Engines Aether Legend of the Lunar Priest NIFE Roadmap
Shatterloop Game Projects Deprecated Starwright
Saepes Mundi Other Projects Blog  

Mafia

Moderated by: Speed Bike Pro

mafia game redackted day round 1 vote now

Posted March 4, 2012 by Yeano

Greetings, everyone!

In this game, I've introduced a few new roles.

Let's hear them!

Vigilante:

The Vigilante is a town-sided role. Once per night, the vigilante can choose to kill someone! Exciting!

Wheel Gator:

The Wheel Gator is a town-sided role. Once per night, the Wheel Gator can bite someone. There is a 25% chance that person will die when bitten. If Wheel Gator bites the same person twice, there will be a 50% chance that person will die. For a third bite, that person is guaranteed to die.

Godfather:

The Godfather is a Mafioso that appears innocent to cops.

Silencer:

The Silencer is mafia-sided. The silencer can choose to silence one person per night, but cannot silence the same person two days in a row. If silenced, the player cannot speak during the day round.

NOTE: It is extremely important to check your role every day round! If you are silenced, your role will be changed to "Silenced" for the day round! If you do speak while silenced, you will be killed by me!

Thug:

The Thug is a mafia-sided role. If a member of the mafia is killed during the night round, the thug will die instead! Additionally, the thug can choose to lynch himself in order to prevent someone else from being lynched.

Here are the players:


1. chiefsonny
2. Knukles2000
3. AdmiralTrainstorm
4. Famov
5. Malas
6. Helius
7. `Roxas`
8. Kassie the Eevee
9. white lancer
10. Black Yoshi
11. Xhin
12. poptart!
13. Shadowwalked
14. #85
15. RubyLizard
16. LLight
17. MajorasMask9
18. BCB
19. Feral

Mafia-Town Ratio: 4-15.

Roles: Godfather (1), Silencer (1), Mafioso (1), Thug (1), Vigilante (1), Cop (1), Doctor (1), Wheel Gator (1), Townies (11)

The first day round will end in 72 hours or when 12 votes have been cast for the same option.

There are 177 Replies

extensionEnable Post Pagination

I will elect to NOT VOTE this round.

March 4, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

I vote feral.

Just kidding!

no vote.

March 4, 2012
Edit
MajorasMask9

Not really enough info to go on anything yet, so no vote.

March 4, 2012
Edit
Shadowwalked

No vote

March 4, 2012
Edit
#85

Just had a good thought. I'm just a regular townie but

The vigilante should say who they are. This gives us the possible mafia #s from 19 to 18. We have no info so any would help.

The mafia are unlikely to go after someone who has a better chance of killing a townie anyway. Plus, the doctor can just protect them

March 4, 2012
Edit
#85

No vote.

March 4, 2012
Edit
BCB

Until I have something to go on, no vote.

March 4, 2012
Edit
Knukles2000

In the first game I asked if a majority of us cast a "No Vote", would the Mafia still have to kill one of us.

Yeano never gave a answer. `Roxas` replied that they would have to off one of us.

If that's the case, then all we are doing with a "No Vote" is sacrificing one of our own.
I need someone to explain the rational behind this move.

March 4, 2012
Edit
chiefsonny
 

A legit point, but it's too great of a chance to lose 2. Maybe we will be able to see a connection by who they target in the night

March 4, 2012
Edit
#85

I asked if a majority of us cast a "No Vote", would the Mafia still have to kill one of us.

The Mafia can vote no kill in the day.

The Mafia can vote no kill in the night.

The goal of the mafia is to equal or outnumber the town. If they feel that they can best accomplish this by not killing people in a particular round, they are free to not kill anyone.

March 4, 2012
Edit
Yeano

Pretty much what #85 said. I don't see the Mafia just "No Vote" on their first night though.

March 4, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

If that's the case, then all we are doing with a "No Vote" is sacrificing one of our own.

I need someone to explain the rational behind this move.

Well right now it's more likely that with randomly voting we'd be sacrificing two of our own.

Not that randomly voting isn't plausible in most cases, but right now it doesn't seem that bad of an idea. As the game progresses we get more info with a cop around.

March 5, 2012
Edit
MajorasMask9

Far be it from me to try and validate my dreary existence through crude mob justice if no one else is going to. No vote.

March 5, 2012
Edit
Famov

No vote.

March 5, 2012
Edit
poptart!
 

No vote for now, until we get some more information.

March 5, 2012
Edit
Black Yoshi

No vote for me as well.

I tried to check this at work to see if the game started or not.

March 5, 2012
Edit
Helius

No vote here as well. The mafia could kill one of us off, but we don't have any information and have a good chance of killing one of our own.

March 5, 2012
Edit
Xhin
Sky's the limit

^That's my problem with going with "no vote" right off the bat. The longer the round goes on, the more we have to go off of in terms of figuring stuff out. I don't want to kill anyone this round, but I do think talking about things can help us figure things out in the future.

As an aside, I've played with the Vigilante and Godfather roles before, and they can be a lot of fun. Also played with a variant on the Silencer role that was town-sided. Interested to see how these play out. And lol at the Wheel Gator role.

March 5, 2012
Edit
white lancer

I just don't feel comfortable with voting right now, and probably not the next round (should I not be silenced or whacked during the night). What I am saying is not intended to be an attack on any of the parties named, just possibilities popping in to my head. I'm in no way trying to convince or even rally anybody during the next round to vote for these people, only personal thoughts.

Even though I think it is safe to assume that the "Wheel Gator" role is AdmiralTrainstorm, I'm still vaguely suspicious of him/her/them (covering all gender identities that way the person that is A.T. does not become offended by the use of just one).

Other than that person, I'm not entirely sure as to who could be and who couldn't be Mafia-related.

I could see Feral being Mafia since he was the first one to be axed last time, but this is going off of absolutely no information. Heck, wouldn't surprise me one bit if he was the Godfather at this point in the game.

LLight, based on the fact that he was so eager to infiltrate the Mafia last game, wouldn't be too big of a surprise either.

Other than these two, I see no other possible suspects at this time.

March 5, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

What I want to know is, what will we do if we never do get a lead? We would have wasted a round, and granted the Mafia a greater chance.

March 5, 2012
Edit
Knukles2000

no vote. we don't want a repeat of LAST GAME, now do we?

March 5, 2012
Edit
Kassie the Eevee

Roxas, your post seems to suggest that Yeano hand-picked people's roles. I was assuming that they were randomized.

March 5, 2012
Edit
white lancer

Does it matter if they were randomized or handpicked? Regardless, it is still a possibility.

And yes, we don't want a repeat of last game with you calling us all bitches, Kassie.

March 5, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

No vote

March 5, 2012
Edit
Malas

And yes, we don't want a repeat of last game with you calling us all bitches, Kassie.

