Engines Aether Legend of the Lunar Priest NIFE Roadmap
Shatterloop Game Projects Deprecated Starwright
Saepes Mundi Other Projects Blog  

Mafia

Moderated by: Speed Bike Pro

star wars republic game 1 day 3 a strange turn of events

Posted June 3, 2012 by Trever Leingod

Day 2 dawned with unfortunate news....

Last night, CtR Black’s chambers went up in flames. Come morning, they found him inside pretty charred… from the autopsy report, he was a Jedi Knight.

Feral was heard screaming in his chambers last night, but by the time someone got to his chambers to check on him, nobody was even in them, mysteriously enough… who knows what happened to him.

Xhin --- Revealed himself as Yoda
chiefsonny
DragonintheShadow
Redack
Count Dooku
hezekiah
Shadowwalked
Feral - Force Phantom turned Obi-Wan
Black Yoshi
Helius
White Thunder
Teddy-Son
`Roxas` - Revealed himself as Obi-Wan
white lancer
CtR Black - Jedi Knight
MajorasMask9 - NOT the Voodoo Lady (LOL)
#85
Zanic
The Bandit

Due to prior concerns, I will not be posting advice anywhere from now on. I will only comment now and then (no advice in said comments), and directly answering questions. My aim is to help the players enjoy themselves and know the game, but which side wins is no concern to me. When the game ends, you are encouraged to comment/complain on my role as Host so I may further improve my role in the next game I Host.

I will allow up to 72 hours for the Day Round. The minimum time for this Day Round will be a requirement of at least 10 votes of the same choice (7 will be 1/3 of said votes), as well as at least 24 hours from the time this message is posted.

GO!

There are 145 Replies

extensionEnable Post Pagination

woo first post

June 3, 2012
Edit
Xhin
Sky's the limit

Good morning, my little green friend {:P}

June 3, 2012
Edit
Trever Leingod

Reply to this post I am doing. On the rest of the round I am waiting so voting I can be doing.

June 3, 2012
Edit
Xhin
Sky's the limit

Last night, we checked Teddy-Son and Count Dooku. They were both innocent.

Still nothing to go off of this game, which stinks for all kinds of reasons.

June 3, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

Reply to this post I am doing. On the rest of the round I am waiting so voting I can be doing.

It should say:

"Replying to this post, I am. On the rest of the votes for this round, I am waiting." {:P}

June 3, 2012
Edit
Trever Leingod

Also, Trevor, 6 votes constitutes the 1/3 rule.

June 3, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

Because 17 players are left alive.

June 3, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

don't care

June 3, 2012
Edit
The Bandit

Ah my bad, I copied that over... I hate this no-edit thing. Right you are, Roxas.

Also, note that the above tally showing the roles of Xhin, Roxas and Feral are all according to claims of the respective people themselves. The only role I myself can confirm as Host is CtR Black, who was a Jedi Knight (aka normal townie).

June 3, 2012
Edit
Trever Leingod

I don't like that you're apparently confirming all of our town roles just because the person revealed them. You're effectively giving the Sith and easy time for converting because all they need to do is let someone claim a role and then wait for you to confirm it in the roster :/

Anyway, I'll hold my vote until more discussion has occurred seeing as the cops didn't find anything last night round. Also remember my activity won't be what it normally is due to my being in America {:)}

June 3, 2012
Edit
Redack

Ignore my moaning above in that case {:P}

June 3, 2012
Edit
Redack

Though I still think for the next game you should just not do it...

June 3, 2012
Edit
Redack

This is my first time ever being involved in the Mafia game, let alone being Host... hence why I am willing to take comments/complaints so I won't make the same mistakes next game.

June 3, 2012
Edit
Trever Leingod

I think it's fine as long as you keep it consistent. Even though it's insanely unlikely, Feral and Roxas could be Sith playing us and you've basically confirmed Feral's role.

but whatever I don't think it matters, anyone can read the thread and see who is who. You listing who has revealed themselves just makes it easier for those short on time.

June 3, 2012
Edit
The Bandit

As I said, I cannot confirm any role but CtR Black. As Bandit said above, I included the claims for convenience of the players.

June 3, 2012
Edit
Trever Leingod

Getting back on topic, I think it's time we started just randomly voting for someone. As Lancer has pointed out, DL/spy is just too deadly, and we're likely losing a ton of townies. It's going to suck if we choose our Medic Droid, but, really, he's the only one that isn't expendable until we kill the spy.

I'm voting Black Yoshi. He hasn't been active in the threads, the medic droid probably has been active, so hopefully it isn't him.

