Engines Aether Legend of the Lunar Priest NIFE Roadmap
Shatterloop Game Projects Deprecated Starwright
Saepes Mundi Other Projects Blog  

Mafia

Moderated by: Speed Bike Pro

mafia game 1 day round 2 lynchin time

Posted February 8, 2012 by Yeano

Hello all! Here is the current list of players.


1. Xhin
2. chiefsonny
3. RubyLizard
4. LLight - (Townie) removed for using his glitch specialist powers to get into the Mafia thread.
5. Kassie the Eevee
6. Feral
7. MajorasMask9
8. Black Yoshi
9. Shadowwalked
10. poptart!
11. Knukles2000
12. Helius
13. white lancer
14. `Roxas`
15. BCB
16. Malas
17. #85

You will notice under the forum title, "Your Role is [something]" If yours says Mafia, then you are on the Mafia. If yours says Cop, then you are the cop. If yours says Doctor, then you are the doctor. I will make special posts for these three roles explaining what you need to do.

If your role shows up as Townie with a number after it, that means you are a townie in this game. You don't have any special night powers.

But it is the day round, so for now, we don't have to worry about that. All town players (Townies, Cop, Doctor) want to kill the mafia. The Mafia wants to kill the town.

So, during the day round, you will get to vote for 1 person that you want to kill.

So go ahead and vote for someone!

You have 72 hours.

There are 109 Replies

extensionEnable Post Pagination

Sorry, I am still confused as hell. I know that we want to kill the players on the other team(Mafia vs Townies), but how do we know who to go after so we don't accidentally kill our teammates?

February 8, 2012
Edit
Feral

We don't know. I mean, at this point, we could randomly vote for someone, but considering there are what... 11 townies according to the top of the forum, the odds are we'd kill someone town-sided. Eh!

I'll vote for Xhin in the meantime.

It should be easier to vote for people who are mafia when the cop/cops start checking people.

Also! Isn't there usually a role list? Where we can see the ratio of town:mafia players, and what roles are alive? This game feels kind of unusually blind.

February 8, 2012
Edit
MajorasMask9

I vote Helius.

February 8, 2012
Edit
Malas

I vote for Feral

February 8, 2012
Edit
#85

I'm under the impression that the mafia can talk among themselves, so they know who's a mafia and who isn't. Townies are the blind ones. Sure, they can say they're townies, but there's no way of actually proving it.

Probably the best way is to wait until a lot of other people have voted so if they're targeting a certain person they're likely to be a mafioso. Thus, I'll vote in a day or two.

February 8, 2012
Edit
Xhin
Sky's the limit

Vote for poptartface

February 8, 2012
Edit
LLight

I mean... I vote white lancer.

I refuse to vote for Malas considering how awesome he is.

February 8, 2012
Edit
Helius

Hmm indeed!

February 9, 2012
Edit
LLight

Why are you idiots voting blind? We should be talking first to figure out who's in the goddamn mafia.

February 9, 2012
Edit
poptart!
 

IMO it's pretty suspicious that #85 is already voting to kill Feral when it seems pretty obvious that Feral is a townie (judging by his reply). Or am I missing something? Is Feral just trying to throw us off? He doesn't seem manipulative enough to do that.

February 9, 2012
Edit
poptart!
 

You're so theatrical about this.

February 9, 2012
Edit
LLight

I'm theatrical about everything!! Don't you know me by now?

February 9, 2012
Edit
poptart!
 

Sorry, forgot the role list and ratio.

Roles:

Mafia (4)
Cop (1)
Doctor (1)
Townies (11 10)

4 Mafiosos - 13 12 Town Members

February 9, 2012
Edit
Yeano

*gets smited by God*

lol, I guess I was the first to die. I thought it might be interesting to confuse the mafia. Fired too? Sadface. {:(}

February 9, 2012
Edit
LLight

Hahahahahahahahahhahahahahahahahhahlskgfjfkgjfgljg.

February 9, 2012
Edit
poptart!
 

removed for using his glitch specialist powers to get into the Mafia thread.

hahahahaha

February 9, 2012
Edit
Kassie the Eevee

Note: If you are a townie, you do not have to make your own thread. During the day round, all posts should go in the stickied thread. So right now, even though you have no information, you want to vote in the main thread (i.e., the one you are reading RIGHT NOW). Your vote will suggest who you want to lynch. For instance, if you want to lynch Yeano, you could say "I vote Yeano." The more people talk, the more you might find their actions suspicious. So even though you have no information, you may be able to find a mafioso as more people talk.

February 9, 2012
Edit
Yeano

I voted for him because I didn't buy his line

February 9, 2012
Edit
#85

Yeah, I think Feral might actually just be fucking with us. I vote Feral.

February 9, 2012
Edit
poptart!
 

poptart's got a good point. I vote Feral too.

Also how on earth did you get into the mafia thread. I even fixed the editing bug on that.

Also, having multiple townie roles makes sense because it keeps townies from talking to each other.

