Engines Aether Legend of the Lunar Priest NIFE Roadmap
Shatterloop Game Projects Deprecated Starwright
Saepes Mundi Other Projects Blog  

Mafia

Moderated by: Speed Bike Pro

star wars republic revenge of the sith end game results

Posted June 7, 2012 by Trever Leingod

The Night was long and tiring. The Jedi managed to kill their traitor, Roxas, by the hand of the Chosen One. His body disappeared however… Lancer, his cohort who pretended to be Mace Windu, nearly died in a fire over the night, but he survived somehow, apparently getting out just in time. Shadowwalked, the Clone arsonist, was the final victim of the Sith killings.

With the Sith evening the numbers against the Jedi, 6-6 (Order 66! The irony!), they had secured a brilliant, nearly lossless victory. The Dark Lord turned Anakin to Darth Vader, turned the clone troopers against the Jedi, and initiated a purge against them. Padme died tragically, secretly giving birth to Anakin’s twin children. The Republic fell…

The Empire rises, but so does the Rebellion!

To be continued in Star Wars Empire…

Final Roster…

Xhin - Was Yoda, became a Jedi Knight by request
chiefsonny - Bail Organa
DragonintheShadow - Jango Fett. Died to Anakin
Redack - Count Dooku
Count Dooku - Dark Lord
hezekiah Jedi Knight. Sadly executed during the day for being too quiet o_0
Shadowwalked
Feral - Force Phantom turned Obi-Wan. Died to a Sith kill and was hidden.
Black Yoshi - Jedi Knight
Helius - Medical Droid turned Sith Probe Droid by Day 2
White Thunder - Jedi Knight turned Sith last night
Teddy-Son – Mace Windu. Died to expose Roxas and Lancer.
`Roxas` – Obi-Wan turned General Grievous the night Feral died. Died to Anakin.
white lancer - Survived the arsonist fire, ending the game. Jedi Outcast turned Silencer.
CtR Black – Jedi Knight. Died in a fire.
MajorasMask9 - Jedi Knight
#85 – Droid Spy
Zanic - Jedi Knight turned Yoda
The Bandit - Anakin Skywalker

I would personally like to commend Count Dooku, Redack, `Roxas` and the other Sith for a game very well played. They brilliantly manipulated the townies until the end, securing a greatly dominating victory. If Yeano agrees to award people points this game, I would commend those three especially to earn some MVP points.

Also some points to Teddy-Son and The Bandit. Teddy was bold to sacrifice himself as he did, and in doing so he nearly bought the Jedi an extra day – leaving Roxas and White Lancer exposed, and letting White Thunder have some suspicions about Count Dooku, the real Dark Lord! Had Lancer died in the fire, Day 5 would have dawned. I commend The Bandit for his thoughtful playing and careful selections as Anakin (The Vigilante), most especially for being a first time player.

Feel free to discuss the game overall, and bring any comments/complaints about me as host to this thread so I can improve myself for any more games I may host. I will begin accepting registration for Star Wars Republic soon.

Lastly, a big thanks to Yeano for allowing this game and me to host it. You have a brilliant mind to have invented this game – it’s involving, clever, and definitely the most addicting forum game I have ever seen. It has a lot of potential to grow on too, especially if you could make up more roles and get a lot more players. It sort of plays like a forum Stratego!

Thank you for playing!

Your host,
~Trever Leingod~

There are 83 Replies

extensionEnable Post Pagination

Oh, I was SO close to surviving too.

Dang it, Zanic.



June 7, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

You will lose 1 point for breaking a Mafia/Game Rule.

You will lose 2 points for a second infraction of Mafia/Game Rules in a single game.

As much as I hate to admit it, hezekiah loses 1 point and I lose 2. Rules are rules.

June 7, 2012
Edit
Feral

Had you survived, I'm sure the mob would be after Zanic {:P}

June 7, 2012
Edit
Trever Leingod

Can't say I blame him for not protecting me, but I was so close to a perfect game with the Sith.

June 7, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

Yeah, you have so much to complain about. Not like you blatantly defected from the town first chance you got or anything. {<00}

This whole "fuck hezekiah for talking while dead" thing has spiraled so far out of control it's not even fucking funny. The ONLY posts I made directly addressing the current state of the game came after Feral prematurely called the game over.