June 3, 2012
Edit
The Bandit

Well, I'll take a shot in the dark.

June 3, 2012
Edit
Zanic

This far into the game and I don't really have a lead. Bandit is playing a little oddly but that might just be his personality.

June 3, 2012
Edit
#85

Not him.

June 3, 2012
Edit
Zanic

Ok. Forget voting randomly.

June 3, 2012
Edit
Zanic

Okay, so I'm not sure why Feral didn't have any sort of protection whatsoever last night, but it's a little late to complain about that now...although the thought strikes me that there's a possibility the Medical Droid was taken by the Dark Lord. Yoda NEEDS to protect Roxas from now on, and the Medical Droid (if he's still on our side) NEEDS to protect Xhin.

I expect the Mafia is up to 6, and you can add Jango Fett to that count as well to make it 7 bad guys. They probably have a Silencer and General Grievous by this point, which means we can't wait too long before we start making aggressive moves. Problem is, I'm not at all sure who to target.

June 3, 2012
Edit
white lancer

Well, I am probably a little odd, but other than waiting for Roxas and Feral to come up with something I don't know what else to do. And that can't be the best strategy if they're gaining a Sith each night.

June 3, 2012
Edit
The Bandit

Or I guess just Roxas. I somehow missed that feral was dead this whole time idk.

June 3, 2012
Edit
The Bandit

Losing Feral was a devastating blow to our ranks. {:/} So long as Xhin protects me from being converted, we will do fine. I don't think that the Sith have taken in the MD yet, so he can protect Xhin and one other person of his choosing.

For now, I shall random vote.

June 3, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

Yoda NEEDS to protect Roxas from now on, and the Medical Droid (if he's still on our side) NEEDS to protect Xhin.

I completely agree. If we keep Roxas defended, and keep Xhin from being killed, then hopefully he'll start getting lucky and find us some guilty verdicts.

In the mean time I'll go with whatever the rest of you guys feel is a good choice. Just remember we can't divide our votes or we'll risk the executioner role using his power.

June 3, 2012
Edit
Redack

I'm looking over those of us that remain, and I'm thinking of who to check. Not sure yet. I am open to suggestions from my fellow Jedi.

June 3, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

Damn we are in a situation were we almost have to take a gamble but have to leads...Roxas needs to stay protected, even at the cost of Xhin's life because if Roxas gets taken then we wont be able to identify any Sith.

June 3, 2012
Edit
#85

have no leads, not have to leads

June 3, 2012
Edit
#85

It does seem strange that the medical droid didn't protect Feral. That, along with losing Feral of course, does not bode well for us. I think it best if we find who we think is most likely and vote them off- we need something that will swing the odds back in our favor. I have no idea who we should go after, though.

June 3, 2012
Edit
White Thunder

We should still have the MD #85, so we're fine. Xhin should protect Roxas, MD should protect himself and Xhin.

I don't know how it usually works, but if I was a Sith I would not post as much in fear of saying something stupid and revealing myself. So I would check those guys. Then, of course, there's always Redack, who is just too evil to be a Jedi.

It does seem strange that the medical droid didn't protect Feral.

That is easily explained. Xhin obviously protected Roxas, and the MD used one of his protects on Xhin. He must have used the other one on Roxas as well, leaving Feral exposed. Still, even then it's VERY odd that the Sith would risk going after Feral when they expect him to be protected. I think Lancer may be right about the MD. :(

June 3, 2012
Edit
The Bandit

I am open to suggestions from my fellow Jedi.

The Bandit
Helius
Zanic


Trever never answered #85 question as to how he assigned roles for the game. Was it random like Yeano does in Mafia or did he assign them.

June 3, 2012
Edit
chiefsonny
 

We'll just have to see how this plays out today.

June 3, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

Oh and I hate to see you waste one of your investigations, but check me out first so we can put that behind us.

June 3, 2012
Edit
chiefsonny
 

@Bandit

Roxas is more than welcome to investigate me. I have nothing to hide. Though I agree about me being too evil, and one of these days I'll finally get the be the bad guy in this game.

@Chief

I asked Trever that on MSN Alfred 85 asked it, he confirmed it is random.

June 3, 2012
Edit
Redack

After*

Auto correct sucks :/

June 3, 2012
Edit
Redack

We can not kill Xhin. If he is Yoda then what will happen to Jedi when he goes?

June 3, 2012
Edit
Teddy-Son

Although there is of course a chance MD is compromised, that would mean the Sith got really lucky. I think its a slightly better chance he just made a bad play and protected the wrong people. All possibilities are open at this point, though.

