Engines Aether Legend of the Lunar Priest NIFE Roadmap
Shatterloop Game Projects Deprecated Starwright
Saepes Mundi Other Projects Blog  

Mafia

Moderated by: Speed Bike Pro

the bandits hideout

Posted January 17, 2015 by Female Alpha Wolf

Hello you dastardly thieves!
You are the bandits that are taking over this train and not any one of these here passengers can tell you any different!

Your ring leader is the great Jesse James himself, who is played by our nasty friend Hindenburg. This role is equal to the Godfather.

And what's a gang without a person that can keep our enemies quiet? Our Silencer is the oddly polite Bill Miner who is played by our vile friend chiefsonny! "Hands up!"

Of course, there are bodies that have to be hidden once in a while... Our lazy clean-up guy is Butch Cassidy who is played by our despicable friend Chaos Incarnate.

Last but certainly not least, every man in power needs underlings to rest his feet upon! Meet our contemptible Bandits, Speed Bike Pro and Jo Nathan!

Let's get those yellow-bellied passengers.

There are 134 Replies


Sorry Butch Cassidy! I forgot to mention:

Since you're so lazy, you'll only be able to hide bodies three times. Choose wisely!

January 17, 2015
Female Alpha Wolf

All right! I haven't been mafia for a while so I'm excited about this. Looks like an interesting team to boot - I look forward to working with you gentlemen.

The setting is neat, too.

January 17, 2015
Jo Nathan

Yes I saw this team and giggled to myself. I'm really looking forward to what ya'll do.

January 17, 2015
Female Alpha Wolf

Fortunately for us, we have an executive host on our team which means we are DEFINITELY going to win!

January 17, 2015
Speed Bike Pro
 

*spams fireball at Speed Bike Pro*

January 17, 2015
Jo Nathan

That's an odd way of saying that you want to die at a young age, Jo.........

January 17, 2015
Speed Bike Pro
 

Feral is a townie.

January 18, 2015
Speed Bike Pro
 

Hello friends and Speed Bike Pro! I know what you're thinking. Wow, how did that guy get to be so large and in charge? I know, I know. I was once in your shoes. I'll be glad to show you the ropes, but in exchange, I have some needs that need to be taken care of. I think we all know what I'm getting at here.

Also, I would just like to point out that this is like the first game in the last 80 where I've had a power role, and this is without a doubt because FAW is host and didn't immediately reroll after seeing I got something. I l-... love you...

January 19, 2015
Hindenburg
Life's path is never straight.

when is this guy gonna stop talking, holy canoli...

January 20, 2015
Speed Bike Pro
 

UH

YEAH

SHOW ME YO MOVES!

January 20, 2015
Female Alpha Wolf

Pretty sure Feral is just a townie trying to lure us into killing him with that subtle Lover claim. So he shouldn't be a target for any of our actions tonight. Then again, maybe he is actually a Lover but I know he has a tendency to try to spring traps like that when he's town-sided.

January 20, 2015
Speed Bike Pro
 

How do I always end up being mafia? Not that I'm complaining, it's interesting. Just... odd.

Well, if no one else is going to vote up to now:

I vote to kill Pirate_Ninja. As we have seen, he is very observant. and from what I have seen, he has been the primary reason for the victory of townies as well as mafia in different games. Better to get him out of the way imo so that we don't end with a sherlock holmes ruining everything.

I'll also choose to hide Pirate_Ninja's body unless something changes and I make it back in time. I assume my role functions as a janitor entirely, correct? How many times am I allowed to hide bodies?

January 20, 2015
Chaos Incarnate

I'll vote for Pirate_Ninja

January 20, 2015
Jo Nathan

How many times am I allowed to hide bodies?


3.

January 20, 2015
Speed Bike Pro
 

I'm okay with killing/Janitoring PN and I think chief would be a decent choice for silencing as well.

January 20, 2015
Speed Bike Pro
 

Oh... chief is the Silencer. Nevermind. (sry) bbl work

January 20, 2015
Speed Bike Pro
 

I think Feral is one of the Lover's. Based on what he wrote in his post, I doubt he read the new twist on the lover ans assumes they will both die.

As for our kill. PN is a good choice as there's no doubt he's a excellent player. But hezy would also be a good choice.
That said, I will vote with the majority.

