll be able to check in next.

We have all the power roles claimed, so there are three possible scenarios: Rox and Shadow were both townies, only one of them was a townie, or neither of them was a townie.

If both of them were townies, that means there's only one vanilla townie remaining. I was cleared by a cop check, so obviously it's most likely to be me. That would leave Kyon, Zanic, and CtR as the remaining Mafia. CtR was the first to vote for 9 yesterday if I remember correctly, so he's not likely Mafia. This more or less rules this option out.

If one of them was a townie, that means both Zanic and Kyon are probably Mafia. This is entirely possible and explains why the night round took the full 24 hours- the Mafia couldn't advance without a majority of votes. Not positive, just possible. That means that one power role is falsely claimed, and I also see Dragon as the most suspicious.

If neither were a townie, that still leaves either Kyon or Zanic as Mafia. That would also mean that there were two falsely claimed power roles; most everyone else is pretty solid, in my opinion, so I believe this option is also not too likely.

So I'm inclined to vote for Dragon here, as well, with guesses that Kyon and Zanic are the other Mafia members. I will wait for 85's word, to be certain.

August 4, 2012
Edit
White Thunder

Or Xhin is just playing with us--wouldn't put it past the Mafia to have a sniper rifle. :P But I agree that it's most likely that Trever was a Sniper kill. Another possibility is that he was targeted by both the Sniper and the Mafia last night.

You're forgetting the third possibility. Hezekiah was lying about being the sniper, and is actually a member of the mafia. The mafia used their kill (and didn't hide the body) in order to make it seem like Hezekiah was the sniper.

I find it highly unlikely that both parties targeted Trever...

August 4, 2012
Edit
Count Dooku

You're forgetting the third possibility. Hezekiah was lying about being the sniper, and is actually a member of the mafia. The mafia used their kill (and didn't hide the body) in order to make it seem like Hezekiah was the sniper.

I addressed this possibility above.

Alright, my guess is that the Mafia chose not to kill anyone last night in order to frame hezekiah. The other possibility is that hezekiah is Mafia and that they targeted someone 'suspicious' to the town in order to cover for him. If that's the case they also decided not to cover Trever with the Janitor's power.

{:P}

August 4, 2012
Edit
white lancer

We know that the Mafia has at LEAST one member in the townie pool, and more likely two. Once they found out Trever was a townie they would be almost certain to hide his body in order to give them more cover. It seems unlikely that they would go so far just to hide one member.

It definitely is possible, though. If hezy is Mafia along with Kyon and Zanic, he wouldn't care if they as inactive players died, and would do whatever to make himself last as long as possible.

But again, I'm inclined to believe the former.

August 4, 2012
Edit
White Thunder

Christ, reading comprehension :(

I'm not sure I buy that the mafia would try to frame him... seems they'd be better off trying to kill our doctor or cop...

August 4, 2012
Edit
Count Dooku

My thoughts exactly on senerio #2, WT.

If Dragon, Kyon, and Zanic ARE Mafia, then I give HUGE props to Dragon for pretty much running the entire organization alone after Red's death. Huge acoplishment there. lol

August 4, 2012
Edit
Feral

That would leave Kyon, Zanic, and CtR as the remaining Mafia. CtR was the first to vote for 9 yesterday if I remember correctly, so he's not likely Mafia. This more or less rules this option out.

This is a good point and why I'm a little less suspicious of CtR than I was before. 9 was killed three votes to two, meaning that CtR's vote essentially decided the lynch. At the same time, though, I don't want to take that as proof of CtR's innocence because the Mafia probably wouldn't mind sacrificing a completely inactive member.

August 4, 2012
Edit
white lancer

I could be wrong but I doubt that Feral or CtR Black would have voted for 9 if they are Mafia. They would know it would bring their numbers down to 3.

Shadowwalked and `Roxas`, were both Mafia kills imo, or why would they hide the bodies?