I also agree with Bandit, either a lot of people are busy or a lot of people are playing under the radar.

June 3, 2012
Edit
#85

I asked Trever that on MSN Alfred 85 asked it, he confirmed it is random.

Thanks.

Why are you here in the US, when the UK is celebrating the Queen's 60 years on the throne.
Shame on you.{:P}

June 3, 2012
Edit
chiefsonny
 

Agree with Bandit and Zanic, I am.

June 3, 2012
Edit
Xhin
Sky's the limit

Even though it's insanely unlikely, Feral and Roxas could be Sith playing us and you've basically confirmed Feral's role.

It's actually pretty likely. The first people the Sith would try to recruit would be the cops, and since Feral died last night, we can pretty much figure out that the paramedic got recruited too.

At this point, therefore, it seems like a bad idea to trust the cops.

June 3, 2012
Edit
Xhin
Sky's the limit

Losing Feral was a devastating blow to our ranks.

Something about the way this sentence is worded makes my intuition go "ROXAS IS A SITH NOW RED ALERT RED ALERT"

June 3, 2012
Edit
Xhin
Sky's the limit

I am open to suggestions from my fellow Jedi.

This sentence too. There's a little too much emphasis on "my fellow Jedi", "our ranks", etc, as though Roxas was trying to affirm that he's still a part of the Jedi. In previous rounds, he didn't use any of that kind of language. He'd say "we", but he wouldn't use phrases like "my fellow Jedi" or "our ranks".

June 3, 2012
Edit
Xhin
Sky's the limit

If you protected Roxas, Xhin, then he is immune to conversions. If you protected Feral, then he would not be dead. Who did you protect?

June 3, 2012
Edit
The Bandit

If you protected Roxas, Xhin, then he is immune to conversions. If you protected Feral, then he would not be dead. Who did you protect?

Presumably Xhin protected himself and left the medical droid to protect the cops. Clearly Feral was unprotected, meaning that IF we still have a medical droid he probably protected Xhin and Roxas.

So if Xhin didn't protect Roxas, it is possible that Roxas was converted. However, with only one cop again I'm not really willing to lynch our only investigator until they lead us wrong.

I'd say lynch one of the less active, quiet people and hope to find someone Sith-aligned trying to fly under the radar.

June 3, 2012
Edit
Count Dooku

Currently, I have no clue on who could be Sith. But Roxas said he a cop, Trever confirmed it. He even keeps saying who is innocent and guilty. On the other hand why would he reveal so early?

I believe in Roxas for now and I don't plan on changing my mind anytime soon. Just a thought though.

June 3, 2012
Edit
Teddy-Son

Well Xhin I hope thats an incorrect theory because that means both the cop AND the MD are compromised. I dont see why the MD would leave BOTH cops vulnerable because that would be a double hit.

June 3, 2012
Edit
#85

I don't understand why Xhin would protect himself. I thought we had already talked about this.

June 3, 2012
Edit
The Bandit

By mentioning Bandit, Helius and me in your post chief, does that mean we are your suspicions?

June 3, 2012
Edit
Zanic

I'm at work so I can't respond all the time (this is consistent with other games) but yeah, I find it a little odd Feral died.

I would caution that we are careful because we don't want to kill someone on our side.

June 3, 2012
Edit
Helius

Oh god, so confusing. I know I'm having a lot of trouble keeping these "Star Wars Roles" straight in my head.

I missed day 1 due to being at work, and was out of town with no internet access from Friday morning until about half an hour ago. Very tired (middle and high schoolers are a lot of work). And this whole Dark Lord thing is quite odd...

June 3, 2012
Edit
hezekiah

Currently, I have no clue on who could be Sith. But Roxas said he a cop, Trever confirmed it. He even keeps saying who is innocent and guilty. On the other hand why would he reveal so early?

If I had a guilty verdict, I'd give it JUST as I did Day One. And I revealed myself "so early" last game and look how that went.

I can say with confidence that I was not converted in the Night. I am still Obi-Wan.

June 3, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

Currently, I have no clue on who could be Sith. But Roxas said he a cop, Trever confirmed it. He even keeps saying who is innocent and guilty. On the other hand why would he reveal so early?

I confirmed nothing, still. Roxas COULD be lying about his role, as could Xhin, and Feral himself could have been doing the same. The roles next to the names on the rosters is according to the claims they made. Whether or not anyone believes them in their own call.

Oh god, so confusing. I know I'm having a lot of trouble keeping these "Star Wars Roles" straight in my head.