June 7, 2012
Edit
hezekiah

I have no idea what you are talking about, good sir. {:P} I did what I thought would be best for me, and it nearly worked to the end.

June 7, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

It would have if you didn't accidentally stumble into Windu's room in night 3.

hezekiah, I'll be the first to say that Redack, in his rage, blew things WAY out of proportion. But in his way, he is right. It doesn't change the fact that although we had the host role, we were still dead and should not have been talking at all. Dead people can't give hints or advice. We are not spirits. I also did NOT have permission from Trever to make either of us hosts on my own, even if he did OK it afterwords.

June 7, 2012
Edit
Feral

I think the Sith were a tad bit overpowered this game, considering this:


Dark Lord – Leader of the Sith. If checked by a Jedi, s/he will show up as Republic-allied, or innocent. Every night round, the Dark Lord may choose one person and guess their role. If this guess is correct, that person will be turned to the Dark Side during the night round – unless that person is the Jedi Grandmaster, in which case, nothing happens. They may choose to give the new recruit any powered role of the Sith alignment that is not currently occupied. If this guess is incorrect, the attempt fails, revealing who the Dark Lord is to the entire Republic the next morning.

Is the godfather, cultist leader, and is immune to the paranoid gun older.

June 7, 2012
Edit
Shadowwalked

Is the godfather, cultist leader, and is immune to the paranoid gun older.

Supposed to be gun owner, guess I can't type today.

June 7, 2012
Edit
Shadowwalked

In past games, there had been quite a bit less drama concerning posting while dead... take a look at game 5. Xhin posted 4 or so times during Day 2, including twice after being directly told by Yeano to stop. Then on Day 4, I had to use some admin tools to clean up after #85 made a post and vote post-death. Neither of them lost any points for this.

June 7, 2012
Edit
hezekiah

The whole points thing is up to Trever. If he wants to look past your part, that's fine. But what I did nearly killed the game, and I personally feel I deserve repercussions.

June 7, 2012
Edit
Feral

@Hez, Feral, Redack...

Yeah, mistakes we're made. But can we please move on? Who talked where and when? Who was made Host and who wasn't? Who goofed up the results? Etc. Non-issues. The Game is done. The only thing to do... is do better next game. Quit arguing, you're only ruining the fun of the moment.

@Everyone else...

I really enjoyed the game, and I want to congratulate everyone on a game well-played. It sucks having to keep quiet about how I was the Medical Droid and was converted... but now you guys know that I was having fun being Sith.

I'd like to congratulate those who assumed correctly that I had been converted. :) Well-played.

June 7, 2012
Edit
Helius

I also did NOT have permission from Trever to make either of us hosts on my own, even if he did OK it afterwords.

I was okay with it only if said people were sure to remain only in the Dead thread and you guys didn't {:?} Considering you are both admins, I thought I could rely on you guys to follow the rules.

Is the godfather, cultist leader, and is immune to the paranoid gun older.

He is not immune to the Paranoid Gun Owner/Mace Windu. If he had gone into Mace's room, he would have died.

I am going to make a point to give the Dark Lord some more risks next time around. Dooku was converting people left and right without any worry, and he appeared innocent when checked, so I definitely want to add something that will make him a bit more wary about converting people.

June 7, 2012
Edit
Trever Leingod

I also have to say Redack did NOT blow up, unless I missed something. He appropriately handled the matter by remaining pretty cool, even if he made some wrong assumptions.

June 7, 2012
Edit
Trever Leingod

He is not immune to the Paranoid Gun Owner/Mace Windu. If he had gone into Mace's room, he would have died.

Oh, my bad, misread it.

June 7, 2012
Edit
Shadowwalked

Dark Lord wasn't immune to the gun owner which is why Teddy was the only person you could trust 100% this game {:P}

But yea, even we figured it was an over powered role. The town played pretty badly and we got lucky with the medical droid early on so that didn't help things :)

June 7, 2012
Edit
Redack

Yup.

