Engines	Aether	Legend of the Lunar Priest	NIFE Roadmap
Shatterloop	Game Projects	Deprecated	Starwright
Saepes Mundi	Other Projects	Blog

Mafia

Moderated by: Speed Bike Pro

What is Mafia? Mafia Rules Mafia Roles Player Scores Player Scores Info Game Archive The Star Wars Republic/Empire Game Mafia Player Profiles Host Priority List

main thread ahuehuehue night 1 no kill

Posted October 23, 2012 by Yeano

Quote Edit

...

Good evening.

You are about to embark on a journey never yet embarked on in GTx0 History.  You are playing/watching the first ever GTX0 Halloween Mafia!!!! (lightning strike).

Let us see who is unfortunate enough to participate in this tragedy.

1. Redack
2. Trever Leingod
3. Jo Nathan
4. Frustro
5. Feral
6. White Thunder
7. white lancer
8. CtR Black
9. hezekiah
10. Zanic
11. Serpe
12. Helius
13. chiefsonny
14. Xhin
15. The Bandit

AHAHAHAHAHAHA! Your poor souls.

First, let us see how the town will lie tonight.

The town consists of Skeletons and Trick or Treaters.  The Skeletons want revenge on the living and are trying to kill the Trick or Treaters.  But the Trick or Treaters want to live.

Unfortunately for the Skeletons, a witch cursed them so they can't even tell who each other is!  They will each vote each night to kill someone, but won't even know who is who!  If there is a tie in skeleton votes for the most votes, no one will die.

Skeleton-Treater Ratio: [r]6[/r]-[g]9[/g]

Additionally, each night, everyone who is still alive can visit either Yeano's House or Majora's House to go trick or treating.  You will post this in your individual thread. AHAHAHAHAHAHA.  Each night, you will receive a piece of candy.  Depending on what candy you get, it could either do nothing, give you special powers the next night, or give you special powers for a duration of time.

These are the types of candy:

1. Candy of Boringness (You eat this candy, but nothing happens).
2. Candy of X-Ray Vision (You eat this candy, and the NEXT NIGHT, you have the power to look into someone's house and find out what role that person is).
3. Candy of Poision (spelled wrong on purpose - You eat this candy, and get sick.  If you eat two of this candy, you will die!)
4. Candy of Anti-Poision (if you eat this candy after already have eating a Candy of Poision, you will be CURED.  If you haven't been poisioned, nothing will happen).
5. Candy of Invincibility (The next time you get killed - regardless of whether it is in the day or the night, you will SURVIVE, but the candy's affects wear off after that).
6. Secret Candies... MUAHAHAHAHA.

I hope you have a good sleep.  Tonight is night 0.  The skeletons will not kill, but everyone can trick or treat.  Make sure to specify whether you're going to Yeano's or Majora's House, and come up with a witty "trick or treat" line, will ya?

You have... 24 hours...

...

Good evening.

You are about to embark on a journey never yet embarked on in GTx0 History. You are playing/watching the first ever GTX0 Halloween Mafia!!!! (lightning strike).

Let us see who is unfortunate enough to participate in this tragedy.

1. Redack
2. Trever Leingod
3. Jo Nathan
4. Frustro
5. Feral
6. White Thunder
7. white lancer
8. CtR Black
9. hezekiah
10. Zanic
11. Serpe
12. Helius
13. chiefsonny
14. Xhin
15. The Bandit

AHAHAHAHAHAHA! Your poor souls.

First, let us see how the town will lie tonight.

The town consists of Skeletons and Trick or Treaters. The Skeletons want revenge on the living and are trying to kill the Trick or Treaters. But the Trick or Treaters want to live.

Unfortunately for the Skeletons, a witch cursed them so they can't even tell who each other is! They will each vote each night to kill someone, but won't even know who is who! If there is a tie in skeleton votes for the most votes, no one will die.

Skeleton-Treater Ratio: 6-9

Additionally, each night, everyone who is still alive can visit either Yeano's House or Majora's House to go trick or treating. You will post this in your individual thread. AHAHAHAHAHAHA. Each night, you will receive a piece of candy. Depending on what candy you get, it could either do nothing, give you special powers the next night, or give you special powers for a duration of time.

