Engines Aether Legend of the Lunar Priest NIFE Roadmap
Shatterloop Game Projects Deprecated Starwright
Saepes Mundi Other Projects Blog  

Mafia

Moderated by: Speed Bike Pro

main thread night 4 make it yourself

Posted November 5, 2012 by Yeano

You had to do it, didn't you?

You just HAD to make the night round so boring.

Let me tell you what happened....

NOTHING.

NOW START THE DAY.

1. Redack - Skeleton
2. Trever Leingod - Trick-or-Treater
3. Jo Nathan
4. Frustro - Skeleton
5. Feral
6. White Thunder
7. white lancer
8. CtR Black
9. hezekiah
10. Zanic
11. Serpe
12. Helius
13. chiefsonny
14. Xhin - Skeleton
15. The Bandit

Ratio: 3-8

Available Candy (See previous thread for details):
-Candy of Boringness
-Candy of X-Ray Vision
-Candy of Poision
-Candy of Anti-Poision
-Candy of Invincibility
-Candy of Silence
-Candy of Influence
-Boo Candy
-Candy of Skeleton's Revenge
-SuperPAC Candy
-Candy of Anonymity

You have 72 hours to finish, or the round will end with 7 votes for the same person.

There are 65 Replies

extensionEnable Post Pagination

Holy shit, a free pass for the town? How fortunate. Must've been a tie in the voting...

November 5, 2012
Edit
Jo Nathan

I was half way expecting one of us to die, but that was a better move by the Skeletons anyhow because it puts previous claims in doubt. Kudos to the Skele crew.

Of course, if this is true... we're looking at skillful players or inactive ones... because that's a possibility too.

November 5, 2012
Edit
Helius

My guess is that they tied the votes between Jo and Feral. And it was either a 1-1-1 tie or one Skeleton member didn't vote (in which case it's likely that the third Skeleton member is inactive--obviously this would almost certainly be Serpe).

At this point, we're ahead enough that we may as well continue taking shots at people. I suggest Serpe, CtR, or Thunder, unless anyone else has any more info--there's a distinct chance someone else has an X-Ray candy result by now.

November 5, 2012
Edit
white lancer

An anonymous message has been received:

I have used an X-ray candy on Zanic. He is definitely a Skeleton; however, as I am afraid that he will be able to overpower my reasoning, I am having this posted anonymously.

November 5, 2012
Edit
Yeano

Ummm, okay. The fact that someone doesn't think they can overpower my reasoning is a dead giveaway that they are lying. I'm one of the weaker players here. If you believe this bullcrap, then so be it.

November 5, 2012
Edit
Zanic

^Still have to be careful of that. Could be a Skeleton directing us to a T or Ter. It was worded WAY to vaguely. What does "Overpower my reasoning" mean? I'm thinking that unless that claim can be verified, we leave Zanic alive at least one more round.

So, I am happy with my work this game. I led the charge against two Skeletons. Why the Skeletons didn't kill me is beyond me.

I think Lancer is right about an inactive person, but not necessarily Serpe. I'm not ready to accuse just yet.

November 5, 2012
Edit
Feral

Okay, add Zanic to the list of possible suspects. I'm not entirely convinced, though--there are some things that don't add up.

1. The odds of someone just happening to hit the X-Ray Candy one round and the Anonymity Candy the next are fairly large. Not impossible at all, but somewhat unlikely.

2. Zanic seems like a rather random choice to hit with the X-Ray Candy given that there were a number of us who were suspicious last round. Again, not impossible, but unlikely.

3. The excuse of not being able to overpower someone's reasoning is quite frankly ridiculous. Not even really because of who Zanic is--even the best players with the best reasoning skills are unlikely to escape condemnation via X-Ray Candy. The fact that Zanic isn't a so-called 'power player' just adds to the problems I have with that excuse.

4. It's possible Zanic is a Trick or Treater, but to be honest he's been low on my suspicions list because he was the very first to volunteer to be hit by an X-Ray Candy in the first round. That's possibly misdirection on his part, but if it is it's very risky misdirection. On the other hand, this could explain why the player decided to check Zanic, but I'm still not sure I buy it.