I was completely justified in my temper tantrum, come on.

March 5, 2012
Edit
Kassie the Eevee

Yeah, it's still a possibility. If it's randomized, though, it doesn't really make Feral and LLight any more likely to be Mafia than, say, me. Not that I'm Mafia...

March 5, 2012
Edit
white lancer

In the same instance though, if we don't learn anything about each other through talking... the only thing we can do is vote. :( I hated it last game where we just randomly voted people off, but it's the only way to tell who is Mafia, I guess.

March 5, 2012
Edit
Helius

Never said you weren't justified, Kassie.

I understand where you are coming from, white lancer, but then we have to factor in what way was it randomized? Did it go in order of who was killed or was it mass randomization? We just don't know at this point in the game.

I agree, Helius. We can't use the same strategy as lat game because we are all simply Townies, with the exceptions of the Wheel Gator, the Cop and the Doc. It would be best if, for a while, those three roles laid low other than doing his or her nightly functions throughout the course of the game.

March 5, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

Sooner or later we are going to have to take a chance, though. The sacrificing strategy isn't good long term

March 5, 2012
Edit
#85

I'm thinking that the individuals who are questioning the idea of not voting might be the Mafioso. They would WANT to convince the rest of us to vote, as there is a good chance we would off one of our own.

Unfortunately, nobody really stands out in that sense...

By the way, this round is over. Ruby cast the 12th vote for "no vote". Not that it matters, but I would have been the 15th person to say "no vote" at this point as well.

March 5, 2012
Edit
Feral

I will vote "No Vote" as well, not that it counts.
However I think it's a bad thing to do this early.

"I'm thinking that the individuals who are questioning the idea of not voting might be the Mafioso. They would WANT to convince the rest of us to vote, as there is a good chance we would off one of our own"

And there's also a chance we could get lucky and off one of them.

"Sooner or later we are going to have to take a chance, though. The sacrificing strategy isn't good long term"

#85 is right. What we've done this time is let them ice one of us while we stand by and wave goodby to one of our group. Where we could have rolled the dice and got one of them.

March 5, 2012
Edit
chiefsonny
 

We would have had a much greater chance of icing our own person as opposed to the Mafia, add in their killing and we are down two people in a round.

Feral does make a good point in saying that the Mafia would want us to change our votes, but like he said, nobody really stands out in this round just yet.

And now with chiefsonny's vote (bringing the total up to sixteen votes for fifteen townies), we know that at least one member of the Mafia has voted along with us.

March 5, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

Until somebody is whacked off (lol, sex joke). But in all seriousness, that is the only way we will find out any information.

March 5, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

I understand where you are coming from, white lancer, but then we have to factor in what way was it randomized? Did it go in order of who was killed or was it mass randomization? We just don't know at this point in the game.

I was assuming it was just mass randomization. When I've played IRL, we've passed out cards to determine the roles. That way, you can't just argue, "Well, the moderator would probably be likely to pick this guy to be Mafia" or "Because this guy got killed early, the mod probably gave him/her an important role" because everyone has an equal chance of being Mafia. Perhaps Yeano could clear up how the roles were chosen, since it's a procedural point?

And Ruby's right. If I had to guess, I'd say that more than one Mafia member has probably voted "no kill" already--in fact, I know that's the case, since I haven't cast an official vote and I'm not part of the Mafia. Just a thought: I'm not so certain that the Wheel Gator role is terribly important to the town's success, so it's not as crucial for them to lay low as it is for the Cop, Doctor, and Vigilante. I'm not saying he/she should reveal themselves immediately, but we could use that to narrow the suspects down in the future.

March 5, 2012
Edit
white lancer

I'm not saying he/she should reveal themselves immediately, but we could use that to narrow the suspects down in the future.

But this ended not so well for us in the first game. We had two people claiming to be a cop. We went with ... well, we vote for one of them and see. The other thing too is... we had a townie claim to be Mafia so that the Mafia would win. How can we trust anyone at this moment?

This first to claim stuff is stupid, which is why the numbering system for posts went away. I think that was the reasoning anyhow.

March 5, 2012
Edit
Helius

Even though I think it is safe to assume that the "Wheel Gator" role is AdmiralTrainstorm

Yeano has assured me that the selection process is completely randomized, as much as I pleaded with him to be a mafia :/ so AT is not necessarily the wheel gator.

As far as the game goes, we can't reasonably vote for someone since we have no leads. Our best hope is to wait for the cop to identify a few people (hopefully there's a mafioso in there) and step forward. Like last game, if there's more than one cop, then we have a good chance of figuring out possible mafiosos. If the cop dies prematurely, we're sort of screwed, but thankfully that's unlikely.

March 5, 2012
Edit
Xhin
Sky's the limit

This first to claim stuff is stupid, which is why the numbering system for posts went away. I think that was the reasoning anyhow.

There shouldn't have BEEN a numbering system. Yeano only made it that way so townies couldn't talk in a townies-only post. In any case, they played that badly; three of them should have taken townie numbers of people who were suspicious before (like rubylizard) and one (who was not targeted by the first cop) would take the cop role to cast suspicion on the cop. They still probably would have lost, but you never know.

March 5, 2012
Edit
Xhin
Sky's the limit

But this ended not so well for us in the first game. We had two people claiming to be a cop. We went with ... well, we vote for one of them and see. The other thing too is... we had a townie claim to be Mafia so that the Mafia would win. How can we trust anyone at this moment?

Of course there's no way to prove someone is telling the truth if they claim a role, but it is a piece of information that can help us to figure the game out. We can't rely 100% on the Cop because the Mafia could easily take him/her out.

In any case, they played that badly; three of them should have taken townie numbers of people who were suspicious before (like rubylizard) and one (who was not targeted by the first cop) would take the cop role to cast suspicion on the cop. They still probably would have lost, but you never know.

Wouldn't have worked. We would have had to wait for the suspicious people to post their numbers first so that we would have known which numbers to claim, and then you guys would have just had to vote out the person who claimed the role second. Or, even easier, since people's roles were revealed when they died, you just had to lynch one of the Cops, and then you would have known which one was telling the truth and use their information. Our only chance was to claim the numbers of dead townies so that there were no duplicates, but that went down the drain when the numbers of the dead townies were revealed.

March 5, 2012
Edit
white lancer

we had a townie claim to be Mafia so that the Mafia would win.

Well, this is Prince of Pain we're talking about. I don't imagine very many other town sided individuals will claim to be with the Mafia for any reason.

Edit: which is another reason why nothing will be found out this day round.

The first day cycle is rarely very enlightening anyway. With the people I've played "no vote" wasn't an option, so someone always had to die in the first round for no good reason. I don't know if a bloodless round is necessarily an improvement or not in terms of learning information, but it's at least in the town's favor to play the first round conservatively.