June 7, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

Even though the Dark Lord was overpowered, if you saw everything that I did as a Host, you could clearly tell the Sith were entirely outwitting the Jedi left and right. They lucked out getting the Medical Droid early, Roxas made the mistake of revealing himself and Feral way too early, and Xhin made the mistake of protecting himself instead of Feral or Roxas the night they were targeted. Then Zanic made the mistake of protecting Roxas the night the Sith tried to kill Teddy. Throughout the game, the only Jedi to make an accurate kill was The Bandit, which is very impressive considering he was new to the game.

June 7, 2012
Edit
Trever Leingod

Heck, my very first post this game was about how over-powered the Dark Lord was, especially in conjunction with the Droid Spy. I had a tricky time with this game because I thought the Sith had the advantage from the start but I was hesitant to do too much about it because I anticipated getting converted by them anyway. The only time I thought the Town might have the advantage was when we had two cops, and we all know how that turned out.

June 7, 2012
Edit
white lancer

I think the Sith would have had a flawless victory if Roxas hadn't told everyone I was Mace Windu. I would have said something along the lines of "I found Mace Windu but I'm not going to tell you who he is because I want to see if the Sith go into his room."

June 7, 2012
Edit
white lancer

Oh, and Xhin deserves props for calling out Roxas when he did. If the Town had listened to him, they might have stood a chance.

June 7, 2012
Edit
white lancer

I think the Sith would have had a flawless victory if Roxas hadn't told everyone I was Mace Windu.

I believe that Redack's idea.

Oh, and Xhin deserves props for calling out Roxas when he did. If the Town had listened to him, they might have stood a chance.

True. He didn't play for long but his instincts were good there.

June 7, 2012
Edit
Trever Leingod

I think the Sith would have had a flawless victory if Roxas hadn't told everyone I was Mace Windu. I would have said something along the lines of "I found Mace Windu but I'm not going to tell you who he is because I want to see if the Sith go into his room."

Maybe I should have waited and we all coordinated what I should have said... {shy}


And yes, props to Xhin for taking note, even if I have spoken that way before as a Town-sided role.

June 7, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

I did say it was a bad idea after suggesting it. I would've tagged it if I didn't feel that was against the rules {:P}

Unfortunately Roxas decided to roll with it without much discussion from everyone. It was a terrible idea that I instantly regretted suggesting {:(}

June 7, 2012
Edit
Redack

Oh well. I still nearly made it though, with Zanic switching to himself as a final decision.

June 7, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

Might have also helped if I asked the MD for some help...

June 7, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

I can't begin to describe how confused I was when I went into the main thread and had the Cop proclaiming me Mace Windu. I hadn't even noticed that I had been converted yet XD

Then when I figured everything out I freaked out a bit because I thought I was going to wind up dead once Teddy counter-claimed. I still can't believe we had everyone so convinced Teddy was Sith because there was no real reason for Teddy to lie about it.

June 7, 2012
Edit
white lancer

Good game everyone ^_^ Personally I'm just happy to have survived to the end.

A shame we weren't able to see the town's reaction to Roxas's body being hidden, I was rather looking forward to that :P

June 7, 2012
Edit
Count Dooku

Would have caused more hell than I did, Dooku. {:P}

June 7, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

if everything is settled, i'd like to try this.

if not not, oh well. =/

June 7, 2012
Edit
Mondo Tubular

But if not not, oh well. =/

BACK TO THE SHADOWS FORUM WITH YOU, KNAVE.

June 7, 2012
Edit
Shadowwalked

BACK TO THE SHADOWS FORUM WITH YOU, KNAVE.

What do you mean? What did I do to you...?

June 7, 2012
Edit
Mondo Tubular

Congrats to the Winners.

Not going to drag this out, but I feel this needs to be said.

1. If you're a Host, you should not be allowed to play. Either play or host, not both at the same time.

2. If you're dead you should only be allowed to talk in the Dead Thread.

3.If Night Talk is allowed (and I don't think it should be) on players that are still alive should be allow to talk in the main thread.

4. Yeano said before this game started that points earned in the SW Mafia game would not be counted in the Regular Mafia Game totals. We all knew that. He needs to stand by that decision.

5. Only Xhin (it's his site) Yeano and Trever (for SW) should be allowed to appoint Host.

We're taking what is one of the best features that has been added to this site and slowly fucking it up.