It just seems a little too perfect in my view. That being said, I advise us NOT to vote for Zanic unless the person who posted that message steps forward. We need to be able to hold them accountable if they're lying to us, and I don't really see a downside to them stepping forward.

If they do step forward, I'll probably cast my vote for Zanic. But I'm definitely not if it's going to remain an anonymous message.

November 5, 2012
Edit
white lancer

#4 should read 'It's possible Zanic is a SKELETON,' not Trick or Treater.

November 5, 2012
Edit
white lancer

I think Lancer is right about an inactive person, but not necessarily Serpe. I'm not ready to accuse just yet.

No one else is really inactive, though--I think everyone except Serpe and hezy posted last round, and hezy posted elsewhere on the site so I expect he was probably Silenced.

November 5, 2012
Edit
white lancer

The town has a strong advantage in numbers, so it shouldn't be a huge hit for someone to risk their life to come forward with information - especially if it does result in a skeleton being lynched. So yeah, I agree it would be more beneficial for the town if that person came forward.

You guys have been playing with each other longer than I have. Does the wording of that message seem reminiscent of any specific player to any of you?

November 5, 2012
Edit
Jo Nathan

1. The odds of someone just happening to hit the X-Ray Candy one round and the Anonymity Candy the next are fairly large. Not impossible at all, but somewhat unlikely.

Well, I think it's obvious the guy did hit x-ray and anonymity. He clearly got anonymity. We know that. And if it's a skeleton, I don't think they would just randomly pick someone (at the risk of losing another skeleton) to accuse. It's either a sincere claim or a skeleton who got an innocent hit on Zanic. I don't see a skeleton taking that chance at this point.

I have used an X-ray candy on Zanic. He is definitely a Skeleton; however, as I am afraid that he will be able to overpower my reasoning, I am having this posted anonymously.

He used a semicolon. This shouldn't be hard to narrow down.

November 5, 2012
Edit
The Bandit

Doesn't sound anything at all like CtR, Bandit, chief, or Feral. Probably not hezy either. My first thought was Helius, but it's not exactly the way I'd imagine him wording things either. Ironically, the wording (but not the content) is probably more similar to how I would word it than anyone else. I could also see it being Serpe or maybe Thunder.

More likely, though, someone made a deliberate effort to disguise their choice of words. The language is fairly formal and it's just too far away from how most people left would word it.

November 5, 2012
Edit
white lancer

Well, I think it's obvious the guy did hit x-ray and anonymity. He clearly got anonymity. We know that. And if it's a skeleton, I don't think they would just randomly pick someone (at the risk of losing another skeleton) to accuse. It's either a sincere claim or a skeleton who got an innocent hit on Zanic. I don't see a skeleton taking that chance at this point.

Maybe. Honestly, I think it's more likely it was a Skeleton hoping for a free Town kill--having confirmation as to whether Zanic was really innocent would be helpful to them but probably not necessary. They could simply have assumed Zanic's innocence based on his willingness to get checked in Round 1, or they could have just picked someone at random and hoped that they weren't a Skeleton (odds are fairly good for that). Either way, I don't think we should listen to the message unless they actually step forward. At this point, there's no reason for them not to if they're Town-sided.

November 5, 2012
Edit
white lancer

I don't think either way helps us know if Zanic is really innocent or guilty, so yeah, not worth discussing.

And, it's possible the person just doesn't want to die. If he steps forward and Zanic is rightly killed, then I think he's an obvious target for the mafia. It's what I would have done, though I would have been honest about it.

November 5, 2012
Edit
The Bandit

Yeah, and I suppose it's also possible they were just having fun with the anonymity power (though the way it was worded doesn't exactly point to that).

A Trick or Treater not coming forward would only hurt the Town, though, as otherwise we probably aren't going to vote Zanic out. There are enough confirmed innocent players here anyway that stepping forward wouldn't be instant death--they could very well still go for Feral or Jo, or tie the votes again.

November 5, 2012
Edit
white lancer

If they do step forward, I'll probably cast my vote for Zanic. But I'm definitely not if it's going to remain an anonymous message.

My thoughts exactly. I would even go so far as to say that the anonymity makes it more likely that Zanic is innocent and not a skeleton. They did it so that we would lynch a townie without consequence to them. If the person comes forward, then obviously we should lynch one of the two.

