I'll have you know I did have PN on my list in the sign-up thread :'(...

Lol... I honestly wasn't sure if I'd use a coin flip but my vote might as well be random. I honestly don't feel I have enough to go on. Both Black Yoshi and Apollo have done things that make me suspicious of them, neither of them interacted with Jo Nathan, and both were kind of inactive during some parts of the game.

I kind of want to vote for Apollo, but the thing is, I think I'm just being way too influenced by confirmation bias. Basically, my gut feeling is that it's Black Yoshi, but also, my gut feeling is that it's Apollo.

I'll give it some thought. I honestly can't think of any more questions I could possibly ask them. I might even just go for a random vote, but if that screws the town I'll feel bad. Then again, if I voted for either BY or Apollo and was wrong I'd probably feel just as bad.

Ok I'm going to give this one last shot as far as questions go. Depending on both Black Yoshi's and Apollo's answers, I might make an actual guess, because I think this could potentially be very revealing assuming I'm thinking this through correctly.

If their responses to my questions together still just raise questions, I'll put in a random vote.

I'm hoping that through the way they describe their actions/intentions during Night 5 (when the Serial Killer didn't make a kill) I will be able to better judge which of them is the serial killer.

What I decide to do really depends on what Black Yoshi says, but it's interesting that Apollo claimed being online at the time. I was almost hoping she'd say she was definitely offline at the time. If she did, and while it could have been a lie, I'd have likely believed it. If you're the Serial Killer and the town knows that the SK didn't make a kill one night, claiming to be offline would seem like a clearly bad decision, since the town could say "hey, you were offline at that time, and the serial killer was inactive... coincidence??"

At the same time this alone isn't enough evidence against Apollo at all. I mean I believe she's telling the truth at this point. She could be a townie and have been online that night, which I honestly think is the case.

Black Yoshi's response is the one I'm most interested in though, because I'll be able to better understand his intentions if he's the serial killer. I feel like his statements in Day 5 were questionable if he were the Serial Killer, but at the same time, he really does seem like the most obvious pick right now.

And Black Yoshi just said exactly what I wasn't expecting. I'm going to have to give this a lot of thought, but I do find it very telling that he decided to be open about his activity rather than lie and say that he was online, on a night that we're assuming the SK may have been too busy.

Going to give this some more thought, and I do have a busy day tomorrow, but I'll have my vote in by tomorrow evening. I need to consider:

1)Whether or not the Serial Killer was actually inactive or he was just faking.
2)How the proposed ideas about the lack of a kill on Night 5 by Black Yoshi and Apollo mesh with the actual events of the game.
3)How their reported activity ties in with that.

And I'll decide which series of roles/events makes the most sense. But I don't think I'll be random voting.