August 4, 2012
Edit
chiefsonny
 

Lancer brings up a question- Who did Majora vote for last round. If he was one of the "two" people who voted the same, he is lying. Anything else, and he is likly telling the truth.

August 4, 2012
Edit
Feral

Majora didn't vote last round. But his status as the DV is pretty much confirmed by the 'No Kill' vote on Day 3.

Anyway, my suggestion is that unless #85 comes up with a Guilty verdict, we start taking out the Townies (now that two people have been removed from the pool). Depending on how many Mafia members we hit there we'll know how many Mafia members are masquerading as power roles. Meanwhile Yoshi and #85 can check our power roles (maybe Yoshi should use his check on #85?) to narrow down suspects there.

August 4, 2012
Edit
white lancer

Majora didn't vote last round.

He voted No Vote

Hmmm. That's strange. Is it not he who said that anyone voting NO Vote was a waste. And this is the only place that he knows of that even has the No Vote

So what harm does it do to check him out. You guy's including him have been quick to brand me as the Godfather, what makes you think he's who he claims he is.

August 4, 2012
Edit
chiefsonny
 

Anyway, my suggestion is that unless #85 comes up with a Guilty verdict, we start taking out the Townies (now that two people have been removed from the pool). Depending on how many Mafia members we hit there we'll know how many Mafia members are masquerading as power roles. Meanwhile Yoshi and #85 can check our power roles (maybe Yoshi should use his check on #85?) to narrow down suspects there.

I'm completely against trying to kill off our townies, because frankly the odds are greater that the mafia has killed power roles (9 power roles, 3 townies (-1 Trever) and assumed their identity.

In my opinion, Hezekiah is a very good bet for mafia. Here's why:

Hezekiah needed to prove he was sniper.

If Hezekiah is mafia, the only way to do that is to use a mafia kill on someone (Trever) and not hide the body.

The argument that maybe the mafia targeted Trever, but Hezekiah killed first, doesn't hold up. Why? Because the mafia would have janitored Trever's body.

It seems too perfect that the mafia targeted no one, or targeted Trever but didn't use the janitor, and Hezekiah just got there first.

The simplest explanation: Hezekiah is mafia, impersonating our dead sniper, and trying to verify himself in our eyes.

August 5, 2012
Edit
Count Dooku

Checked Dragon and he is guilty. Wow, Dragon got so lucky I checked Yoshi and not him the other day. It was literally a last second decision lol.

Anyways, I'm not sure what to make of the sniper situation. Going to reread after this post.

My guess is Kyon might be the final identifiable mafia.

Going to be tough to determine who the godfather is.

August 5, 2012
Edit
#85

Excellent. Voting Dragon out now. I suggest #85 check one of hezekiah/Kyon/Zanic. Yoshi could check one of those three or he could check #85.

August 5, 2012
Edit
white lancer

... Guess I'll vote for Hezekiah if I survive the night then.

And seriously, that said, if I die this coming night I don't want to see any 'The mafia killed Dooku to make Hezekiah look suspicious' crap.

August 5, 2012
Edit
Count Dooku

Damn, called it in day 2! I just KNEW Dragon reacted WAY to fast to my sugesting we lynch 9 that day!

So, yeah, Kyon and Zanic should be our next targets.

August 5, 2012
Edit
Feral

Hopefully Dragon is the Janitor and not the Executioner.

August 5, 2012
Edit
#85

Anyway, my suggestion is that unless #85 comes up with a Guilty verdict, we start taking out the Townies

Yea, that's a great idea. Let's help the Mafia and start WILLY-NILLY killing townies.
Why didn't you take this approach and vote for 9, who was Mafia.

Know something we didn't?

August 5, 2012
Edit
chiefsonny
 

Excuse the of-topic post hete.

Chief(or another global mod/admin), could you please check my request in the mod forum? A minor maintnence issue has arisen. Thanks.