There are a bunch of other possible scenarios that popped into my head, and it is entirely possible that both Zanic and the anon are Skeletons (wouldn't that be quite a play), but how I described it is what I think is most likely.

November 5, 2012
Edit
White Thunder

So, I am happy with my work this game. I led the charge against two Skeletons


Well Congratulations for a job well done.


Vote for Ron Paul for Dog Catcher
He can win that one.

November 5, 2012
Edit
chiefsonny
 

I'm so happy I didn't get that stupid candy.

November 5, 2012
Edit
The Bandit

Since I don't have a life, I just went through all the post made so far in the Day Rounds and I only seen the semicolon used twice, and it did not appear to be a normal part of those 2 peoples posting patterns.


Vote For Redack for Grand Overlord.(ashamed)

November 6, 2012
Edit
chiefsonny
 

Vote Quimby

As assumed, I was silenced yesterday (and I'm stuck on the campaign trail today). I concur with those who assume that the Anonymous post was meant to get a free TnT kill. Clearly my hunch was wrong, but better to clear him (right?) that way than through death.

CtR seems like as good a choice as any, pending further discussion.

November 6, 2012
Edit
hezekiah

I'll justify my absence in the previous day round with an extremely ironic silencing. Though like Feral, I've nothing to report.

"Overpower my reasoning"...that just sounds clunky.

Oh, and a random conspiracy theory. What if the message is reverse psychology, posted by Zanic himself to reduce suspicion of himself as a result of insufficient evidence? Or...something.

At any rate, I still don't there's enough to go on currently other than hunches, unless older posts might provide clues.

November 6, 2012
Edit
Serpe

So I dont have any leads. But I think it's funny that people suspect me when I was the first one to vote for and point out that Xhin was suspicious

November 6, 2012
Edit
CtR Black

Though to be honest, Xhin's habit of voting for himself is unintentionally suspect.

November 6, 2012
Edit
Serpe

Serpe, Hezy was silenced, not me. 8p

I was suspicious of Xhin from as soon as he voted for himself.

Personally, I am fairly certain that Zanic, Helius, and Lancer are innosent. Zanic was way to quick to volunteer to be x-rayed by Red in day 1. Helius' reason for x-raying me still sits well. Lancer has been playing hard this game, not holding back. He is way to agressive to be a Skelleton. I am leaning toward innosence on Bandit too.

I'm not against voting CtR, but there is some one else I am much more suspicious of. Gonna keep watching them.

November 6, 2012
Edit
Feral

Woops. Sorry for the mix-up.

I think we can safely take Lancer off the list as well. If he legitimately thought hezy or I was a skeleton, then throwing either of us under the bus with their low numbers is the least beneficial strategy I could think of.

November 6, 2012
Edit
Serpe

It was I who posted the anonymous message. It shouldn't be too surprising, and yes, I was lying.

But here's why...

First, I was kind of suspicious of Zanic after looking back at previous rounds. So I decided to test Zanic by having that posted and seeing the response from players. I was hoping to gain insight into who could be a potential skeleton.

Secondly, I am even more suspicious of white lancer (no offense). Its understandable to defend Zanic, but to not admit that there's a major possibility that he can be a Skeleton... worries me. Mainly because Zanic hasn't been "confirmed".

Thirdly, As Feral points outs,

Lancer has been playing hard this game, not holding back.


If I were a Skeleton especially at this point of the game, I'd be playing pretty hard too because it keeps the narrative off of me and on others.

Fourthly, Lancer also states,

And it was either a 1-1-1 tie or one Skeleton member didn't vote (in which case it's likely that the third Skeleton member is inactive--obviously this would almost certainly be Serpe).


I don't immediately rush to that concept. I also know that Jo said that there must have been a tie.

Is there enough to lynch him? Probably not, but it has increased his blip on my radar. Of course, I've been known to be wrong in the past anyhow.

November 6, 2012
Edit
Helius

First, it makes me happy that my first guess as to who posted that was right. Second:

Secondly, I am even more suspicious of white lancer (no offense). Its understandable to defend Zanic, but to not admit that there's a major possibility that he can be a Skeleton... worries me. Mainly because Zanic hasn't been "confirmed".