Just for the sake of the non-Star Wars savvy, I am going to make a little guide... be right back.

June 3, 2012
Edit
Trever Leingod

The only person that we can trust 100% at this point is Xhin, since he's the one who is immune to conversion. It's possible that Roxas was taken last night as well especially since Xhin apparently didn't protect him, and if that's the case the MD not protecting Feral was a HUGE mistake (unless he, too, has been converted) because we may have gone from two Obi-Wans to one. Hopefully that's not the case and we can trust Roxas, but we have to take into account the possibility.

Shadowwalked and Majora are both very quiet this game, which I find interesting. It's more interesting in Majora's case since Shadow tends to lie low in early rounds of the game if he's not a special role of some kind.

June 3, 2012
Edit
white lancer

By mentioning Bandit, Helius and me in your post chief, does that mean we are your suspicions?

Nope. At this point I don't know who's who except for for Feral and CtR Black.

He asked for names, I gave him some including my self.
Gotta start somewhere.
But anyone that is innocent should welcome a investigation by the Cop, whoever that may be.

June 3, 2012
Edit
chiefsonny
 

For your reference, hezekiah and chief... I'll put this in the Star Wars document above too so you always can see it. Remind me to make one for the next round too.

“Townie Roles”

Jedi Knight = Townie

Obi-Wan Kenobi = Cop

Yoda = Doctor + Dark Lord warding ability

Mace Windu = Paranoid Gun Owner

Anakin Skywalker = Vigilant

Padme/Bail Organa = Governor

Clone Arsonist = Arsonist

Medical Droid = Paramedic

Jedi Outcast = The Outsider

“Mob Roles”

Droid Trooper = Mafioso

Dark Lord = Godfather + Assassin (except he converts rather than kills)

Dark Sorcerer = Silencer

General Grievous = Thug

Dooku/Ventress = The Executioner

Droid Spy = Mafia Investigator

Sith Probe Droid = The Janitor

June 3, 2012
Edit
Trever Leingod

Oh yeah....

Third party roles

Force Ghost = Ghoul

Jango Fett = Lunatic

June 3, 2012
Edit
Trever Leingod

Guys ive been extremely busy and some of the rules this time have been damn confusing (like i just found out that the yoda can keep people from being converted) not to mention the role names are completely different.

Id like to petition that i be host killed, provided that someone takes over the cop role.

June 3, 2012
Edit
Xhin
Sky's the limit

No way Xhin, it will for sure be over for the Jedi if you do. You are the only guarantee (although for now I give roxas the benefit of the doubt)

What you should do if you want out is protect roxas, and sith will probably take you out. This is tricky though because roxas may or may not be compromised. But if he isn't, he has to be a huge target, as he is deep into the checks.

June 3, 2012
Edit
#85

Why would you want to be host-killed, Xhin? Just because you don't have enough time to figure out the roles? Because we're royally screwed if you leave the game now.

Also, I think I may have just noticed something. It's not incredibly helpful, but I did note that Trever said he couldn't confirm Feral's role, even though he's dead. That means we can assume that one of the players converted by the Dark Lord assumed the Sith Probe Droid/Janitor role and hid Feral's body, so Feral was likely a Sith kill (while CtR was probably Jango Fett or maybe the Arsonist).

June 3, 2012
Edit
white lancer

Considering I just posted a helpful new guide, I would reconsider, Xhin. If you are Yoda as you claim, you dying off with the Jedi feeling very anxious as they are does leave them in a difficult place.

June 3, 2012
Edit
Trever Leingod

Ok Chief. I was just wondering if somehow you knew that us three were jedi or if you suspected us.

June 3, 2012
Edit
Zanic

Damn, where's Han Solo and his dog, what's his name, Chewbacca when you need them?

June 3, 2012
Edit
chiefsonny
 

Damn, where's Han Solo and his dog, what's his name, Chewbacca when you need them?

In the next game, Chief {:P}

June 3, 2012
Edit
Trever Leingod

Okay I get it now.

June 3, 2012
Edit
Teddy-Son

Dooku, why would you want to kill me? I may not be active, but killing me doesn't do the town...err, Republic any good; I'm just a Jedi, whatever that is. I assume that's the equivalent of a Townie?

Anyway, enough making an ASS out of U and ME...going with what Bandit said.

June 3, 2012
Edit
Black Yoshi

If Xhin protected himself, then it's very likely Roxas has been converted. If I was the Sith I would have tried to convert one of the cops and killed the other one. If Xhin protected himself, that leaves both cops vulnerable. I don't think the MD has been taken, however. Like I said, that could just be bad luck (with the MD protecting Xhin and Roxas).

