Engines Aether Legend of the Lunar Priest NIFE Roadmap
Shatterloop Game Projects Deprecated Starwright
Saepes Mundi Other Projects Blog  

Mafia

Moderated by: Speed Bike Pro

night 5

Posted February 3, 2015 by Female Alpha Wolf

”This is silly!”, shouted Feral. Everyone looked up from their respective seats to see what all the commotion was about. When he didn't explain himself further, white lancer decided to speak up. “Yeah... We definitely should have been to Las Vegas by now.”

Of course this was not what Feral was referring to. What Feral was referring to was that they had not checked the most obviously guilty person upon the train. The person who carried the name of the enemy within his own name: The Bandit.

How could they have been so dumb?!

Oh why was fate so cruel?

Would the Z Fighters ever defeat Cell?

With makeshift weapons in their hands, they marched towards The Bandit's room. Perhaps he was beginning to feel guilty from all of the blood on his hands and thus why he secluded himself within his quarters. Yet as they opened the door, it seemed as if someone had already beaten them to the lynch.

”A suicide?”, said Speed Bike Pro.

Reaching into his pocket, Jo Nathan pulled out his train ticket. ”No... A murder.” He lifted up the ticket so that all could read it. In big, bold letters was the word Passenger.

The Players Club:
1) Speed Bike Pro 
2) hezekiah  ?????
3) The Bandit  Passenger
4) Ghowilo 
5) EvilGuy0613 
6) white lancer 
7) Hindenburg  Jesse James
8) Lady Flare 
9) Lightvayne  Eccentric Mystery Novelist
10) CtR Black  Passenger
11) Xhin 
12) Pirate_Ninja  Passenger
13) Jo Nathan 
14) Kyon 
15) Chaos Incarnate  Butch Cassidy
16) Feral Wolf 
17) chiefsonny

Ratio:
8:3: 0

Roles:
Passengers x3, Watcher, Gambler, Doctor, Lovers
Bill Miner, Bandits x2


Round will end after 72 hours or after 6 votes for the same option.

There are 64 Replies

extensionEnable Post Pagination

wtf? the bandit deaded but not actually bandit ???

February 3, 2015
Edit
Speed Bike Pro
 



February 3, 2015
Edit
Ghowilo

You're welcome btw.

February 3, 2015
Edit
Ghowilo

:( I miss bandit

February 3, 2015
Edit
Xhin
Sky's the limit

Je suis bandit

February 3, 2015
Edit
Ghowilo

Just wanted to let yall know I made a 99 on my probability homework...

February 3, 2015
Edit
Ghowilo

I'm on my lunch break, so I'll try to make this quick and come back for more discussion later.

1. I was silenced last round, and I suspect that Lightvayne may have been silenced the round before (as I recall, it was either him, Xhin, or no one, and I don't believe Xhin claimed to be silenced). If the Watcher is still alive and they have anyone visiting me the night before, now would be a good time to speak up.

2. I buy Ghow's claim of being the Gambler...he seems to have hinted at it way back on Day 1 before anyone died, so unless that's quite a coincidence and hezy wound up being the Gambler, he's probably telling the truth. We don't have a counter-claim yet, at the very least.

3. Going off of that, if Ghow is innocent, I'm pretty suspicious of Jo Nathan. He's played this game quite passively except when he mentioned being suspicious of Ghowilo, so I'm quite wary of him. It's also noteworthy that Hindenburg's most substantial game-related post was trying to throw suspicion on Ghow--while this could be some misdirection on the Mafia's part, Ghow has wanted to vote off Hindy from the start, and I also think it's pretty easy to imagine the Mafia seeing Ghow as a pretty easy lynch target. I also noted chiefsonny, Speed, and (kinda) EvilGuy as saying that Ghowilo was suspicious, while Flare was against lynching him from early on. Not sure I'd go with that 100%, but the ones targeting Ghowilo seem to be a good place to start looking.

February 3, 2015
Edit
white lancer

I have yet to be silenced. Maybe I should be. :P

February 3, 2015
Edit
Xhin
Sky's the limit

LOGIC MAKES MY BRAIN HURT

February 3, 2015
Edit
Xhin
Sky's the limit

I don't recall finding Ghowilo suspicious. I only thought Speed's theory was interesting and didn't want to let my guard down just in case. (Happened before.) I did think he was acting strange but the reason behind that is cleared up for now.