August 5, 2012
Edit
Feral

With Dragon being pretty much confirmed Mafia, that leaves us with only a few options. Only 1 of the claimed power roles remaining can possibly be guilty, and I'm not sure any of them are.

-Dragon tried to redirect votes to chief yesterday.

-#85 has now given us two Mafia members and he was willing to vote Dragon out even without confirmation yesterday.

-Yoshi has been confirmed Innocent (though one of the two Mafia members left will be the Godfather, so that's not a clear-cut case of innocence).

-Majora, as I outlined yesterday, is pretty much confirmed innocent unless one of the players who voted 'No Kill' in Round 3 was lying to us.

-Dooku was willing to vote himself off yesterday and is the most likely to be insane out of all of us (plus we know the Governor is still alive).

-Feral was one of the first to be suspicious of Dragon and was very adamant that I wasn't going to die last night.

-Hezekiah is probably the least trustworthy of that group given that only one player died last night, but Xhin's description seems to indicate death by Sniper.

So I figure it's likely that more than one of our Townies are Mafia members. We know that at least one of them are.

August 5, 2012
Edit
white lancer

~Laughs~

guess my time has come. And Redack was right. #85 is mafia. The Cop was our first kill and #85 took his role. But #85, the Don as he liked to be called in the thread, wanted to call all the shots. Leading to fights throughout the game. Last night I had enough and told him if he didn't stop trying to control us, I would ask for a host kill. Enjoy the rest of the game. And Xhin, bury me up-side down so #85 can kiss my ass.

August 5, 2012
Edit
Dragon in the Shadows

Yea, that's a great idea. Let's help the Mafia and start WILLY-NILLY killing townies.

1. We know FOR A FACT that at least one and maybe two of the four Townies left is a Mafia member.

2. Three of them really haven't given us much to go off of so killing them 'willy-nilly' is really our only option if we don't have a Guilty verdict.

Why didn't you take this approach and vote for 9, who was Mafia.

Because there were more Townies at that point in time, because I wanted hezekiah to take a shot at someone during the night (so I didn't want to take the risk of losing three Townies in one round) and because if 9 was Mafia he was basically dead weight to their team anyway. I still think that statistically it wasn't a great decision to vote 9 off, especially because if he wound up as the last Mafia member standing we'd know for sure it was him because the Mafia wouldn't do anything with their night turn. Sometimes poor decisions work well through sheer dumb luck.

Know something we didn't?

...lol. Thinking I'm anything other than the Doctor at this point really doesn't make logical sense, given what's happened in this game.

August 5, 2012
Edit
white lancer

Lol, awesome story. I was the godfather before and I didn't power trip....hmmm...

August 5, 2012
Edit
#85

You guys know that we only need 3 votes for Dragon.to be lynched. It may be to late because the count is already at 4 and that's all it takes for the Executioner to take action, and have the janitor hide the body.

That way we would not know for sure and only have #85' word, and give them the perfect chance to put the Cop role in further question

August 5, 2012
Edit
chiefsonny
 

for the record, even if 9 wasn't mafia I wouldn't have voted to kill him for being inactive. It's not who I am.

August 5, 2012
Edit
Dragon in the Shadows

Oh, come on! If this story your spinning is true, #85 should have been host killed on day 2! If 85 IS mafia, he is the worst, and most selfish, mafia in history for offing two of his team.

Seriously, it would be heart breaking to think I have been playing a tremendous game, only to realize that the Mafia was more dysfunctional then the Griffins.

August 5, 2012
Edit
Feral

I guess my time has come. And Redack was right. =#85 is mafia. The Cop was our first kill and #85 took his role. But #85, the Don as he liked to be called in the thread, wanted to call all the shots. Leading to fights throughout the game. Last night I had enough and told him if he didn't stop trying to control us, I would ask for a host kill. Enjoy the rest of the game. And Xhin, bury me up-side down so #85 can kiss my ass.

XD. If this winds up being true you'll be able to knock me over with a feather when the game's over.