These are the types of candy:

1. Candy of Boringness (You eat this candy, but nothing happens).
2. Candy of X-Ray Vision (You eat this candy, and the NEXT NIGHT, you have the power to look into someone's house and find out what role that person is).
3. Candy of Poision (spelled wrong on purpose - You eat this candy, and get sick. If you eat two of this candy, you will die!)
4. Candy of Anti-Poision (if you eat this candy after already have eating a Candy of Poision, you will be CURED. If you haven't been poisioned, nothing will happen).
5. Candy of Invincibility (The next time you get killed - regardless of whether it is in the day or the night, you will SURVIVE, but the candy's affects wear off after that).
6. Secret Candies... MUAHAHAHAHA.

I hope you have a good sleep. Tonight is night 0. The skeletons will not kill, but everyone can trick or treat. Make sure to specify whether you're going to Yeano's or Majora's House, and come up with a witty "trick or treat" line, will ya?

You have... 24 hours...

There are 103 Replies

Enable Post Pagination

Good... or should I say... Bad... Morning, Town!

It's time for your to participate in your daily activities. You need 9 votes to end the day round early! You have 72 hours! {boo}

October 24, 2012

Edit

Yeano

Good morning to all. Clearly the best way for the town to win is via roleclaim. I'm just an 'armless Trick or Treater.

My vote is for TPing Yeano.

October 24, 2012

Edit

hezekiah

I'm guessing that was a joke considering roleclaiming won't really help.

And I'm up for TPing Yeano. Maybe we can TP lancer's willfully undecorated mid-suburban house too.

October 24, 2012

Edit

Zanic

Role-claim? This early???? O.o

October 24, 2012

Edit

Helius

How do you get your candy if you're armless?

October 24, 2012

Edit

The Bandit

There shall be no TPing of my house. It shall remain undecorated, just the way I like it!

And obviously since hezy suggested roleclaiming, he's a Skeleton who wants to kill off all our best Trick or Treaters!

October 24, 2012

Edit

white lancer

Hezekiah wants to roleclaim ! LYNCH HIM!

You want to roleclaim? Fine by me. My role is "Feral" the Zombified Wolf. Don't see how that helps anyone, though.

Now, as for the game, I think the Skeletons are at a dissatvantage not knowing who each other is or how eachother are voting. With 15 of us floating around, there is a good chance their nightkill votes will tie.

October 24, 2012

Edit

Feral

Would it still end when the Trick or Treaters are outnumbered? I'm thinking it should only be when one group is entirely eliminated.

October 24, 2012

Edit

White Thunder

Well listen to this guy's.

When I went trick or treating last night, this really mean person came to the door and told me to wait while he found the candy.
I was kept waiting on that porch for 14 hours. And it was very cold and I was ascared.
And then I only got 1 little piece of candy.

So I snuck back and put a bag of dog poop on the porch by the step and took the porch light bulb.(hehe)

Don't tell anyone.

October 24, 2012

Edit

chiefsonny

I just realized that a role-claim might help figure out who the skeletons are for the skeletons but that would just be plain stupid because no one is going to say they are a skeleton...

October 24, 2012

Edit

Helius

Does a skeleton know it's a skeleton?

October 24, 2012

Edit

Xhin

Sky's the limit

I got poison candy. He didn't like my robot costume... (cry)

So yeah. I will admit to being a trick or treater but I agree it does no good for anyone right now. For all intents and purposes, it's pretty much any man for himself. Until skeletons start confirming each other during the night rounds, anyway.

October 24, 2012

Edit

Jo Nathan

Yea, if they look and see all the skin and flesh is missing from their bones.

That might be a big hint.{:P}

October 24, 2012

Edit

chiefsonny

Until skeletons start confirming each other during the night rounds, anyway.

I would like to know what exactly you mean by this.

October 24, 2012

Edit

white lancer

Chief, I visited that house! The guy there just grumped on and on.

October 24, 2012

Edit

Feral

I would like to know what exactly you mean by this.

If/when a skeleton eats a Candy of X-Ray Vision, he has a chance to discover a teammate (or a target).

October 24, 2012

Edit

Jo Nathan

(cry) I got poison candy, ewwwwwww!

Yeano and MM9, what the hell did you do to our Halloween game idea?! {:P} It was supposed to be werewolves and witches, and now it's just a deadly game of trick or treat!

October 24, 2012

Edit

Trever Leingod

Shoot, I didn't realize that the skeletons Tricked or treated too.

October 24, 2012

Edit

Feral

Hmmm..... If I didn't know any better, I'd say you are acting disappointed, like a skeleton who missed out on the Trick or Treating last night.