Apparently, you missed this:

Okay, add Zanic to the list of possible suspects.

And this:

#4 should read 'It's possible Zanic is a SKELETON,' not Trick or Treater.

Oh, and this:

If they do step forward, I'll probably cast my vote for Zanic.

But, yeah, I totally discounted the possibility that he was a Skeleton. I think I laid out my reasons for not wanting to vote Zanic off this round fairly clearly.

As for the tie thing, I thought that was rather obvious. It's a lot more likely than that all three of them decided not to kill somebody...without coordinating with one another...on a night where not killing anyone was a REALLY, REALLY bad idea (given that we have some virtually confirmed innocents). So yeah, a tie is many times more likely than any other explanation I can think of.

As for you, well...I'm not sure what to make of this move. If you were just trying to get us to lynch Zanic (say, if you were a Skeleton trying to get rid of another innocent), it was a fairly clumsy way of doing so since there were a lot of holes with it. Though I suppose a Skeleton might think it was worth it to take a shot and hope it worked (a Hail Mary pass, as it were) since there probably wasn't much else you could do with that particular candy. On the other hand, I don't think most Skeletons would reveal themselves after that attempt failed, although the very fact that I'm making this argument suggests there's some merit to the strategy, and if anyone were going to pull a move like that, it would be Helius (or maybe Xhin). Suffice it to say that I'm a lot warier of you now than I was before.

November 6, 2012
Edit
white lancer

So I dont have any leads. But I think it's funny that people suspect me when I was the first one to vote for and point out that Xhin was suspicious

This is a point that should be taken into consideration, but it doesn't clear you by any means, CtR. It makes me a little less likely to vote for you, but the fact remains that you had no way of knowing whether Xhin was a Skeleton no matter what role you have, so if you were a Skeleton you wouldn't have known that you were sacrificing one of your own.

I'm going to take this opportunity to point out that everyone has spoken this round, so no one has been silenced (maybe in response to there being apparently two silencings in one night for each of the previous two nights?). For what it's worth, that also means that at least one of the candies was duplicated last night (we have an equal number of distinct candies and people).

I'm also wondering if Feral's secret suspicion matches my own. :D

November 6, 2012
Edit
white lancer

Well I've lost track of who's been checked out and found innocent and I'm not reading through all those damn post again.
Maybe someone can post it and I'm going to give you another name to add to it.

On Night 2 I got a piece of X-ray candy which as you know I could not use until last night and I did.

I considered 2 people based mainly on their inactivity and what little they had to say when they posted.

They were Serpe and Hezy

I decided to check out the more experienced player because in past games he has played very good games.

Hezy is innocent.


Vote for Harry Reed for Wac-Job of the year. His campaign slogan should be "If I had a brain, I'd be dangerous".

November 6, 2012
Edit
chiefsonny
 

Confirmed:

Feral
Hezy

Maybe confirmed:

Helius

Unconfirmed

Jo Nathan
White Thunder
white lancer
CtR Black
hezekiah
Zanic
Serpe
chiefsonny
The Bandit

----------------

I know for certain that Feral was a Trick o Treater. As far as my move with Zanic, I'm just stirring up the pot to see what will come up. If you decide to lynch me, I've already played my part in this mess.

Now, I will say that it's possible that Skeletons have worked out who each other are. We have had four nights to work out who each other are, and as far as I know (and my list may be uncomplete) only a few people have claimed to have X-ray Candy:

Chief (Night 2)
Helius (Night 1) as I was silenced.
White Thunder (Night 2?)
Redack (but look where that got him)

We have had only three people with X-ray Candy. Something seem a bit off? I think there are some more out there.

November 6, 2012
Edit
Helius

I'm wondering if the skeletons actually haven't identified each other yet, or if there's at least one skeleton who's still in the dark. I can't fathom why they would deliberately do a no-kill last night, and if they were working together they would not have tied.

Also if Feral is considered confirmed, should I not also be on account of Feral using X-Ray on me?

November 6, 2012
Edit
Jo Nathan

I can see how they (the skeletons)can communicate with each other.

If one of them got or gets a piece of X-ray candy and when they use it they find another skeleton, and then post that the person they checked is innocent, that would send a message to that person that the person making the report is one of them.