The hardest part about online Mafia is you don't get to see anyone's poker face. It's easier to mask your intentions behind a computer screen. If you're familiar with other people in the game you can use what you know about them, and how they react to certain situations, to begin piecing things together even in round one. Innocent townspeople are still likely to die though.

Of course, playing with (relative) strangers has its own advantages. Some of the people I played with I knew too well and would very often figure them out before the game really even started.

March 5, 2012
Edit
Famov

We'll just see how this round goes. Whoever dies, dies; nothing we can do about it.

March 5, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

AdmiralTrainstorm and LLight havent responded yet, it may not be crazy to guess that one could be mafia

Allthough it's certain that a mafia has cast a no vote this round

March 6, 2012
Edit
#85

The replies in their thread started going up after I brought up AT, Feral and LLight. Not saying that any combination of those three are Mafia, just an observation.

March 6, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

AdmiralTrainstorm and LLight havent responded yet, it may not be crazy to guess that one could be mafia

true, they could be trying to keep a low profile. but they could also have just not checked the thread yet.

March 6, 2012
Edit
Kassie the Eevee

It took me a few minutes to see where my role was under the new banner and to see that the title has changed. Well, that's nice. I also like how people insinuate that other people are mafia. I just did something to stand out in the first game and was the first to die. If I find something nice this game, I'm either an asset to the townies regardless of role or a bane to the mafia. Either way, the mafia would prefer me dead. You could cast your vote on me, but all this talk--what I'm doing now--will just sow more seeds of doubt and uncertainty. Those that voted "no vote" are wise because it really is too early to tell and you won't be able to tell anything unless someone starts yapping their mouth like I am now.

LLight, based on the fact that he was so eager to infiltrate the Mafia last game, wouldn't be too big of a surprise either.

I wouldn't say that, it was more like "oh, cool, I can do this".

Randomized vote: Shadowwalked

poptartface and this guy are always buddy-buddy and would be in favour of townies losing regardless of role. He did it last game and was a townie, so I'd say vote just to be safe.

March 6, 2012
Edit
LLight

And just to be clear does a "no vote" count as a vote or does the majority go to the valid vote? Can't elect a president if you don't vote.

March 6, 2012
Edit
LLight

In all seriousness, if Trainstorm were Mafia, the game would be over before it began. It stands to reason that he's the Wheel Gator, since he came up with that role in the first place.

As for LLight, he may just be hanging low to see how the game plays out -- either that, or he's contemplating whether to hack into other threads to find out who those people are...

March 6, 2012
Edit
Black Yoshi

Perhaps Yeano could clear up how the roles were chosen, since it's a procedural point?

Numbered people in the order in which they registered. Used a random number generator. Decided that whoever got 1 was Godfather, 2 was Silencer, etc. Matched the random numbers with the people on the list.

And just to be clear does a "no vote" count as a vote or does the majority go to the valid vote?

No vote counts as a valid vote. Think about it not as abstaining, but rather as voting not to kill someone.

NIGHT 1

The town chose not to kill anyone.

1. chiefsonny
2. Knukles2000
3. AdmiralTrainstorm
4. Famov
5. Malas
6. Helius
7. `Roxas`
8. Kassie the Eevee
9. white lancer
10. Black Yoshi
11. Xhin
12. poptart!
13. Shadowwalked
14. #85
15. RubyLizard
16. LLight
17. MajorasMask9
18. BCB
19. Feral

Mafia-Town Ratio: 4-15.

Roles: Godfather (1), Silencer (1), Mafioso (1), Thug (1), Vigilante (1), Cop (1), Doctor (1), Wheel Gator (1), Townies (11)

Night roles have 24 hours to send in their actions.

March 6, 2012
Edit
Yeano

So uhh while working on an admin tool, I accidentally broke all account information for mods. This only affected mafia ranks fortunately. So I was going to set all of those people to No Rank in case Yeano has a list of players and their roles somewhere off-site, but ended up accidentally setting everyone to No Rank.

Hopefully yeano has a list and can fix everything. If not, at least it's still early in the game.

Sorry guys :/

March 6, 2012
Edit
Xhin
Sky's the limit

Fixed.

March 6, 2012
Edit
Yeano

DAY 2

In the morning, the town found `Roxas` dead in the middle of the town plaza. He had a knife in his back. Rest in peace, Townie.

1. chiefsonny
2. Knukles2000
3. AdmiralTrainstorm
4. Famov
5. Malas
6. Helius
7. `Roxas` (Townie)
8. Kassie the Eevee
9. white lancer
10. Black Yoshi
11. Xhin
12. poptart!
13. Shadowwalked
14. #85
15. RubyLizard
16. LLight
17. MajorasMask9
18. BCB
19. Feral

Mafia-Town Ratio: 4-14.

Roles: Godfather (1), Silencer (1), Mafioso (1), Thug (1), Vigilante (1), Cop (1), Doctor (1), Wheel Gator (1), Townies (10)

72 hours or 11 votes.

March 7, 2012
Edit
Yeano

Alright, so we've lost Roxas, but at least he was just a Townie and not the Cop. I don't have any specific suspicions at this point in time. It's worth noting that Roxas was mildly suspicious of LLight and Feral, but that doesn't necessarily mean anything.

March 7, 2012
Edit
white lancer

Townies don't know anything. That would hold more weight if he was Vigilante, Cop, or WG but as you can see he was neither as all 3 are still alive.

March 7, 2012
Edit
LLight

Well, the only way we're going to know anything is to talk or to vote. Voting seems stupid as pointed out by Llight:

Townies don't know anything.

I concur. So do we do another no vote or play survivor this round?

March 7, 2012
Edit
Helius

It really wouldn't hold any weight unless he was the Cop, as the Vigilante and WG don't really have any information either. You could make the case that Roxas was taken out because the Mafia didn't like the way his thoughts were going, but then you could also say that the Mafia probably hoped we would make that assumption.

As I said, I don't currently have any suspicions. We're early enough that a "no kill" vote is still a decent option, but it does carry some risk as each night that passes is another night that the Mafia have to try to kill the Cop.

March 7, 2012
Edit
white lancer

We should take a gamble. In seriousness we can afford one and the possible benefit outweighs the loss. If we are wrong this day, we can stop, and re evaluate if we want to do another no vote.

In the mean time my vote goes for

AdmiralTrainstorm

It's still open for change though.

March 7, 2012
Edit
#85

I agree with the people implying we can't just sit around and wait for information. If we continue to no vote, we're going to just waste another life to the mafia, and possibly the Wheel Gator and vigilante if they mess up. And pass up another chance to vote out a mafia. As such, I cast my vote in favor of Roxas's suspicions, and vote for Llight. Since it's the only very very tiny lead we have atm.