June 7, 2012
Edit
chiefsonny
 

I'm in agreement with you chiefsonny, Host needs to be carefully controlled.

I fully understand wanting to see who is who once you've died, but everything is revealed at the end of the game and you'll have to make do with seeing it then.

June 7, 2012
Edit
Count Dooku

I totally forgot that there was a vigilante alive until after the night round ended which would explain how there was a death on top of Roxas visiting someone. I guess that means that Yoda didn't protect Roxas or Feral on Night 2 for some reason???

June 7, 2012
Edit
MajorasMask9

??? What do you mean? What did I do to you...?

The last time I checked, you were banished to my forum for as long as everybody still thinks your knuckles.

June 7, 2012
Edit
Shadowwalked

I guess that means that Yoda didn't protect Roxas or Feral on Night 2 for some reason???

Xhin was being greedy and didn't think the Medic Droid would protect him, which he was right about at the time. Neither of us were protected whatsoever.

June 7, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

have not the foggiest what you mean... I have been allowed to post everywhere... I'm just not allowed to play Mafia...

please stop mentioning him... you are giving me mini panic attacks... just stop... please. I just wanted to play a game, not feel like I may faint... Just please leave me alone... I have done nothing to you...

June 7, 2012
Edit
Mondo Tubular

1. If you're a Host, you should not be allowed to play. Either play or host, not both at the same time.

I don't think you can actually really play as a host, considering you know who everyone is.

2. If you're dead you should only be allowed to talk in the Dead Thread.

Certainly true and I expected the others to stand by that call.

3.If Night Talk is allowed (and I don't think it should be) on players that are still alive should be allow to talk in the main thread.

In this case I allowed because the Day Round had been so short, and it was a last call for the Jedi. I was certain they were going to lose but I figured they should at least have a fighting chance.

4. Yeano said before this game started that points earned in the SW Mafia game would not be counted in the Regular Mafia Game totals. We all knew that. He needs to stand by that decision.

I talked to him about and he considered taking that back. Whether or not he will, I don't know. I know he wants a break from this, and since 3 people are only 1 point from being host eligible, giving points for playing this game will allow them to host once Star Wars Empire ends. After all, people DID play a game of Mafia, even if it was a slightly different version.

5. Only Xhin (it's his site) Yeano and Trever (for SW) should be allowed to appoint Host.

Agreed. I decided not to go against Feral or Hezekiah as admins, but if it happens again, I will have to report the event immediately.

June 7, 2012
Edit
Trever Leingod

A shame we weren't able to see the town's reaction to Roxas's body being hidden, I was rather looking forward to that :P

It would have been interesting {:P} Had Shadowwalked's coin come up Heads, Lancer would have died and the game would have gone another round.

June 7, 2012
Edit
Trever Leingod

is the reason now...? I was told that it is obvious I am not... him... by an admin... Why can't I?

offered to tell my identity via email... but no one has picked up... I don't want to be him... it was never meant to be taken seriously when I said I am him... When will you just drop it...? Call me anything but him... please...

June 7, 2012
Edit
Mondo Tubular

Gah Roxas. You played me. Well done. I thought it was ironic though that being the one townie on your side at the end, I still didn't protect you. {:P}

It was a close call, but that last comment about you double checking Teddy was my deal breaker.

June 7, 2012
Edit
Zanic

Well craaap. {:P} I'm not sure you were the only one, but one of few.

June 7, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

I was assuming Mondo Tubular was our dear Admiral Trainstorm, who played once before and caused no problems.

June 7, 2012
Edit
white lancer

I am an idiot that's why no one will believe me.

June 7, 2012
Edit
Teddy-Son

You're not an idiot, Teddy.

June 7, 2012
Edit
`Roxas`

1. If you're a Host, you should not be allowed to play. Either play or host, not both at the same time.

I thought that was obvious. I haven't been here over the last week, so anyone care to tell me what happened?

2. If you're dead you should only be allowed to talk in the Dead Thread.

It depends on the game really. I did add that option in the panel; Trever should have kept dead set to "cannot post in main mafia thread" if he wanted dead talk off. Although he may not have known how to do that.

3.If Night Talk is allowed (and I don't think it should be) on players that are still alive should be allow to talk in the main thread.