But I don't see how that would help them at night since they can't talk to each other unless they do it through other means (im's).

The only advantage to them would be who not to vote for during the day.

That to me is the major drawback to this X-ray candy. Who's being honest and who's sending a message?

@Helius, In your list above. How can Hezy be Confirmed and Unconfirmed?


Vote for Lady Gaga for Tramp of the Year.

November 6, 2012
Edit
chiefsonny
 

If one of them got or gets a piece of X-ray candy and when they use it they find another skeleton, and then post that the person they checked is innocent, that would send a message to that person that the person making the report is one of them.


That had occurred to me but I didn't want to say anything in case I was giving them an idea.

Ironically, I was wondering if you were doing exactly that when you calimed Hezy was innocent. But since you're spelling this strategy out for us, I'm inclined to believe that is not the case.

November 6, 2012
Edit
Jo Nathan

*claimed

November 6, 2012
Edit
Jo Nathan

Ironically, I was wondering if you were doing exactly that when you calimed Hezy was innocent. But since you're spelling this strategy out for us, I'm inclined to believe that is not the case


And I pondered if I should spell it out. But I figured if someone as old and dumb as me could figure it out, other players must have also figured it out.

Also with only 3 of them left I find it very unlikely they are talking, especially since there was no kill last night.
If they know who each other is, they surely would have taken one of us out last night.


Vote for chiefsonny for Assistant Super Admin.
"I"m your man, I got a Plan"

If I get that damn piece of candy again, I'm going to ask to be Host Killed.(fedup)

November 6, 2012
Edit
chiefsonny
 

We have had only three people with X-ray Candy. Something seem a bit off? I think there are some more out there.

To the contrary: if we believe everyone who has claimed to have X-Ray Candy, we've had well over the amount of checks we would have had with just a normal Cop. 5 Candies in 3 days? Doesn't seem odd at all, maybe even a little too many. Also, this:

Also with only 3 of them left I find it very unlikely they are talking, especially since there was no kill last night.
If they know who each other is, they surely would have taken one of us out last night.

is a very good point.

And I pondered if I should spell it out. But I figured if someone as old and dumb as me could figure it out, other players must have also figured it out.

As a matter of fact, I spelled that very possibility out yesterday. :P

Anyway, if we believe everyone who claimed to have X-Ray Candy (that's a big if, IMO--I think it unlikely that all of them are innocent), we have this:

Innocent:

Feral (Essentially confirmed)
Jo Nathan (Ditto)
Hezekiah

X-Ray Candy Users:

Helius
White Thunder
Chiefsonny

That leaves:

white lancer
CtR Black
Zanic
Serpe
The Bandit

Out of that list, I know I'm innocent, and Bandit strikes me as more likely innocent than not. Zanic is a possibility but I still think it's unlikely given how willing he was to be checked by Redack on Day 1 (before we knew Red was a Skeleton). That would leave Serpe and CtR as people who haven't had any contact with X-Ray Candy and the mostly likely to be Skeletons IMO. Of course, I could be very wrong about Zanic or Bandit, and there's definitely no guarantee that Helius/Thunder/chief are innocent.

November 6, 2012
Edit
white lancer

From everything that was gathered, I guess CtR or Serpe is our best bet for lynching today. Will change if anymore info reveals a better choice.

November 6, 2012
Edit
Feral

Yeah it doesnt clear me. but that was the most suspicious thing I'd noticed. Since it was so suspicious, if i were skeleton there'd be no reason to point it out.

But the way I see it, if we're taking all the x-ray candies as truth, we might as well wait until next round when they'll be more x-ray candies received. chances are skeletons wont kill anyone again this night.

but i guess if you guys are lynch hungry and dont wanna wait, we can find out

November 6, 2012
Edit
CtR Black

chances are skeletons wont kill anyone again this night.

How do you figure? I don't see why the Skeletons wouldn't choose to target anyone in the night, and I'm not going to hope for a(nother?) 1-1-1 tie (especially since we now know everyone is active). Although it is nice that we have three players who have been checked and found innocent, so there's a chance they could split again, but I'm not counting on it.