I will most likely change this, if we get more evidence against anyone else.

March 7, 2012
Edit
Knukles2000

I'll admit, I am a mite suspicious of Llight -- I mean, that post above just rings some bells within me that scream MAFIA. And anyway, given his power to hack, he'll probably lose his patience and get himself killed in the long run...

Thus my vote (for now, subject to change) goes to Llight.

March 7, 2012
Edit
Black Yoshi

Well that went really great.{:(}

I hate to say I told you so. But I told you so.
We lost one of ours and stood by and gave them a free ride by not rolling the dice and hope we got one of theirs.

Oh goody, lets try that again.

NOT!!

March 7, 2012
Edit
chiefsonny
 

(Rises behind wall)

(Inspects)

(Decends back bahind wall at the same pace)

March 7, 2012
Edit
AdmiralTrainstorm

Too in the middle about it, we kill someone and no matter the circumstances we run a potentially crippling risk. We don't and we get more thinking time, then again so does the mafia.

I'd like to say kill someone but I'd look like a mafia guy wouldn't I? I'm gonna go ahead and say not to vote. Don't wanna risk losing any townies, vigilantes or good ol' WHEEL GATOR!!!

I'd rather just let one slip up and give us a nice safe vote.

March 7, 2012
Edit
AdmiralTrainstorm

I don't think Roxas's minor suspicion of LLight/Feral is quite enough to make me vote for either of them this round...although LLight's post last round is a bit of a head-scratcher. Like I said, it's possible the Mafia killed Roxas to make us believe that he was on the right track.

March 7, 2012
Edit
white lancer

None of us know anything at all yet, Ruby. Thats why sometimes you have to take a chance and vote for what adds up the most. Cause suppose we sit back every single time till we get information, Then the mafia kills the cop, or Doctor? Then we're screwed, and will likely never have solid info.

March 7, 2012
Edit
Knukles2000

In the same instance, we can't just vote for anyone...

I find it kind of suspicious that #85 voting for Admiral with no basis other than taking a gamble. Though I find Llight pretty suspicious with his previous posts. If I had to take a gamble and I do, my vote goes for Llight

March 7, 2012
Edit
Helius

Honestly I wouldn't vote for #85, he's likely just trying trial and error to root them out, and public enemy Admiral Trainstorm's his initial target by default. I'm actually gonna refrain from pointing fingers, as doing so just tells them to up their game.

March 7, 2012
Edit
AdmiralTrainstorm

On the other hand, Admiral. you could both be Mafia for all we know. I mean, you do seem to be acting pretty secretive. And for all we know, you could both be in on it. I guess we will just have to see everything pans out, and do things our own way.

March 7, 2012
Edit
Knukles2000

I could. And that's a horrible trap you can't avoid with a game like this. I'm going to say vote me if you want. Secrecy is pretty much essential to a game like this.

March 7, 2012
Edit
AdmiralTrainstorm

Well I know this is going to sound crazy but here goes.

At this point in the game it's true we don't have a lot to go on so I suggest this.

Let's not work so hard on getting a consensus among us, it's to early for that, and just vote for who we as an individual townie think's is Mafia.

The worst that can happen is we don't have enough votes to get rid of anyone, which would be the same as another "No Vote"

On the other hand we may end up getting a consensus and get a Mafia member whacked.

I'm not saying we should not talk, we should. But at this point in the game, we have no good info on anybody.

Man, I hope I haven't put a target on my back with all this ranting.

How much time we have left to vote?
Anybody keeping track?

March 7, 2012
Edit
chiefsonny
 

About 52 hours.

March 7, 2012
Edit
Knukles2000

Sonny, hate to say it but you didn't put a target on yout back with the ranting. You put a target on your back with "Man, I hope I haven't put a target on my back with all this ranting."

But yes, we might wanna take a wild leap and just vote someone.

March 7, 2012
Edit
AdmiralTrainstorm

I agree we need to take wild leaps. We don't have any choice at this point. So I also vote for Llight.

March 7, 2012
Edit
Xhin
Sky's the limit

I'm a little less suspicious of AT now. Don't really know where to throw the vote. It would be great if the vigilante and wheel gator spoke up. That way :

Lessens the possible number of mafia

The cop knows who not to check

The doctor can protect you anyway

Like i said before I'm just a townie so don't waste your check on me cop.

I hesitated to make a post talking about the cop because well, it makes you look like the cop. But if they do target me at least it's just a townie

March 7, 2012
Edit
#85

After giving it some more thought, I've decided to vote "no kill." I think it's too early to be taking wild leaps--odds are we'll just end up killing a townsperson. The plus side is that they've also got a much smaller chance of hitting the Cop at this early stage.

I also think it's too early for the Vigilante to speak up, since they could be beneficial to the town and we don't want the Doctor to get stuck protecting them. The Wheel Gator could probably speak up without repercussions, since I'm not sure how helpful they'll be to the town other than acting as one of our "knowns."

March 7, 2012
Edit
white lancer

Hate to look like an orbitting weirdo, but I'm so sure that secrecy is paramount to winning here.

Not gonna defend LLight yet, considering I'd look like a mafia, should he turn out to be one. But if the majority really wants to take a wild leap with him, I'll support it.

March 7, 2012
Edit
AdmiralTrainstorm

I sorta agree there. If the Wheel Gator speaks up it could be like a weapon with safety from the majority.

Your choice, Mr. Croc.

March 7, 2012
Edit
AdmiralTrainstorm

The vigilante role doesn't really benefit the town early in the game, only after we have identified mafia, which we have yet to do

March 7, 2012
Edit
#85

Man, I hope I haven't put a target on my back with all this ranting.

As far as I'm concerned, you have. I was even suspicious after your second to last post. Seemed kind of overbearing...

I'm still kind of suspicious of LLight and Feral, but I think the Mafia might have been trying to throw us off by voting for them.

I'm considering either no vote, chiefsonny or LLight. I might change my vote but for now I'm going with chiefsonny.

March 8, 2012
Edit
BCB

Gonna agree with BCB in this one. Hey, it's gotta be unlikely he's mafia twice right?

Vote for chiefsonny

March 8, 2012
Edit
#85

I'll go for LLight if that's the consensus, But it kind of seems like mob mentality again.

March 8, 2012
Edit
#85

When isn't it mob mentality, really?

The only time that we are absolutely, positively sure about someone is whether we have irrefutable proof by their actions or the cop speaks up.

I went with Llight, but mob mentality and guessing is all we have at the moment.

March 8, 2012
Edit
Helius

Hey, it's gotta be unlikely he's mafia twice right?

Not to nit pick, but with random assigning of roles everyone has the same chance of being Mafia.