February 9, 2012
Edit
Xhin
Sky's the limit

Majora's Mask probably assumes I'm Mafia because I'm Xhin, so he's probably a townie.

February 9, 2012
Edit
Xhin
Sky's the limit

The first vote is tricky cause we don't have a lot to go off of. If I had to guess, though, I'd put my money on LLight not being Mafia.

I am considering voting Helius just for that little comment of his. ;)

February 9, 2012
Edit
white lancer

I'll submit it as a bug report when the game is over. It's actually not as game breaking as you think.

February 9, 2012
Edit
LLight

Majora's Mask probably assumes I'm Mafia because I'm Xhin, so he's probably a townie.

Nah, I just picked the first name that came to mind. I don't think you'll die anyway :).

But ya I am a townie!

February 9, 2012
Edit
MajorasMask9

There is actually a scientific reason why the first person to go always gets the raw end of the stick. I was reading it the other day.

I could vote Malas since he voted for me... but Lancer, you're always suspicious.

February 9, 2012
Edit
Helius

My thoughts -

The mafias best bet would be to wait till we cast our votes since we are sort of spread out, and then vote in a block and get rid of one of us.

But on the other hand that would identify who they are pretty early

So I'm calling on everyone to vote for feral.

February 9, 2012
Edit
#85

Current votes:

Feral (3 votes - #85, poptart!, Xhin)
Xhin (1 vote - MajorasMask9)
Helius (1 vote - Malas)
white lancer (1 vote - Helius)

You still have like 32 hours.

February 9, 2012
Edit
Yeano

I vote for Feral.

February 9, 2012
Edit
BCB

It's between Feral and #85 for me. I think #85 might just be the Cop. So I vote for Feral. He looks and talks like a Mafia Don.

When do me use the individual threads?

P.S. Xhin please do something about those dumb ass pumpkins that keep showing up on my post.

February 9, 2012
Edit
chiefsonny
 

It seems that the overall consensus is that Feral is a terrible person and deserves to be lynched publicly. And since it's the first day and the only thing we can really go on is mob mentality, I too shall vote for Feral.

February 9, 2012
Edit
Shadowwalked

Mob mentality is dangerous.

That being said, I regretfully am voting for Feral.

February 10, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

Geez. Killed for being a noob at this, I guess. But then, who is actually wrong here? ;p

I'm voting #85 simply out of survival here. If I get one more vote, the round is over and I am eliminated. The only way for me to survive now is for all 5 of the remaining votes to be cast for #85, and that would just tie us at 7 apiece.

February 10, 2012
Edit
Feral

I could vote Malas since he voted for me... but Lancer, you're always suspicious.

That's what everyone always tells me. It's because I'm Italian, right?

I'm still deciding about my vote. It's tough to read someone over the internet, and since it's the first round we don't really have a lot of information. If it's the day round, the Cop hasn't even had a chance to guess yet, right?

February 10, 2012
Edit
white lancer

I vote MajorasMask9's. simply cause he announced what he was, thats obviously meant to throw us off whether he is a mafia, or a townie. Idc what the majority is voting. I will vote for who seems the most suspicious.

I'm only voting now cause he seems to be playing a deceptive game, and everyone seems to be hopped up on donuts not doing their job.

However, if a chance to change our votes is presented, I MIGHT take it.

February 10, 2012
Edit
Knukles2000

^ We're allowed to change our votes.

Changing my vote to Feral.

February 11, 2012
Edit
MajorasMask9

The day round is over!

During the day round, LLight succeeded in breaking into the Mafia's stronghold, but he didn't expect the trap awaiting him. He stepped on a floor that gave way and fell 500 yards down into a pit of spikes. He was a Townie.

Additionally, the town decided to lynch poor ol' Feral. As the noose tightened around his neck, he tried to convince the town he was innocent, but alas, he was hung. So long, Feral the Townie.

Player List:

1. Xhin
2. chiefsonny
3. RubyLizard
4. LLight - (Townie)
5. Kassie the Eevee
6. Feral - (Townie)
7. MajorasMask9
8. Black Yoshi
9. Shadowwalked
10. poptart!
11. Knukles2000
12. Helius
13. white lancer
14. `Roxas`
15. BCB
16. Malas
17. #85

Ratio: 4-11.

Roles: Mafia (4), Doctor (1), Cop (1), Townies (9)

Now, we are entering the night round. For all townies, you do nothing but wait until the day round to start again. Mafiosos, in the Mafia thread, vote on who you want to kill. Doctor, in the Doctor thread, say who you want to protect. Cop, in the Cop thread, say who you want to investigate.

These roles have 24 hours to respond.

February 11, 2012
Edit
Yeano

I've a question for Yeano that I'd rather not discuss on a public thread. do you have AIM or MSN?

February 11, 2012
Edit
Kassie the Eevee

AIM: YeanoGames

February 11, 2012
Edit
Yeano

DAY ROUND 2:

During the night, the Mafia had a clever little trap for someone. Right before he was about to go to sleep, poptart! brushed his teeth with poisoned toothpaste! But, unfortunately for the Mafia, the Doctor showed up and revived poptart!