I still say we kill a random. : / Sitting on our ass waiting for all of us to be converted is not going to win this for us, especially if our cop is converted. Even if we trust Roxas 100%, we can't even be sure that his results are good because of the DL and Outcast. It doesn't have to be Black Yoshi, so long as it's not Xhin, Roxas, Teddy, Dooku or me I'll vote for anyone.

June 3, 2012
Edit
The Bandit

Even with me investigating people, I'm don't agree with letting another day pass that I can be converted.

June 3, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

I don't agree**

June 3, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

.

June 3, 2012
Edit
hezekiah

For the record the Fetts (Jango and Bolba) aren't really lunitics. They just work for who ever pays the most.

For some reason I haven't trusted this guy since well before the start of the game. {:3}

June 3, 2012
Edit
DragonintheShadow

His name is Boba Fett. And I agree. We should lynch someone. I'm just not sure that lynching someone that showed up as innocent would help. Even with the DL, I think it would be better to lynch someone who hasn't been investigated. Because I feel like we'd have a better chance of hitting a sith if we didn't go for someone who showed as innocent. We can't afford to lose a jedi.

June 4, 2012
Edit
Zanic

I put the Fetts in that position more because they get paid to do whatever. And also because it was the most fitting role I could give them.

June 4, 2012
Edit
Trever Leingod

Maybe we should vote for someone. it is the third round and only two people died so far. If no no goes crazy I'm gonna go random.

June 4, 2012
Edit
Teddy-Son

So who do you suggest, Zanic?

June 4, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

No one is really being suspicious right now, but maybe Hezekiah. He seems to be posting way less than normal. I understand having real life issues, but he practically missed the first two rounds and has posted twice this round. Not accusing, just pointing it out.

June 4, 2012
Edit
Zanic

Dooku, why would you want to kill me? I may not be active, but killing me doesn't do the town...err, Republic any good; I'm just a Jedi, whatever that is. I assume that's the equivalent of a Townie?

Well, you weren't really saying much and Bandit had voted for you. Sorry?

I am somewhat concerned that, despite being declared innocent, there are several votes for me. One of which has a '.' as the reasoning behind it.

Anyway, I'll swap to no kill until we make up our mind.

June 4, 2012
Edit
Count Dooku

`Roxas`
Last night, we checked Teddy-Son and Count Dooku. They were both innocent.

Now if he is Obi-Wan and we kill one of these 2 today and they show up as innocent it will help prove he is who he says he is, but at what cost. Another townie. Can we afford to take that chance knowing they will get one more of us during the night round?

Two that are starting to make me wonder based on their previous play style are Hezekiah and Shadowwalked. I have no proof they are mafia but they have not had much to say which is out of character for them.

This choice will probably change.

June 4, 2012
Edit
chiefsonny
 

Its been more then an hour and no one suspicious yet so random will have to do for now.

June 4, 2012
Edit
Teddy-Son

Oops forgot to vote.{<00}

June 4, 2012
Edit
Teddy-Son

It's okay, Dooku, I just got a little defensive. Anyway, come to think of it, when I was Mafia in the past, I found myself much more cautious on what to say, lest I give myself away. Last game I was a Townie and I was far more open. Many games thus far, Hezekiah has been Town-sided and has been far more outspoken, but in the few he's been Mafia or otherwise he's been more cautious...but not like this. Something's up here...

June 4, 2012
Edit
Black Yoshi

This is only my second game, so I don't know people's habits that well, but it sounds like hezy might be a good bet. I'll need some more corroboration, though.

June 4, 2012
Edit
White Thunder

Heze has been a logical player in the past. Little surprised at a blank vote. I do want to go on the offensive and think a non talker is a better bet .

June 4, 2012
Edit
#85

Like I said, I don't care, so long as it's not someone who we have been told is innocent.

June 4, 2012
Edit
The Bandit

Non-talker...

Well, there goes half the town.

June 4, 2012
Edit
Helius

The ratio could very well be 10-7 at this point. : /

June 4, 2012
Edit
The Bandit

I had a typo there; I meant that, say, a regular townie/jedi should get upgraded to my role so I can leave without the game being fucked up for everyone.

June 4, 2012
Edit
Xhin
Sky's the limit

I had a typo there; I meant that, say, a regular townie/jedi should get upgraded to my role so I can leave without the game being fucked up for everyone.