August 5, 2012
Edit
white lancer

After Dragon in the Shadows post above, everyone should know why I have some serious doubts about these so called role claims.

August 5, 2012
Edit
chiefsonny
 

You guys know that we only need 3 votes for Dragon.to be lynched. It may be to late because the count is already at 4 and that's all it takes for the Executioner to take action, and have the janitor hide the body.

... Uh...

The janitor can't hide a day kill body...

August 5, 2012
Edit
Count Dooku

Well, since we past the point of no return with the exeecutioner, we The Executioner is actually irrelevent thiss time. If his body is hid, he was the Executioner. The Janitor wouldn't be able to hide his own body, and #85 eliminted the possibility of being Godfather.

August 5, 2012
Edit
Feral

Didn't backspace enough...

August 5, 2012
Edit
Feral

Mayhap I should check on #85 to see if Dragon's claim is true...

...in any case, going with the crowd on this one.

August 5, 2012
Edit
Black Yoshi

Janitor - Every night, the Janitor can select one person. If that person dies that night, the Janitor will hide their body, preventing that person's role from being revealed. (Note: This can be used in conjunction with Mafia killings, but is not required to be used in this manner). Since the Janitor deals with hiding the body, the Janitor will be informed of the person's role upon death, but the town at large will not.

Every night, the Janitor can select one person.

Every night

Every night

Every night

August 5, 2012
Edit
Count Dooku

So maybe the Janitor chose the wrong person? Maybe the Mafia just didn't kill anyone last night and Hezy is our Sniper?

Or maybe, as stated above, the Janitor just didn't hide the body, and the Mafia made their kill look like the Sniper's shot?

August 5, 2012
Edit
Black Yoshi

another mafia dead

August 5, 2012
Edit
CtR Black

to punch a hole in to #85's plan. We decided not to kill last night. So we could get you guys to off Hez. That is the last bone I'm gonna toss you guys.

August 5, 2012
Edit
Dragon in the Shadows

Or maybe the Janitor is sombody who hasn't been around the last day to take action. Somebody like Kyon or Zanic.

If 85 is Mafia, he is probably Godfather(Dragon is highly likely Executioner), so I don't think checking him would do any good. I would concentrate on our target townies.

If one of Kyon or Zanic comes up innosent, we can consentrate on 85(as well as roles like myself or Hezy, who haven't been proven innocent).

August 5, 2012
Edit
Feral

I haven't read all of the replies yet but I did read #85's so

August 5, 2012
Edit
MajorasMask9

Every night, the Janitor can select one person.

Every night

Every night

Every night

No need to get emotional(cry)

But since the Executioner actions are locked in but don't take effect until the end of the day round, then that would be

Night

Night

Night

August 5, 2012
Edit
chiefsonny
 

Just to punch a hole in to #85's plan. We decided not to kill last night. So we could get you guys to off Hez. That is the last bone I'm gonna toss you guys.

Boy, you all but confirmed my suspicions. Trying to get us to doubt #85 again AND being nice enough to 'confirm' that Hezekiah is innocent? Clever!

August 5, 2012
Edit
Count Dooku

He voted No Vote

Hmmm. That's strange. Is it not he who said that anyone voting NO Vote was a waste. And this is the only place that he knows of that even has the No Vote

So what harm does it do to check him out. You guy's including him have been quick to brand me as the Godfather, what makes you think he's who he claims he is.

-chiefsonny


I said that "Not Voting" should only be used for retracting your vote. Prior to my "Not Voting" vote, I had a vote in for you. Unless you wanted me to keep the vote on you, then I don't see the problem here.

We already went over this--several times--how I was confirmed to be the double voter a few days back. We had 8 voters, and we reached the 9 vote limit for no-kill making Xhin end the round. Out of the 8 voters, I was the only one to claim double voter.

August 5, 2012
Edit
MajorasMask9

just bored. And like I said I didn't like how #85 was running things.