Again, depends on the game. I don't think we've ever played a game where night talk was on, but day talk has always been on for special roles that make decisisons during the night.

4. Yeano said before this game started that points earned in the SW Mafia game would not be counted in the Regular Mafia Game totals. We all knew that. He needs to stand by that decision.

AGREED.

5. Only Xhin (it's his site) Yeano and Trever (for SW) should be allowed to appoint Host.

Also agreed.

Again, someone tell me wtf is going on. I see a post in the mod forum about feral having access to the yeanopanel, though I was pretty sure this game was going to be trever with yeano giving him help and feral decided to play instead of host.

June 7, 2012
Edit
Xhin
Sky's the limit

Also I'm the idiot for not realizing that Yoda would keep someone from being converted. I figured "what's the point in protecting the cops, they can just be converted instead of killed"

Also I've been extremely busy this entire game.

June 7, 2012
Edit
Xhin
Sky's the limit

Mondo Tubular is too fucking happy and girly to be Knuckles. He is more like. When have you seen Knuckles be so happy and girly huh?

And guess what Shadow, Feral, a fucking admin who is HIGHER then you says he can't be Knuckles. Feral does not even like Knuckles and yet he knows he isn't Knuckles.

I know I am an idiot, but even I know Knuckles is not that girly.

June 7, 2012
Edit
Teddy-Son

Then why else would no one believe me no matter what I say? Either I am an idiot or people don't like me.

June 7, 2012
Edit
Teddy-Son

Sorry I got so mad its just enough with this.{:(}

June 7, 2012
Edit
Teddy-Son

Hey, so I technically won the game. Thanks for converting me then.

Ah, I was getting so close though. One more day and I think the Jedi could've pulled it out. If on the last night you asked me to list who I thought was Sith at that point, I would've guessed all of them right, except maybe Helius.

June 7, 2012
Edit
White Thunder

I almost believed you. I never voted for you, Teddy, but everyone else jumped on it first.

To be honest, though, if I had been forced to pick I probably would've picked you.

June 7, 2012
Edit
White Thunder

Then why else would no one believe me no matter what I say? Either I am an idiot or people don't like me.

You're the only one calling yourself an idiot so unless you really believe it to be true then its not. Also, whether or not anyone likes you on the Internet is beside the point. As long as you like you and your friends like you then it doesn't matter who likes you.

The reason it happened the way it did is because we managed to keep just enough belief in the town that Roxas was still their cop and so they decided to trust the person they thought was the cop. As long as they had that tiny doubt regarding Roxas being cop or Sith, they were always going to lynch you first.

June 7, 2012
Edit
Redack

It's cause I fly underneath the radar as long as I don't do anything stupid.... like in that one game.

June 7, 2012
Edit
Helius

This is not about Mondo Tubular being Knuckles or not being Knuckles'

Xhin's not allowing him to play because he flooded the site and caused a lot of trouble.

June 7, 2012
Edit
chiefsonny
 

And guess what Shadow, Feral, a fucking admin who is HIGHER then you says he can't be Knuckles. Feral does not even like Knuckles and yet he knows he isn't Knuckles.

Just because Feral is an admin doesn't make him any better or more knowledgable than anyone else on this site. Also in the hierarchy admins are only "higher" when it comes to site changing decisions (which mods and users are usually asked about anyway) or when a mod's competence is brought into question.

I also know Feral wouldn't approve of you labelling him as higher than Shadowwalked just because he's an admin.

June 7, 2012
Edit
Redack

I didn't flood... I just posted a lot of videos. I was only goofing around Because I thought this was like old Gametalk...

June 7, 2012
Edit
Mondo Tubular

Looked at the Sith threads, glad I gave you guys so much trouble {:P}

June 7, 2012
Edit
White Thunder

And guess what Shadow, Feral, a fucking admin who is HIGHER then you says he can't be Knuckles. Feral does not even like Knuckles and yet he knows he isn't Knuckles.

The last thing I saw on the matter was this:

"Any mod who still doesn't think Mondo is Knuckles, I just can't understand why. What do we know:

Knuckles claims to have alternative personalities.
Mondo started posting imminently after Knuckles was perma banned.
Mondo hangs around in the same forums as Knuckles did and has expressed interest in the same things, such as Twilight Princess.
Before adopting this kawwai personality, Mondo's posting style was much like Knuckles', even using the same phrases, such as bowlshit, (which he has now conveniently dropped).
Mondo has admitted to be Knuckles.