October 24, 2012

Edit

Jo Nathan

I got poison candy. He didn't like my robot costume...

I got poison candy, ewwwwwww!

Sucks to be you guys!

I got X-Ray, anyone want to volunteer themselves for Redspection in Night 1? It's like an inspection only it won't be pleasant at all!

October 24, 2012

Edit

Redack

Just to clarify, skeletons are allowed to trick-or-treat. They're basically the same as trick-or-treaters except they can vote to kill in the night as well.

October 24, 2012

Edit

MajorasMask9

Upon this recreation of hallowed Abaddon dwells within its murk cadaverous abominations that connive contrivances with such depravity that should they be fully observed would drive a man to madness. But by the agencies of bewitchment and sweet almsgivers should these conspiracies be disrupt, and allow once more the extant mortals their befitting assertion to this earthly realm, whereupon no further horrors to the sound sanity will pervert what we foolishly know to be reality.

... Sorry. With a Shoggoth on my roof I tend to go into bouts of Lovecraftian monologues. It's pretty chill though, so long as I keep away from the tome of eldritch lore in the bathroom.

October 24, 2012

Edit

Frustro

You can inspect me Redack. For once in the past 3 games, I have no problem with it.

October 24, 2012

Edit

Zanic

If Red is a skeleton, and he identifies a townie, he will know who to kill.

Know it makes me sound bad, but volunteering is NOT a good idea.

October 24, 2012

Edit

Feral

OK, OK

I don't know what kind of candy Frustro got, but I want some. That must be some good shit to make you talk like that.

October 24, 2012

Edit

chiefsonny

If Red is a skeleton, and he identifies a townie, he will know who to kill.

A perfectly logical possibility I won't deny but there's a bit of a flaw to it, if I were a skeleton and identified a treater then only I would know to kill that person whilst the other skeletons would likely vote for their preferred target. Frankly to me it seems more likely I've made myself a huge target for skeletons given that I can now potentially identify either an enemy or an ally (giving me a slight advantage over every other player in the game).

But that's how I like to play, I don't shy away into the corner hoping the mafia (skeletons) will leave me alone. I stand in the spotlight making myself a high value target... And then shortly after I end up in a grave due to some kind spider related murder (I hate Dooku for revealing that fear {:/})

October 24, 2012

Edit

Redack

I don't know what kind of candy Frustro got, but I want some. That must be some good shit to make you talk like that.

Well they do say "special candy" are possible.

October 24, 2012

Edit

Redack

Make that secret not special but I take secret to mean special!

October 24, 2012

Edit

Redack

There isn't a whole lot to go on for the first day... we usually just wind up doing a no vote.

October 24, 2012

Edit

Helius

{boo}

October 24, 2012

Edit

Yeano

I don't know what kind of candy Frustro got, but I want some. That must be some good shit to make you talk like that.

Go ahead, try some! ~~it was poision~~

But on a more serious note, something I just noticed: the X-Ray Vision can become a double-edged sword. Namely, if you announce someone who's innocent, then they're pretty much dead... well, deader than the Skeletons are. Similarly, if you announce someone's guilty, then there comes the same problem with the cop without a doctor. Whiiich makes me wonder if one of the Secret candies will allow you to perform a Doctor role for one Night. If that ever pops up for anyone, then save it for when a situation like this happens... unless if you're a Skeleton. Then here, have some poision.

But that's how I like to play, I don't shy away into the corner hoping the mafia (skeletons) will leave me alone. I stand in the spotlight

Songs will be written about you.

October 25, 2012

Edit

Frustro

So there are two roles, skeletons and trick or treaters. so everyone is going to claim trick or treater. unless you get the x-ray candy theres no way to prove someone is or isnt.

October 25, 2012

Edit

CtR Black

=If/when a skeleton eats a Candy of X-Ray Vision, he has a chance to discover a teammate (or a target).

Indeed. What I find interesting is you treating the X-Ray Candy as though its primary function was helping Skeletons discover other Skeletons.

=If Red is a skeleton, and he identifies a townie, he will know who to kill.

=Know it makes me sound bad, but volunteering is NOT a good idea.

Volunteering might not be the best of ideas, agreed. At least not if only a couple of us do so. If a number of people start going "OOH! OOH! PICK ME!" it'll be easier for the Skeletons as a group to identify potential targets as opposed to Skeletons, who would naturally be less likely to want to be checked. Then again, by that same token we as a Town would also have a higher chance of picking out those who were reluctant as possible Skeletons, so it's a trade-off.