March 8, 2012
Edit
Famov

Mostly my fault for drawing attention. It's any easy way to exit the game, imo. Not really fair since I'm the first to speak up. I'm a prime, ripe target because of my unique skills regardless of role. I proved that last game. If I was mafia, drawing attention to myself would be a bad idea because I'm only an asset to the townies.

That being said, I'm hoping to tip the majority vote over to chiefsonny. So there's my vote.

March 8, 2012
Edit
LLight

wild leap indeed. the game's only going to go stagnant if we don't elect to kill anyone. the mafia kills either way.

nothing personal, but vote for LLight.

March 8, 2012
Edit
Kassie the Eevee

I'd like to change my vote to chiefsonny then. Llight makes a good point.

March 8, 2012
Edit
Xhin
Sky's the limit

We still haven't got jack for information. I'm going to wait till turn three because we're just going to fuck it up again.

I miss being mafia :(

March 8, 2012
Edit
Malas

I'm voting for chiefsonny because fuck it!

March 8, 2012
Edit
poptart!
 

Well yeah, I'll support this Chiefsonny group vote thing. I vote for Chiefsonny.

March 8, 2012
Edit
AdmiralTrainstorm

An eye for an eye.

I vote for LLight.

March 8, 2012
Edit
chiefsonny
 

Though they said the same thing for me when I voted for myself last game. Either I was Mafia tricking them into thinking I was a Townie or I was actually a Townie.

Your rationale is still strange to me. If you're an asset to the Townies, then why do you keep on saying it to everyone? I think I got it the first time. Though, I can't write in my journals at night.

I'm changing my vote to Myself.

I refuse to have blood on my hands again. I have a conscience in this game after all.

Chief, I think its a bad idea to do an eye for an eye. Mainly that's what got me killed last game with Lancer.

March 8, 2012
Edit
Helius

"Chief, I think its a bad idea to do an eye for an eye"

You're right.

An eye for an eye

A vote for a vote.

"I'm hoping to tip the majority

Me to.

March 8, 2012
Edit
chiefsonny
 

1. Sorry for my lack of imput. My DSI browser can't load this long thread.

2. (And not important to the game), HOLY SHIT! Our good Admiral is capable of posting non-nonsence posts! I don't believe it! lol

3. I am a bit biased against mob mentality, since that is what caused me to be killed off right at the start last round.

Honestly, I don't believe LLight when he said it took him a day to find his rank in the forum banner. Once I realized I forgot to log in, it took me mare seconds. Sounds like stalling to me. He may not be Mafia, but I have a good feeling he IS some important role, and spent that time making personal plans.

After reading through this thread, I find one person is trying too hard to get important roles to reveal themselves, thus favoring the mafia.

For the reason, my vote goes to #85.

March 8, 2012
Edit
Feral

Oh yeah because the wheel gator is super important (no offense to the wheel gator lol )

March 8, 2012
Edit
#85

Well, the way I see it and I may be wrong:

Chief has five six votes (Xhin, BCB, Llight, Pop, Admiral, #85)

Chief hasn't done anything wrong or suspicious other than pointing out that mob mentality isn't the way to go.

Llight has three votes (Kassie, Black Yoshi, Knuckles)

Llight has done some things that look suspicious, but we don't know if he's a Townie or not. I can understand self-preservation in this game I guess.

Admiral has one vote (#85)

No comment.

Lancer has voted for a no vote.

Honestly, this seems like the way to go at the moment. I don't know if Chief or Llight is Mafia, but I'd rather not vote either one of them or all of them except for the no vote.

Another thing I'd like to bring up...

Anyone notice that Majora's Mask is silent? I mean Majora is one of our strongest players (at least I can tell from last game). Why the silence? Any ideas?

March 8, 2012
Edit
Helius

I changed my vote to chief, helius

March 8, 2012
Edit
#85

Oops, I'll change it. Sorry.

March 8, 2012
Edit
Helius

Chief, I think its a bad idea to do an eye for an eye. Mainly that's what got me killed last game with Lancer.

:-}


And to add to Helius's post, RubyLizard also voted "no kill" and Feral has voted for #85. I think there are reasons to be suspicious of each of them, but not good enough reasons to take them out at this point in time. I would prefer to file these suspicions away for later purposes but not act on them today.

Also, I'd like to say that I found this interesting:

I have a good feeling he IS some important role, and spent that time making personal plans.

I find one person is trying too hard to get important roles to reveal themselves

Feral openly states his suspicions that LLight is a special role, and then votes against someone else (#85) for trying to reveal special roles. Could be just an oversight, but if it is, it's an amusing one.

ETA:

Anyone notice that Majora's Mask is silent? I mean Majora is one of our strongest players (at least I can tell from last game). Why the silence? Any ideas?

I just remembered that we do have a Silencer in this game, so it's possible that Majora has been silenced this round. We also haven't seen Shadowwalked this time around.

March 8, 2012
Edit
white lancer

An eye for an eye makes the world go blind!!

March 9, 2012
Edit
poptart!
 

Hmm... Let's close the gap a bit.

I vote for Lllllllllllllllight.

March 9, 2012
Edit
Famov

I just remembered that we do have a Silencer in this game, so it's possible that Majora has been silenced this round. We also haven't seen Shadowwalked this time around.

I'm still around, spring break and all. Looking over the votes though seems to be a shitstorm of votes for whoever, so I'll hold off on my vote til whenever.

March 9, 2012
Edit
Shadowwalked

Less then 20 hours remain I think.

March 9, 2012
Edit
chiefsonny
 

Well, i've been observing this for a while now. And I noticed some key factors I think you all should review before blindly casting your votes to anyone.

Llight:

*He talks somewhat like a mafia

*He purposely drawed attention to his role, but did not name it. As if he were trying to make us think he is an important Townie-sided role. And while he could be, keep in mind this is also something a Mafia would do to avoid a target on his back.

*As quoted by Llight: "I'm either an asset to the townies regardless of role or a bane to the mafia". True, he could be a valuable asset. But why would he even say that unless he wanted to put a mafia target on his back, or he is a Mafia?

Chiefsonny:

*He basically stated his concern for no votes. While that is very suspicious, I think we all were thinking it. We just didn't want to put a target on our backs. So we silently went with no vote. Other than that, I don't see why everyone has randomly jumped to Chief. It seems more like he is just having trouble keeping up with the game, and how it works.

Xhin:

*He seems to be a tad more silent this game. Last game, he threw out all kinds of options, and was more a leader to us townies. but suddenly he seems to be more going with whatever would to seem to keep him unnoticed.

Majora:

*He has been silent all round. True, he could of been silenced, but why would the mafia target him? It seems like there are a lot of better people they could have shut up.

Shadowwalked:

*He also was a great leader for us townies in the last game. But this game he is providing very little.