"BUT KINECT (LAWL! J/K) I DID AN IP SEARCH AND THEIR IPs AREN'T THE SAME, LAWL. SO IT CANNOT BE HIM."

Proxies, son. Clearly."

Which was in a thread dealing with a complaint made by Mondo that he couldn't play the Mafia game, which was eventually tagged as Knuckles threw another tantrum.

June 7, 2012
Edit
Shadowwalked

Thanks Redack

June 7, 2012
Edit
Teddy-Son

I thought that was obvious. I haven't been here over the last week, so anyone care to tell me what happened?

Feral and Hezekiah made themselves hosts so they could view the game. Later they both began posting outside the Dead thread.

It depends on the game really. I did add that option in the panel; Trever should have kept dead set to "cannot post in main mafia thread" if he wanted dead talk off. Although he may not have known how to do that.

I actually did do that, but I didn't make the Night thread a main thread because they were goofing off with the voting system before the Day Round. Apparently this allowed a loophole so Teddy was able to post in there.

Again, depends on the game. I don't think we've ever played a game where night talk was on, but day talk has always been on for special roles that make decisisons during the night.

I allowed this the one time because the Jedi were in deep trouble, with the Sith winning by a huge margin. Also, since Teddy wanted to be host-killed, it ended the Day Round in under 8 hours, with the posted minimum as 24 hours, so to compensate for the extra 16 hours I allowed Night Talk.

I know Yeano said he wouldn't award points, but it was a Mafia game and it would allow Yeano more of a break. Though that's entirely his call.

June 7, 2012
Edit
Trever Leingod

me alone you ass!!!!!!! CAN'T YOU SEE I have SUFFERED ENOUGH FROM HIM!? STOP ACCUSING ME, PLEASE! It hurts...

June 7, 2012
Edit
Mondo Tubular

Ahh sorry if I pissed you off BTW. Again I am wrong...

June 7, 2012
Edit
Teddy-Son

Feral and Hezekiah made themselves hosts so they could view the game. Later they both began posting outside the Dead thread.

No one wants to talk about this anymore, but I'm not going to play anymore if this is the way things work.

June 7, 2012
Edit
The Bandit

No one wants to talk about this anymore, but I'm not going to play anymore if this is the way things work.

That was done outside the rules and turned into a bit of a mess last night. Yeano and I will be watching to make sure there is no repeat of this "extra host" drama.

June 7, 2012
Edit
Trever Leingod

Alright then, I won't say anything else.

As far as the game goes, this:

I think the Sith would have had a flawless victory if Roxas hadn't told everyone I was Mace Windu.

This, for sure. I don't know what he's trying to get at, but he lied and back tracked his argument so often in the Night thread that I don't see how anyone could have believed him. He flat out said he checked Lancer on night 3, and we knew that wasn't true. : / Even hiding the body wouldn't have cast any doubt any my mind. His claims just weren't possible.

I think the game could have gone much differently the night we lost Roxas and Feral, but oh well. They all played very well, we didn't play so good. Congrats.

June 7, 2012
Edit
The Bandit

I know Yeano said he wouldn't award points, but it was a Mafia game and it would allow Yeano more of a break. Though that's entirely his call.

Yeah, but we played it under the assumption that no one would be awarded points. If you want to award points for the next game that's fine, but let us know beforehand (also meet it with yeanoapproval obviously).

June 7, 2012
Edit
Xhin
Sky's the limit

"Yeano and I will be watching to make sure there is no repeat of this "extra host" drama."

I hope so because I would like to play again. No ones blaming you Trever but the burden is now on you and Yeano to make sure this does not happen again.

You know, I was watching this and thinking "What the hell must the regs be thinking?" If this was pissing me and Redack off, both of who are staff, then the regs must be really pissed.

On a game note. For what it's worth, I think the Mafia had a little to much of a power advantage. Just my thoughts.

Thanks for Hosting.