Personally, I'd say that anyone who is a Trick or Treater who got an X-Ray candy should investigate someone who didn't volunteer, because those who volunteered first are less likely to be actual Skeletons anyway. Plus, it doesn't do the rest of us any real good if someone claims to have found someone innocent because we won't necessarily be able to trust their claim.

=Similarly, if you announce someone's guilty, then there comes the same problem with the cop without a doctor.

Except the X-Ray Candy is a one-shot thing, meaning there's no real reason for any Trick or Treater not to reveal the result of their check immediately. It's not like they're any more or less likely to get the X-Ray Candy again. That also makes Redack's early claim to have the X-Ray Candy make no sense--there's no advantage to revealing that you have that type of candy until after you've had a chance to use it.

I have a question for Majora or Yeano: are all six types of candy available each night (i.e. Two different people who visited the same person could wind up with different kinds of candies, right?)?

If/when a skeleton eats a Candy of X-Ray Vision, he has a chance to discover a teammate (or a target).

Indeed. What I find interesting is you treating the X-Ray Candy as though its primary function was helping Skeletons discover other Skeletons.

If Red is a skeleton, and he identifies a townie, he will know who to kill.

Know it makes me sound bad, but volunteering is NOT a good idea.

Volunteering might not be the best of ideas, agreed. At least not if only a couple of us do so. If a number of people start going "OOH! OOH! PICK ME!" it'll be easier for the Skeletons as a group to identify potential targets as opposed to Skeletons, who would naturally be less likely to want to be checked. Then again, by that same token we as a Town would also have a higher chance of picking out those who were reluctant as possible Skeletons, so it's a trade-off.

Personally, I'd say that anyone who is a Trick or Treater who got an X-Ray candy should investigate someone who didn't volunteer, because those who volunteered first are less likely to be actual Skeletons anyway. Plus, it doesn't do the rest of us any real good if someone claims to have found someone innocent because we won't necessarily be able to trust their claim.

Similarly, if you announce someone's guilty, then there comes the same problem with the cop without a doctor.

Except the X-Ray Candy is a one-shot thing, meaning there's no real reason for any Trick or Treater not to reveal the result of their check immediately. It's not like they're any more or less likely to get the X-Ray Candy again. That also makes Redack's early claim to have the X-Ray Candy make no sense--there's no advantage to revealing that you have that type of candy until after you've had a chance to use it.

I have a question for Majora or Yeano: are all six types of candy available each night (i.e. Two different people who visited the same person could wind up with different kinds of candies, right?)?

October 25, 2012

Edit

white lancer

I have a question for Majora or Yeano: are all six types of candy available each night (i.e. Two different people who visited the same person could wind up with different kinds of candies, right?)?

There are a few factors and a little bit of randomization involved, but yes, you could get any of the candies.

October 25, 2012

Edit

Yeano

I am betting the hosts are using that same random generator they use to assign roles to pick who gets what candy.

October 25, 2012

Edit

Trever Leingod

It's not that the person who did the inspection poses further threat, but that if they find someone guilty and announce that, then they're obviously a Trick-or-Treater and the Skeletons will have an easy kill. Granted, it could be considered a worthy sacrifice, but having people throw themselves to the flames for the greater good is... eegghhh...

On the topic of Redack's announcement, I find it really weird, for what white lancer detailed. It could be that idea of exposing who isn't volunteering (have at it with me btw), but there's even a downside with that. Namely, whoever's freely volunteering is probably innocent, giving the Skeletons a general direction for kills. This two-way street thing is ingenius... and aggravating.

October 25, 2012

Edit

Frustro

I do feel like we'll have the best shot at winning if we play proactively. The longer the game goes, the more info the Skeletons get. And even though the Trick or Treaters can gather more info total, it's pretty much impossible to verify without sacrifice. I'll be reading through the day's discussion again at work tomorrow, and fully intend to cast a vote.

October 25, 2012

Edit

hezekiah

Our problem is that we're very close in numbers, which is making me a little nervous. We can afford to mislynch just once, and only if we start this day round (assuming the Skeletons reach a majority on both of the next two nights, and that none of our normal Trick or Treaters die of poisoning during the night). That doesn't mean we shouldn't cast a vote today, but it does mean that we need to be very careful.

I'm not really worried about the Skeletons getting information--it's not like we have any special roles that we really need to be protecting or anything. The only info they're going to get is info on who is in their gang and who isn't, which is info they'd have in a normal game anyway (so it's a disadvantage to them rather than an advantage).