Speaking of Jo Nathan, I wanted to mention that his and Lady Flare's bandwagon on Chaos stood out the most to me but I didn't look into too much because everyone kind of voted him off around the same time.

February 4, 2015
Edit
EvilGuy0613

No officer, it's how high are you, not hi how are you.

February 4, 2015
Edit
Ghowilo

I think we should look at the inactive members... oh wait that's everybody.

February 4, 2015
Edit
Ghowilo

He's played this game quite passively except when he mentioned being suspicious of Ghowilo, so I'm quite wary of him.


Meh. I have no excuse for this.

I wanted to mention that his and Lady Flare's bandwagon on Chaos stood out the most to me


I was actually away from the game during the time when all of the votes piled onto him. I imagine the same may have been the case for Lady Flare.

February 4, 2015
Edit
Jo Nathan

This just in, important information coming from... nobody.

February 4, 2015
Edit
Ghowilo

Ghowilo did it.

February 4, 2015
Edit
Feral Wolf
The Rogue Wolf

Well, we need to get some activiy. We are just short of 24 hours left.

I wound up being wrong about Hindy, so I am curious if I was wrong about Xhin...

But, between his unlikely inactivity, late vote for Chaos, and having no opinion on HIndy whatsoever, my best judgement is...

February 5, 2015
Edit
Feral Wolf
The Rogue Wolf

Here's to hoping hezekiah wasn't the watcher and they've just been inactive/silenced.

February 5, 2015
Edit
Xhin
Sky's the limit

Wait, who the Fuck is this is he even playing?

February 5, 2015
Edit
Ghowilo

Wow, I didn't even realize that the round was getting close to ending already...I believe the ratio should be 7-3 as well, correct?

I'm pretty much operating under the assumption that the Watcher is dead, at this point. They've had plenty of opportunities to ccome forward and they should be aware that the later they come forward, the less likely we are to actually believe their claim (I'm going to have a tough time believing it if they roleclaim if/when we get into a lynch-or-lose scenario, which could be as early as next round). They shouldn't really be worried about outing Town power roles either, since the Doctor is likely protecting themselves and we know that Ghow is probably the Gambler. The alternative is that they just don't have much that is useful or that they're somehow very confident they won't be a kill target, but even a little information could help us narrow down the Silencer.

And, well, I guess I'm going with this one. I was pretty torn between Jo and chief coming into this round...strangely, I thought chief was guilty because it felt like he got super defensive yesterday, but now Jo feels suspicious because it feels like he's trying too hard to not act defensive. That read makes me a little nervous, because it's entirely possible that I've already convinced myself Jo was guilty so I'm reading into things way too much...but this is my gut instinct so far so I'll vote here for now.

February 5, 2015
Edit
white lancer

Also, Duceus is Kyon.

February 5, 2015
Edit
white lancer

Let's kill Kyon, he's been too inactive yet hasn't been host killed to not be mafia.

February 5, 2015
Edit
Ghowilo

Actually scratch that, I just went back and looked at his posts, I'm willing to put off accusing him since it's close to the end of the round, will go back to my default.

February 5, 2015
Edit
Ghowilo

Geez this round went by fast...

Well for now unless somebody comes forward with something.

February 5, 2015
Edit
EvilGuy0613

You know, that last reply there makes me feel better about my vote. Why would EvilGuy purposely tie the vote with less then 7 hours remaining with no reasoning as to why unless he is protecting Jo by attempting to force a "no kill"?

I'm thiking Jo and EvilGuy are both Mafia and EG is trying to save his teammate.

February 5, 2015
Edit
Feral Wolf
The Rogue Wolf

I was thinking the same thing tbh, but this doesn't change my conviction about Xhin being mafia.

February 5, 2015
Edit
Ghowilo

Well, that didn't help much. Maybe this?

February 5, 2015
Edit
Ghowilo

I actually didn't realize I was tying the votes. I thought Jo Nathan only had one vote and choose to go with Xhin in the end. Wasn't trying to protect Jo Nathan especially being that I did find his bandwagon sort of suspicious...unless that post I made was bypassed. {:(}

February 5, 2015
Edit
EvilGuy0613

lol you can't freakin win in these things. Away from the site for the better part of a day, come back to see a bandwagon has already started against Chaos, decide to cast a vote and that's what people are dinging me for. If I hadn't voted for him at all, I'd be dinged for "reluctance to vote off a team member" or something. If you're going to vote for me, do it because of how relatively inactive I've been, not because I cast the third-to-last vote for Chaos.