Does anyone else have anything to add? I think it's imperative that we think everything over carefully.

March 9, 2012
Edit
Knukles2000

Shadowwalked:

*He also was a great leader for us townies in the last game. But this game he is providing very little.

Haven't had much time to get engaged. That, and I haven't noticed many trends this match.

March 10, 2012
Edit
Shadowwalked

*He seems to be a tad more silent this game. Last game, he threw out all kinds of options, and was more a leader to us townies. but suddenly he seems to be more going with whatever would to seem to keep him unnoticed.

There's not enough information in play right now. Also last game I ended up fucking a bunch of people over based on information I thought I had.

March 10, 2012
Edit
Xhin
Sky's the limit

There's not enough information in play right now. Also last game I ended up fucking a bunch of people over based on information I thought I had.

Exactly why I tried to get something to go on... going, as I have a feeling there won't be much info. Plus whoever the cop is seems to be keeping to their self....

March 10, 2012
Edit
Knukles2000

Everything here should be taken with a grain of salt. You'd have to be a paranoid schizophrenic if you could base the purported information presented here as solid. I've attempted to identified things that I could say are true, like if I were to die, townies would supposedly lose an asset, but even if I died I'm still an asset to them unless there was a rule that says I can't divulge any game sensitive details, but no rule like that exists and you can't sliver it into this game while we're in the middle of it.

Hmm, I guess when put that way, it doesn't matter if I die. Not sure if I want to die yet because I might lose interest in the game.

March 10, 2012
Edit
LLight

Right now it's good to base your judgement from what you know about these people outside of the game. For instance, Knuckles isn't the sharpest tool in the shed and Xhin has the added advantage of programming the game, therefore understanding it more and Shadowwalked/pop are buddy-buddy who like to fuck around. Are they out of character right now?

March 10, 2012
Edit
LLight

@Llight. I'm just trying to get something started here. I'm not necessarily accusing you. I'm just stating all of the facts I see for the benefit of my allies.

March 10, 2012
Edit
Knukles2000

"but even if I died I'm still an asset to them unless there was a rule that says I can't divulge any game sensitive details, but no rule like that exists and you can't sliver it into this game while we're in the middle of it."

Well that makes me feel all warm and fuzzy inside.

March 10, 2012
Edit
chiefsonny
 

Shadowwalked/pop are buddy-buddy who like to fuck around. Are they out of character right now?

Well, you have to take into account that last game I was the Doctor, and I tend to take more advantage if I'm in a powerful position, and pop's fucking around is greatly hindered when he's off smoking somewhere.

March 10, 2012
Edit
Shadowwalked

I was just trying to think of examples of observations of people outside of the game. We can't take into account that you were doctor last game because that does not fit this criteria.

March 10, 2012
Edit
LLight

I have an idea, but that all depends on how this day ends.

March 10, 2012
Edit
LLight

Either way, it looks like the votes are either going to Llight or Chief. And whoever dies can't talk here cause dead talking is off by default.

March 10, 2012
Edit
Knukles2000

Wait, what? Where did you read that you can't talk when dead? I died last game and talked plenty (as a ghost of course).

March 10, 2012
Edit
LLight

Dead Talk - Dead Talk is the ability for users who are dead to discuss the game in the main thread. By default, Dead Talk is off (unless otherwise stated by the Host).

March 10, 2012
Edit
Knukles2000

Damnit you're right.

March 10, 2012
Edit
LLight

I was just trying to think of examples of observations of people outside of the game. We can't take into account that you were doctor last game because that does not fit this criteria.

Ah, but you have to take into account my personality. Having a special role tickles my ego just enough to want to rape the mafia into submission. I don't have a special role this time around, so I can't necessarily protect myself every night like I used to, so anything I do this game will be after I have a very good understanding of who is who.

March 10, 2012
Edit
Shadowwalked

It does take into account your personality because it is an objective observation that does not assume that your current role in this game is neither special townie, townie, nor mafia. For you it's too early to tell, but based on my findings so far you're not a threat.

March 10, 2012
Edit
LLight

This thread is a nightmare to load and scroll through on a DSI.

Concidering how "as soon as tomorrow" turned into a week, I think Xhin has just beeb busy in real life. How is that for observation? ;)

Guess we will see what happens next round...

March 10, 2012
Edit
Feral

Good job team, a mafioso dies today.

March 10, 2012
Edit
LLight

By my count I will be leaving the game tonight.

So you guys enjoy the rest of the game and remember boys and girls:

"It's just a game".

So play nice together.{:P}

March 10, 2012
Edit
chiefsonny
 

Post count of mafia thread +1 when chief posts. I'm right. I bet he questions the awesomeness of this standard townie, because who else could do it? I'll likely die after the night round, but that's where you're all going to be revealed... hopefully. I'm going snowboarding tomorrow so depending on what happens tomorrow all you mafiosos could be in my scope.

March 10, 2012
Edit
LLight

Oh this buzz is increasing that post count nicely. Knuckles, so you're either trying to see if that mafia post is revealed by a Xhin kerfuffle like last game or you're also mafia.

March 10, 2012
Edit
LLight

No matter how many times I read that over, I have no idea what your trying to say except you suspect me.

March 10, 2012
Edit
Knukles2000

You clicked on the mafia post where only mafia can post so those are the only two possibilities. Considering the post count increase from 60-64 in the past half hour or so, chief must be talking to someone else or himself.

March 10, 2012
Edit
LLight

I assume you are either cheating, insane, or you keylogged my computer. Either way, since your going to go to this DRASTIC length, I am the cop, I clicked on it by accident a few times.

March 10, 2012
Edit
Knukles2000

Well we'll leave to the Game Master to judge to decide or so God may smite me from this game as well. I'm refreshing 3 pages a lot and clicking on the People tab if you're wondering. This took a great deal of effort so I don't think it's cheating unless I wrote a script to display the People tab for only the mafia post, which I think I can do.

March 10, 2012
Edit
LLight

Oh and time, especially the time. I'm hardcore like that and a mad genius. Mayhaps it's a deterrent for mafia communication in that single thread if this is allowed. It would also encourage you to make new topics yourself to confuse me. More than 2 of you online would confuse me greatly.

March 10, 2012
Edit
LLight

I'm signed on 24/7. Never sign off.

March 10, 2012
Edit
chiefsonny
 

People tab refreshes only when you click a link. It displays your name in yellow if that user is viewing the same topic, but does not do it when you click the People tab (javascript based?! I think so), which is why if you did that with me viewing the topic in another window, you would not see me in yellow.

I sign autographs, chea.

March 10, 2012
Edit
LLight

I bet you use a walk through when you play a game to.

March 10, 2012
Edit
chiefsonny
 

Also Knuckles claims he's a cop. If he's not the real cop, then the real cop can investigate him to verify now Edit: unless he's the mafia type that appears as a townie, then I'm either lying and you can lynch me.