October 25, 2012

Edit

white lancer

I had another GT dream last night. I HOPE it's not a foretelling.

This time, I dreampt that Majora resigned as mod(Yeah, I know, he isn't a mod), and retired from Gametalk. Yeano was telling me that I had to make a huge announcement about it! lol

No one hasn't given away much yet. A few suspicious things were said, but not enough to identify anybody yet.

October 25, 2012

Edit

Feral

I had another GT dream last night. I HOPE it's not a foretelling.

This time, I dreampt that Majora resigned as mod(Yeah, I know, he isn't a mod), and retired from Gametalk. Yeano was telling me that I had to make a huge announcement about it! lol

Well we know that's not likely to happen, since Yeano would be telling you the opposite if that happened.

October 25, 2012

Edit

Redack

That also makes Redack's early claim to have the X-Ray Candy make no sense--there's no advantage to revealing that you have that type of candy until after you've had a chance to use it.

Unless by forcing people to volunteer I've given the town a bit more info...

I'd also like to point out I had no intention of sharing the result with you guys, since in this one nobody knows who anybody is there's more benefit to me keeping it to myself so the skeletons can't narrow each other down. (Though if I found a treater I'd let them know so we could work together :) )

October 25, 2012

Edit

Redack

I had another GT dream last night. I HOPE it's not a foretelling.

To be very honest if I were you I would be concerned about a young man your age having dreams about GT instead of dreaming of naked chicks.

Just saying (hehe)

October 25, 2012

Edit

chiefsonny

To be very honest if I were you I would be concerned about a young man your age having dreams about GT instead of dreaming of naked chicks.

He never said anyone in the dream was CLOTHED...

October 25, 2012

Edit

Frustro

If anyone else has X-Ray Candy I would advise them to use it on Redack. Just a suggestion.

October 25, 2012

Edit

Jo Nathan

Naked GT Mafia players in your dreams.

Things that make you want to go Brrrrr.

October 25, 2012

Edit

chiefsonny

If anyone else has X-Ray Candy I would advise them to use it on Redack. Just a suggestion.

So untrusting {:P}

October 25, 2012

Edit

Redack

We all know that anyone who fully trusts Redack is a fool {:P}

October 25, 2012

Edit

Trever Leingod

Well, when I read this:

Though if I found a treater I'd let them know so we could work together :)

I could just imagine you being a skeleton and leading some poor soul astray.

But you'll probably turn out to be innocent which will make me look like a total ass. {:P}

October 25, 2012

Edit

Jo Nathan

Unless by forcing people to volunteer I've given the town a bit more info...

...you've also given that same info to the Skeletons, so it's a bit of a wash. Except I'd argue they've come out ahead because now they know someone who has the X-Ray candy.

I'd also like to point out I had no intention of sharing the result with you guys, since in this one nobody knows who anybody is there's more benefit to me keeping it to myself so the skeletons can't narrow each other down. (Though if I found a treater I'd let them know so we could work together :) )

Also makes no sense, because if you wind up dead your investigation doesn't benefit us at all. Maybe keeping the results a secret would have been helpful if you hadn't revealed the X-Ray Candy to everyone, but as it is it's likely to be wasted. And if you found a Skeleton, there would be even less of a reason to keep that secret.

October 25, 2012

Edit

white lancer

Sorry I haven't been very active so far. I had a long drive yesterday and was exhausted.

If we're all intent on voting someone off on the first day, then I'm totally cool with offing Redack. I'm not sure if voting for someone is the best bet, but I think Redack is the most suspicious from what I've read.

October 25, 2012

Edit

The Bandit

But you'll probably turn out to be innocent which will make me look like a total ass.

Well you are!

@Lancer

Maybe, I suppose it was a bad move. Still the fact remains I did it and we'll just have to live with the consequence. I suppose I'll tell you what I find out, should you all be willing to spare the town idiot {:(}

October 25, 2012

Edit

Redack

Naked GT Mafia players in your dreams.

Things that make you want to go Brrrrr.

Happy Halloween~

What gets me is that Redack appears like such a power player. If he was either a Trick-or-Treater OR a Skeleton, keeping that info to himself would've been a LOT more advantageous in both positions, and he's probably already considered that. So to do something really, really reckless just leaves me going, ".. Huh?" If all the 'reasons' Redack's supplied are legit the excuses he's going with, I'm more than happy to vote for him, because white lancer's already pointed out everything that's so illogical about it.