February 5, 2015
Edit
Jo Nathan

I'm voting for you because I don't want a tie

February 5, 2015
Edit
Ghowilo

{y}

February 5, 2015
Edit
Jo Nathan

Ugh, all the second-guessing. I do think we need a lynch today, though, and Jo Nathan feels the most suspicious to me right now. I also think it's a bit deceptive to paint this as just people going after you for being late on the Chaos lunch--I think Feral was the only one who even mentioned that? My main reasons have been because of your targeting of Ghowilo and your relative passivity this game, combined with a general lack of evidence against most other players this game. I'm curious what your alternative would be, though, JN.

I generally try not to read too much into things like the EvilGuy tie vote, just because it seems super risky for the Mafia to act together openly like that unless they're in a good position to win the game, which doesn't yet seem to be the case. It is a little curious, however, in light of the fact that he mentioned finding JN a little suspicious, that he voted for Xhin with no reason given. Mind explaining why you find Xhin more suspicious than Jo here, EvilGuy?

Flare, Kyon, and chief have not spoken this round, but it seems unlikely that Kyon is the one silenced (if anyone). The other two both seem reasonable targets for the Silencer, as both would normally have spoken up this round. It's also possible that one of them dies tonight and the other is Mafia who will claim to have been silenced this round, if the Mafia are wanting to be that tricky.

February 5, 2015
Edit
white lancer

For what it's worth my gut and all the reading I've done leads me to believe that 3 of the 4 remaing Mafia are:

Xhin
Feral
Ghowilo


After Ghowilo claimed The Gambler and no one counter claimed.

Well if I was wrong about you then I may have to rethink my choices.

chiefsonny Changed his vote to No Kill


Well I have gone back and looked at things again and I still questions.

Why didn't our Doc protect The Bandit. You have to think that he would be considered a Mafia target with all the posting he was doing.

Now the Doc may be hezy. But I'm more inclined to think the Doc has just been protecting his self.

And we are now into day 5 and no report from the Watcher. Was the Watcher hezy. I'm more inclined to believe it is someone that's not active and was not used his power or doesn't want to put a target on his back.

Anyway, I'm vote I made last round before I changed it to No Kill after Ghowilo role claimed still stands.

February 5, 2015
Edit
chiefsonny
 

Well if I was wrong about you then I may have to rethink my choices.

chiefsonny Changed his vote to No Kill

Well I have gone back and looked at things again and I still questions


^^This should have all been in quotes in the above post.

February 5, 2015
Edit
chiefsonny
 

Okay, scratch that last paragraph--Flare is almost certainly silenced. But I really, really think we should avoid a tie here if at all possible, and it's making me nervous that the votes are just one apart. I'm legitimately curious about the target on Xhin's back--I have no particular reason to think that he's innocent, but no particular reason to think he's guilty either. Care to fill me in?

February 5, 2015
Edit
white lancer

So instead of a tie you'd lynch people that have been active instead of people that drop in make 1 line post and have only votes once in the game. Talk about keeping under the radar.

Duceus

And I wasn't the one that cast the first vote for Xhin, even though I do agree with it.

Care to fill me in?


Better yet. You tell me why I should'nt. I've read every post in this game 5 times. Time for someone else to do the leg work.

And while you're at it maybe someone can explain why last round we had 13 players alive and 12 that could vote and only 6 do. wtf.

February 5, 2015
Edit
chiefsonny
 

I'm very, very concerned and very suspicious that there haven't been any actual reasons given for voting for Xhin. I've given you my reasons for voting for Jo, and you've given nothing for voting for Xhin. This looks so much like a Mafia attempt to tie the vote to me now.

February 5, 2015
Edit
white lancer

FUCK YEAH KILL XHIN!

February 5, 2015
Edit
Ghowilo

Sigh...

If Xhin is innocent, EvilGuy and Chief will have a LOT of explaining to do. Chief, especially, will come off looking horrible.

February 5, 2015
Edit
Feral Wolf
The Rogue Wolf

This looks so much like a Mafia attempt to tie the vote to me now.