I'd be okay with someone else getting your role, but there is the issue of it putting the town (republic?) down a person. If Bandit is correct, that would make the game 9-7. I suspect it would end after just this next night.

June 4, 2012
Edit
Count Dooku

The game can't end after next night that would be too soon.

June 4, 2012
Edit
Teddy-Son

It could Teddy. 9-7, and if the Sith recruit a person and Anakin doesn't take out a member of the Sith, that puts the ratio at 8-8. Sith wins in tie.

June 4, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

The current ratio is unknown but if it goes to 8/8, the Sith win the game Teddy.

June 4, 2012
Edit
Trever Leingod

I will change a townie into Yoda immediately and host-kill Xhin at the end of the day round unless he changes his mind.

June 4, 2012
Edit
Trever Leingod

Well that sucks that means the game will end too soon :(

June 4, 2012
Edit
Teddy-Son

It could Teddy. 9-7, and if the Sith recruit a person and Anakin doesn't take out a member of the Sith, that puts the ratio at 8-8. Sith wins in tie.

Plus the Sith get to kill at night, so even if Anakin took out one of them we'd still wind up losing unless we took one of them out today.

June 4, 2012
Edit
white lancer

That's also assuming Anakin hasn't already been recruited by the Sith. If Xhin quits we definitely need to take a shot in the dark today, and we may need to do so regardless. I wish we had more to go off of; the last few rounds haven't involved much discussion because we were depending on our cops.

I almost suggested a mass roleclaim as a last resort, but even that won't work with the DL in the game since it's possible he's recruited several special roles.

June 4, 2012
Edit
white lancer

I don't want to bring suspicion on myself for taking up for the mafia, but is this fair? Changing the Grandmaster's role I mean? I guess it doesn't matter that much since he can't be converted, but they did know that Xhin was basically immortal and not to target him. Now they don't have a clue. : /

June 4, 2012
Edit
The Bandit

END this game and start a NEW one.

It was done once before for different reason's just ask LLight.

To much has happened at this point and everyone is going to look at this with a different take.

And how did we get to this point?

June 4, 2012
Edit
chiefsonny
 

I'd like to see it to the end. I mean, it's Trevor's first time as Host. Maybe, just maybe, he can find out other flaws in the way the game is ran, and the next game will be better for it. :/

I really haven't had the opportunity to participate too much in this game. I'm not sure how I feel with Xhin being host-killed and the role being switched though.

June 4, 2012
Edit
Helius

"I'm not sure how I feel with Xhin being host-killed and the role being switched though."

And if that happens, do we get our 2nd cop back?

June 4, 2012
Edit
chiefsonny
 

I'm going to approach this as fairly to both sides as possible.

I personally do not think it is fair for Xhin's role to be transferred to another player for all sides. It throws everybody off, the Jedis, Sith, and myself as Obi-Wan. While it may greatly benefit the Jedis, it is a complete hindrance to the Sith.

Let's reverse this now. If the Dark Lord were to want to be host killed and his role were to be transferred to some other Sith player, would it be fair to the town that this takes place?

I don't think so, so why let it happen the other way around, y'know?

June 4, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

How about just take Xhin's role and give it to one of the regular Jedi then turn Xhin into a regular Jedi. That way the town isn't losing a member, but also gets to use its Yoda...

I don't agree with Chief regarding stopping the game. Just because some of our people have played pretty badly (Xhin) doesn't justify ending the game to start over otherwise the game where LLight was cop should've been started over because the town played badly, or the last game should've because the mob and mafia played pretty badly (though they were at a disadvantage too).

tl:dr = No game restart just because Xhin played badly.

Also having caught up with what people have said I'm going to vote for as he seems to be the popular vote and I have to admit his blank post where he voted was really weird :/

June 4, 2012
Edit
Redack

And if that happens, do we get our 2nd cop back?

As much as I would love the cop back, I don't think there's a justifiable reason to have Feral back. Xhin could've only defended one of them anyway, the medical droid for some reason didn't save Feral so yea...

June 4, 2012
Edit
Redack

"I don't agree with Chief regarding stopping the game"

Now that I've had time to think it through, I don't agree with him either.

But it was not just Xhin, who ever is playing these power roles that mean something to the game, need to pay attention. If they did we would probably still have our 2nd Cop.

June 4, 2012
Edit
chiefsonny
 

We don't need to restart or kill Xhin or anything like that. It's just a game and it'll be over soon anyway. Let's do our best and see what we can do. Not great odds now so we definitely have to try and take someone out, nothing to lose really. Let's go for hezy.