October 25, 2012

Edit

Frustro

I think appears is the key word in that.

October 25, 2012

Edit

Redack

... Fair enough.

October 25, 2012

Edit

Frustro

I admit, I made a fairly stupid error that has probably helped the skeletons more than the town. Therefore I think for now lets just leave it at "appears like" until I redeem myself.

October 25, 2012

Edit

Redack

I'm torn what to do about Redack. The move just doesn't make any sense to me, but it wouldn't be especially helpful from a Skeleton position either. I guess there's always a chance that he was going to investigate someone and pass them off as guilty if he discovered that they were innocent (auto-win for the Skeletons if we believe him next round), but he wouldn't need to reveal today to do that. There's a decent chance he's a Skeleton but I'm not completely sure.

I'm also suspicious of JN, for what it's worth. Seemed like he was thinking from the Skeleton's point of view when he made his comment earlier.

October 25, 2012

Edit

white lancer

It's possible Redack never even got an x-ray power and just wanted some innocents to "expose" themselves.

It's weird. In this game, confirming you're a townie is almost as dangerous as confirming you're mafia in a normal game.

It could just be a stupid slip up, I guess. This is a new game type, after all. Still, it just makes much more sense for a skeleton to want to know who townies are than a honest trick or treater asking for people to investigate. And Redack is a very smart player, so this isn't past him.

October 25, 2012

Edit

The Bandit

White lancer, which comment specifically are you referring to?

October 25, 2012

Edit

Jo Nathan

The more I think about it the more I think we're better off voting to kill someone this round, since we have a couple of vote options and the ratio is so close. There are only two ways we'll have room for a mislynch tomorrow, and that's if the Skeletons tie the vote or if we manage to kill one of them today, and I kinda want to take our first shot now and see how it goes. Plus, it's not like we're going to be losing any crucial roles or anything if we vote wrong.

Redack is a distinct possibility and I think we should keep him in mind for tomorrow's vote, but personally I'm going to go for JN. Some of his posts have struck me as being maybe a little off, and he said he got poison candy so it's not like he's going to be a big blow to us if we're wrong anyway. I'd also like to keep Redack around for at least one more round just in case he really does have the X-Ray Candy.

October 25, 2012

Edit

white lancer

White lancer, which comment specifically are you referring to?

The one about the Skeletons confirming each other. Seems very strange that that particular use of the X-Ray candies would be your first thought as to how they could be used.

October 25, 2012

Edit

white lancer

So you're referring to this one:

If/when a skeleton eats a Candy of X-Ray Vision, he has a chance to discover a teammate (or a target).

I only posted that because you requested that I explain my previous comment. And my previous comment was just me lamenting how it's almost like every man for himself. Acknowledging that skeletons may start discovering each other and posing a threat was an afterthought that I added just before I posted.

October 25, 2012

Edit

Jo Nathan

Oh wait, scratch that, you were referring to the original comment, not the one I quoted.

Still, that was just an afterthought. I didn't think someone would mistaken that as me trying to strategize for the skeletons.

October 25, 2012

Edit

Jo Nathan

I don't know if it's been mentioned yet because I haven't bothered reading every single post, but even if Redack does have an X-Ray candy, how are we supposed to believe him? There's no way of really knowing if he is a trick or treater or not. So him mentioning that he had an x-ray does absolutely nothing. He could easily be a skeleton who finds a townie tonight and says that he is guilty.

October 25, 2012

Edit

Zanic

And if I claimed someone is guilty and you lynched them and then you'd lynch me. If I was a skeleton I'd not do that. Whichever side I was on I would tell the truth because that's what's most likely to keep me alive. So regardless of what I find, I don't think it should really alter your suspicion, or lack of suspicion.

The difference between this game and regular mafia is that the mafia (skeletons) aren't aware of each other. They aren't going to act as a team, probably not even after they find each other because they might not be able to easily communicate with each other.

October 25, 2012

Edit

Redack

I'm not saying I'm suspicious of you. I'm just saying that you saying you have an x-ray candy is irrelevant. Because there's no way we can believe you.

October 25, 2012

Edit

Zanic

Yes, I agreed. I was just expanding on it.

October 25, 2012

Edit

Redack

Skeleton or not, I'd be surprised if Red survived the night. Could be wrong, but I would think the Skellys would target those who draw attention to themselves.