August 5, 2012
Edit
Dragon in the Shadows

Don't believe in bandwagons, but this may give me what I need to beleive #85 is who he says he is

August 5, 2012
Edit
chiefsonny
 

surprized you guys didn't ask about the remaining mafia member. The fact is I would never betray him. He had my back through the whole game.

August 5, 2012
Edit
Dragon in the Shadows

I'm surprized you guys didn't ask about the remaining mafia member.


Why in the world would we ask a mafia member who the other mafia member is?? That would be as reliable as Redack telling us #85 isn't really the cop.

August 5, 2012
Edit
MajorasMask9

I'm sorry I've been inactive guys. I'll try to catch up. Cop check is good enough for me.

August 5, 2012
Edit
Zanic

there has been a lot of fighting amongst the mafia. I mean a lot. I'm surprized Xhin didn't restart. I'm actually happy to be getting killed. I couldn't deal with that shit.

August 5, 2012
Edit
Dragon in the Shadows

So we basically have #85 vs Hezekiah, one of whom has to be the Godfather. We have heard from 85, so I want to hear from Hezekiah before I decide. But think about this;

Dragon acused 85 as being Mafia. 85 obviously doesn't have his back. The last Mafia(the Janitor) is likely an inactive townie who also wouldn't have had his back. Dragon's last post was a lie, so I have no reason to believe him about 85.

I know I haven't tenichally be proven guilty, but I am hoping the fact that I practically handed you guys both 9 and Dragon on a silver platter at least gives you cause to believe.

August 5, 2012
Edit
Feral

Uh, proven innosent, not guilty! LMAO!

August 5, 2012
Edit
Feral

Always when they are on death row they try this. {:D}

August 5, 2012
Edit
#85

So we basically have #85 vs Hezekiah, one of whom has to be the Godfather. We have heard from 85, so I want to hear from Hezekiah before I decide. But think about this;

Neither of them HAS to be the Godfather. One of them COULD be the Godfather, but it's also possible that both of them are innocent and that the last two Mafia are among the Townies.

August 5, 2012
Edit
white lancer

I know I haven't tenichally be proven guilty, but I am hoping the fact that I practically handed you guys both 9 and Dragon on a silver platter at least gives you cause to believe.

When did you hand us Dragon on a platter...

August 5, 2012
Edit
Count Dooku

is taking too long.

~Pulls out a gun an shots himself in the head~

August 5, 2012
Edit
Dragon in the Shadows

I'm surprized you guys didn't ask about the remaining mafia member.

I'll bite. Lay it on us.

August 5, 2012
Edit
chiefsonny
 

I had been highly suspicious of Dragon since day 2, when he jumped on my seconds after I suggested we lynch the inactive 9, whom wound up being Mafia. I had a strong hunch that both were Mafia and pushed the hell out of it. Once I was proven right about 9 last night,my first post today said, and I quote,

*Points finger at Dragon* GET HIM!


August 5, 2012
Edit
Feral

Meh, I figured out he was a fake spy based on Roxas's hints (well, its fair to assume Roxas was the spy at this point) so I want half the credit!

August 5, 2012
Edit
Count Dooku

Xhin is taking too long.

No. Take your time Xhin. At least another day. All this finger pointing and he said - she said is getting interesting.

August 5, 2012
Edit
chiefsonny
 

Dooku gets most of the credit in my book, since he called out Dragon even after he was hiding behind the Spy role. I definitely give Feral some credit for his little back-and-forth with Dragon, which read as highly suspicious on Dragon's part once I went back and read it with Dooku's suspicions in mind.

August 5, 2012
Edit
white lancer

Deal, Dooku. I get full credit for 9 anyway.

Besides, you are the one proven innosent! {troll}

August 5, 2012
Edit
Feral

I'm just not following why the mafia didn't take someone out.

August 5, 2012
Edit
#85

Deal, Dooku. I get full credit for 9 anyway.