Player List:

1. Xhin
2. chiefsonny
3. RubyLizard
4. LLight - (Townie)
5. Kassie the Eevee
6. Feral - (Townie)
7. MajorasMask9
8. Black Yoshi
9. Shadowwalked
10. poptart!
11. Knukles2000
12. Helius
13. white lancer
14. `Roxas`
15. BCB
16. Malas
17. #85

Ratio: 4-11.

Roles: Mafia (4), Doctor (1), Cop (1), Townies (9)

Just like the first day round, place your votes on whom to lynch here.

You have 72 hours.

February 11, 2012
Edit
Yeano

Okay, so we have two pieces of information now. We know poptart isn't Mafia since they tried to kill him, and the Cop has had a chance to investigate someone and knows whether that person is Mafia or not. I'd suggest that the Cop plays quietly for now to avoid becoming a target.

Other than that, I'm not really sure who is likely to be Mafia right now. So for now I'll vote Helius because he voted me last time. >:-{

February 11, 2012
Edit
white lancer

Actually, if the cop revealed any useful information, it might be beneficial for them to post what it was; we do have a doctor that's still alive. Depends upon the information I guess! Granted, only one day has passed so nothing game-changing could come from a cop check, and the doctor might not even protect the cop, etc.

Don't really have any idea who to vote for, but just judging from the last day round, I'll vote for Malas for now. He kind of seemed suspicious (or at least, a bit moreso than other people), but I'd probably be willing to change it if something comes up.

February 11, 2012
Edit
MajorasMask9

It's good knowing that there is a definite townie we know not to vote for going forward from here.

I find it odd that out of all of the participants, the only one not to comment in this thread is Black Yoshi.

That being said, I cast my vote for Black Yoshi.

February 11, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

I have a question. Can the mafia vote in this post? Like, they could pretend to vote for someone in this post, yeano wouldn't count it, and the mafia would then vote on someone else in the mafia post?

February 11, 2012
Edit
Xhin
Sky's the limit

Or is the day round separate from the night round, so they could vote in this post and then vote in the mafia post too?

February 11, 2012
Edit
Xhin
Sky's the limit

I vote Shadowwalked

Any particular reason, might I ask? Or are you just firing into the dark? Because if that's what this game is being reduced to, we're going to end up killing ourselves faster than the mafia can get to us.

That being said, there has to be some way to distinguish who is a townie and who is in the mafia. We all fucked up by picking Feral, and we have to take into consideration that it was either an honest mistake by #85, or that he purposely voted for Feral just so we would all lynch him, thus being one townie down.

If you recall from earlier in the thread, the prince of pain! was suspicious of #85, but then decided to vote for Feral.

Is it not odd that the very person who first suspects #85 is the first person targeted by the Mafia at night? It might have been an attempt to silence tpop before he had a chance to turn his suspicion back to #85.

Xhin was the third to vote for Feral, but only after stating that tpop! had a good point, so I find it more reasonable to think that he was just going along with the crowd, rather than having any sinister intent.

So rather than do the time old technique of "You voted for me? Bastard!" and vote for RubyLizard, I'm going to cast my vote for #85. It's the only logical conclusion I can go on based on what has already occurred.

And if my theory is correct, then I can expect immediate retribution by the remaining three mafia members. Thus, I see no harm in admitting that I am the Doctor, and it was based on my conclusions that I protected the prince of pain! last night.

My reasoning has been justified up to this point. And when the night round starts again, I will take action by protecting myself.

Or is the day round separate from the night round, so they could vote in this post and then vote in the mafia post too?

If they couldn't, then why would be voting for each other? This would be the easiest game ever, we'd just vote for whoever didn't talk.

February 11, 2012
Edit
Shadowwalked

Also, completely relevant:

February 11, 2012
Edit
Shadowwalked

How do any of us know that you aren't making conspiracy theories, and #85 made an honest mistake though, and you aren't part of the mafia, Shadowwalked? It's just not that simple. People will vote for who they vote for, for different reasons, suspicions, and sides.

Regardless though, i'll wing it for now and vote #85 unless I am given reason to change my mind.

February 11, 2012
Edit
Knukles2000

Shadowwalked makes a valid point. I did not even notice that when reviewing the first round of voting.

But at the same time, how are we not to suspect that you stating you are The Doctor, when clearly nobody but you could know whether you are or not, is just a decoy as to draw attention off of you being a member of the Mafia?

We all have every reason to suspect one another of being a member of the Mafia at this point in time, and that was a mistake, I believe, that swayed our decisions to vote for Feral.

All in all, I have decided to change my vote to #85.

February 11, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

Shadowwalked and Roxas both make good points. We definitely have to be careful about believing everything everyone tells us; for all we know, poptart himself could be the doctor. But we definitely can't keep taking stabs in the dark, and without much concrete info I'm gonna have to go on speculation, and Shadowwalked's is the best we've got right now. I'm changing my vote to #85.