I know how you all (T and Ters) feel about wording everything so carefully. I am finding myself double checkng everyhing I write, so as not to misconstrue(spl?) myself.

October 25, 2012

Edit

Feral

Still, that was just an afterthought. I didn't think someone would mistaken that as me trying to strategize for the skeletons.

It just struck me as weird, is all. If I'm wrong, I'm sorry, but it seemed like it could have been a slip and it put you ahead of everyone else on my suspicion list.

Anyway, if anyone else is going to vote, you've got about an hour to do so.

October 25, 2012

Edit

white lancer

That's wrong, though; there's still another full day in this round.

October 25, 2012

Edit

hezekiah

Whoops, you're right. I was counting from the original post, but that started Night 0, not Day 1.

October 25, 2012

Edit

white lancer

What I'm looking for this round is anything that might indicate that the Skeletons are trying to alert each other of their status. The advantage in this game is that they can't communicate with each other right away, and I'd like that to be the case for as long as possible. If Jo has said something fishy, that'd get my attention right quick, but so far I haven't really noticed him say anything weird.

It's possible Redack never even got an x-ray power and just wanted some innocents to "expose" themselves.

That actually makes a lot of sense in explaining why he did what he did. {duck}

October 26, 2012

Edit

Frustro

If I'm wrong, I'm sorry, but it seemed like it could have been a slip and it put you ahead of everyone else on my suspicion list.

Hey, no big deal. I do try to think like the enemy so I can anticipate what they might do, but I won't fault you if I'm genuinely on the top of your suspicion list.

I've been trying to find possible "slips" myself. In fact, I pointed out something I thought was suspicious of Feral and he's yet to acknowledge it... {pump}

October 26, 2012

Edit

Jo Nathan

15 players playing what can be best described as 15 individual games. And the best strategy seems to be watch what you say at all cost.

Should be a long game.

October 26, 2012

Edit

chiefsonny

Because I figured you caught your obvious mistake. If I didn't trick or treat, why would I have joked about visiting the same grumpy person as Chief?

October 26, 2012

Edit

Feral

You all so boring. {meow}

October 26, 2012

Edit

Yeano

The god of this Mafia world is not entertained by our antics... I suggest we make a sacrifice to make up for it.

@Feral - I have to admit sometimes I totally miss things that are blatantly obvious (I think I missed/forgotten about someone's role claim in Game 11), so... yeah, sorry 'bout that.

October 26, 2012

Edit

Jo Nathan

*Eggs Yeano's mansion*

It's alright Jo. All any of us can do at this point is scrutinize everybody else and hope somebody makes a mistake. Sometimes we miss the big picture because we are so focused on the details.

October 26, 2012

Edit

Feral

The thing about this game is that the Skeletons are likely to play more similarly to the Trick or Treaters during the day than we're used to. It's gonna be hard to tell who's who.

October 26, 2012

Edit

White Thunder

Even if we sacrifice someone, they don't necessarily die, correct? We still have night talk in this game with the dead?

If I'm understanding this correctly, we'll know their role... and the dead might help our cause... but who can really trust the dead in the first place?

October 26, 2012

Edit

Helius

Nevermind, looks like I was going off of the Mafia ideas from the other post.

October 26, 2012

Edit

Helius

Two people failed to post this round- The ever inactive Serpe and the usually active Trever. I have to wonder if Trev got a candy that glued his mouth shut or something, cause he has been active elsewhere.

October 26, 2012

Edit

Feral

When I get a chance I'm going to review this round and see if anything sticks out, aside from Redack. I don't intend to vote for him anyway, but I do intend to vote.

I'd like to make an official appeal - if someone goes like 7 real-life days in a row with zero participation, even if they participated prior to that, can they be host-killed?

October 26, 2012

Edit

Jo Nathan

Trever has voted. He's The Amazing Spiderman. He hasn't said anything very useful, however.

October 26, 2012

Edit

The Bandit

Er, not voted. He's said things.

October 26, 2012

Edit

The Bandit

Trever has posted 3 times in the Day round. Serpe has not posted yet.

Is vote lock on?

October 26, 2012

Edit

chiefsonny

There isn't much useful to say right now! The only controversial/suspicious thing that has really happened is Redack's claim to have X-ray vision candy! {pump} And it's not nearly enough evidence to make him necessarily guilty.

October 26, 2012

Edit

Trever Leingod

Trever has voted. He's The Amazing Spiderman.

Way to ruin his secret identity, now he has to move out of town, get a new identity and start up all over again.

