Oooo, fun!

I got lucky twice. Apprentice last game and now this.

This should be sweet. Although our long term survival is dubious.

I'm not saying that if I die its Castrael, but its Castrael

Typically the better players don't like killing off the other better players on Night1. Specifically, I think I recall Majora and Apollo both saying they didn't approve of that. Considering who got killed last night, I would be slightly less likely to consider them as guilty suspects for right now.

Sounds about right. Chief and you took me out last game... was there anyone else he helped get lynched?

Roxas.

Maybe Apollo is just on my mind because of my previous comment, but the Journalist article just sounds like her to me.

I agree with you on the journalist, but if it means an early Mafia kill I'm willing to take the risk while the ratio is in our favor.

BRING BACK DOOKU

I'm going to talk to myself a lot, because I have my own thread and why not.

Trying to decide if I want to role reveal or not. I think my horrible misread of the Journalist will keep me safe from any mafia shenanigans for a while, and my role itself isn't worth going after anyway, so there isn't much downside to it. Revealing my role and what Dooku said would give some credence to the idea that we should lynch Cas, and I'm thinking it's probably the best choice. Or at least a perfectly viable one. I can definitely see CtR panicking and asking the mafia thread who he should kill, and Cas, being the only one around, suggesting that he offs Dooku.

If my other reads are right (which there certainly is no guarantee of), then I don't think Apollo or Majora are mafia right now, and if they're not, then killing them during the day when they can't get Doctored or Journalisted would be much more beneficial than going after Dooku, who is much less likely to receive those power role blessings IMO. It was just not the best choice the Marksman could have made.

Probably my biggest mistake in this game though is assuming that everyone thinks like I do. Just because I've thought of the fact that Apollo is likely to be watched by the Journalist or protected by the Doctor doesn't mean the mafia did. Sometimes the other players notice things that I don't notice and come to better decisions, and sometimes they don't notice the things I've noticed. And, again, Apollo and Majora and any other better day kill out there could just be mafia themselves, and Dooku actually was the most optimal Marksman kill and that's why he was offed.

The choice may be made for me. I have a feeling people are thinking that I should be lynched, given that I've defended a mafia player and tried to vote off someone with just a "Goodbye" message, which is pretty unlike me. I'm not trusting my judgment too much right now, so regardless of what I do, I'll definitely wait and see if the other players have any better ideas before giving away my role.