February 11, 2012
Edit
white lancer

How do any of us know that you aren't making conspiracy theories, and #85 made an honest mistake though, and you aren't part of the mafia, Shadowwalked?

But at the same time, how are we not to suspect that you stating you are The Doctor, when clearly nobody but you could know whether you are or not, is just a decoy as to draw attention off of you being a member of the Mafia?

Simple enough. Tonight I'm going to choose to protect myself. As far as I know, the prince of pain! should be relatively safe (Having him killed would only confirm my suspicions), and picking anyone else would be just as much a shot in the dark as picking who to protect by drawing a name out of a hat.

Another townie might die other than tpop and I, but our ability to trust each other and determine who the mafia is will go up dramatically.

And if I am indeed wrong about #85, you still have the benefit of knowing for certainty the doctor and a townie.

We definitely have to be careful about believing everything everyone tells us; for all we know, poptart himself could be the doctor.

Then don't take my word for it, and ask him yourself. I wouldn't see any reason for him to lie at this point.

Also, something I caught:

I find it odd that out of all of the participants, the only one not to comment in this thread is Black Yoshi.

Be careful with this. One of the Mafia roles is the silencer, which prevents them from speaking in the thread. Worse case scenario is that he's the cop, and has been silenced this whole time.

February 11, 2012
Edit
Shadowwalked

But it is now Day Two, and still nothing. Although it is possible that the Cop (in this scenario, Black Yoshi) has been silenced twice, I find that a little doubtful.

February 11, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

But it is now Day Two, and still nothing. Although it is possible that the Cop (in this scenario, Black Yoshi) has been silenced twice, I find that a little doubtful.

If that is the case, we're pretty fucked. But I agree that it's a long-shot to assume that Day Two and they've already figured out the cop.

February 12, 2012
Edit
Shadowwalked

I'm going to have to agree with Shadow on this one, first round I just voted out random because we had nothing to go on. Now there's quite a few posts to look at and I have to say I agree, my vote goes to #85.

February 12, 2012
Edit
Malas

Shadowwalked, could you point out to me where in this entire game it was ever stated that one of the mafia is a silencer?

EDIT: I guess you could assume there's a silencer based on the list of roles in the forum documents, but I wouldn't assume there is a silencer in play at the moment. Based on other games I've seen, special roles like that are usually specified in the main thread with the role list. This could be different I guess...

February 12, 2012
Edit
MajorasMask9

Well considering that the only thing we can read is replies in this thread and we've already wasted one of our own by sending Feral packing we can ill afford to fuck up again.

What is the point of having a Doctor thread or Cop thread if you can not read what's in the thread?

It does bother me that we have not seen any post by Black Yoshi.

I vote for Black Yoshi.
If we don't get a response from him after two rounds maybe he has been silenced or is taking a low profile because he does not want to bring attention to him self which has failed or he is the Silencer.

February 12, 2012
Edit
chiefsonny
 

@Majora, check under Mafia roles. You'll see it only appears under the mafia section.

February 12, 2012
Edit
Knukles2000

Under
Mafia Roles:

Silencer - Can target one person per day to silence. Once silenced, this person cannot speak for the rest of that day.

February 12, 2012
Edit
chiefsonny
 

Shadowwalked, could you point out to me where in this entire game it was ever stated that one of the mafia is a silencer?

There's like, six documents at the top of the page that state the rules of the game and what is and what is not allowed. I was reading through them to see whether or not I could admit that I was a doctor, and whether I could protect myself if I did.

February 12, 2012
Edit
Shadowwalked

fair enough

Guess I'll stick with my Malas vote :).

February 12, 2012
Edit
MajorasMask9

Clearing a few things up...

1. In order to lynch someone during the day round, a person must vote in this thread. So if a mafia member would want to vote to lynch someone, they would have to do it in this thread. They could not do it in the Mafia thread.

2. There is no silencer in this game. While I did include Godfather and Silencer in the role list document, I did not include them in this game. All mafia members are vanilla Mafiosos.

That is all.

February 12, 2012
Edit
Yeano

Well if no one can be silenced, then that gives me even more concern as to why Black Yoshi is the only one that has not made a post.

February 12, 2012
Edit
chiefsonny
 

Well if no one can be silenced, then that gives me even more concern as to why Black Yoshi is the only one that has not made a post.

I agree that his silence is of concern, now that I know there is no silencer. My priority of suspects is:

1. #85
2. Black Yoshi

However, trying not to draw attention to yourself is a strategy both townies and mafia can use, and it would be understandable if Black Yoshi wanted to sit back in the thread and wait to see how things play out.

If he doesn't say anything by day three, I think it would be a wise choice to vote for him then, so my vote remains on #85.

February 12, 2012
Edit
Shadowwalked

I agree that his silence is of concern, now that I know there is no silencer. My priority of suspects is:

1. #85
2. Black Yoshi

However, trying not to draw attention to yourself is a strategy both townies and mafia can use, and it would be understandable if Black Yoshi wanted to sit back in the thread and wait to see how things play out.

If he doesn't say anything by day three, I think it would be a wise choice to vote for him then, so my vote remains on #85.