If I die either by lynching or murder, my role will be revealed as a townie and then suddenly my observations will make more sense. Call it martyrdom, like a boss.

March 10, 2012
Edit
LLight

You go to work, and the thread count goes up. Wow. I just got done reading this btw.

March 10, 2012
Edit
Helius

Helius clicked on the Mafia thread just now, post count did not go up. (Still at 73)

So far I'm not convinced mafia are: RubyLizard (never clicked on the mafia thread during my observations) and Feral. I saw #85 and 'Roxas' online but they either clicked too often and I didn't catch them or not likely mafia. Baited Feral here: [p:60577].

Baited Feral into checking the game after the Mafia post incremented by 1 from a chiefsonny reply. He did not check the mafia thread, instead went straight to the main game topic so he's probably a townie. If he checked the mafia thread then he would have for sure been mafia, just to see what chief posted.

March 10, 2012
Edit
LLight

I call for llight to be disqualified, and banned from further games on the grounds of cheating, and using bowlshit logic to try to disprove he is cheating.

March 10, 2012
Edit
Knukles2000

No, actually I claimed to be a cop because Llight is a damn cheater shit in denial abusing his power, and I refuse to play anymore games as long as he is in them.

March 10, 2012
Edit
Knukles2000

If the real cop investigated Knuckles, he'll show up as mafia or townie. There's also the chance that he's the mafia boss so he'll show up as innocent or townie, in which case you guys kill me. It wastes our cop investigation, but what other leads do you have to go on? 3 or 4 people can die from Vigilante, WG, lynch and mafia murder this and the next night round, so there's ample opportunity to kill me and the sooner will reveal my role as a townie.

Knuckles personality fits his "outside game" persona because right now he's tripping balls over cheater accusations as he'd normally do under any asinine situations.

All will fall into place once chief dies from lynching and his role is revealed as mafia. You'll see. Though I'd be baffled if he wasn't, but he's pretty stoic as always. This fits his outside game persona as well.

I call for llight to be disqualified, and banned from further games on the grounds of cheating, and using bowlshit logic to try to disprove he is cheating.

Agreed, but only after judge and administrator executive decision. I'd also like all access to be removed from GTX0 (glitch specialist + TP) and possibly permanently global banned.

March 10, 2012
Edit
LLight

Well now that LLight has solved everything for everyone, might as well end the game.

Yes I am Mafia and have enough votes for you guys to kill me.

Hope you enjoy the rest of the game. All you have to do is sit back and wait for LLight to tell you who to vote for.
I like you dude, but why take all the fun out of the game?

March 10, 2012
Edit
chiefsonny
 

Agreed, but only after judge and administrator executive decision. I'd also like all access to be removed from GTX0 (glitch specialist + TP) and possibly permanently global banned.

He basically confessed. this game is basically over anyway since he saw the inside of the mafia forum. Might as well start it over, and get rid of this dirty cheater.

March 10, 2012
Edit
Knukles2000

I click a lot of things. :P Doesn't prove anything.

March 10, 2012
Edit
Helius

Well, might as well well say it, I was in the mafia as well. I had you all fooled till Llight opened his cheating trap, didn't I?

March 10, 2012
Edit
Knukles2000

I confessed to using the People tab and wasting 2 hours refreshing this game. Am I cheating or is it effort and brilliant deduction?

Everything I've done is well within the rules of the game for the time being. There is the chance that people actually did accidentally click on the mafia thread, which is my unknown variable.

March 10, 2012
Edit
LLight

Oh no, I think I ruined the game. There's still one mafia left.

March 10, 2012
Edit
LLight

Everything I've done is well within the rules of the game for the time being. There is the chance that people actually did accidentally click on the mafia thread, which is my unknown variable.

Or we clicked on it purposely to mess with your unknown variable... I don't like digital detective work so now I'm just screwing with your unknown variable.

Besides, the unknown is fun.

March 10, 2012
Edit
Helius

Yeah there's still a chance that Helius isn't mafia. Only a cop investigation can verify. If we played the game by rolling dice, then we're pretty much gambling. That's all this is.

March 10, 2012
Edit
LLight

.....Ugh. Bowlshit. Idk why invested so much time into this only to be cheated by a cheater in severe denial. Just check the mafia thread, and line it up with what he said RIGHT when he posted It's the only way he could have known.

March 10, 2012
Edit
Knukles2000

Truth be told, I'm not really a fan of using the People tab to try to collect information, any more than I was a fan of the whole "name your Townie number" strategy. IMO, Mafia should be about reading people through the posts in this thread, not about taking advantage of whatever loopholes you can find because of GTX0's programming.

March 10, 2012
Edit
white lancer

<3 Ruby!

I like that song (if that is what you're referring too)

March 10, 2012
Edit
Helius

Cheating would be knowing who is who, as in entering the thread and reading your names for 100% confirmation, but I didn't do that. There was a 50% chance that you click the mafia thread. The odds further dwindle if the reply count increases because players would be drawn to read the new reply since they don't show up in Newest Replies, which everyone mostly hovers around. That's how Feral was baited.

What other cues does this game have? If we played irl, we'd have more believable body language and verbal language cues.

March 10, 2012
Edit
LLight

So Xhin will have to fix the People tab to not work in the mafia game.

March 10, 2012
Edit
LLight

Llight, I'd like to formally request that you stop doing your job (mostly the bug reporting part) in the middle of a Mafia game, unless the glitch you found completely breaks the game. In this case, yeah, I didn't think about the "People" tab but I also didn't think someone would hang out in a thread they can't access and refresh the people tab for two hours.

Because of how boring the last game turned out once *I* broke the game, I think game 2 should be completely restarted, which I'll talk to yeano about as soon as I fix the glitch.

March 10, 2012
Edit
Xhin
Sky's the limit

You can say that over and over. But thats not the cheating we are referring to. Either way, theres no way at all you could of known all of that, right then unless you saw our posts, but whatever. This is over anyway.

March 10, 2012
Edit
Knukles2000

Listen people, there will always be another game. Each game builds off of the next one, rules and programming can be modified. What I've done is provide a source of drama and post count. I'm sorry but, if being removed from my position is necessary, then I'll gladly do it. Been looking for a reason to leave because I don't think I can do it on my own.

March 10, 2012
Edit
LLight

Blarg, wait till Yeano see'z all dis.

Yeano was on. I assume he had a massive epic facepalm, and decided to exit the site.

March 10, 2012
Edit
Knukles2000

Very well, we'll have to reset this game. I win?

March 10, 2012
Edit
LLight

What I've done is provide a source of drama and post count.

No, what you've done is get people pissed about a game they're invested in and may make them stop playing over it.