October 26, 2012

Edit

Redack

My bad, sorry Trev. I move that if Serpe doesn't post by the end of day 2, we lynch him then.

October 26, 2012

Edit

Feral

Well shoot. I re-read everything in this round and I got pretty much nothing. Redack's behavior has been interesting, but I could see him doing that innocent or guilty so I'm leaving him alone for now.

Hmm.... FAW was Mafia in Game 11 and I was Mafia last game. Among the newbie players, it's totally Frustro's turn to be Mafia now. I think that is more than enough evidence to vote for him, yes?

October 26, 2012

Edit

Jo Nathan

I recall LLight once described me as "interesting" in this game...

October 26, 2012

Edit

Redack

This will be my last chance to vote because I'll be unavailable for the rest of the night, so...

October 26, 2012

Edit

Jo Nathan

Let me try that again, I didn't want to vote for Feral.

October 26, 2012

Edit

Jo Nathan

My bad, sorry Trev. I move that if Serpe doesn't post by the end of day 2, we lynch him then.

Not with the ratio as close as it is. Lynching inactive players is generally inadvisable anyway (nearly killed the Town last game), but by next round we'll probably have only one shot to get someone right and I'd rather not waste it on someone who hasn't shown up at all.

I'd be fine with a host-kill on him if he doesn't show up, though (as long as it wouldn't end the game). And if he doesn't actually play this game, he should be barred from future Mafia games.

October 26, 2012

Edit

white lancer

A random vote? Why? And I thought you found Feral suspicious?

October 26, 2012

Edit

white lancer

It's a day late, but I've read through the round again. This person has said multiple things that I think make them look suspicious.

October 26, 2012

Edit

hezekiah

I originally thought Feral was suspicious but he pointed out a mistake I made so I took it back. My random vote was to potentially keep me from dying from a single vote in case nobody else voted. But it's cool. I'm prepared to go if I have to.

I got on my phone to come back here because I cant in good conscience vote for Trever based on nothing.

October 26, 2012

Edit

Jo Nathan

Personally I'm not convinced Jo is a skeleton but I realise the ratio is close so I won't get in the way by voting not kill. So I'm not going to vote this round...

October 26, 2012

Edit

Redack

I'm not entirely sure either, but he seems more suspicious to me than anyone else at this point. If we're going to mostly be limited to going by our gut, I'd rather have two shots at getting one right (this round and next round) than just one.

October 26, 2012

Edit

white lancer

Nobody else wants to vote for Frustro? I thought my reasoning was pretty sound. {:P}

October 26, 2012

Edit

Jo Nathan

This day round should be over in 26 min.

If you don't want to play. Don't sign up.

October 26, 2012

Edit

chiefsonny

I'm sorry, if I have a chance to not die I'll take it. Even if you lynch me in the next round you'll thank me later for stalling a mis-lynch for one round.

But if I get one more vote I'll just have to get a big bowl of popcorn and enjoy the rest of the game pressure free. {8D}

October 27, 2012

Edit

Jo Nathan

I agree with Lancer regarding inactive players. We should just have them host killed. I say we give Serpe another day, then ask for a host kill. I would rather not lynch people anymore based on nothing. Why he signs up if he can't play at all, even though he claims he will be more active later, is beyond me.

October 27, 2012

Edit

Trever Leingod

Tonight, nobody died. Not even Jo Nathan. You might have thought that Jo Nathan would have died 30 minutes ago. Hasty people might have even thought there was no way to avoid it! But he's alive. It's a miracle. Keep on miracle'ing, Jo Nathan.

1. Redack
2. Trever Leingod
3. Jo Nathan
4. Frustro
5. Feral
6. White Thunder
7. white lancer
8. CtR Black
9. hezekiah
10. Zanic
11. Serpe
12. Helius
13. chiefsonny
14. Xhin
15. The Bandit

Ratio: 6-9

NEW CANDIES APPROACHING: From this night round on, these new candies will have a chance of appearing:

1)Candy of Silence - Whoever eats this candy will be silenced for the next day round.
2)Candy of Influence - When you eat this candy, you'll feel a lot more confident in yourself. In the next day round, your vote will count as two votes.

Be sure to trick-or-treat, and tell us who you're visiting!

October 27, 2012

Edit

MajorasMask9

Username
Password
Preview

Mafia

main thread ahuehuehue night 1 no kill

There are 103 Replies

Reply to: main thread ahuehuehue night 1 no kill