Ditto.

February 12, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

this is absurd, it's definitely 'Roxas'. he's the silently evil sort.

February 12, 2012
Edit
Kassie the Eevee

Sorry, I just haven't had much time to get on here, and when I have, I've barely had enough time to read this post, let alone reply to it.

Anyway, my vote goes to Shadowwalked.

February 12, 2012
Edit
Black Yoshi

And yet I'm one of the most vocal and observant of those of us who are obviously trying to figure out who is Mafia and who is not, Kassie. I am playing the game as well as I can to keep as much of the town safe as possible. Like I have said, anybody could be a member of the Mafia, but I guaran-damn-tee that I am not. You want proof? I can make a post that will prove that I am not a member of the Mafia, mostly because nobody else who is playing would make such a post.

I'm just throwing out the names of people who are the most suspicious/defensive of being charged as being Mafia. To be honest, and it is nothing personal against anybody that I have named, those that have come off as being possibly Mafia were Black Yoshi, this perspective is probable to change in time, and #85, being the kind that I have observed is the most defensive when pointed out as a possibility of being Mafia (see the attack on poptart! as Exhibit A).

My votes are cast by observation and observation alone, not biases, grudges or prejudices against anybody else.

February 12, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

Sorry, I just haven't had much time to get on here, and when I have, I've barely had enough time to read this post, let alone reply to it.

Anyway, my vote goes to Shadowwalked.

That troubles me, to be honest. My suspicion of you up until now has been based entirely on your silence as pointed out by chiefsonny. Unless you only read the post dealing with you, I've stated that I was the Doctor, and that during the night round I was going to save myself to prove my validity.

I can only assume that voting for me is an attempt to stop me from proving that I'm the Doctor. Now I must take into account that you might have actually been trying to keep attention off yourself, and at having cover blown, try to kill me by another means.

February 12, 2012
Edit
Shadowwalked

My votes are cast by observation and observation alone, not biases, grudges or prejudices against anybody else.

Following this method is the only way that we'll have a chance to win. Going against Feral was a fuck up, to be sure, but it gave us the information necessary for our two suspects.

It's not much to go on, but until the cop surfaces, it's all we have.

February 12, 2012
Edit
Shadowwalked

I vote for #85.

Also, I'm not the doctor.

February 12, 2012
Edit
poptart!
 

If we try to kill Shadowwalked and he gets resurrected, we'll have proof that he's the doctor. However, we would have wasted our turn. Knowing this, is it likely that Shadowwalked would have spoken up if he was Mafia?

I think we should look at the people who have spoken the least in general. If you're a mafia, you're one of four. Speaking up and making waves is very risky and is probably going to get you targeted (see: shadowwalked and #85). Not speaking at all is also a bad idea (see: Black Yoshi), however saying nothing more than casting a vote for what people are already going for makes you look like a townie.

The following people haven't made any waves:

1. RubyLizard (voted for Malas,then shadowwalked)
2. Kassie the Eevee (laughed at Llight, asked Yeano a question, then voted for `Roxas`.
3. Black Yoshi obviously
4. Helius (voted for white lancer twice and did nothing else)

Considering that's exactly four people, and the mafia consists of four people, we should vote for those guys.

Note that everyone else has been busy trying to figure out who is who (or appears that way). If you're mafia, then you already know who's who because you can talk with the other mafia members in the mafia post, so unless you're exceptionally devious, you're going to act based on what you know. But acting devious is a very high-risk strategy.

February 12, 2012
Edit
Xhin
Sky's the limit

Another thing to consider with Shadowwalked. He claims he's the doctor, and no one else has yet claimed they were the doctor. Since poptart was saved by the doctor, the doctor IS active and has been actively reading this thread. Shadowwalked must realize this, so if he was mafia, claiming he was the doctor is a very bad plan.

My hope is that you'll all follow me with aiming for the four relatively inactive players. If they don't want to be taken down, they'll speak up, and the more players speak up the more likely mafia players are to slip up.

February 12, 2012
Edit
Xhin
Sky's the limit

I noticed that too, Xhin. There are definitely some people who are managing to escape notice and play under the radar, and I think we need to keep all of them in mind, especially Black Yoshi. I'm still sketchy on #85, though, so my vote for him stands.

If we try to kill Shadowwalked and he gets resurrected, we'll have proof that he's the doctor. However, we would have wasted our turn. Knowing this, is it likely that Shadowwalked would have spoken up if he was Mafia?

I don't think Shadowwalked is able to protect himself from being lynched. Pretty sure the Doctor's powers only protect from the Mafia.

February 12, 2012
Edit
white lancer

If we try to kill Shadowwalked and he gets resurrected, we'll have proof that he's the doctor.

I can't keep myself from being lynched, I can only keep myself from being assassinated by Mafia. If you were to vote for me, you would both waste a turn AND lose your doctor.

Another thing to consider with Shadowwalked. He claims he's the doctor, and no one else has yet claimed they were the doctor. Since poptart was saved by the doctor, the doctor IS active and has been actively reading this thread. Shadowwalked must realize this, so if he was mafia, claiming he was the doctor is a very bad plan.