I'm sorry but, if being removed from my position is necessary, then I'll gladly do it.

Firing you after you just did a good job at what I hired you for would be ludicrous, although you're perfectly capable of resigning.

March 10, 2012
Edit
Xhin
Sky's the limit

It's like uhhh if there's a giant RP thread or a debate that a lot of people are involved in, if you go in and troll them it creates drama and increases post count (right up until you're banned), whereas if you delete all their posts it gets people pissed at the site.

March 10, 2012
Edit
Xhin
Sky's the limit

I just wanted to say

I was the cop! da reel cop! And I was excited to enforce the law! This excitement has thus been abruptly taken away from me!

Someone's gonna pay next round, y'all.

I KNEW IT! I TOLD YOU CHIEF, HELIUS, AND KASSIE. BUT YOU DIDN'T BELIEVE ME! WHY DIDN'T YOU BELIEVE!? Lol.

March 10, 2012
Edit
Knukles2000

Well Knuckles was definitely pissed, but he always gets pissed, very easily too. chiefsonny was pissed off, but he did it quietly, I could tell. Helius and white lancer were rational but saddened and pointed out the disadvantages where I could not because, to be honest, I was having fun. Not gonna lie.

I won't quit because I can't. I can do these things without my official position which is what caught your eye in the first place.

March 10, 2012
Edit
LLight

Spoke to Yeano on AIM. He's gone for the night so this might have to wait until tomorrow. I probably won't be here for half the day due to snowboarding.

March 10, 2012
Edit
LLight

And fixed. All traffic to this entire forum gets shown as "Mafia Game".

March 10, 2012
Edit
Xhin
Sky's the limit

You remove colour?

March 10, 2012
Edit
LLight

"chiefsonny was pissed off, but he did it quietly, I could tell."

Pissed off, yes a little, but more disappointed. I know you are a very smart person and I could tell from the way you were talking that you were doing something. I did not have any idea what, but something that most of us would not have thought of doing and therefore putting all of us at a disadvantage.
Was that cheating, or just doing your job, or both or neither. I don't know, But I was hoping it would not fuck up the game.

As far as my position in the game, I knew I screwed up and put a target on my back with the long rant I made after the first round. So I tried to put the target on you after I seen you had 3/4 votes. But I did it with trash talk.

I have a lot of respect for you and hope you hang around. I just would ask that you put your brain in a lower gear sometimes when you deal with the rest of us dumb asses. {:(}

March 10, 2012
Edit
chiefsonny
 

Well you were the keystone in all this so if it turned out I was wrong when you died, then my whole story crumbles and they'd go after me, but then the real cop would at least have ample suspicions after I rocked this game.

With these roles, every round up to 2 people can die.

March 10, 2012
Edit
LLight

I was trying to hold back long as I could. But I eventually became too pissy to hold it in after I found out. Long as it dosn't happen again, i'm fine.

March 10, 2012
Edit
Knukles2000

You remove colour?

The page you're on will never match "Mafia Game", so yes, although what's important is that the "Mafia Game" page applies for all posts in this forum.

Also, I just realized I'm the only one who actually gets links of where people are rather than just the yellow thing.

With these roles, every round up to 2 people can die.

Four actually (mafia kill, townie lynching, vigilante kill, possibility of a wheel gator kill).

March 10, 2012
Edit
Xhin
Sky's the limit

You broke the moment you said you were the cop. No rational thinking townie would do that, but you might. There was the possibility that some players did not know how you act and that one of them was the cop, therefore drawing attention to yourself. All I had to do from that point was to deduce what made sense in order to convince the real cop.

March 10, 2012
Edit
LLight

Four actually (mafia kill, townie lynching, vigilante kill, possibility of a wheel gator kill).

Wheel Gator, Townie Lynch, and Vigilante can only select their victims during the day iirc. Mafia can only do it at night, but can post in their respective topics during the day. Could be wrong though. Please confirm?

March 10, 2012
Edit
LLight

Only a townie lynching can occur during day rounds, only mafia killing, vigilante killing, and wheel gator biting can occur during night rounds. Since what follows Day Round 1 is Night Round 1, I assumed that Day and Night were part of the same "round".

March 10, 2012
Edit
Xhin
Sky's the limit

I suspected Llight as the doctor. Just saying.

March 10, 2012
Edit
Knukles2000

I assume we're doing away with this game and starting anew, then?

I either missed Knuckles' post about claiming the cop or it got deleted, but that move would have wound up fatal even if LLight hadn't worked his magic. When people's roles are revealed after they die, claiming the Cop isn't really a viable strategy except as a stalling device.

March 10, 2012
Edit
white lancer

I only gave you two options for any of my own plausible roles (townie or mafia) and it accounted for all outcomes except for chiefsonny being a townie, which I was only certain of after the post count increase and we were the only people online who were listed as playing the game. He posted in both the mafia thread and the main game thread. The rest was bait to get the ball rolling. It was only a matter of how many mafia showed up to get caught.

March 10, 2012
Edit
LLight

After reading through this thread, I have determined that what LLight did was not cheating, but was horribly broken.

Since it was not cheating, he will not be penalized in this game for his actions.

I also see that Xhin has remedied the problem. This is also good.

Normally, under these circumstances, I would have the game continue, but it seems that everyone wants to restart the game, so I will oblige.

March 10, 2012
Edit
Yeano

Gee, I sure was silent that round.

March 10, 2012
Edit
MajorasMask9

as delightful as this game was, I'm sitting the next one out. and refraining from comment about LLight.

I was the Godfather, by the way.

March 10, 2012
Edit
Kassie the Eevee

as delightful as this game was, I'm sitting the next one out. and refraining from comment about LLight.

I was the Godfather, by the way.

You will be missed in the game of Mafia. Though I gotta agree, all this is rly annoying.

March 10, 2012
Edit
Knukles2000

I either missed Knuckles' post about claiming the cop or it got deleted

CTRL+F on "cheat", it's the first occurrence.

March 11, 2012
Edit
LLight

I suspected Llight as the doctor. Just saying.

Incorrect. I was the doctor. Never had a chance to save anybody, though.

Not that I did, but I should point out that mods can easily cheat via the "User Search" tool, that shows were every online user is in the site an any given time.

March 11, 2012
Edit
Feral

First of all it's the Recent Users tool, second of all I'd be lying if I didn't know about it. Thirdly, it's just a master list of everything that's in the People tab since the tab only shows the last 15. They're basically the same, but with the way that I did it, anyone could do it.

Waitaminute, I count 14. There's either a duplicate name/IP combination in there or Xhin feel prey to the counter 0 problem found in arrays and loops. I remember him saying it was supposed to be 15.

March 12, 2012
Edit
LLight

Reply to: mafia game redackted day round 1 vote now

Username
Password