I think chief would be a decent choice for silencing as well.


I agree.(gagged)

So who do we want to silence?

January 20, 2015
chiefsonny
 

It might make sense to silence who we think we might want to kill next.

It's true that hez would be a good choice to kill since he is usually sharp.

I would think silence hez now and kill him later, but on the other hand he's usually pretty quiet anyway.

Hmm.... just kinda thinking out loud here, don't take it too seriously. (hmm)

January 20, 2015
Jo Nathan

Wouldn't be opposed to hezy tbh.

January 20, 2015
Speed Bike Pro
 

Well hezy does not talk a lot so using a silence on him may be a waste at this time where a kill will get him out of the game.

After giving some thought to what Chaos Incarnate posted above, PN and others are going to think the same thing and may be bad for the Mafia game in the long run.

We know how good he is and we can get him at anytime. So let's throw them a curve.

For now I suggest this:

Kill: Hezy

Silence: PN

January 20, 2015
chiefsonny
 

dude.......... i'm down

January 20, 2015
Speed Bike Pro
 

I'll second chief's suggestion.

January 20, 2015
Jo Nathan

I.e., I vote to kill hezy

January 20, 2015
Jo Nathan

To make my vote official

Kill: Hezy

Silence: PN

January 20, 2015
chiefsonny
 

Alright, hide Hezy's body instead.

January 21, 2015
Chaos Incarnate

And change my vote to Hezy just to be sure.

January 21, 2015
Chaos Incarnate

kill hez silence pn

January 21, 2015
Speed Bike Pro
 

Oooooh...

You have killed and hid the Watcher!

January 21, 2015
Female Alpha Wolf

Excellent work, team. :^)

January 21, 2015
Speed Bike Pro
 

@Female Alpha Wolf & Speed Bike Pro

I forget how this works. But are you supposed to change the ratio: numbers when you hide a body? Defeats the purpose in a way. Although they don't know who, they do are able to tell it was a townies.

January 21, 2015
chiefsonny
 

Also this is not a OOG thing. It's a question about game mechanics.

January 21, 2015
chiefsonny
 

chief raises a good point. In a conventional two-party game (town and mafia), I don't think it'd matter but since this game utilizes a third-party role (Novelist), changing the ratio does reveal that we killed a town-sided role which is more info than they're supposed to glean from that.

A small mistake but I won't hold it against FAW. I don't think it'll matter much in the long run.

January 21, 2015
Speed Bike Pro
 

OK thanks. That was the point I was tying to make. With a 3rd party role and not changing the ratio does keep everyone guessing.

January 21, 2015
chiefsonny
 

OOPS IM SO SORRY I WONT DO IT AGAIN(cry)

January 21, 2015
Female Alpha Wolf

@Female Alpha Wolf

Also you should not tell who is silenced. That let's everyone know that person is either townie or 3rd party. Kinda defeats the purpose.

January 21, 2015
chiefsonny
 

I overlooked that as well. I am failing as an executive host. (????)

January 21, 2015
Speed Bike Pro
 

Sorry I missed last night's activities, I was practicing jerking off in the shower. Thanks to my leadership we were able to kill the Watcher, but what now.........

January 21, 2015
Hindenburg
Life's path is never straight.

I overlooked that as well. I am failing as an executive host. (????)


It's all part of the learning process. {y}

January 21, 2015
chiefsonny
 

Just an idea for a strategy we could employ at some point:

I claim Watcher, yada yada yada, and then you guys kill me and hide the body barring Doctor interference. I'm only a Bandit so the team wouldn't be losing much by offing me. Before I die, I could feed some feigned Watcher results to the town which people would probably doubt at first given the Janitor's presence in this game but killing me would lend my fake results a little more credence.

I didn't think this through very much beyond conceiving le epik trickster strategies to fool the town so any input is very much appreciated.

January 21, 2015
Speed Bike Pro
 

Not for this unless it got to point it was the only way we could win.

I'm only a Bandit so the team wouldn't be losing much by offing me.


You're part of the team and just as important as any one else. As I tried to tell the Mafia in the Game you hosted, we need numbers. All we need to do is tie, and that takes numbers.