It wouldn't just be a bad plan, it would be downright retarded. If someone else was the doctor, they could literally protect any other person during the night to disprove me.

And I think I've made it quite clear that I've actively been reading this thread.

February 12, 2012
Edit
Shadowwalked

My vote goes to Kassie. She even posted in the voting thread but didn't make a vote until it all played out which I am greatly suspicious of


I understand peoples suspicion of me, but cmon who can't understand the townies role? So I made the wrong call. The fact that i tried to make a move so early should help, not hurt my case. We didn't have much to go on . Lol I don't think it was that dumb

February 12, 2012
Edit
#85

I understand peoples suspicion of me, but cmon who can't understand the townies role? So I made the wrong call. The fact that i tried to make a move so early should help, not hurt my case. We didn't have much to go on . Lol I don't think it was that dumb

To be honest, it's not that you voted on someone early. Hell, I voted for Feral too. The odds of someone innocent dying far outweighed the odds of someone guilty dying, and it had to be done so that we could gather more information. But the only lead we have right now is that the first person to suspect you was the first person targeted by the Mafia.

If you do turn out to be innocent, then Xhin's theory will have much more weight, and you will still be avenged in the end, as the person who you would vote for this round would be one of the suspects in the next round.

February 12, 2012
Edit
Shadowwalked

Well, let me make my wave then... lol. I've been thinking about what we saw in this thread. It's all public knowledge, and I want to be known as the crazy conspiracy theorist anyhow.

What We know...

Llight had said: vote for poptartface. He didn't defend himself in this regards. He still hasn't. Llight is now gone. Killed by the Mafia. It is true he bent the rules; however, he did tell us who to vote for before he met his demise.

In fact, poptartface laughed at Llight being smited by God. He felt no remorse... why? Could it be that he is Mafioso sent to infiltrate our ranks and deceive us. If so, he's doing a poor job. (Other possibility is this is just PoP's sense of humor)

Poptartface also voted for Feral. This could point to a thinning of our ranks.

End of conspiracy theory

Though, I do not regard him being targeted by Mafioso as a clear sign he is an endowed Townie.

It is possible...

That since his identity was compromised by Llight and his trickery that the Mafia decided to attempt to kill PoP. This means that they would have to be working in cahoots with the doctor or that it was just random coincidence or they planted information to make the Doc feel like he was it.

Now that he had an attempt, we have cleared him as 100% townie, which is a mistake in my book. Llight didn't even change his vote either when he could have after breaking in.

As far as me not taking an active role in the first round, it was the first round. I was looking for evidence because I didn't have any concrete evidence. I also work and have school. I cannot be everywhere at once. ;)

But my vote goes to poptartface

February 12, 2012
Edit
Helius

I think the mafia didn't target me because my agreesive gameplay makes me a natural target and causes some drama. I'm sure they have thrown my name around though

I believe you are the doctor but you protected poptart, which is interesting because he was the first to start accusing and eager to hear people talking.

But i definatley am buying into Xhin theory the most

February 12, 2012
Edit
#85

Well, I've read through the recent replies, and I think I'm going to change my vote from Malas to #85.

February 12, 2012
Edit
MajorasMask9

Xhin's theory does make the most sense, in which case we should vote for one of those four. But at the same time, we could make a horrible mistake by doing so and not voting for #85, leaving him alive in the game for later rounds. Regardless of what we do is, what I consider at this point in the game, a lose-lose situation.

Other than this, the only thing we could go off of is if Xhin is the one targeted by the Mafia this round, which would only prove that at least one, if not all, of those suspects he named are indeed Mafia members.

February 12, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

What do you guys mean by waves? Not sure I'm getting the expression.

February 12, 2012
Edit
Malas

Those four players haven't made any significant thoughts or actions known that could be detrimental to the township.

February 12, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

Thirteen people have voted here, which means at least two of them are Mafia. To continue on this note, all four suspects that Xhin has named have voted twice for Shadowwalked (RubyLizard and Black Yoshi), once for poptart! (Helius), and once for me (Kassie the Eevee).

At this point, I see no harm in taking Xhin's advice. If we lose #85 because of another "herding" process, then we are down to ten townies.

Only two people have not voted this round, and those are Xhin himself and BCB. Please note that BCB's only post has been his vote for Feral in the first round.


I no longer believe that #85 is a Mafia member. Two of the four suspects Xhin has listed have both voted for The Doctor, Shadowwalked.

Logic is telling me to vote for one of those two people, unless they can somehow bring something together to prove that they are indeed not a member of the Mafia.

That being said, and it is not a "vote-for-vote" instance nor is it another herding behind #85's vote, I have decided to change me vote, and urge anybody else who believes this to change his or her vote, to Kassie the Eevee.

February 12, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

Did not realize that BCB has only posted once.

In the 1st Round Yeano posted where the voting stood with 32 hours remaining. Would like to see this again for this round. Especially how much time is left to vote or change a vote.