June 7, 2012
Edit
chiefsonny
 

I don't know what he's trying to get at, but he lied and back tracked his argument so often in the Night thread that I don't see how anyone could have believed him. He flat out said he checked Lancer on night 3, and we knew that wasn't true. : /

He was clearly lying his pants off. Lancer was never Windu, and then he claimed he knew Teddy was Windu because he checked him again on that other night, but still chose to have him lynched.


Yeah, but we played it under the assumption that no one would be awarded points. If you want to award points for the next game that's fine, but let us know beforehand (also meet it with yeanoapproval obviously).

True, but to begin with, I did approach Yeano about that, and if he isn't willing to award points for the last game, I would urge him to do so next time.

I hope so because I would like to play again. No ones blaming you Trever but the burden is now on you and Yeano to make sure this does not happen again.

I check the roles very often so if someone is changing their role, I will know.

On a game note. For what it's worth, I think the Mafia had a little to much of a power advantage. Just my thoughts.

Due to the Dark Lord, yeah. I didn't really notice how powerful he really was until the game already started and I couldn't change the rules mid-game. I am going to have it that if he crosses paths with Yoda when trying to convert someone, he will be exposed. That should up the risks and make him think twice about trying to convert someone.

Thanks for Hosting.

My pleasure.

June 7, 2012
Edit
Trever Leingod

Even if I choose not to award points (which I will not be doing for this game), I can still deduct points for rule breaking.

Will not this time. What happened didn't really impact the game too much, so no point deductions.

Also, I'm not stating whether or not points will be awarded for the next game. That's up to you to decide.

June 7, 2012
Edit
Yeano

You're not an idiot Teddy. The position you were in got in an unlucky spot. Not your fault. And my hats' off to the sith. They played a devious game. Grr.

June 7, 2012
Edit
Zanic

Ha! Dooku was the Sith Lord! I knew it! I even called it before the game started. {:3}

And Bandit: I want to punch you so bad that my fist has a boner.


June 7, 2012
Edit
DragonintheShadow

Well thanks guys, I just went nuts again...

And as mean as Bandit can be at least he makes sense. I'd take bandit over Poptart any day.

June 7, 2012
Edit
Teddy-Son

If it's my call, I say give them points next game. And anyone that is playing, even after death, cannot be made a host - just to avoid any more trouble.

June 7, 2012
Edit
Trever Leingod

^^
That's more then fair.

June 7, 2012
Edit
chiefsonny
 

I already agreed. I will avoid the Mafia panel like a Knuckles tantrum.

June 7, 2012
Edit
Feral

{:D}

June 7, 2012
Edit
chiefsonny
 

That's more then fair.

I hope so {:D}

I already agreed. I will avoid the Mafia panel like a Knuckles tantrum.

Lol. Good one.

June 7, 2012
Edit
Trever Leingod

Yeah, rules need to stay constant next game. None of this changing stuff because the game goes a certain way (changing Yoda, allowing Night Talk, altering round time limits). Not so much host talking (the more you say, the more you give away). More randomness in role assignments (clearly I wasn't one of Trever's favorite people).

June 8, 2012
Edit
hezekiah

None of this changing stuff because the game goes a certain way (changing Yoda, allowing Night Talk, altering round time limits).

I only changed Yoda because Xhin was generally inactive and Yoda was one of the most important Jedi roles. Changing the time limits was necessary because some people, like yourself, were not happy missing the Day Rounds. Night Talk can be allowed by the host at certain times, and it was appropriate considering I ended the Day Round in under 8 hours due to a requested host-kill.

Not so much host talking (the more you say, the more you give away). More randomness in role assignments (clearly I wasn't one of Trever's favorite people).

I agree I talked too much, and I will be certain to make no advice posts, and only clarify certain things and take questions next game. I actually DID pick randomly, so don't feel bad you were only a Jedi Knight. Xhin was really the only one handpicked, because it was clear people liked killing him a lot. But that was about it.

June 8, 2012
Edit
Trever Leingod

You host-killed somebody? I must have missed that.

June 8, 2012
Edit
Feral

Yes, Teddy-Son wanted to prove he was Mace Windu so rather than waste all those hours in the Day Round, he asked for a host-kill.

June 8, 2012
Edit
Trever Leingod

Reply to: star wars republic revenge of the sith end game results

Username
Password