Well you think what you want. But here's the bottom line:

The Mafia knows who they are.

For us it's just a guessing game. We hope when we vote we're right but in a game where very few people are saying anything, we have to go with our gut and what little things we can pick up.

February 5, 2015
Edit
chiefsonny
 

Chief, especially, will come off looking horrible


You're right. And all because I had the balls to take a guess.
But nothing will be said about the people that jumped on the bandwagon with no explanation why.

And I will repeat myself. Here we are 3 hours away from the end of the game and only 6 out of 11 have voted.

February 5, 2015
Edit
chiefsonny
 

It's like a wish come true.

February 5, 2015
Edit
Ghowilo

Hell, we might as well all just vote No Kill and then we can all have a feel good feeling.

February 5, 2015
Edit
chiefsonny
 

No. XHIN DIESSSSSSSS

February 5, 2015
Edit
Ghowilo

But nothing will be said about the people that jumped on the bandwagon with no explanation why.


What bandwagon? The one you started by tagging along with the obviously untrustworthy Gambler, Ghow? And YOU are the one refusing to give a reason for your vote. A "guess" as you put it is a dumb reason to cast a vote tying the tally. I'm convinced you know something you are not saying.

I'd still rather lynch Jo, but I'd rather take out Xhin then nobody at all, and I am not willing to risk the Mafia forcing a last minute tie.

Also, what makes you say that this lynch will end the game? That's rather bold assumption(unless it was a typo).

February 5, 2015
Edit
Feral Wolf
The Rogue Wolf

Well taking a look at how Xhin's been voting all over the place has made me kind of suspicious of him. That and I'm kind of putting my faith in the dead journalist since he was right on Hindenburg.

There isn't really much to go on so I'm just going with who I thinks stands out the most.

February 5, 2015
Edit
EvilGuy0613

The Journalist said nothing indicating Xhin as being guilty.

Chapter 2: Silence of the lamb

The next suspect on the list; Xhin, after all he was the owner of the train, why has he not been able to do anything about this robbery? How does the owner of this train not have the keys to access the engine room? Further investigation shows that Xhin was in massive debt . The train was also carrying valuable cargo in one of the compartments. Was he in on it?

PN, the passenger that had the crap scared out of him the day before, was found dead. Poor guy didn't even have a chance. Did he somehow find out that someone, maybe Xhin was part of this robbery?


A bunch of worthless speculation. He never even makes it clear if he visited Xhin or Hindy that night, but as he make the joke about Hindy's bladder and Hindy wound up Guilty, it's safe to say Vayne watched Hindy both nights, and never watched Xhin at all, just dumbly making up junk about someone he was never near.

February 5, 2015
Edit
Feral Wolf
The Rogue Wolf

Also, what makes you say that this lynch will end the game? That's rather bold assumption(unless it was a typo).


And I will repeat myself. Here we are 3 hours away from the end of the game and only 6 out of 11 have voted.


If you're talking about this ^^^.
It was a typo and there is no editing. So for those who could not figure out on their own what I was trying to say:

End of game should have said. end of round.

OMG {fp}

February 5, 2015
Edit
chiefsonny
 

...well, I guess this is where I cross my fingers and just hope that my reads are completely wrong.

If Xhin is innocent, EvilGuy and Chief will have a LOT of explaining to do. Chief, especially, will come off looking horrible.

If Xhin is innocent, I'm fairly confident that those two and Jo will be Guilty. Unfortunately, I think the rest of the Town's inactivity + the Silencer effectively removing one of us from the game each round will seal the game. The lynch and the Nightkill would bring us to 5-3 (unless the Doctor managed to block the kill), and they would just have to Silence any of us and we'd be dependent on Kyon showing up to cast a vote. If Xhin is guilty, than chief and EvilGuy are probably innocent, though it wouldn't say anything about Jo either way.

But nothing will be said about the people that jumped on the bandwagon with no explanation why.

Ironically, this applies to you just as much. Feral's provided just as much explanation for voting Xhin as you have. And considering you were convinced Ghowilo was Guilty last round and that Hindenburg was Innocent a couple of rounds before, forgive me if I don't trust your gut this game (which is a big reason I find you so suspicious this game--usually your gut instincts are much better).