February 12, 2012
Edit
chiefsonny
 

I came across that he posted once when scrolling through to figure out who, in the game, has yet to vote this round.

February 12, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

On further review, I decided to change my vote to Kassie. #85 could just turn out to be another Feral, or indeed a Mafia. But Kassie strikes me as suspicious, there is some good evidence against her, and more she seems the best to vote for besides #85 due to currents votes. Plus I don't want to risk it with #85 in case he is indeed a townie.

February 12, 2012
Edit
Knukles2000

I forgot about BCB. Yeah, he's done almost nothing as well.

Kassie seems entirely likely because she had to talk to Yeano about something privately. I can't imagine what this would be if she was a townie.

Helius just slipped up and almost certainly proved he's mafia. The mafia targeted poptart, so unless they're in cahoots with the doctor (impossible), they'd be killing one of their own if he's in the mafia. That's highly unlikely. Helius knows this, so why would he vote for some who has a 95% certainty of being a townie unless he's in the mafia?

Also, RubyLizard is trying to defend Kassie, which would make sense if they're both mafia (since rubylizard is also under suspicion). She's also trying to set herself apart by not voting for #85 and for being suspicious about Black Yoshi. However, since people are jumping on board with my theory, as long as she doesn't directly agree with the premise, she can agree with any one of the people it targets and it'll make her look like a townie. Also she definitely voted to kill Shadowwalked.

I'm going to have to also go with Kassie the Eevee.

February 12, 2012
Edit
Xhin
Sky's the limit

If I get killed tonight (likely if a majority vote for kassie), then that virtually proves my theory. Although if I'm completely wrong, the mafia's best interest would be trying to kill me as well, since that'll make my theory seem legit and we'll end up killing four of our own. So I'm probably screwed.

That said, our best strategy moving forward is to target the four (five, with BCB) and vote to lynch them as long as they stay inactive. If they suddenly become inactive then we can examine them and see if they slip up like Helius did.

February 12, 2012
Edit
Xhin
Sky's the limit

`Roxas` brings up an interesting point that the original four I listed voted for people who were making waves, probably in an attempt to get us to kill our own. BCB followed the crowd and killed Feral. I don't think BCB is mafia because, while inactive, he didn't try to kill people who were making waves like `Roxas` said.

Still, after Kassie, Helius looks the most likely, followed by RubyLizard, Black Yoshi, and then BCB. Until more evidence comes along, that's how I'll vote unless I get killed tonight.

February 12, 2012
Edit
Xhin
Sky's the limit

Kassie seems entirely likely because she had to talk to Yeano about something privately. I can't imagine what this would be if she was a townie.

Well, apparently there was an issue with roles getting unintentionally switched around earlier (according to one of Yeano's posts). I could see it having to do with that. Then again, I'd have to wonder why it'd be so important to keep that private if that was the case.

Not really sure what to make of this game. Disregard my vote for #85. I guess Kassie does seem a bit suspicious, I'll vote for Kassie the Eevee.

February 12, 2012
Edit
MajorasMask9

As being divided in our votes will get us nowhere, I'm going to change my vote to Kassie. My theory only leaves us with one suspect (Who may very well be innocent), while Xhin's theory if validated will give us the entire Mafia.

February 12, 2012
Edit
Shadowwalked

What I have said is plain logic... I cannot prove I'm a townie so your only option is to vote for me and find out. Though you would only be voting a townie out. PoP makes since cause his identity was compromised but eh... Do as you see fit

February 12, 2012
Edit
Helius

I'm still suspicious of #85, but like Shadow said, no point in splitting votes. I'll change my vote to Kassie as well, although I personally see Helius and Black Yoshi as being more suspicious than her. Next time I'd vote for one of them or for #85.

February 12, 2012
Edit
white lancer

In the 1st Round Yeano posted where the voting stood with 32 hours remaining. Would like to see this again for this round. Especially how much time is left to vote or change a vote.

At the present moment, there are 42 hours left, with vote distribution as such:

Kassie the Eevee (8)
#85 (2)
Black Yoshi (1)
`Roxas` (1)
poptart! (1)

Everyone but BCB has cast a vote.

February 12, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

What I have said is plain logic... I cannot prove I'm a townie so your only option is to vote for me and find out. Though you would only be voting a townie out. PoP makes since cause his identity was compromised but eh... Do as you see fit

It's too early in the morning for me to address your theory properly, so I'm just going to put that on hold until I don't feel like shit.

February 12, 2012
Edit
Shadowwalked

What I have said is plain logic... I cannot prove I'm a townie so your only option is to vote for me and find out. Though you would only be voting a townie out. PoP makes since cause his identity was compromised but eh... Do as you see fit

So you want us to vote for somebody we know is a townie? Not likely.

February 12, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

Kassie the Eevee (8)
#85 (2)
Black Yoshi (1)
`Roxas` (1)
poptart! (1)

That's 13 votes and BCB has not voted. There are 9 of us left, + the Doc and the Cop which equal 11.
Numbers don't add up.
Which means that you counted all votes including the ones that changed their votes or the Mafia is voting to.