January 22, 2015
chiefsonny
 

After reading his post I think Ghowilo has a power role. he's trying to hard to convince everyone he's a townie.

Just a gut feeling at this time.

January 22, 2015
chiefsonny
 

No man left behind, Speed.... Maybe that's how the TOWNIES do things, but not us.

Also, I think that gut feeling you have is dislike for Ghowilo. If nothing else comes up and it comes down to a random vote then I would be more than happy to nominate the nancy boy.

January 22, 2015
Hindenburg
Life's path is never straight.

i love you...

January 22, 2015
Speed Bike Pro
 

Also, I think that gut feeling you have is dislike for Ghowilo


So now you think you know who I like and don't like? Get over your self and grow the fuck up.

January 22, 2015
chiefsonny
 

I'd like to see how Ghowilo reacts to my accusation. If he responds in a super defensive way, others might start suspecting him and cast their vote.

January 22, 2015
Jo Nathan

Also what I did really goes against my usual quietness when I'm mafia so hopefully it just makes me look innocent. {:3}

January 22, 2015
Jo Nathan

Hoo... Things sure got heated real fast in here...

January 22, 2015
Speed Bike Pro
 

Chief, you're not in WW2 anymore... That ended 70 years ago... This is just a game of Mafia... We're all friends here, c'mon...

January 23, 2015
Hindenburg
Life's path is never straight.

Chief, you're not in WW2 anymore


At least get the facts right please.

I served in the The Vietnam War 1965-1971

I was born 1 year 2 months after WWII

January 23, 2015
chiefsonny
 

For what it's worth after the post white lancer just made I think he is the other lover.

Lovers:
Feral
White Lancer

We know hezy was The Watcher

So that leaves the Gambler and the Doctor as the remaining power players + the Eccentric Mystery Novelist

I still believe Ghowilo is one of the remaining power players (based on the way he posted and nothing personal)

At this point I'm not sure about anyone else.

January 23, 2015
chiefsonny
 

However the problem with taking Ghowilo out with a night kill, if he's the Doctor and protecting himself. We've wasted a kill. May be best to wait and see if he get's lynched.

January 23, 2015
chiefsonny
 

I trust your judgments since you were right about literally everything in the game I hosted, chiefy. Lead us to the promised land.

January 23, 2015
Speed Bike Pro
 

Also what I did really goes against my usual quietness when I'm mafia so hopefully it just makes me look innocent. {:3}


-I also disagree with Jo Nathan about Ghowilo. Although his analysis was not correct, the fact that he gave such a detailed post at all at this point in the game leads me to believe that he's more likely to be innocent. It just usually isn't in the mafia MO to make a post of that kind this early.


(¬?¬)

January 23, 2015
Speed Bike Pro
 

lolololol

January 23, 2015
Jo Nathan

Either way, I think we should be killing Pirate_Ninja now since the town knows he is than likely on their side before he has a chance to speak. I won't be using a hide on him as I figure he's just a Passenger. Even if he isn't, it probably shouldn't be too big of a deal since we already have the watcher down.

Also, I highly suggest silencing Lightvayne IF we know that FAW won't tell them he's silenced. he voted for CTR, and he usually tends to be not that active anyway. It may just be cause enough for people to assume that he is mafia taking into account that Badnit and Ghowilo just tend to be sporadic, and Hindenburg is Hindenburg.

Otherwise, I would suggest silencing one of our own, as that may be a reason for them to believe as innocent.

January 24, 2015
Chaos Incarnate

And to make it official, I'm voting to kill Pirate_Ninja.

January 24, 2015
Chaos Incarnate

Ugh, sorry about the words out of place, and errors. I'm typing as I'm about to go to bed.

January 24, 2015
Chaos Incarnate

@Female Alpha Wolf

If 1 lover is killed and the other is silenced in the same night round can the silenced lover use his gun the next day round?

January 24, 2015
chiefsonny
 

Hm that's a good question. I'm going to say yes but they still cannot post anything themselves in the round.

They could also use their weapon in the following night round after their silenced day round.

January 24, 2015
Female Alpha Wolf

Alright, so come tomorrow I may be buttfucked, but maybe something will come up to distract them. Although with the Watcher gone I guess I'm no more useful than a normal Bandito so whatever. IDK about who to kill but I feel like Feral might get killed on his own by the town somewhere along the line here. PN is probably a safe bet.