Well taking a look at how Xhin's been voting all over the place has made me kind of suspicious of him. That and I'm kind of putting my faith in the dead journalist since he was right on Hindenburg.

Not that it matters, but the Journalist lied about Hindenburg. Even if they visited Hindenburg, they wouldn't have seen him leave since Hindenburg was the Godfather. Also, as Feral pointed out, the Journalist really said nothing about Xhin.

February 5, 2015
Edit
white lancer

My "to kill" list

Xhin (Yay!!!)
Feral
Kyon

February 6, 2015
Edit
Ghowilo

Noooooooo guys I'm the doctor

February 6, 2015
Edit
Xhin
Sky's the limit

Also wtf, how does this game go from "everyone is inactive" to "DIE XHIN DIE" in like half a day?

February 6, 2015
Edit
Xhin
Sky's the limit

We got 5 mins left. If ANYBODY is willing to throw a vote on Jo, I will change mine. ANYBODY?

February 6, 2015
Edit
Feral Wolf
The Rogue Wolf

Fuck. Can't chance killing the Doc.

February 6, 2015
Edit
Feral Wolf
The Rogue Wolf

Flare, Kyon, you are both here! COME ON!!!

February 6, 2015
Edit
Feral Wolf
The Rogue Wolf

{fp}{fp}{fp}

February 6, 2015
Edit
white lancer

Fuck. We got a day 4 no-kill.

Thanks very much, all you inactive people!

February 6, 2015
Edit
Feral Wolf
The Rogue Wolf

........

February 6, 2015
Edit
EvilGuy0613

Noooooooo guys I'm the doctor


Why didn't you come out and say that and save everyone a lot of worries on who to vote for. You could after all save your self as it looks like you've been doing.

Why didn't you protect The Bandit. You had to know he stood a good chance of being night killed?

February 6, 2015
Edit
chiefsonny
 

Nice try, but 10 mins to late. Round ended with the tie.

Suffice to say, I am one of the Lovers, and my partner and I pretty much have this figured out.

Xhin- I highly suggest you protect yourself. The Mafia can come after me, but my partner already knows who to use our kill on if I die tonight, and vice versa if they are killed. By targeting me, they would take a major chance at losing one of their own in the crossfire. If either of us do use the kill tomorrow, it will also serve to prove our innocence.

February 6, 2015
Edit
Feral Wolf
The Rogue Wolf

Suffice to say, I am one of the Lovers


The Mafia can come after me, but my partner already knows who to use our kill on if I die tonight,


(suprised)
(no)

Wow that took alot of balls(smirk)

February 6, 2015
Edit
chiefsonny
 

lol wtf this is like one of the weirdest rounds in Mafia I've seen in a while.

February 6, 2015
Edit
Jo Nathan

Seriously speaking, I am deeply sorry about this round, I spent too much time working and wasting time with people irl who probably don't even deserve my attention to commit the necessary attention to this. BUT I AM COMING BACK WITH A VENGEANCE TOMORROW BABY YEHAW SADDLE UP

February 6, 2015
Edit
Speed Bike Pro
 

It'll be night time tomorrow

February 6, 2015
Edit
Ghowilo

(Sorry for the late reply. I had a long day and passed out the second I got home after almost passing out while driving home!)

The passengers kept going back and forth as they were completely split down the middle as to who to vote for. It almost seemed as if our passengers were stuck within an old Looney Tunes movie.

But then, the clock struck. The loud gongs silenced the passengers as they had realized that it was now time for bed- and they had not found anyone guilty.

Would this be a very bad mistake?!

The Players Club:
1) Speed Bike Pro 
2) hezekiah  ?????
3) The Bandit  Passenger
4) Ghowilo 
5) EvilGuy0613 
6) white lancer 
7) Hindenburg  Jesse James
8) Lady Flare 
9) Lightvayne  Eccentric Mystery Novelist
10) CtR Black  Passenger
11) Xhin 
12) Pirate_Ninja  Passenger
13) Jo Nathan 
14) Kyon 
15) Chaos Incarnate  Butch Cassidy
16) Feral Wolf 
17) chiefsonny

Ratio:
8:3: 0

Roles:
Passengers x3, Watcher, Gambler, Doctor, Lovers
Bill Miner, Bandits x2


Round will end after 24 hours or after all night action are completed.

February 6, 2015
Edit
Female Alpha Wolf

This thread is locked