I'm down for voting CtR--I think he's one of the best options at this point. Serpe is also an option, and the other choice as I see it is to vote chief in an attempt to prove hezy's innocence. CtR is probably the safest immediate choice while the payoffs for voting chief would probably be better long-term. I would feel bad voting chief out just for stepping up with information, though, so I'm going to cast my vote for CtR for now.

November 6, 2012
Edit
white lancer

I hope I don't regret this... but Xhin did give off suspicious vibes and CtR went after him two rounds in a row.

November 6, 2012
Edit
Jo Nathan

I think we should go for it. We have a big enough advantage that it shouldn't be a big blow to us if we lynch someone. Based on all the evidence that I've analyzed, this is the most likely candidate.

November 6, 2012
Edit
Zanic

Yeah, not crazy about the pick, but it's our best bet at this point.

November 6, 2012
Edit
White Thunder

All right, let's see who you are, CtR.

November 6, 2012
Edit
Jo Nathan

I guess it can't be helped...although CtR's going after Xhin gives him enough potential to be innocent in my mind, I'll go with the majority on this one.

November 6, 2012
Edit
Serpe

I guess it can't be helped...although CtR's going after Xhin gives him enough potential to be innocent in my mind, I'll go with the majority on this one.

November 6, 2012
Edit
Serpe

And we finally managed to get a round done early.

If anyone has an X-Ray Candy, I suggest checking chief or maybe one of Helius/Thunder. It would be nice to know that we actually can trust them.

November 6, 2012
Edit
white lancer

[qoute]I suggest checking chief or maybe one of Helius/Thunder.


I see you left your name off that list. Does that mean that you don't think anyone but you is telling the truth about being innocent.

A person that was really innocent would have put their name on the list just to show they did not have anything to hide.

CtR is probably the safest immediate choice while the payoffs for voting chief would probably be better long-term


And what exactly were you trying to imply with this statement.

If you guys get the X-ray candy and want to check me out. Go for it. I have nothing to hide.

Vote for Yeano for Mafia Over Ruler.

November 6, 2012
Edit
chiefsonny
 

Although I agree lancer should be checked eventually if at all possible, I think it's more beneficial at this point to verify someone who's making an X-Ray claim.

November 6, 2012
Edit
Jo Nathan

So to make this easy for the skeletons. here's a list of people to vote for in a row.

1 Feral
2 Hezy
3 White Lancer
4 Helius

If you both vote for them in the night round you're ensured kills, and it's not enough people to expose yourself. GL Skellys! heed my word please

November 6, 2012
Edit
CtR Black

keep to the order to keep it going

November 6, 2012
Edit
CtR Black

I see you left your name off that list. Does that mean that you don't think anyone but you is telling the truth about being innocent.

I did put my name on a similar list at the end of the last day round.

And what exactly were you trying to imply with this statement.

Voting you off would be beneficial to the Town because it would confirm hezy's innocence (assuming you are innocent and not a Skeleton). However, having you checked in the night would accomplish *almost* the same thing, which is why I think that's the optimal move. I'm willing to go through another round or two with suspicion on me if it means we have a stronger chance of winning (just don't vote me off until you have a chance to check me -_-). I will gladly volunteer to be checked whenever, especially if you're so suspicious of me that you plan to vote me out; I just think that chief would be a better selection as of right now.

Plus, the longer people think I'm suspicious, the less likely I am to be targeted by the Skeletons. I'm hoping I'll actually be able to survive a game for once. ;)

November 6, 2012
Edit
white lancer

Oh! And Feral/Jo are BOTH 100% confirmed innocent with CtR's admission of being a Skeleton. Only two left, so it's impossible for all three of Helius/Thunder/Feral to be guilty.

And Helius/Thunder aren't priority checks anymore. Check chief, or if you really want to check me.

November 6, 2012
Edit
white lancer

That was really simple I guess.

November 6, 2012
Edit
The Bandit

Well with suspicious Black post I guess this is not a bandwagon vote.

To be honest I had couple suspicions, but CtR was not one of them.

November 6, 2012
Edit
chiefsonny
 

"Well with suspicious Black post{/b]

Should have read

"Well with CtR Blacks post"


Vote for Yoda, with ears like that he has to know what;s going on in he world.