January 24, 2015
Hindenburg
Life's path is never straight.

The one that seemed to be after you the most was Ghowilo

I agree that Feral may be lynched by the town.

Kill PN

Silence Ghowilo

Bury No One

January 25, 2015
chiefsonny
 

I'm cool with that.

January 25, 2015
Speed Bike Pro
 

Silencing Ghowilo will bring to much attention to Hindenburg and myself.

Kill: PN

Silence: Lightvayne

Bury: No One

January 25, 2015
chiefsonny
 

I'M COOL WITH THAT YO

January 25, 2015
Speed Bike Pro
 

DIE PN

January 25, 2015
Hindenburg
Life's path is never straight.

Well alrighty then.

January 25, 2015
Female Alpha Wolf

@Am I right in assuming that if we has not killed Hezy, that of this day round we would have 2 reports to make?

Working on a plan and I need that ifo. I think I'm right.

January 25, 2015
chiefsonny
 

Also when the Watcher makes a report, Does if have to give the name of the visitor or just who received a visitor.

Example: Watcher: " On night one I watched Xhin and he had a visitor. It was dark and the visitor worn dark clothing and a hoodie.

January 25, 2015
chiefsonny
 

When the Watcher choose a person's place to stake out at, they CAN see the name of the person who comes to visit.

i.e
Watcher: I choose chiefsonny to watch
Me: Oooo~ Looks like Diddlyyumkins paid him a visit!

January 25, 2015
Female Alpha Wolf

@Female Alpha Wolf

Since the watcher is dead, if one of us role claim the Watcher can we not name the visitor?

i.e

Watcher: I choose chiefsonny to watch

Watcher:. It was dark and the visitor worn dark clothing and a hoodie.

January 25, 2015
chiefsonny
 

@Team.

I'm trying to see if it would help us if one of us role claim The Watcher.

Thoughts?

January 25, 2015
chiefsonny
 

Thinking about Hindenburg or Speed.

January 25, 2015
chiefsonny
 

Well, considering many of them have played for a while, they might notice the difference and say something on it. Because if that was how the Watcher saw things they wouldn't be very useful. {:P}

But of course you can try if you wanna

January 25, 2015
Female Alpha Wolf

^

All it takes is someone asking FAW how the role works and the roleclaim is shot if you try it like that.

January 25, 2015
Speed Bike Pro
 

NM. I was just trying to find a way to protect some of us.

To be very honest I'm losing interest very fast.

January 26, 2015
chiefsonny
 

if you guys don't save me i'm cutting myself

January 26, 2015
Hindenburg
Life's path is never straight.

I thought the Watcher role claim would do it. But to many things could go wrong.

If the votes start piling up on you we have 5 votes to put on someone else, and with the inactivity that may be enough.

January 26, 2015
chiefsonny
 

Then do it. Throw me off the train. I BET YOU WON'T


When Ghowilo made this post,^^ it lead me to believe he's the Doc protecting himself. That's why PN was not protected imo.

January 26, 2015
chiefsonny
 

I don't think Hindy is in any real danger tbh. The person leading the charge against him has been universally labeled as fucking insane so we're fine there.

January 26, 2015
Speed Bike Pro
 

This is for the greater good, Chaos. Sometimes you gotta break some eggs to make an omelette.

January 27, 2015
Speed Bike Pro
 

Well technically you have to...

Unless you use those white egg whites/yolks in a jug....

January 27, 2015
Female Alpha Wolf

When did this bandwagon for Chaos Incarnate start?

January 27, 2015
chiefsonny
 

As soon as white lancer voted for him. The only reason I hopped on as quickly as I did is because at this point in the round and with no other directions people were willing to take, I think the chance of Chaos getting lynched was basically 100%. If he's gonna die, I'd rather be one of the first people to vote so that I look nice and innocent.

Besides, what kind of mafia would kill their own Janitor? (smirk)

January 27, 2015
Speed Bike Pro
 

I just voted for him and I understand sometime you have to do this in the game. But it was a hard vote. Don't remember the last time I had to do that.

Sorry Chaos.