Good, I was about to put through an edict giving myself full credit but I'll respect our terms.

August 5, 2012
Edit
Count Dooku

I'm just not following why the mafia didn't take someone out.

My theory being that Hez isn't the sniper, the real sniper is dead, the mafia killed Trever so Hez would appear to be the real sniper. They also didn't hide the body, as that would have taken away from the argument that Hez killed Trever.

August 5, 2012
Edit
Count Dooku

Hey, I should get a 1/2 credit. In was one of the 3 that voted for 9

August 5, 2012
Edit
chiefsonny
 

My theory being that Hez isn't the sniper, the real sniper is dead, the mafia killed Trever so Hez would appear to be the real sniper. They also didn't hide the body, as that would have taken away from the argument that Hez killed Trever.

This was my first thought, but why would the wording of the kill suggest a sniper kill?

August 5, 2012
Edit
#85

Cause I suggested it!

Anyway, if Hezy is a fake Sniper, then Shadow had to be the real one. We now know, due to his own subtle hints, that Roxas was the real spy.

I don't quite know why, but somthing about the way Zanic offered to be cop checked makes me feel he is innosent, unless 85 is guilty and would give a fake result. I suggest Yoshi investigate Zanic tonight. If he is found innosent, we can safley asume Kyon is the last Mafia, and 85 is innosent, putting hezy in the spot light. If he is guilty, then 85 probably is to.

August 5, 2012
Edit
Feral

Or as I said at the start of this round

"Not sure that Trever was not a Mafia kill. It would be smart on their part to do the kill, but not hide the body, in order to make us a little wary about using our sniper again."

With their numbers down to 3, they would not want to take a chance on the Sniper being right with his next shot.

August 5, 2012
Edit
chiefsonny
 

I don't quite know why, but somthing about the way Zanic offered to be cop checked makes me feel he is innosent, unless 85 is guilty and would give a fake result. I suggest Yoshi investigate Zanic tonight. If he is found innosent, we can safley asume Kyon is the last Mafia, and 85 is innosent, putting hezy in the spot light. If he is guilty, then 85 probably is to.

I don't think Zanic was offering to be Cop checked--I think he was saying that #85's Cop check of Dragon was good enough to make him vote that way. Anyway, there's still no reason why both #85 and hezekiah can't be innocent.

I think hezekiah should feel free to snipe another one of the Townies (preferably not White Thunder) tonight, assuming he really is the Sniper.

August 5, 2012
Edit
white lancer

Also, Feral, are you still covering me tonight?

August 5, 2012
Edit
white lancer

I hadn't thought about it. If you want me to, I will.

August 5, 2012
Edit
Feral

The best part of this game, more so then any past games, is going to be reading the Mafia and Dead Forums after the game is over.{:P}

August 5, 2012
Edit
chiefsonny
 

I think that would be good. We have a good combo going here--no sense bursting it now. ^_^

August 5, 2012
Edit
white lancer

This was my first thought, but why would the wording of the kill suggest a sniper kill?

Frankly, that's a good question. My only answer is that previous hosts have let the mafia decide how the kill was done.

For example, during one of the games when I was mafia we killed someone by dropping a toaster in their bathtub.

It's possible the mafia staged the kill and Xhin went along with it. Perhaps Xhin can confirm if he would do such a thing, without specifically confirming that it was done.

August 5, 2012
Edit
Count Dooku

For example, during one of the games when I was mafia we killed someone by dropping a toaster in their bathtub.

Yeah. Thanks for that. >:-{

August 5, 2012
Edit
white lancer

True. I remember when me, Majora, and Zanic were Mafia, we jokingly said we wanted to kill somebody(Red I think) via scorpion venom, and Yeano did it that way.

August 5, 2012
Edit
Feral

Yeah. Thanks for that. >:-{

Bahaha, I forgot who it was! Although it wasn't exactly as I'd imagined... I think the host said that the toaster fell out of a trapdoor in the ceiling or something... I figured we'd just walk in while you were in the bath and toss it in as you watched in horror.