June 4, 2012
Edit
White Thunder

Maybe we'll get lucky and hit Fett.

June 4, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

Yea Fett is a weird one... Does he win with the Jedi or the Sith anyway or does he just exist to annoy both sides?

June 4, 2012
Edit
Redack

I think the latter. {:s} But he may win if the Sith wins. Not too sure. Could you clarify this, Trevor?

June 4, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

{:?} Amazing how everyone misspells my name when it's right there for reference...

Though he is technically a third party role, he wins with the Sith but generally exists to be a free-lancing nuisance. {:P}

June 4, 2012
Edit
Trever Leingod

Thanks trever. I have some free time, uh, tomorrow and stuff, so I'd like to still play as a normal townie/jedi. Congrats to whoever became Yoda.

June 4, 2012
Edit
Xhin
Sky's the limit

So yeah let's kill hezekiah.

June 4, 2012
Edit
Xhin
Sky's the limit

I'm lost here, why are we voting off Hezekiah? Did he do something that looked suspicious?

June 4, 2012
Edit
Teddy-Son

Apparently my "blank vote" for Dooku was suspicious, even though Xhin had previously (reply 1338749295) done essentially the same thing. It's hard as hell for me to keep track of this game with its renamed roles, and that's even without having missed the first few rounds (at the time of my vote, I hadn't even read a lot of what was posted, much less understood it (I still don't)). I'm getting burned out by the constant changes to Mafia, all these new roles being added that have a giant impact on gameplay.

Anyway, I'm not mafia. Roxas or chief could check me tonight to verify this. Having now read more of the stuff I missed, I'm suspicious of Redack, especially reply 1338820192; it's pretty possible that they're damn near a victory, and so they'd want to get that win instead of having to replay.

June 4, 2012
Edit
hezekiah

We have to start somewhere, and there were really no other suggestions that took place other than hezekiah.

June 4, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

Sorry Hez. Didn't know so many people would follow my suggestion. But we do have to start somewhere.

June 4, 2012
Edit
Zanic

Start somewhere useful, then.

June 4, 2012
Edit
hezekiah

Shadowwalked and Majora are both very quiet this game, which I find interesting. It's more interesting in Majora's case since Shadow tends to lie low in early rounds of the game if he's not a special role of some kind.

I've just been busy and tired :). I tried to give some input when I was on last round. Honestly though this game seems pretty straight forward. Yoda stays on Roxas, Medical Droid stays on Yoda (Xhin I guess). I don't see much reason to worry!

June 4, 2012
Edit
MajorasMask9

It's not just that it was a blank vote, but a vote for a person who was declared innocent. That's pretty useful in my opinion.

June 4, 2012
Edit
The Bandit

If #85 is the Medical Droid I don't think he should have revealed. If we control night actions this much to where Yoda protects the Medical Droid, and the Medical Droid protects Yoda and Obi-Wan, the Dark Lord is just going to convert Roxas and we'll have no way of proving whether or not he's converted. I think Yoda should stay on Roxas.

I'm not sure that the evidence against hezekiah is strong enough at this point to warrant a kill but I don't want to end with a no-kill. I'll "not vote" for now in case something comes up, but if not I'll probably have to go along with killing hezekiah.

June 4, 2012
Edit
MajorasMask9

85 did not say he was the medic droid...

June 4, 2012
Edit
The Bandit

Weird I was skimming the thread and thought I saw someone say he is.

Never mind then!

June 4, 2012
Edit
MajorasMask9

So Bandit, then why the hell did you vote for Dooku?

June 4, 2012
Edit
hezekiah

Also: because of the two Not Votings and there being 17 people still alive, one more vote for me would terminate the round (9/15 ~= 10/17) and cost the Republic one of its members.
Related, I don't get why the 1/3 cutoff for Dooku/Ventress is 7 people out of 17...

June 4, 2012
Edit
hezekiah

Oh right, he clarified the 7/17 thing in a reply. Damn this no editing :-P

June 4, 2012
Edit
hezekiah

I was joking. : / I changed it like my second post. Even if we are suspicious of Roxas, voting for a person declared innocent makes no sense.

If you have reasons to doubt Dooku, or anyone else, I'm sure we'll all listen.

June 4, 2012
Edit
The Bandit

Just as Bandit says, if anybody has any reason to vote for somebody, I am sure we will all be willing to listen.

June 4, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

I almost take back what I said about Hezekiah being suspicious. In game when we were the mafia, we had an executioner, Dooku I believe. If we have an executioner in this game then Hezekiah would have been dead by now.