January 27, 2015
chiefsonny
 

When we win this, Chaos, I'll see to it that songs will be writ of your sacrifice. (cry)

January 27, 2015
Jo Nathan

CHOOSE YOUR NEXT VICTIM!

January 27, 2015
Female Alpha Wolf

Ok so here's who we've got to choose from:

The Bandit
Ghowilo
EvilGuy0613
white lancer
Lady Flare
Lightvayne
Xhin
Kyon
Feral Wolf


Ghowilo and Feral will probably be good suspects for possible lynching. Kyon and Xhin too, if only for their relative inactivity.

My thoughts would be to kill either The Bandit or white lancer, although there's always the risk that the Doctor may be protecting one of them.

January 27, 2015
Jo Nathan

white lancer may be a good silencer target. I find it easy to imagine that the Doctor also has him on their mind. I would prefer to kill either Bandit or Flare, they are our biggest late-game threats besides lancer.

January 27, 2015
Speed Bike Pro
 

Based on this post by Feral:

My only response is that killing me would be a waste and would cost you two passengers.


And this post by white lancer:

Question for FAW: are the Lovers shown as leaving their homes or visiting each other in the night?


There's no doubt in my mind they are the 2 Lovers.

And I'm also 100% sure Ghowilo is Mafia.

Xhin didn't post at all the last day round and should be host killed imo.

Of all the people that are on the list above, the one that worries me the most would be Lightvayne. He don't talk much but he's a very good player. And he's coming back off of a silence day.

My suggestion and it's only that.

Silence Lancer

and kill

Either: Lightvayne or Flare.

January 28, 2015
chiefsonny
 

Since I can't edit that last round should have read

And kill

Either: Lightvayne , Flare or Ghowilo. if Ghowilo is the Doc we will have wasted a kill but we will no for sure who he is.

January 28, 2015
chiefsonny
 

Lightvayne or Flare... hmm... me likey...

I may roleclaim Watcher soon.

January 28, 2015
Speed Bike Pro
 

Gotta go to work and I'll be gone when the round ends so my official vote is to silence lancer and kill Lightvayne.

January 28, 2015
Speed Bike Pro
 

Sounds good to me. Vote to:

Silence: lancer
Kill: Lightvayne.

January 28, 2015
chiefsonny
 

Does everyone agree with this vote?

January 29, 2015
Female Alpha Wolf

What the hell is the problem. We can't get our own people to vote. {fp}


@FAW

Speed voted
I voted

24 hours are up go with those votes. If nobody else wants to take the time to vote then that's a majority.

January 29, 2015
chiefsonny
 

Kill lightvayne

January 29, 2015
Jo Nathan

So tell me what you want, what you really, really want.

February 1, 2015
Female Alpha Wolf

I don't care anymore. When you have 13 players alive and 12 that can vote and only 6 do. wtf.

And Hindenburg makes no attempt to defend himself or for that matter even take the time to offer input or vote in this thread last night round.

February 2, 2015
chiefsonny
 

My vote is for The Bandit because he's definitely not going to be an easy one to get lynched and he's just plain dangerous.

February 2, 2015
Jo Nathan

Kill Bandit, silence Flare?

February 2, 2015
Speed Bike Pro
 

This^^


And before the next day round ends this is my take on the power players if Ghowilo is who he say's he is.

Feral & white lancer: The lovers

Xhin: Doctor

But remember if he' protecting himself which I think he has been doing the entire game, then he can only be killed by a Day Lynch.

I

February 2, 2015
chiefsonny
 

I'm gonna claim Watcher next round, m8s.

February 2, 2015
Speed Bike Pro
 

Good. Maybe you can come up with a story to make Xhin look like he's Mafia.{y}

February 2, 2015
chiefsonny
 

Goodbye team. Sorry for getting myself killed.

February 5, 2015
Jo Nathan

You can tie this now with a vote for Xhin.

February 5, 2015
chiefsonny
 

I'll resort to that closer to the end of the round if I have to.

February 5, 2015
Jo Nathan

@Female Alpha Wolf

Can we silence the same person more than once?

February 5, 2015
chiefsonny
 

I'm gonna claim Watcher next round, m8s.


You only have 2 hours left to do it.

February 6, 2015
chiefsonny
 

Way to show up team and help us get the one person that that can only be killed with a day lynch.

