Awww kind of knew Moonray wasn't guilty. Wasn't so sure about Hindenburg though.




Well at the very least things are kind of cleared up now. I still believe Lightvanye might be guilty. As for the other remaining foe...any ideas?

PN & Hezy, come forward with the gifts you received, whether you have used them, any results you garnered, and why or why not you have chose to use your gift.

Damn, I was almost positive Hindy of one of the bad guys. :<

I would like to see what we get out of PN and Hez before I jump to any conclusions, we are getting a bit scarce with townfolk :<

ya sure

I received the Box of Cookies, but have unfortunately been an utter failure of a Doctor :\

I got them on Night 2 (or the morning of Day 3, I guess) and spent the first use protecting hezekiah on Night 4. He picked up a few votes during the day round, but then claimed to have a Santa gift and the round ended with Chaos being lynched. Since the Elf could've called him out if that was untrue, I figured he did indeed have a gift and would make for a likely target if not mafia.

and then I used my second save attempt last night - according to Elf-Roxas, he himself had the Gingerbread Badge and had given Speed the Bottle of Strong Spirits the night he was killed. Since I had the Box of Cookies, that left the Angel and Reindeer Suit unaccounted for. Roxas never disputed hezekiah's claim of getting a gift and he said Moonray was the other recipient...and since that ill-fated lynch went through yesterday, I figured that hez must have the Angel. Since numbers are getting tight and it seemed like he was safe already, I tried protecting myself.

So what exactly are we waiting for now?

Well if nobody has any objections I'm going to go head and throw my vote in a few hours or so.

Obviously hez hasn't been targeted or he would have been used up already. So three of us are accounted for.

That leaves EG, Lightvayne and CtR as Mafia

Just because they have gifts does not mean they could use them. They could both be mafia for all we know. PN could be lying about her doctors thing. So could Hezy. If he is telling the truth and a townie, then if we lynched him he'd survive it.

I don't think this game is that cut and clear.

Probably shouldn't leave hezekiah off the hook all together but for now I trust that he's not mafia. I'd wait to see what he has to say before considering anything though.

Well..I'm surprised I'm still being considered Mafia despite how things played out. By now I thought it might have been clear that I'm town sided...


Well it's been longer then a few hours so.....yeah

Busy (and long) day involving a 7+ hour drive, but the conclusion that I got the angel candy was accurate. See y'all in the morning.

Why the vote for Lightvayne?

There's only one way we can be sure that hezekiah received the angel: we vote for him. If he doesn't die, he's town sided. If he does, he's Mafia. Really, we're at the who damned if you do, damned if you don't stage.

I'll agree with Roxas, though it feels a bit wasteful to waste a lynch like that nor do I think that we have enough turns to play around with that idea, then again, I'm not really sure how the angel works so...

As I stated before, I am a snowman, but I have no way of proving it unfortunatly. I also have not received any gifts. (not feeling very loved at the moment :< )

This game has been played very well, the only thing I am sure of is Roxas being the Elf, everyonee else still seems like a suspect in my book. With that in mind, I'll trust Roxas' instinct on this one and also vote for hez, unless a better plan comes along.

ok at least that's confirmed then, ty hez

at 4-2 a mislynch will kill us, but a No Kill is still safe. Strictly speaking, it does sound like "testing" the Angel is our safest bet - it only saves innocent players, so we'd either end up lynching a mafia member or effectively voting NK. Worst-case scenario, we have slightly better odds tomorrow.

This is a terrible idea. The mafia has access to an additional night kill thanks to the Giant Candle, which would be enough to knot it at 2-2 and give the win to the mafia.

We can't actually know at this point if the Giant Candle is still in play, but the last Grinch definitely has a gift they'll be able to use tonight.

I think the mafia are CtR and Light.

oh shit the candle

Damn it, I didn't know what time the round was ending...

Well, I suppose you can just let mafia do the kill and end it once the action is sent since we're going to lose anyways.

May as well just let it play out, there's always the chance of somebody not having been honest about their role or actions.

Terrible move there, PN... I thought I could trust you.