My original vote was for Black Yoshi, but it looks like most of my neighbors want to go a different way, so in order for us to try and stay unified,
I will change my vote to Kassie the Eevee.

I've already helped send one townie packing with my last vote. Hope it's not a repeat performance.

If `Roxas` count is right. It should now be:

Kassie the Eevee (9)
#85 (2)
Black Yoshi (0)
`Roxas` (1)
poptart! (1)

Do the math guys. Somebody is playing us and getting away with it.

"42 hours left"
How many hours is a day?

February 12, 2012
Edit
chiefsonny
 

The last vote was Black Yoshi's vote for Shadowwalked. That adds up to 14, which is just what it should be if there are 15 players left and BCB hasn't voted.

February 12, 2012
Edit
white lancer

Maybe when Bcb votes we should just move it along. That'd help speed things up. And this game is going a tad slow. I know people could change their votes, but still.

February 12, 2012
Edit
Knukles2000

Here is my official vote count.

Shadowwalked (1 vote – Black Yoshi)

#85 (2 votes – Malas, poptart!)

Kassie the Eevee (9 votes - #85, `Roxas`, Knukles2000, Xhin, RubyLizard, MajorasMask9, Shadowwalked, white lancer, chiefsonny)

poptart! (1 vote – Helius)

About 41 hours remain, but if Kassie gets to 10 votes (67%), I see no reason to delay the ending of the day round with such a super majority.

February 12, 2012
Edit
Yeano

Kassie's vote against me wasn't counted in that tally, Yeano.

February 13, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

Ok,

`Roxas` (1 vote - Kassie the Eevee)

February 13, 2012
Edit
Yeano

I'm not really sure what has happened. There were 14 votes cast at that point, I have each recorded, along with the number of changes.

Feel free to correct me wrong, but this is what I have:

White Lancer: Originally voted for Helius; changed to #85; changed again to Kassie the Eevee

MajorasMask9: Originally voted for Malas; changed to #85; changed again to Kassie the Eevee

`Roxas`: Originally voted for Black Yoshi; changed to #85; changed again to Kassie the Eevee

RubyLizard: Originally voted for Shadowwalked; changed to Kassie the Eevee

Shadowwalked: Originally voted for #85; changed to Kassie the Eevee

Knukles2000: Originally voted for #85; changed to Kassie the Eevee

Malas: Originally voted for #85

chiefsonny: Originally voted for Black Yoshi; changed vote to Kassie the Eevee

Kassie the Eevee: Originally voted for `Roxas`

Black Yoshi: Originally voted for Shadowwalked

poptart!: Originally voted for #85

#85: Originally voted for Kassie the Eevee

Helius: Originally voted for poptart!

Xhin: Originally voted for Kassie the Eevee

BCB: *Has yet to vote

As you can see, distribution is:

Kassie the Eevee: 9
#85: 2
Shadowwalked: 1
poptart!: 1
`Roxas`:1

February 13, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

w/e I change my vote to Kassie. Might as well follow the crowd

February 13, 2012
Edit
poptart!
 

Actually, Kassie never officially voted for you. She just said you're the evil type.

February 13, 2012
Edit
Yeano

Then that is where I messed up. Unless her vote consists of saying "it's 'Roxas'." Sorry for any confusion.

February 13, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

Well, if kassie ends up being mafia then we are on the right track and we won't have to reevaluate our plan (of course we will still want to see who the mafia targets, my guess is myself or Xhin)

So if we are right I say black yoshi should be next, what are peoples thoughts on this?

February 13, 2012
Edit
#85

The game will continue in [p:59811].

February 13, 2012
Edit
Yeano

I must say I agree, #85. Although, since Xhin was the mastermind behind the theory we are going by, I believe he will be the next. If Kassie is indeed the Mafia member we believe she is, then I think Black Yoshi or Helius be next.

February 13, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

Thread Index for Game 1

Thread 1 - [p:59636]
Thread 2 - [p:59811]
Thread 3 - [p:59985]
Mafia Thread - [p:59637]
Cop Thread - [p:59727]
Doctor Thread - [p:59728]
Player Scores Thread - [p:60135]

Note: Replies from this game are missing due to a site glitch.

Results

1. Xhin - Townie
2. chiefsonny - Townie
3. RubyLizard - Townie
4. LLight - Townie
5. Kassie the Eevee - Townie
6. Feral - Townie
7. MajorasMask9 - Cop
8. Black Yoshi - Mafioso
9. Shadowwalked - Doctor
10. poptart! - Townie
11. Knukles2000 - Townie
12. Helius - Townie
13. white lancer - Mafioso
14. `Roxas` - Townie
15. BCB - Mafioso
16. Malas - Mafioso
17. #85 - Townie

Starting Ratio
4-13

Ending Ratio
0-5

Roles
Cop, Doctor, Townie x11
Mafioso x4

May 16, 2014
Edit
MajorasMask9

Reply to: mafia game 1 day round 2 lynchin time

Username
Password