November 6, 2012
Edit
chiefsonny
 

I honestly cant tell if lancer's a skeleton or not. I dont understand his reasoning. kinda wanna scratch him off my list ;)

I put jo and feral on that list because you guys said they were innocent. I'm going off the same info as the rest of you, as are the other skellies

November 6, 2012
Edit
CtR Black

WARNING: Chief will be silenced next round. He failed to political advertise in his second to last reply.

Seems I'm not jumping on bandwagons this game. I'm driving the damn things! lol

With both Lancer and Chief so willing to be X-Rayed, and enough people who's x-ray claims can be believed, I would focus on interrogating Thunder and Serpe next. Espicially Serpe, who seems dismayed at the charge at CtR.

November 7, 2012
Edit
Feral

Well, there goes my doubt.

white lancer, I'm curious as to why you suddenly don't see Thunder or Helius as priority checks. As Redack demonstrated, we can't go with hearsay when it comes to people claiming x-ray candies. In that case, wouldn't it be more beneficial to wait for more probable innocents to get the same candy before any snap decisions? That way you can vet the 3 claimants and, by association, the people they're covering.

November 7, 2012
Edit
Serpe

And hardly dismayed, Feral. Only uncomfortable, like Jo was before his vote change. My previous decision(s) not to vote can attest to that. I just like being 100% sure of everything.

November 7, 2012
Edit
Serpe

Homer for sanitation commissioner!

Ugh, chief... way to fail. Thank you for (all but) confirming my innocence, though.

Sure wish Majora or Yeano would show up to end the round, and that the night goes quicker than previous go-rounds!

November 7, 2012
Edit
hezekiah

Well, we can use the extra time for a bonding session.



November 7, 2012
Edit
Serpe

white lancer, I'm curious as to why you suddenly don't see Thunder or Helius as priority checks. As Redack demonstrated, we can't go with hearsay when it comes to people claiming x-ray candies. In that case, wouldn't it be more beneficial to wait for more probable innocents to get the same candy before any snap decisions? That way you can vet the 3 claimants and, by association, the people they're covering.

The reason they're not priority anymore is because we already know for a fact that the people they're covering are innocent. Once CtR dies, there will only be 2 Skeletons left, and that means that there's no way Feral can be Guilty (he's got two people covering for him, so both of them would have to be Guilty for him to be Guilty). The same was true for Jo Nathan this round (because he essentially had 3 players vouching for him), but I didn't mention it because we weren't going to vote him out anyway and I didn't want there to be an obvious target for the Skeletons.

Since Feral's innocence is already verified, checking Helius or Thunder will only clear one person. Checking chief would clear two (both him and hezy). Note that when I say 'clear' here, I don't necessarily mean 100% confirmed innocent--hezy's the only one whose innocence can be confirmed beyond a shadow of a doubt tonight, and that only if someone checks chief and he comes up innocent.

That being said, Helius or Thunder (or even both) could still easily be Guilty. We just don't get as much mileage out of checking them tonight as we would have before.

November 7, 2012
Edit
white lancer

WARNING: Chief will be silenced next round. He failed to political advertise in his second to last reply.


And you just had to be the first person to rat me out.

They might have missed it.

Seems I'm not jumping on bandwagons this game. I'm driving the damn things! lol[/quote}

Well Yippie Fucking Ki Yay.


November 7, 2012
Edit
chiefsonny
 

Jo, I missed you on my list.

It seems like everyone has been busy so.... let me add my name to the list of votes.

November 7, 2012
Edit
Helius

Night 4

GUESS WHAT? YOU GUYS LYNCHED CTR BLACK! Turns out, he was a Skeleton. Oh man!

1. Redack - Skeleton
2. Trever Leingod - Trick-or-Treater
3. Jo Nathan
4. Frustro - Skeleton
5. Feral
6. White Thunder
7. white lancer
8. CtR Black - Skeleton
9. hezekiah
10. Zanic
11. Serpe
12. Helius
13. chiefsonny
14. Xhin - Skeleton
15. The Bandit

Ratio: 2-8

No new candies tonight! Be sure to get your trick or treat requests in + any night actions you have.

November 7, 2012
Edit
MajorasMask9

Reply to: main thread night 4 make it yourself

Username
Password