Anyway, I'm in agreement with Lancer about at least one mafia being hidden among the townies. I'm not particularly in favor of just killing them left and right until we get lucky though (although there are (presumably) three townies left in all.

Still would like to see a bit more discussion about Hezekiah >.> Just saying...

August 5, 2012
Edit
Count Dooku

I think I'll have more to say on Hezekiah next round.

August 5, 2012
Edit
white lancer

I prefer to wait for hezy to speak before deciding wether to string him up or not.

My suspicions:

Godfather- #85/Hezekiah
Silencer- Redack
Executioner- Dragon
Janitor-Kyon
Mafioso-9

August 5, 2012
Edit
Feral

I prefer to wait for hezy to speak before deciding wether to string him up or not.

Well yes, he'll have his chance tomorrow. No need to let Dragon get another night action in if he's the janitor...

August 5, 2012
Edit
Count Dooku

I don't think Zanic was offering to be Cop checked--I think he was saying that #85's Cop check of Dragon was good enough to make him vote that way.

Lancer was correct. But I have no problem with being cop checked too.

August 5, 2012
Edit
Zanic

The governor should come forward.

It is possible kyon is the governor since he is inactive.

August 5, 2012
Edit
#85

The Governor DID come forward. Dooku is proven governor.

August 5, 2012
Edit
Feral

Jesus, I leave for 5 hours and there's 91 replies and 3 votes more than you guys need?!

Give me some time to read through everything before Dragon dies.

August 5, 2012
Edit
Xhin
Sky's the limit

Debating between checking Hez and Kyon tonight, open to thoughts.

August 5, 2012
Edit
#85

gotcha feral, wasnt sure that was confirmed

August 5, 2012
Edit
#85

Check Kyon. It's better to have us know who you're checking so Yoshi checks someone different.

August 5, 2012
Edit
white lancer

Check Kyon, but with one of two remaining Mafia being the Godfather the odds aren't in our favor. Still, can't hurt.

Assuming just for a minute that 85 is the actual cop, Redack's play was absolutely brilliant, I'll give him that. Look at how little we all are trusting him. Dragon's, however, feels much less genuine. Good effort but his attempt actually makes it seem even more likely to me that 85 is innocent.

And, for good measure,

August 5, 2012
Edit
White Thunder

Hmm, I'm not sure if the governor actually prevented the day killing or not. I can't tell if it's a hypothetical or an actual command. It reads:

Perhaps I could force them. 'Either vote Hezekiah or I'll prevent anyone from dying.'


Any ideas?

August 5, 2012
Edit
Xhin
Sky's the limit

"Perhaps I could..." He was thinking out loud.

So no.

August 5, 2012
Edit
Feral

It sounds like he's stopping the killings, but Idk why he would.

August 5, 2012
Edit
Zanic

It's in quotes, so it's not invoking his power. He was just thinking about what he might tell us if we started going a direction he didn't want.

August 5, 2012
Edit
white lancer

Well, I can't reach him anyway. Fair enough. Climactic death in 3... 2... 1...

Night 5

The townies decided they had had enough of Dragon in the Shadows, so they

decided to kill him. #85 came up with a genius idea of slowly cutting him in half

with a laser on a piece of the governor statue. As the laser crept towards him,

chiefsonny said, "I'll bite. Lay it on us." As the laser was almost at him, dragon yelled "DO YOU EXPECT ME TO TALK?" to which chiefsonny replied, "No Mr. Shadow. I expect you to die."

.

.

.

.

.

.

.

Unlike a real Spy, he did. Per request, Dragon in the Shadows, the Executioner was buried face-down.

24 hours or until all night actions are completed.

August 5, 2012
Edit
Xhin
Sky's the limit

Reply to: game ix thread 5 night 5 a town here lay in slumber where the townies do outnumber and those wh

Username
Password