Unless he is apart of the Sith cause we are clearly past 1/3 of the votes to off him. And a Sith would not kill himself off on less said person wants to throw the Jedi off.

But, I am not sure if he is Sith or not he has not done enough to prove either way.

June 4, 2012
Edit
Teddy-Son

Teddy, Executioner killings take place at the end of the day round. We won't know until then if he'll die or not, assuming that Padme doesn't step in and stop killings.

June 4, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

Too lazy to get caught up. Just gonna follow the crowd.

June 4, 2012
Edit
DragonintheShadow

Looks like it's hezekiah tonight; I'm not entirely convinced but I don't have any other major suspicions. But if we wind up being wrong on hezekiah then Anakin and/or the Arsonist NEED to take someone out tonight, because otherwise we're going to lose.

June 5, 2012
Edit
white lancer

Teddy, as others said the Executioner (whatever the hell he's called in this) happens at the end of the round, not as soon as they say they want the kill to happen. But it's a moot fucking point anyway, since there are 9/15 (2 NV removed from totals) for me, I'd expect that you'll see that you're a Jedi down as soon as Trever is back on.

June 5, 2012
Edit
hezekiah

Odd how Shadowwalked doesn't show up on the Vote Tallies By Round list. Xhin, y u break game (again)?

June 5, 2012
Edit
hezekiah

Hmmm. Having re-read the posts, I'm not sure on hezekiah either.

I'll just randomly vote and see where it takes me.

That being said, there isn't really much to go on. :/ I don't know who is who in this game.

June 5, 2012
Edit
Helius

Heh, your random vote matches up with my theory. However, it's a moot point. Unless the governor (whatever they're called) steps in, I'm a dead man.

What happens if a cop investigates somebody who gets taken by the Dark Lord that same night? Would they show up as guilty or innocent?

June 5, 2012
Edit
hezekiah

@Hezekiah, that's because Shadowwalked hasn't even voted. You only show up in it if you vote in at least one round.

June 5, 2012
Edit
Redack

Hezekiah, you know things might turn around, sometimes miracles happen.

June 5, 2012
Edit
Teddy-Son

What theory is that Hez? I must have overlooked it.

I honestly don't want to see you dead.

June 5, 2012
Edit
Helius

It's not a very in-depth theory, but it's my suggestion that Redack is mafia based on him not wanting a game replay, and the way he words his argument.

June 5, 2012
Edit
hezekiah

I don't want a game replay either. Nothing unfair has happened this game, people have just not played well.

June 5, 2012
Edit
The Bandit

Game replay because one side is possibly winning? Makes no sense,

Game replay because LLight cheated, made sense.

You see the difference I assume.

Also do tell on the way I word my arguments? I'm 100% certain it's consistent with my previous games and out of game wordings. Unlike some people I've just been myself every game.

June 5, 2012
Edit
Redack

I'm thinking we should have taken out Shadow. Sith or Jedi, he isn't even playing.

June 5, 2012
Edit
#85

I'm still not sure on Hez. He was hardly posting which was unusual for him. He said it was because he had little time, but why does he have so much time to defend himself? Just a thought.

June 5, 2012
Edit
Zanic

I missed the first day round because I was at work for the entirety of it. I then left Friday morning, and was without internet until Sunday afternoon. I got less than 8 hours of sleep over the weekend, so was rather out of it on Sunday. Now I'm mostly back to my normal, meaning I have more time to give to the game.

June 5, 2012
Edit
hezekiah

I'd be okay with lynching Shadow. Has he even made a post in the game?

June 5, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

I just went back through all the post since this game started and unless I missed something Shadowwalked has not posted or voted in the game so far.

Now I don't know if hezekiah is telling the truth about why he did not post sooner, but I'm willing to give him the benefit of the doubt and unless someone has some other suspicions about him, I won't vote fro him at this time. I know how rl issues can be.

But that said, it may be to late to save him if the The Executioner has locked in his vote.

For now I will vote for Shadowwalked until he or someone else gives me a reason not to.

June 5, 2012
Edit
chiefsonny
 

chief, it's probably better not to vote towards Shadowwalked this round. We'll just give the Sith a free executioner kill if we all change our votes.

June 5, 2012
Edit
Count Dooku

If hezy is a townie he's dead anyway. We might as well stick with him and not take the risk of taking out another townie, as well as giving out a free executioner kill. Shadow might be a good arsonist/Anakin target, though.

June 5, 2012
Edit
White Thunder

Reply to: star wars republic game 1 day 3 a strange turn of events

Username
Password