(clap)

Good job.{fp}

February 6, 2015
chiefsonny
 

Should we take out Feral, assuming he is one of the lovers? It may be a longshot but there's always the possibility that they will take out someone who's innocent with their kill.

Maybe consider doing this after I'm lynched next round since I would probably be the lovers' first choice for their kill anyway. >_<

I vote to kill white lancer.

February 6, 2015
Jo Nathan

So what the hell just happened. I thought there was enough votes to lynch JN b4 the round ended.

February 6, 2015
chiefsonny
 

My thoughts:

I think we hold off killing the Lovers because we know they will use the gun and we could lose 2 of us in one round. And like last round, we may get lucky and all survive the next round.
And they probably expect us to kill lancer. So it may throw them off a little by not doing so.

The 2 biggest threats for getting things stirred up are white lancer and Lady Flare, who will be coming off being silence and ready to talk.

I suggest we:

Silence: white lancer again

Kill Lady Flare.

February 6, 2015
chiefsonny
 

I approve.

February 6, 2015
Speed Bike Pro
 

Can we silence the same person more than once?


Yes but not two rounds in a row. That's not very fun.

February 6, 2015
Female Alpha Wolf

Ok Thanks. Since LF was silenced last round it won't be 2 in a row.

And I don't like having to do it, but we are down to 3 and of the remaining players, lancer and Lady Flare are the best at getting things stirred up and people voting with them.
So we have to get the talkers out if we can.

February 6, 2015
chiefsonny
 

Makes sense.

February 6, 2015
Jo Nathan

So just to be clear, I'm changing my kill vote to Lady Flare.

February 6, 2015
Jo Nathan

That's what Speed and I are doing, so yes if you want to.

February 6, 2015
chiefsonny
 

Silence White Lancer

and

Kill Lady Flare

gotcha

February 7, 2015
Female Alpha Wolf

Thanks for throwing me under the bus. Why didn't you go after

EvilGuy0613
Kyon

or even JN. You targeted the one role we had that was a power player.

Dumb ass move.

February 7, 2015
chiefsonny
 

Trust.

The bandwagon was already in motion. This is the best we can make out of a bad situation. The town should be firmly in my pocket after this round.

February 7, 2015
Speed Bike Pro
 

You probably already noticed this, but you will have to take out one of the lovers before the ratio gets too small because if it gets down to the wire and it's just you and them... well obviously they'll know by process of elimination that you are the remaining Mafia.

February 8, 2015
Jo Nathan

I think we should kill white lancer. That puts Feral in a position to use that gun and (hopefully) shoot EvilGuy or something.

February 8, 2015
Speed Bike Pro
 

Actually, he'd probably just shoot you but I still feel like white lancer is our best bet. It removes the strongest player that's still alive and gives me a pretty good playing field the rest of the way.

February 8, 2015
Speed Bike Pro
 

I feel like I'd be the one who gets it, but I'm as good as dead no matter what. Also I think if anyone can save the town from Feral's misplaced trust in you, it would be lancer so it's definitely worth the risk to take him out. If he's alive next round, I am certain your façade will be compromised.

February 8, 2015
Jo Nathan

rofl @ timing

Ok so it looks like we're on the same page.

February 8, 2015
Jo Nathan

It is a necessity... (fedup)

February 8, 2015
Speed Bike Pro
 

Alrighty!

So kill white lancer yes?

February 9, 2015
Female Alpha Wolf

AYE AYE CAPTAIN

February 9, 2015
Speed Bike Pro
 

FUCKing doctor, man.

February 9, 2015
Speed Bike Pro
 

Is the Doctor able to save the same target in consecutive turns?

February 9, 2015
Speed Bike Pro
 

Also I want to kill Feral.

February 10, 2015
Speed Bike Pro
 

Yeah he can.

And alrighty!

February 10, 2015
Female Alpha Wolf

@everyone reading this thread after the game ends, the reason I chose Feral is because I wanted to force the Lover kill action and white lancer is too hotly contested between power roles. So by killing Feral instead, I:

1) still get to force the Lover kill, hopefully on someone other than myself
2) can believably say I watched someone else during the night (probably white lancer) and therefore didn't catch the murderer in the act

woop woop go mafia

February 10, 2015
Speed Bike Pro
 

This thread is locked